The Rookie Werewolf - Game Thread

[Kevin the Armorer]

Moe did suggest the read might have been tampered with.

[Lieutenant Grey]

“7-Lincoln-200 to all units sighting of Rosalind Dyer in North Hollywood. I am en-route will update with further information.


….


7-Lincoln-200 to all units. Not conscious Not breathing body at scene, looks like it went through extensive torture and disfigurement. Looks like @Friar Tuck so en-route to morgue”

[Robin the Jester]

13 most likely remain alive, assuming friar will die at some stage today

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Damn, there goes my "Dora is Rosalind" theory then. Between that and Jacob and Magda, I've lost pretty much all my bad reads this morning.

[Gordon the Cook]

Wow, 3 dead and I haven’t even finished serving breakfast.

[Robin the Jester]

need that wolf priest dead. 

[Boris the Fool]

Make that four dead.

[Kevin the Armorer]

Damn, there goes my "Dora is Rosalind" theory then. Between that and Jacob and Magda, I've lost pretty much all my bad reads this morning.

Is it possible that Dora was the SK and it was one of the roled villagers with a gun that shot her?

On the flip side... I wonder if the SK had been killed would Friar have survived. Impossible to know but that would imply the SK is still alive.

[Gordon the Cook]

ok... so same as a few others. I noted posts 299 and 484 that he mentioned finding the traitor. He could still have been the traitor though? The the wolves missed the signals.

IF he wasn't the traitor... the other theory that popped out at me on the vote results was Gordon aligning his vote with Moe. Is that a signal? Moe voted first so it seems doubly odd to align with the person the wagon is against.

I had voted Magda the night before also. I wasn’t aligning with anyone.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Damn, there goes my "Dora is Rosalind" theory then. Between that and Jacob and Magda, I've lost pretty much all my bad reads this morning.

Is it possible that Dora was the SK and it was one of the roled villagers with a gun that shot her?

On the flip side... I wonder if the SK had been killed would Friar have survived. Impossible to know but that would imply the SK is still alive.

The post about Friar dying says "sighting of Roselind Dyer in North Hollywood", and was posted after Dora died though?

[Kevin the Armorer]

ok... so same as a few others. I noted posts 299 and 484 that he mentioned finding the traitor. He could still have been the traitor though? The the wolves missed the signals.

IF he wasn't the traitor... the other theory that popped out at me on the vote results was Gordon aligning his vote with Moe. Is that a signal? Moe voted first so it seems doubly odd to align with the person the wagon is against.

I had voted Magda the night before also. I wasn’t aligning with anyone.

Ah ok. Fair enough. That covers that I guess.

[Dexter the Dragoon]

My thoughts and I can be a little bit more clear now.

I aimed a shot at Dora yesterday before lynch, just after I posted about using my protect on myself. I didn't protect myself by the way.

I was suss on Jacob and didn't respond to his question about who I'd shoot this morning on purpose.

Magda I was leaning good on.
Re multiple shots. Is it possible the SK and vig both chose her to shoot?

Any other questions from Boris and whoever else was holding off, send them my way.

Moe was alpha for sure, no doubts on that one.

[Kevin the Armorer]

Is it possible that Dora was the SK and it was one of the roled villagers with a gun that shot her?

On the flip side... I wonder if the SK had been killed would Friar have survived. Impossible to know but that would imply the SK is still alive.

The post about Friar dying says "sighting of Roselind Dyer in North Hollywood", and was posted after Dora died though?

Good catch. Ok so the SK is still at large. Damn, I was full sure it was Dora.

[Lilly the Millennial]

Damn, there goes my "Dora is Rosalind" theory then. Between that and Jacob and Magda, I've lost pretty much all my bad reads this morning.

Why can’t Dora be Rosalind? Friar was taken before she was killed so we wait and see if there is a kidnapping today

[Boris the Fool]

My thoughts and I can be a little bit more clear now.

I aimed a shot at Dora yesterday before lynch, just after I posted about using my protect on myself. I didn't protect myself by the way.

I was suss on Jacob and didn't respond to his question about who I'd shoot this morning on purpose.

Magda I was leaning good on.
Re multiple shots. Is it possible the SK and vig both chose her to shoot?

Any other questions from Boris and whoever else was holding off, send them my way.

Moe was alpha for sure, no doubts on that one.

Knew you hadn't protect yourself 🤣🤣 got away with it.
Why did your shot fail on Dora? Was she protected or was it randed?

[Lilly the Millennial]

My thoughts and I can be a little bit more clear now.

I aimed a shot at Dora yesterday before lynch, just after I posted about using my protect on myself. I didn't protect myself by the way.

I was suss on Jacob and didn't respond to his question about who I'd shoot this morning on purpose.

Magda I was leaning good on.
Re multiple shots. Is it possible the SK and vig both chose her to shoot?

Any other questions from Boris and whoever else was holding off, send them my way.

