The Traitors- Boards/FOG Edition

[Donald the Spoofer]

some players have asked, why Magda? Traitors will likely have picked someone who can't be linked back to them. So someone with little interaction and not on anyones list would be a good pick.

If its murder in plain sight there has to be some interaction

You mean to commit the murder? My point was why they might have picked magda in the first place

[McDonald the Farmer]

Dunno what’s niggling at you tbh. I win a prize, I used prize on myself, I made the choice to declare what I did on thread when there was a possibility that I (like others) could be banished. I had no need to hide and better that as much info as possible out in the open should I die.

Can you provide the exact name of the prize you won? We know the kill prize was called an "Insta banish"

Didn’t have a name. Just congratulations you have won the prize to remove one player who was on trial for murder.

[William the Grave Robber]

Traitors tipple

[Chris the Carpenter]

Tratiors Tipple

[Betty the Beggar]

Gordon and Pat seem the ones for me

Gordon said - "exactly. maybe ask magda that, it was them casting that weird wide aspersion."

Pat made a correction on Maeve/Magda

[Maeve the Madam]

Oh, can you do that? Traitors Tipple for me too so please.

[Rhoda the Spinster]

Gordon and Pat seem the ones for me

Gordon said - "exactly. maybe ask magda that, it was them casting that weird wide aspersion."

Pat made a correction on Maeve/Magda

Was that before or after banishment? Only watched one series  and first traitors game. Do we know if murders in plain sight are always after banishment in show? Does the game follow the show rules.

Bearing them in mind anyway as someone to watch for, along with Zeena and Weyland.

[Dora the Explorer]

Gordon and Pat seem the ones for me

Gordon said - "exactly. maybe ask magda that, it was them casting that weird wide aspersion."

Pat made a correction on Maeve/Magda

Are you traitor trying to push it in a certain direction? 

Whats your thoughts on the zeena comment just before the results of the round table last night?? Did it make any sense to you??

[William the Grave Robber]

Assuming the Bona Fidas of yesterday's claim, id alignment check you and Pat.

The shield, it would depend on the caveats that came with it.

Insta banish Betty or Dora at this point but would wait until closer to the roundtable and todays activities

@William the Grave Robber what about you

I would alignment check McD and Dora.
Banish Zeena

[William the Grave Robber]

What prize would you choose yourself @William the Grave Robber and who would you use it on?

I'd choose the banish. Use it on Zeena.
Could use it on you too though. Few posts and disappear. Wouldn't mind disappearing you permanently

[William the Grave Robber]

10 people won yesterday.

2 prizes definitely used. 1 supposedly used. I think there was at least one more prize. Double vote, possibly even a blocked vote too.

Therefore as I said yesterday there's at least one traitor in the 10. That's where I'll be voting today

[Gordon the Cook]

Whats left? Can i have a Traitor’s Tipple
if not, can i have a Faithful’s Fancy please.

[Gordon the Cook]

mcdonald, can you stop flooding the thread. its making it unreadable and only helping the traitors.

[Prada the Seamstress]

@McDonald the Farmer has been removed from being on trial for murder.

An Insta Banishment has been used. No, this has nothing to do with Instragram, before all you horrible influencers get excited! 

A player has been banished from the castle immediately. One moment please....

I removed myself from list just incase I’m banished.

I removed myself from list just incase I’m banished.

can you explain that please

can you explain that please

I won the power to remove a player from trial. Of course I chose myself

Can you provide the exact name of the prize you won? We know the kill prize was called an "Insta banish"

Didn’t have a name. Just congratulations you have won the prize to remove one player who was on trial for murder.

This is what is niggling me @McDonald the Farmer the prize was being removed from trial for murder. But you removed yourself from banishment. 
It didn't save you from banishment, it saved you from murder.

[Gordon the Cook]

Gordon and Pat seem the ones for me

Gordon said - "exactly. maybe ask magda that, it was them casting that weird wide aspersion."

Pat made a correction on Maeve/Magda

Amy the Singer Wrote: [/url]

Betty wasn't given that info, just that Benjamin and Vincent have the same alignment.

