The Rookie Werewolf - Game Thread

[Magda the Maid]

Hypothetically if someone had a bullet and had suspicions on who the SK might be and who a wolf might be.  Is the logical thing here to aim for the wolf as the SK needs to kill wolves as well?

Mentioning Bullets again! How is no one else seeing this!!

Me Gordon I'm seeing it, she's always at it.

Pew Pew.

Don't worry Gordo you're still not on my Radar.

[Magda the Maid]

Right plan for today.

Shoot Dora - Erratic play either playing as SK or poor villager so either way happy to send Dora packing to the Morgue.

Lynch Ina - Interactions with Alpha Moe was suss and tried to lay low yesterday with "helpful" posts like listing out who hasnt posted since the kidnapping, or simply put posting fluff until the heat on her dies down, but I haven't forgotten about her.

That wraps up Day 3 with the Alpha, SK and Ina Wolf all gone. A good day for the village.

[Boris the Fool]

Mentioning Bullets again! How is no one else seeing this!!

I just don’t think the vig would be that open

They wouldn't. That's what I'm trying figure out is it just nrv throwing bluff or a wolf trying to sound like they can be helpful.

[Kevin the Armorer]

I think we need to start doing some proper digging - without a priest we don't have any wagonomics but even if we did, we have two runaway wagons and zero FFAs. Can everyone do an FFA today?

For any newbies, that's a list of your top 3 suspects and reasons (even if they're rubbish reasons) for suspecting them - the purpose of this is that it's much easier for villagers to do this than wolves (as they will always be conscious of mentioning / not mentioning other wolves) and also it gives us something to look back on when we catch a wolf.

I've been so open about thinking Dora is the SK that I feel I'm at risk of a kill. Whether or not she is, I'm a good target regardless. So I'm happy to give out my reads (doing now as I've to take the dog for her walk).

Dora - SK. I've outlined in previous posts.
Mick the Drunk - goes missing for large chunks and when he is here I feel he is more reactive to other posts rather than trying to put out ideas.
Robin the Jester - the random vote on night one. Also someone who is overlooking basic stuff (e.g. last night not knowing why Friar was out of action) which could be hiding behind "oh silly me".

Gordon was up there. Not contributing a lot in the first day. There was that "markie" thing which was odd (what he called Countess). Benji did the same. I have that in my notes as as an odd unexplained thing that was said. HOWEVER, why would he vote alone (with Moe) like that. There's no real suspicion on him so why do that. That has made me rethink him.
I'm also growing more suss of Amy. I know you are a newish player like myself but I dunno, I think you're hiding behind that. Playing dumb but actually a wolf.

Dexter is probably the only person I trust. I had a good vibe off Friar too but he might be dead now. Magda too I lean towards trusting... but I need to look back again and the posters who were poking her over the last few days, see if there's anything to it.

There's a few mid-poster-table players who I've not dug into. If I get time today I'll try to look at

Ina May the Midwife 38
Lilly the Millennial 34
Edward the Barber 30

[Magda the Maid]

Coming for you Dora

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

I just don’t think the vig would be that open

They wouldn't. That's what I'm trying figure out is it just nrv throwing bluff or a wolf trying to sound like they can be helpful.

I said yesterday about how I disliked the comments about Countess playing a “good game”. It felt like someone talking with insider info that they shouldn’t have. But they were very headstrong vs Moe, and Moes final posts yesterday make me think he was a wolf who didn’t want to risk hurting his own team. But then could it be two wolves who didn’t expect the alpha to be caught so quick and they weren’t planning for the landslide?
I also don’t think it’s particularly helpful to try and landslide Ina today. Fair enough if she’s who we agree on but I personally felt that cause everyone lumped on moe, and lumped on William, there was little motivation to dig deeper on anyone.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

I am down with the “shoot Dora” plan though.

[Magda the Maid]

They wouldn't. That's what I'm trying figure out is it just nrv throwing bluff or a wolf trying to sound like they can be helpful.

I said yesterday about how I disliked the comments about Countess playing a “good game”. It felt like someone talking with insider info that they shouldn’t have. But they were very headstrong vs Moe, and Moes final posts yesterday make me think he was a wolf who didn’t want to risk hurting his own team. But then could it be two wolves who didn’t expect the alpha to be caught so quick and they weren’t planning for the landslide?
I also don’t think it’s particularly helpful to try and landslide Ina today. Fair enough if she’s who we agree on but I personally felt that cause everyone lumped on moe, and lumped on William, there was little motivation to dig deeper on anyone.

