The Rookie Werewolf - Game Thread

[Gordon the Cook]

I couldn’t say I’m 100% until we see the reveal

No one can be. But what way are you falling? Baddie or goodie?

Well I’m assuming bad based on how many people have voted for him.

[Robin the Jester]

Robin didn't I've already called them out on it. I was told earlier to ignore them that's how they play.

It was too ignore his first vote as he always votes randomly on the first vote. I wouldn’t be ignoring him not voting tonight. 

@Robin the Jester why the no vote?

i did. i'm sure the mods will correct the record

[Boris the Fool]

It was too ignore his first vote as he always votes randomly on the first vote. I wouldn’t be ignoring him not voting tonight. 

@Robin the Jester why the no vote?

i did. i'm sure the mods will correct the record

Who did you vote for and what time?

[Lieutenant Grey]

You can't get good help these days

   

[Gordon the Cook]

Some of my. Toes:
Amy the Singer - alive
Benjamin the Alchemist
Boris the Fool - ok for now
Countess Markievicz - Dead
Dexter the Dragoon Suspicious
Dora the Explorer Crazy
Edward the Barber
Friar Tuck - Kidnapped
Gordon the Cook - NRV
Ina May the Midwife - watch this space
Jacob the Tailor
Kevin the Armorer
Lilly The Millennial
Magda the Maid (suspicious)
Mick The Drunk
Moe the Innkeeper Dead
Robin the Jester - chilled
Vincent the Artist - inquisitive
Weyland the Blacksmith
William the Grave Robber DEAD

[Gordon the Cook]

Should say some of my thoughts! ⬆️

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Some of my. Toes:
Amy the Singer - alive
Benjamin the Alchemist
Boris the Fool - ok for now
Countess Markievicz - Dead
Dexter the Dragoon Suspicious
Dora the Explorer Crazy
Edward the Barber
Friar Tuck - Kidnapped
Gordon the Cook - NRV
Ina May the Midwife - watch this space
Jacob the Tailor
Kevin the Armorer
Lilly The Millennial
Magda the Maid (suspicious)
Mick The Drunk
Moe the Innkeeper Dead
Robin the Jester - chilled
Vincent the Artist - inquisitive
Weyland the Blacksmith
William the Grave Robber DEAD

Heads obviously still in the oven because if they're your thoughts I am worried for you. 
What a whole load of nothing

[Vincent the Artist]

Some of my. Toes:
Amy the Singer - alive
Benjamin the Alchemist
Boris the Fool - ok for now
Countess Markievicz - Dead
Dexter the Dragoon Suspicious
Dora the Explorer Crazy
Edward the Barber
Friar Tuck - Kidnapped
Gordon the Cook - NRV
Ina May the Midwife - watch this space
Jacob the Tailor
Kevin the Armorer
Lilly The Millennial
Magda the Maid (suspicious)
Mick The Drunk
Moe the Innkeeper Dead
Robin the Jester - chilled
Vincent the Artist - inquisitive
Weyland the Blacksmith
William the Grave Robber DEAD

A lesson in how to post without making any conclusions whatsoever.
Apart from Magda, who do you suspect and why?

[Gordon the Cook]

Ok goodnight, restaurant now closed. Takings were high, so thanks to all the village team. Open for breakfast tomorrow morning.

[Dora the Explorer]

That's not all that's high. Way-o!!
Must be a gas oven

[Gordon the Cook]

Some of my. Toes:
Amy the Singer - alive
Benjamin the Alchemist
Boris the Fool - ok for now
Countess Markievicz - Dead
Dexter the Dragoon Suspicious
Dora the Explorer Crazy
Edward the Barber
Friar Tuck - Kidnapped
Gordon the Cook - NRV
Ina May the Midwife - watch this space
Jacob the Tailor
Kevin the Armorer
Lilly The Millennial
Magda the Maid (suspicious)
Mick The Drunk
Moe the Innkeeper Dead
Robin the Jester - chilled
Vincent the Artist - inquisitive
Weyland the Blacksmith
William the Grave Robber DEAD

Heads obviously still in the oven because if they're your thoughts I am worried for you. 
What a whole load of nothing

[Gordon the Cook]

Some of my. Toes:
Amy the Singer - alive
Benjamin the Alchemist
Boris the Fool - ok for now
Countess Markievicz - Dead
Dexter the Dragoon Suspicious
Dora the Explorer Crazy
Edward the Barber
Friar Tuck - Kidnapped
Gordon the Cook - NRV
Ina May the Midwife - watch this space
Jacob the Tailor
Kevin the Armorer
Lilly The Millennial
Magda the Maid (suspicious)
Mick The Drunk
Moe the Innkeeper Dead
Robin the Jester - chilled
Vincent the Artist - inquisitive
Weyland the Blacksmith
William the Grave Robber DEAD

A lesson in how to post without making any conclusions whatsoever.
Apart from Magda, who do you suspect and why?