The Traitors are probably less likely to murder Vincent now as his reveal will either clear or implicated Benji. So, "Pat the Baker", it's between you and I for murder.

Magda the Maid Wrote:

Well it is a game of deception so there's always the possibility that the alignment is a tactic so that the Traitors can murder Vincent to "clear" Benjamin.

Afternoon all.

Gordon the Cook Wrote: [url=https://forumofgames.com/showthread.php?pid=97415#pid97415]

That only works if betty is a traitor. Why would faithful:betty lie about them being alligned?

Betty the Beggar wrote:

And if I was a traitor why would I stick my head above the paraphet like that

which is the reason i wrote:

exactly. maybe ask magda that, it was them casting that weird wide aspersion.

I found it odd enough behavior from you yesterday, but now, bringing up the same interaction against me? Did you ever ask Magda about that? Please show me those interactions.

Why did you call your vote yesterday self preservation, when all you were doing was saving zeena, not yourself?

[Betty the Beggar]

Gordon and Pat seem the ones for me

Gordon said - "exactly. maybe ask magda that, it was them casting that weird wide aspersion."

Pat made a correction on Maeve/Magda

Was that before or after banishment? Only watched one series  and first traitors game. Do we know if murders in plain sight are always after banishment in show? Does the game follow the show rules.

Bearing them in mind anyway as someone to watch for, along with Zeena and Weyland.

I wouldn't rule out before or after the banishment. As I said, this is the only time Magda was explicitly mentioned. If they did have to name check a player its odd that they picked someone with so few posts, these stand out because it only happens twice

[Betty the Beggar]

Gordon and Pat seem the ones for me

Gordon said - "exactly. maybe ask magda that, it was them casting that weird wide aspersion."

Pat made a correction on Maeve/Magda

Are you traitor trying to push it in a certain direction? 

Whats your thoughts on the zeena comment just before the results of the round table last night?? Did it make any sense to you??

No, I'm trying to solve the game and see what makes sense.
I found it odd that she didn't use their names or really give any explanation other than "read my posts"

[Betty the Beggar]

10 people won yesterday.

2 prizes definitely used. 1 supposedly used. I think there was at least one more prize. Double vote, possibly even a blocked vote too.

Therefore as I said yesterday there's at least one traitor in the 10. That's where I'll be voting today

10 people won yesterday - winners were chosen from a group of 10 was my reading, Lorcan specifically said "prize(s)", so it was unclear how many

[Boris the Fool]

@Friar Tuck

@Boris the Fool

@Chris the Carpenter

@Weyland the Blacksmith

If you were lucky enough to win a prize today. What prize (let's assume the same prizes as yesterday )would you choose and how would you use it?

Just catching up - unlikely to win a prize as I’m busy all day. What were the prizes yesterday? A double votes, an instant banishment? What else? 
i suppose that in the event of ever winning a prize a double vote would be nice 😊

[Rhoda the Spinster]

I think it's important for us to clarify whether suspicious Magda interactions/namechecks etc.happened before or after banishment when trying to decide what are most likely candidates for killed in plain sight.

If anyone has more info on the show and the game could they let the group know whether murders in plain sight in the show or game have ever happened before banishment?
Does anyone who has previously played Traitors know if the game is faithful to the show in terms of rules?

The Magda kill is one of the best pieces of information we have at the moment.

[lorcand1990]

Hi folks

Sincere apologies,  I made a mistake on yesterday's Murder in Plain Sight.

Magda should not have been the target. @Maeve the Madam was the target

Apologies also to Magda who was caught up in that

As a result, to make things fair to everyone I have to remove @Maeve the Madam as they were the original target for murder in plain sight

I have balanced this extra kill in the background to make it as fair as possible 

Apologies again.  Feel free to rip the piss out of me later

[Gordon the Cook]

Whats left? Can i have a Traitor’s Tipple
if not, can i have a Faithful’s Fancy please.

I was too late. here is the tally.

ff mcd, rhoda, betty, tuck, pat, laura, donald.
tt prada, dora, ina, vincent, william, chris, maeve.

the tt's are a more faithful looking bunch than the ff's.