Landslide voting for Ina is still beneficial when it's revealed she was a wolf.

But I do agree everyone needs to be looked at today as well, as there is still a 3rd wolf out there and seeing as Moe took all of the focus yesterday they can hide easily. 

I think it's important to look at low posters who suddenly woke up after Moe was caught and started posting more, a change in posting styles or frequencies could indicate a change in wolves gameplan.

[Boris the Fool]

They wouldn't. That's what I'm trying figure out is it just nrv throwing bluff or a wolf trying to sound like they can be helpful.

I said yesterday about how I disliked the comments about Countess playing a “good game”. It felt like someone talking with insider info that they shouldn’t have. But they were very headstrong vs Moe, and Moes final posts yesterday make me think he was a wolf who didn’t want to risk hurting his own team. But then could it be two wolves who didn’t expect the alpha to be caught so quick and they weren’t planning for the landslide?
I also don’t think it’s particularly helpful to try and landslide Ina today. Fair enough if she’s who we agree on but I personally felt that cause everyone lumped on moe, and lumped on William, there was little motivation to dig deeper on anyone.

I need to catch up on my thoughts I'll do it in a coupe of hours but I don't see an Ina wagon as a number one priority. Not because I think she is definitly village I would like to see a spread of thoughts and get people giving their own opinions. It too easy hide behind wagons.

[Magda the Maid]

Mentioning Bullets again! How is no one else seeing this!!

I just don’t think the vig would be that open

IF I was the vig I could be hiding in plain sight to discourage being munched... 

I'm speaking hypothetically of course 

[Lieutenant Grey]

“Okay Wednesday roll-call folks, settle down. Thanks everyone for their support yesterday and through the night.


We are missing someone. Where is @Jacob the Tailor?


Another business card on the floor here…


“Monica Stevens - Attorney at Law”


Looks like there is something scribbled on the back again.


“@Jacob the Tailor is dead, I told you to leave us alone. Now, more will fall. Prepare for war.”


Everyone gear up, get out there and leave no stone unturned! Prepare for anything that they might throw at you. It's time for these scum to feel the heat.”

Lynch/Yeet form is now open!

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Jacob? I'm not sure what to say on that one. I was really sure he was the traitor wolf from his posts. Thats frazzled me.

[Magda the Maid]

Who would you shoot Jacob if you had a bullet?

Ina or Dora, I think they would be my targets

Gordon sticking out like sore thumb with his vote is interesting, leaning village on him

How about yourself?

I feel like this was the post that got him killed as he didn't have much else going on.

[Magda the Maid]

Did Dexter imply that Jacob was the Vig and the wolves jump on that?

Dexter was right about Moe if that's the case.

[Lilly the Millennial]

Nothing on Friar?

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

No word on what's happened to Friar yet?

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Jacob? I'm not sure what to say on that one. I was really sure he was the traitor wolf from his posts. Thats frazzled me.

I had "mentions the traitor" down against Jacob also

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Nothing on Friar?

Maybe it's 24h from his kidnapping that we'll hear?

[Boris the Fool]

Ina or Dora, I think they would be my targets

Gordon sticking out like sore thumb with his vote is interesting, leaning village on him

How about yourself?

I feel like this was the post that got him killed as he didn't have much else going on.

Interesting.. Very quick off the mark for you to go back pick that post from an hour ago and decide yep this is it. It's almost your a wolf trying to lead the thread

[Magda the Maid]

I feel like this was the post that got him killed as he didn't have much else going on.

Interesting.. Very quick off the mark for you to go back pick that post from an hour ago and decide yep this is it. It's almost your a wolf trying to lead the thread

First thing I do is read the post history of all killed players looking for clues, this was the most obvious post that stood out.

[Kevin the Armorer]

ok... so same as a few others. I noted posts 299 and 484 that he mentioned finding the traitor. He could still have been the traitor though? The the wolves missed the signals.

IF he wasn't the traitor... the other theory that popped out at me on the vote results was Gordon aligning his vote with Moe. Is that a signal? Moe voted first so it seems doubly odd to align with the person the wagon is against.

[Mick the Drunk]

Hang on. I have just thought of something. If both Amy AND Friar are gone, is one the suspect and one is the victim?

Like Ina said, this would be too damaging an effect on the SK to have them be forced off thread for the rest of the day too. I think Amy is just offline. They will hopefully give a good account of themselves later.

Hopefully there's a mechanism to release Friar and he isn't suffering a slow painful death. If he returns, will he have flipped and be corrupted. He may need to be resolved anyway.