Vincent the artist. - reason - throwing a lot of shade.

[Gordon the Cook]

That's not all that's high. Way-o!!
Must be a gas oven

I’ve been standing up for you. Friendship over!!

[Robin the Jester]

goodnight folks

[Ina May the Midwife]

Ok, fingers crossed it’s not you sending a signal of who you’re shooting next.

Nah I’m not interested in shooting you. Yet. 

Ina I’m coming for you. 

---

[Vincent the Artist]

A lesson in how to post without making any conclusions whatsoever.
Apart from Magda, who do you suspect and why?

Vincent the artist. - reason - throwing a lot of shade.

This is such an OMGUS answer.
Are you saying I shouldn't be poking looking for reasons from people? I really wouldn't call that "shade* but you do you.

[Amy the Singer]

Morning all. Just wondering are there any "trips to the armoury" type contests in this game? They were always mid-morning in Traitors and I usually missed them.
Hoping that the fact that I can post this means I haven't been munched.

[Dora the Explorer]

Vincent the artist. - reason - throwing a lot of shade.

This is such an OMGUS answer.
Are you saying I shouldn't be poking looking for reasons from people? I really wouldn't call that "shade* but you do you.

 
And at 20.25 yesterday he said you were faithful. Flaky like pastry Gordon, sorry

[Boris the Fool]

Morning all. Just wondering are there any "trips to the armoury" type contests in this game? They were always mid-morning in Traitors and I usually missed them.
Hoping that the fact that I can post this means I haven't been munched.

Any thoughts amy? I understand your newish but 16 posts in at this stage and no reads ain't helpful.

[Jacob the Tailor]

Morning all, are we only down 3 players so far? Potentially 2 more this morning. That leave 15 left. Surely the vig will get a shot off today if they are still alive. The bodies need to start piling up

[Edward the Barber]

Is it just me or did Gordon take on a completely different personality last night?

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Is it just me or did Gordon take on a completely different personality last night?

Morning all.

Any examples, Eddy?

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Is it just me or did Gordon take on a completely different personality last night?

Corrupted and gone to the other side?

His list definitely felt forced anyway, in that it was non committal to anything, under the guise of being helpful

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Morning all, are we only down 3 players so far? Potentially 2 more this morning. That leave 15 left. Surely the vig will get a shot off today if they are still alive. The bodies need to start piling up

Who would you shoot Jacob if you had a bullet?

[Edward the Barber]

Is it just me or did Gordon take on a completely different personality last night?

Morning all.

Any examples, Eddy?

They just seemed very quiet and then the read list they produced had nothing on it then the kitchen is closed post

[Kevin the Armorer]

Morning all.

You can't get good help these days

Barely anything to go off of there but it's interesting that Gordon didn't go on the wagon. That feels like a very risky move for a wolf... particularly so if they were losing their alpha. Why stand out like that.

[Edward the Barber]

Is it just me or did Gordon take on a completely different personality last night?

Corrupted and gone to the other side?

His list definitely felt forced anyway, in that it was non committal to anything, under the guise of being helpful

The double post of it was weird as there was no text from him in the first one. And I’m trying to work out what “toes” was a typo for?

[Lilly the Millennial]

Morning all, are we only down 3 players so far? Potentially 2 more this morning. That leave 15 left. Surely the vig will get a shot off today if they are still alive. The bodies need to start piling up

We are down William, Countess and Moe and working with the assumption that Friar is also gone as he was kidnapped

[Amy the Singer]

Morning all. Just wondering are there any "trips to the armoury" type contests in this game? They were always mid-morning in Traitors and I usually missed them.
Hoping that the fact that I can post this means I haven't been munched.

Any thoughts amy? I understand your newish but 16 posts in at this stage and no reads ain't helpful.