[Gordon the Cook]

mcdonald, please don't now repeat spamming the thread with tons of maeve posts.

[Rhoda the Spinster]

Surely it's Pat as a traitor then, if they made the Maeve/Magda correction?

[Rhoda the Spinster]

Hi folks

Sincere apologies,  I made a mistake on yesterday's Murder in Plain Sight.

Magda should not have been the target. @Maeve the Madam was the target

Apologies also to Magda who was caught up in that

As a result, to make things fair to everyone I have to remove @Maeve the Madam as they were the original target for murder in plain sight

I have balanced this extra kill in the background to make it as fair as possible 

Apologies again.  Feel free to rip the piss out of me later

Why would we wait till later? 🤔

[Betty the Beggar]

Answers sent I think. I know it's too late but can you confirm they went through. I'm not used to this interface so had to make a couple of attempts.
Thanks.

@Maeve the Madam what are your thoughts? You appeared around the time of the task also? Did you get an alert telling you?

If Amy isn't murdered tonight, she's going in my suspect list. If she says "I'm faithful " one more time!

I don't want to vote for anyone as I'm still finding following the thread very difficult with all the multi quotes etc (I'll never say a bad word about Boards format again).
However as I've to pick somebody it will have to be Amy as she appears to be popping up everywhere saying she's Faithful. Maybe the lady doth protest too much. Sorry if you are .

VOTE Amy the Singer.

I find this post by Maeve to be strange - it’s like she is just copying Zeena’s theory from earlier. I’m pretty sure it was also her that reworded a post by Amy like it was hers earlier. 

Vote: Maeve

These are the only two explicit mentions of Maeve

[lorcand1990]

Congratulations to:

McDonald the Farmer
Rhoda the Spinster
Betty the Beggar
Friar Tuck
Pat the Baker
Laura the Lace Mistress
Donald the Spoofer

You have won a trip to the Armoury. Winners will be PM'd as soon as possible!

[Pat the Baker]

Surely it's Pat as a traitor then, if they made the Maeve/Magda correction?

So because Lorcan also mixed them up then it must be me 🙄

[Pat the Baker]

Congratulations to:

McDonald the Farmer
Rhoda the Spinster
Betty the Beggar
Friar Tuck
Pat the Baker
Laura the Lace Mistress
Donald the Spoofer

You have won a trip to the Armoury. Winners will be PM'd as soon as possible!

No prize here yet

[Donald the Spoofer]

Ok folks, I have won an insta banishment, I have until thread closes to use it, thoughts

[Dora the Explorer]

@Maeve the Madam what are your thoughts? You appeared around the time of the task also? Did you get an alert telling you?

I find this post by Maeve to be strange - it’s like she is just copying Zeena’s theory from earlier. I’m pretty sure it was also her that reworded a post by Amy like it was hers earlier. 

Vote: Maeve

These are the only two explicit mentions of Maeve

Had a look myself. Would it be that it has to be activated before end of day yesterday? I can't see prada making the call early in the day and that leaves pat

[McDonald the Farmer]

@McDonald the Farmer has been removed from being on trial for murder.

An Insta Banishment has been used. No, this has nothing to do with Instragram, before all you horrible influencers get excited! 

A player has been banished from the castle immediately. One moment please....

I removed myself from list just incase I’m banished.

can you explain that please

I won the power to remove a player from trial. Of course I chose myself

Didn’t have a name. Just congratulations you have won the prize to remove one player who was on trial for murder.

This is what is niggling me @McDonald the Farmer the prize was being removed from trial for murder. But you removed yourself from banishment. 
It didn't save you from banishment, it saved you from murder.

It’s my lack of punctuation and grammar that’s causing the confusion. 

10am mod post has a “list” of 5 players up for murder. 
I received a prize in the quiz which allowed me to remove someone that was up for murder. As I was one of the 5 on the “list” I removed myself. 
Mod confirms on thread that McDonald has been removed from trial. They don’t say who removed them and I know I’m not obligated to say. 
Mod then says someone has been banished and just incase it’s my name that comes up in their next post I quickly post that I removed myself from list. I definitely could have worded this better but I rushed to post. 
I was talking about using my prize of removing myself from being murdered.