All shots fired have been unsuccessful. I know it says Moe is hard to kill and we have nothing to say that he has been the target each time, but I suspect something more at play here.

"Hopefully there's a mechanism to release Friar and he isn't suffering a slow painful death."

Is there a chance he'd be released if we killed the serial killer, do you think the kidnap was the SK. 

These 3 presumed it was Friar coming back when Amy hadnt posted, Kevin has addressed why he thought that

These were all posted before Amy came back. 

I need to go back and look at day 1, ive notes that multiple players didnt think the kidnap was the SK. Need to cross reference those with those above

[Mick the Drunk]

Morning all, are we only down 3 players so far? Potentially 2 more this morning. That leave 15 left. Surely the vig will get a shot off today if they are still alive. The bodies need to start piling up

Who would you shoot Jacob if you had a bullet?

Ina or Dora, I think they would be my targets

Gordon sticking out like sore thumb with his vote is interesting, leaning village on him

How about yourself?

Ina or Dora, I think they would be my targets

Gordon sticking out like sore thumb with his vote is interesting, leaning village on him

How about yourself?

I feel like this was the post that got him killed as he didn't have much else going on.

@Magda the Maid why do you think the above got him killed? The initial post that launched this conversation was around him saying the vig will surely get a shot off today.

[Boris the Fool]

Interesting.. Very quick off the mark for you to go back pick that post from an hour ago and decide yep this is it. It's almost your a wolf trying to lead the thread

First thing I do is read the post history of all killed players looking for clues, this was the most obvious post that stood out.

All in the space of 3 minutes. It's seems a bit rushed to me Magda, it seems like a wolf thing to do. Let's kill Jacob and look he mentioned Ina and Dora an hour ago we can try push a wagon on them easy.

[Magda the Maid]

Did Dexter imply that Jacob was the Vig and the wolves jump on that?

Dexter was right about Moe if that's the case.

Morning all, are we only down 3 players so far? Potentially 2 more this morning. That leave 15 left. Surely the vig will get a shot off today if they are still alive. The bodies need to start piling up

Ina or Dora, I think they would be my targets

Gordon sticking out like sore thumb with his vote is interesting, leaning village on him

How about yourself?

I feel like this was the post that got him killed as he didn't have much else going on.

@Magda the Maid why do you think the above got him killed? The initial post that launched this conversation was around him saying the vig will surely get a shot off today.

As I said up above Did Dexter imply that Jacob was the Vig and the wolves jump on that?

Dexter was right about Moe if that's the case.

[Magda the Maid]

@Dexter the Dragoon any thoughts on Jacobs munch?

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

First thing I do is read the post history of all killed players looking for clues, this was the most obvious post that stood out.

All in the space of 3 minutes. It's seems a bit rushed to me Magda, it seems like a wolf thing to do. Let's kill Jacob and look he mentioned Ina and Dora an hour ago we can try push a wagon on them easy.

See, this is what worries me cause he did the same with Countess and Dora yesterday too.

[Kevin the Armorer]

Like Ina said, this would be too damaging an effect on the SK to have them be forced off thread for the rest of the day too. I think Amy is just offline. They will hopefully give a good account of themselves later.

Hopefully there's a mechanism to release Friar and he isn't suffering a slow painful death. If he returns, will he have flipped and be corrupted. He may need to be resolved anyway.

All shots fired have been unsuccessful. I know it says Moe is hard to kill and we have nothing to say that he has been the target each time, but I suspect something more at play here.

"Hopefully there's a mechanism to release Friar and he isn't suffering a slow painful death."

Is there a chance he'd be released if we killed the serial killer, do you think the kidnap was the SK. 

These 3 presumed it was Friar coming back when Amy hadnt posted, Kevin has addressed why he thought that

I think it was just a genuine typo there in your post but to avoid confusion. I presumed it was Friar that WASN'T coming back. Not that he WAS coming back.

[Boris the Fool]

@Dexter the Dragoon any thoughts on Jacobs munch?

I'd like to hear his thoughts on you. 

@Dexter the Dragoon

[Lieutenant Grey]

“7-Lincoln-200 to Wesley, reports of multiple shots fired in the vicinity of Mid-Wilshire station. Intel has advised that there is a shootout among the factions with our officers caught in the middle. I will update when I get on scene.

…

“7-Lincoln-200 to Wesley. On Scene, Multiple wounded. Multiple dead.