Moe was alpha for sure, no doubts on that one.

I wonder was one of the two shots one of the failed shots previously?

[Kevin the Armorer]

Damn, there goes my "Dora is Rosalind" theory then. Between that and Jacob and Magda, I've lost pretty much all my bad reads this morning.

Why can’t Dora be Rosalind? Friar was taken before she was killed so we wait and see if there is a kidnapping today

As Benji pointed out. Rosalind was spotted AFTER Dora was killed.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Damn, there goes my "Dora is Rosalind" theory then. Between that and Jacob and Magda, I've lost pretty much all my bad reads this morning.

Why can’t Dora be Rosalind? Friar was taken before she was killed so we wait and see if there is a kidnapping today

Is it possible that Dora was the SK and it was one of the roled villagers with a gun that shot her?

On the flip side... I wonder if the SK had been killed would Friar have survived. Impossible to know but that would imply the SK is still alive.

The post about Friar dying says "sighting of Roselind Dyer in North Hollywood", and was posted after Dora died though?

Requoting as an answer

[Boris the Fool]

Damn, there goes my "Dora is Rosalind" theory then. Between that and Jacob and Magda, I've lost pretty much all my bad reads this morning.

Why can’t Dora be Rosalind? Friar was taken before she was killed so we wait and see if there is a kidnapping today

The flavour says the Rosalind had been spot after Dora dying so assuming trigger would not be so amateur and not change the flavour if she was already dead then we can take it that she is alive.

[Lilly the Millennial]

Thanks both

[Lieutenant Grey]

"7-Lincoln-200 to all units... Kidnapping in progress on the corner of seventh and Main. All units to Location."


....
...


"7-Adam-100 to 7-Lincoln-200.. At location, suspect and victim gone. spoke to a witness. Suspect fits the description of Rosalind Dyer"

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

And if we needed any more confirmation shes still at large, there it is.

[Robin the Jester]

so, who's been kidnapped?

[Kevin the Armorer]

Checking in. Still here.

[Ina May the Midwife]

Morning all.
Not kidnapped. Catching up on the thread now.

[Kevin the Armorer]

so, who's been kidnapped?

I can't put my finger on it but your posts just give an odd vibe. Right here... why ask that question. It's just happened, noone knows (well one person does).

[Gordon the Cook]

so, who's been kidnapped?

Not me.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Still here.

Two shots to kill Magda - if @Dexter the Dragoon is certain that Moe was the alpha, does that mean two separate players targeted Magda? If that's the case, at least one of those came from the village (or the SK)

Dora being shot feels like a village shot, she had a good bit of heat and presumably would have been kept by the wolves (esp if she was a wolf!)

[Lilly the Millennial]

Still here too.

As a side note - we need to see if we can get something sorted with the SQL errors after the game. I’m sure if it costs money we could all chip in. It’s so frustrating

[Mick the Drunk]

I presume the kidnapping was the SK?

"Word on the streets is that she has built a new bunker where she will torture her victims thoughout the night."

So there should only be one death tomorrow morning, if it was a wolf role block they know who the SK is, could have been a village protect either.

I presume the kidnapping was the SK?

"Word on the streets is that she has built a new bunker where she will torture her victims thoughout the night."

So there should only be one death tomorrow morning, if it was a wolf role block they know who the SK is, could have been a village protect either.

But surely that indicates a night action for the serial killer, They can't kidnap the victims and then kill later as then that person would be unable to vote. Don't see how the attempted kidnap could be a serial killer.

But surely that indicates a night action for the serial killer, They can't kidnap the victims and then kill later as then that person would be unable to vote. Don't see how the attempted kidnap could be a serial killer.

She has a bunker where she will.torture her victim throughout the night?

Who else could be kidnapping people?

She has a bunker where she will.torture her victim throughout the night?

Who else could be kidnapping people?

If that's the case the sk kidnaps the person during the day and tortures at night but it failed today?

Only other thing I can think of is this is the criminals trying to kidnap the traitor but I dunno if that makes sense from the flavour

Doesn’t sound plausible that an SK could kidnap a player during the day and hold them from now until the morning and what then…. Kill them?

What about the kidnapped players vote at lynch?

Not sure I buy it.

It doesn't say that the serial killer kills at the same time as the wolves specifically in the OP. Maybe they get their kill randomly? But why would it have not worked?

The OP says overnight

But if the serial killer kidnaps during the day prior to lynch vote that means the kidnapped player can't vote. So serial killer can effect votes as well as kill. I've only played a few ganes with an SK but has that ever happened before?

What if the player who was targeted had already cast their lynch vote. Surely it would have to count. I don’t think it’s the SK tbh as the OP clearly mentions night.

i like the idea that it was the wolves trying to kidnap someone, trying to find the traitor.

we have been informed that there is a traitor in our ranks. Try to take them down before the criminals find them

A kidnapping would suggest that player cant vote or post but hopefully they will be returned to the game, maybe tomorrow and can tell us what happened. I dont think it is the sk, what would happen if they were lynched tonight or the kidnapped person.
It is possible it was the criminals trying to find the traitor, did the succeed or fail though?