I did give one thought on Ina earlier. And I explained my Friar vote on night 1 as being related to a very belligerent defence of Ina. Now that friars kidnapped it looks like he’s a villager, or a wolves trick to kidnap one of their own and then send him back into the game as a bona fide villager later?

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

I think we need to start doing some proper digging - without a priest we don't have any wagonomics but even if we did, we have two runaway wagons and zero FFAs. Can everyone do an FFA today?

For any newbies, that's a list of your top 3 suspects and reasons (even if they're rubbish reasons) for suspecting them - the purpose of this is that it's much easier for villagers to do this than wolves (as they will always be conscious of mentioning / not mentioning other wolves) and also it gives us something to look back on when we catch a wolf.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

This is the list of posters and their posts:

Boris the Fool 67
Friar Tuck 59
Dora the Explorer 58
Magda the Maid 56
Robin the Jester 49
Kevin the Armorer 48
Benjamin the Alchemist 42
Vincent the Artist 40
Dexter the Dragoon 38
Ina May the Midwife 38
Gordon the Cook 37
Lilly the Millennial 34
Edward the Barber 30
Mick the Drunk 26
Weyland the Blacksmith 25
Jacob the Tailor 19
Amy the Singer 16

I'm going to pick 3 to analyse - anyone care to join me in taking 3?

I'll look at Boris, Benji and Jacob

[Edward the Barber]

"7-Lincoln-200 to all units... Kidnapping in progress on the corner of seventh and Main. All units to Location."

....
...

"7-Adam-100 to 7-Lincoln-200.. At location, suspect and victim gone. spoke to witness. Suspect fits the description of Rosalind Dyer"

@Amy the Singer you checked in like the rest of us yesterday based on this post.

[Jacob the Tailor]

Morning all, are we only down 3 players so far? Potentially 2 more this morning. That leave 15 left. Surely the vig will get a shot off today if they are still alive. The bodies need to start piling up

Who would you shoot Jacob if you had a bullet?

Ina or Dora, I think they would be my targets

Gordon sticking out like sore thumb with his vote is interesting, leaning village on him

How about yourself?

[Lilly the Millennial]

Any thoughts amy? I understand your newish but 16 posts in at this stage and no reads ain't helpful.

I did give one thought on Ina earlier. And I explained my Friar vote on night 1 as being related to a very belligerent defence of Ina. Now that friars kidnapped it looks like he’s a villager, or a wolves trick to kidnap one of their own and then send him back into the game as a bona fide villager later?

The kidnapper was the SK, not a wolf so Friar could still be a wolf

[Amy the Singer]

"7-Lincoln-200 to all units... Kidnapping in progress on the corner of seventh and Main. All units to Location."

....
...

"7-Adam-100 to 7-Lincoln-200.. At location, suspect and victim gone. spoke to witness. Suspect fits the description of Rosalind Dyer"

@Amy the Singer you checked in like the rest of us yesterday based on this post.

Okay so my grip on this game is tenuous at best, but I genuinely don’t know what you mean by this 🤔

[Magda the Maid]

Hypothetically if someone had a bullet and had suspicions on who the SK might be and who a wolf might be. Is the logical thing here to aim for the wolf as the SK needs to kill wolves as well?

[Lilly the Millennial]

Hypothetically if someone had a bullet and had suspicions on who the SK might be and who a wolf might be.  Is the logical thing here to aim for the wolf as the SK needs to kill wolves as well?

The plus side of keeping the SK is that they can help us kill the wolf but the downside is that they may end up killing more villagers and reduce our numbers quicker

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Hypothetically if someone had a bullet and had suspicions on who the SK might be and who a wolf might be.  Is the logical thing here to aim for the wolf as the SK needs to kill wolves as well?

No, IMO. Kill the SK as it reduces the kill rate; wolves want to keep the kill rate as high as possible

[Gordon the Cook]

Hypothetically if someone had a bullet and had suspicions on who the SK might be and who a wolf might be.  Is the logical thing here to aim for the wolf as the SK needs to kill wolves as well?

Mentioning Bullets again! How is no one else seeing this!!

[Lilly the Millennial]

Hypothetically if someone had a bullet and had suspicions on who the SK might be and who a wolf might be.  Is the logical thing here to aim for the wolf as the SK needs to kill wolves as well?

Mentioning Bullets again! How is no one else seeing this!!

I just don’t think the vig would be that open