@Magda the Maid been shot twice and is dead
@Dora the Explorer has been shot and is dead”

[Boris the Fool]

Like Ina said, this would be too damaging an effect on the SK to have them be forced off thread for the rest of the day too. I think Amy is just offline. They will hopefully give a good account of themselves later.

Hopefully there's a mechanism to release Friar and he isn't suffering a slow painful death. If he returns, will he have flipped and be corrupted. He may need to be resolved anyway.

All shots fired have been unsuccessful. I know it says Moe is hard to kill and we have nothing to say that he has been the target each time, but I suspect something more at play here.

"Hopefully there's a mechanism to release Friar and he isn't suffering a slow painful death."

Is there a chance he'd be released if we killed the serial killer, do you think the kidnap was the SK. 

These 3 presumed it was Friar coming back when Amy hadnt posted, Kevin has addressed why he thought that

These were all posted before Amy came back. 

I need to go back and look at day 1, ive notes that multiple players didnt think the kidnap was the SK. Need to cross reference those with those above

Mick do some digging on this if you think it's helpful. I don't really understand what you mean but maybe if you find something you can explain.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

“7-Lincoln-200 to Wesley, reports of multiple shots fired in the vicinity of Mid-Wilshire station. Intel has advised that there is a shootout among the factions with our officers caught in the middle. I will update when I get on scene.

…

“7-Lincoln-200 to Wesley. On Scene, Multiple wounded. Multiple dead.

@Magda the Maid been shot twice and is dead
@Dora the Explorer has been shot and is dead”

What the hell is happening.

[Boris the Fool]

Wow ok that was sudden

[Mick the Drunk]

These 3 presumed it was Friar coming back when Amy hadnt posted, Kevin has addressed why he thought that

I think it was just a genuine typo there in your post but to avoid confusion. I presumed it was Friar that WASN'T coming back. Not that he WAS coming back.

Correct, was a typo, all three presumed Friar WASN'T coming back

[Robin the Jester]

“7-Lincoln-200 to Wesley, reports of multiple shots fired in the vicinity of Mid-Wilshire station. Intel has advised that there is a shootout among the factions with our officers caught in the middle. I will update when I get on scene.

…

“7-Lincoln-200 to Wesley. On Scene, Multiple wounded. Multiple dead.

@Magda the Maid been shot twice and is dead
@Dora the Explorer has been shot and is dead”

so magda was the alpha i presume

[Mick the Drunk]

These 3 presumed it was Friar coming back when Amy hadnt posted, Kevin has addressed why he thought that

These were all posted before Amy came back. 

I need to go back and look at day 1, ive notes that multiple players didnt think the kidnap was the SK. Need to cross reference those with those above

Mick do some digging on this if you think it's helpful. I don't really understand what you mean but maybe if you find something you can explain.

Sk hunting, the SK would know who is and isnt coming back. So any of these 3 could be a slip

[Mick the Drunk]

“7-Lincoln-200 to Wesley, reports of multiple shots fired in the vicinity of Mid-Wilshire station. Intel has advised that there is a shootout among the factions with our officers caught in the middle. I will update when I get on scene.

…

“7-Lincoln-200 to Wesley. On Scene, Multiple wounded. Multiple dead.

@Magda the Maid been shot twice and is dead
@Dora the Explorer has been shot and is dead”

Shot twice, Alpha?

[Kevin the Armorer]

Wow ok. WTF. 3 shots. Is there that many to go around from the role descriptions?

If not, there must have been an on thread task to get the extra shots.

[Mick the Drunk]

“7-Lincoln-200 to Wesley, reports of multiple shots fired in the vicinity of Mid-Wilshire station. Intel has advised that there is a shootout among the factions with our officers caught in the middle. I will update when I get on scene.

…

“7-Lincoln-200 to Wesley. On Scene, Multiple wounded. Multiple dead.

@Magda the Maid been shot twice and is dead
@Dora the Explorer has been shot and is dead”

so magda was the alpha i presume

@Dexter the Dragoon any thoughts on this?

[Boris the Fool]

“7-Lincoln-200 to Wesley, reports of multiple shots fired in the vicinity of Mid-Wilshire station. Intel has advised that there is a shootout among the factions with our officers caught in the middle. I will update when I get on scene.

…

“7-Lincoln-200 to Wesley. On Scene, Multiple wounded. Multiple dead.

@Magda the Maid been shot twice and is dead
@Dora the Explorer has been shot and is dead”

so magda was the alpha i presume

So you saying Dexter read was wring all along?