[Rhoda the Spinster]

Surely it's Pat as a traitor then, if they made the Maeve/Magda correction?

So because Lorcan also mixed them up then it must be me 🙄

Most likely option to me. Also you are one of the few people to reference Maeve.

Murder in plain sight, whoever you vote for is murdered. So you voted off wagon. Because otherwise what is the point in wasting it on someone who is likely to be banished anyway.
How you voted was confusing as you clarified Magda not Maeve, hence Lorcan getting confused too. 

Fits as far as I can see.

[McDonald the Farmer]

mcdonald, please don't now repeat spamming the thread with tons of maeve posts.

Spoilsport 😢

[Pat the Baker]

So because Lorcan also mixed them up then it must be me 🙄

Most likely option to me. Also you are one of the few people to reference Maeve.

Murder in plain sight, whoever you vote for is murdered. So you voted off wagon. Because otherwise what is the point in wasting it on someone who is likely to be banished anyway.
How you voted was confusing as you clarified Magda not Maeve, hence Lorcan getting confused too. 

Fits as far as I can see.

No my vote was correct as I voted for her due to the comment amount Amy saying she was faithful a lot - it was a copy of an earlier comment. The comment I got mixed up was the one someone repeated Amy’s theory - the look back wouldn’t have changed my vote. 

I don’t think voting off wagon would be the mechanic as I wasn’t the only one to do so, therefore we can’t all be traitors

[Donald the Spoofer]

I'm going to be offline for awhile, please discuss who we should insta banish

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Is anyone taking any notice of my posts? I think Zeena put in the kill order.

Yeah I was following what you were posting I was waiting for you to put in a bit of insight at the end..

That post from Zeena was odd at the time and I did call her out on it and explain which I think she ignored. Are you basing it purely on the anagram in it?

I didn't ignore you. Someone else asked the same question,  and I pointed you (or someone anyway to my post). I already had my suspicions on Amy- clearly incorrect- and Gordon as well as one of the more over- helpful posters and my suspicions generally. 

I'm on the plane now and only on p17 of the thread. I'll try get to most recent post, but suffice it to say in the meantime, you have it wrong.

[Rhoda the Spinster]

Most likely option to me. Also you are one of the few people to reference Maeve.

Murder in plain sight, whoever you vote for is murdered. So you voted off wagon. Because otherwise what is the point in wasting it on someone who is likely to be banished anyway.
How you voted was confusing as you clarified Magda not Maeve, hence Lorcan getting confused too. 

Fits as far as I can see.

No my vote was correct as I voted for her due to the comment amount Amy saying she was faithful a lot - it was a copy of an earlier comment. The comment I got mixed up was the one someone repeated Amy’s theory - the look back wouldn’t have changed my vote. 

I don’t think voting off wagon would be the mechanic as I wasn’t the only one to do so, therefore we can’t all be traitors

I'm claiming that voting for her was the mechanic.
You voted off wagon in this scenario as it's a waste of a kill otherwise if you placed a kill on someone who was banished beforehand.

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Anagrams are a feature I. This game and you will find MAGDA within Amy and Gordon

Actually, now that I look at the voting - Amy & Gordon voted for Zeena but they're weren't the last two voters or anything: 

zeena - prada, gordon, mcdonald, william, rhoda, amy
zeena - prada, gordon, mcdonald, william, rhoda, amy
@Zeena Warrior Princess, why did you "Poo" those two voters in particular?

Poo was me being upset as I thought I lost the vote.My explanation, much luke anyone else's at this stage,  purely subjective and I've explained it in my previous post there. Sorry for brevity

[William the Grave Robber]

Hi folks

Sincere apologies,  I made a mistake on yesterday's Murder in Plain Sight.

Magda should not have been the target. @Maeve the Madam was the target

Apologies also to Magda who was caught up in that

As a result, to make things fair to everyone I have to remove @Maeve the Madam as they were the original target for murder in plain sight

I have balanced this extra kill in the background to make it as fair as possible 

Apologies again.  Feel free to rip the piss out of me later

Hard to be 100% with these things lorc😉 I forgive you