Is it possible there is some other mechanism in the game that wasn't in the OP? Does that happen on these games? I'm thinking along the lines of a villager being coerced into a kidnapping for the sk or wolves through some posting pattern and in this case they failed? Or maybe it was the wolves or sk themselves who were given a task and failed?

The most obvious reason is that it was a failed recruitment as suggested by many, but I don't want us to get too rabbit holed by the obvious.

A kidnapping would suggest that player cant vote or post but hopefully they will be returned to the game, maybe tomorrow and can tell us what happened. I dont think it is the sk, what would happen if they were lynched tonight or the kidnapped person.
It is possible it was the criminals trying to find the traitor, did the succeed or fail though?

The kidnapping failed, no one has left the game. The post said the victim is fine and I doubt they were informed as that would prove they're not a wolf.(if the wolf theory is correct)

I don't think it's just flavour. The first one reads like someone attempted an action in the game but it failed. I'm inclined to agree with the theory that it's the criminals trying to identify the traitor and that if the person they've selected isn't the traitor that the kidnap attempt fails. I think we're not getting the victim's name because then it'd be a confirmed villager and the wolves already know the alignment of that person because it's not one of them.

The second one is a failed shot fired in the station area. Lopez has a long gun and can only fire during the day so maybe it's her? If so then it could be Elijah's power who affected it?

Friar and the SK, Friar mentioned they thought the kidnapper failed attempted was the SK, given the SK then took Friar, the interactions around those time are worth noting. A couple of people felt they weren't SK attempts. There isnt a whole lot in the interactions and posts here as to why Friar would be targeted by the SK but a few people pointing it towards a failed wolf attack.

Could really do with eliminating the wolf priest ASAP

[Robin the Jester]

so, who's been kidnapped?

I can't put my finger on it but your posts just give an odd vibe. Right here... why ask that question. It's just happened, noone knows (well one person does).

it was more rhetorical. we will figure it out shortly.

[Kevin the Armorer]

I can't put my finger on it but your posts just give an odd vibe. Right here... why ask that question. It's just happened, noone knows (well one person does).

it was more rhetorical. we will figure it out shortly.

It might well have been but it just read to me as a question put out there to imply you couldn't know the answer. I'm probably being more nit picky with you due to the random vote on night 1, and I don't know what was going on with the chat about whether you voted or not. Looks like you just didn't declare it, which goes against the grain.

[Robin the Jester]

it was more rhetorical. we will figure it out shortly.

It might well have been but it just read to me as a question put out there to imply you couldn't know the answer. I'm probably being more nit picky with you due to the random vote on night 1, and I don't know what was going on with the chat about whether you voted or not. Looks like you just didn't declare it, which goes against the grain.

i voted, the mods forgot to add me to the results, then corrected it when they realised by re-releasing the vote results. 

but yes, i didnt declare on thread that i voted moe

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

It might well have been but it just read to me as a question put out there to imply you couldn't know the answer. I'm probably being more nit picky with you due to the random vote on night 1, and I don't know what was going on with the chat about whether you voted or not. Looks like you just didn't declare it, which goes against the grain.

i voted, the mods forgot to add me to the results, then corrected it when they realised by re-releasing the vote results. 

but yes, i didnt declare on thread that i voted moe

What time did you vote at?

[Amy the Singer]

Just posting that I’m still here - not kidnapped
.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

I think that leaves

Boris
Dexter
Edward
Vincent

[Robin the Jester]

i voted, the mods forgot to add me to the results, then corrected it when they realised by re-releasing the vote results. 

but yes, i didnt declare on thread that i voted moe

What time did you vote at?

it would have been towards the end as was watching chelsea vs brighton, so sometime between 8.45 and 9.30

[Robin the Jester]

Morning all. Just wondering are there any "trips to the armoury" type contests in this game? They were always mid-morning in Traitors and I usually missed them.
Hoping that the fact that I can post this means I haven't been munched.

i've gone through amy's post and this is the only thing that stood out to me.

references being munched by the wolves but nothing of being kidnapped by the SK

[Kevin the Armorer]

From whos left (ordered by post count)

Boris the Fool
Kevin the Armorer
Robin the Jester
Benjamin the Alchemist
Lilly the Millennial
Dexter the Dragoon
Gordon the Cook
Vincent the Artist
Ina May the Midwife
Edward the Barber
Mick the Drunk
Weyland the Blacksmith
Amy the Singer

Taking out who checked in...

Boris the Fool
Dexter the Dragoon
Vincent the Artist
Ina May the Midwife
Edward the Barber

Have I got that right?

[Kevin the Armorer]

Oh and Ina checked in. So...
Boris the Fool
Dexter the Dragoon
Vincent the Artist
Edward the Barber