The Traitors- Boards/FOG Edition

[Vincent the Artist]

Interesting and understandable, I wonder does that mean there could still be a shielded player too?

[Vincent the Artist]

@Kevin the Armorer you have been banished from the castle immediately

Please reveal now if you are a traitor or faithful, or else I will reveal it for you shortly.

Just bumping this to the next page.

[McDonald the Farmer]

What strikes me as interesting is that @Betty the Beggar suddenly appeared when the task was announced. Prompted to jump in by a fellow traitor perhaps??

Betty is between myself and Pat in list. I sent PM at 20 past and Pat’s post time declaring says 21 past

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

can you explain that please

I won the power to remove a player from trial. Of course I chose myself

and there was me thinking friar tuck might have won it.


Friar Tuck Wrote:

Ooh a trip to the Armoury, sounds dangerous 😆 thanks @lorcand1990

[McDonald the Farmer]

I won the power to remove a player from trial. Of course I chose myself

and there was me thinking friar tuck might have won it.


Friar Tuck Wrote:

Ooh a trip to the Armoury, sounds dangerous 😆 thanks @lorcand1990

 Someone has played an insta banishment though so could be more than one prize

[Vincent the Artist]

What strikes me as interesting is that @Betty the Beggar suddenly appeared when the task was announced. Prompted to jump in by a fellow traitor perhaps??

Betty is between myself and Pat in list. I sent PM at 20 past and Pat’s post time declaring says 21 past

Are you thinking Pat and Betty are linked or just looking at the timing?

My thoughts are mainly that Betty had not posted at all until after the task announcement where there were prizes to be had.

[Betty the Beggar]

I got an alignment result on two players, both aligned. I’m not going to name them yet but hopefully it helps me figure this out

[McDonald the Farmer]

Betty is between myself and Pat in list. I sent PM at 20 past and Pat’s post time declaring says 21 past

Are you thinking Pat and Betty are linked or just looking at the timing?

My thoughts are mainly that Betty had not posted at all until after the task announcement where there were prizes to be had.

Just noting the timing. 

@Benjamin the Alchemist Betty says your posts are suss. Anything to say to her?

And that’s now 3 declared prizes

[lorcand1990]

Kevin the Armourer was.....

A Faithful

[Pat the Baker]

What strikes me as interesting is that @Betty the Beggar suddenly appeared when the task was announced. Prompted to jump in by a fellow traitor perhaps??

Betty is between myself and Pat in list. I sent PM at 20 past and Pat’s post time declaring says 21 past

Just to confirm mine was sent at 20 past and then posted in here. I’ve no alignment to Betty though.

[Vincent the Artist]

That leaves Amy, Pat and myself up for murder tonight then...

[McDonald the Farmer]

Betty is between myself and Pat in list. I sent PM at 20 past and Pat’s post time declaring says 21 past

Just to confirm mine was sent at 20 past and then posted in here. I’ve no alignment to Betty though.

So Betty also sent PM at 20 past. Just worth noting when she actually participated in the game versus posting in the game thread.

[Ina May the Midwife]

Just to confirm mine was sent at 20 past and then posted in here. I’ve no alignment to Betty though.

So Betty also sent PM at 20 past. Just worth noting when she actually participated in the game versus posting in the game thread.

That's a good spot - Betty appears to have submitted her answers to the quiz before she made her first post in the thread at 1126?
 
She then posted at 1133 saying that she had her answers in

[Betty the Beggar]

Answers in

I sent my answers at 11.20, then came back and saw I needed to post here. 
The timing of my first post with the prizes is a coincidence, I wouldn't read too much into it. I actually thought i had put in an hello earlier before I read the thread but obviously didn't hit post

[Gordon the Cook]

@Kevin the Armorer you have been banished from the castle immediately

Please reveal now if you are a traitor or faithful, or else I will reveal it for you shortly.

So, the baker 5 become the baker 3

[Gordon the Cook]

I got an alignment result on two players, both aligned. I’m not going to name them yet but hopefully it helps me figure this out

i don't know why you wouldn't share the info. if you die, the info is lost.

[Gordon the Cook]

I got an alignment result on two players, both aligned. I’m not going to name them yet but hopefully it helps me figure this out

i don't know why you wouldn't share the info. if you die, the info is lost.

also, while its your secret that is known about, you are in danger.
if everybody knows, then you become just like everybody else again, and not a target.

[Ina May the Midwife]

I agree - the traitors already know who's aligned and who's not.

Unless of course you're fibbing about what the prize was?

[Ina May the Midwife]

Am I right in saying Kevin hadn't posted before being killed?

Seems more likely that he was killed by a faithful anyway - the traitors would hardly knock off a non-posting faithful

[Amy the Singer]

I got an alignment result on two players, both aligned. I’m not going to name them yet but hopefully it helps me figure this out

Might be no harm to name them now as we've already lost one player.

I'm guessing Kevin the Armourer was banished by a traitor, so there's a traitor in the list of winners.

[William the Grave Robber]

Kevin the Armourer was.....

A Faithful

That was me by the way. Sorry Kev

Had to insta banish someone, had to be used today.

I wanted to keep it in the pool of 5, 4 once McDonald removed themselves. Chose Kevin as they hadn't posted and wanted to check why a non poster was chosen.

[Gordon the Cook]

I got an alignment result on two players, both aligned. I’m not going to name them yet but hopefully it helps me figure this out

Might be no harm to name them now as we've already lost one player.

I'm guessing Kevin the Armourer was banished by a traitor, so there's a traitor in the list of winners.

This does not make sense. Please run me your thought process to coming up with this, or fix the typo

[Amy the Singer]

@Kevin the Armorer you have been banished from the castle immediately

Please reveal now if you are a traitor or faithful, or else I will reveal it for you shortly.

So, the baker 5 become the baker 3

It would be handy if Betty had one of the three in her check.

[Amy the Singer]

Might be no harm to name them now as we've already lost one player.

I'm guessing Kevin the Armourer was banished by a traitor, so there's a traitor in the list of winners.

This does not make sense. Please run me your thought process to coming up with this, or fix the typo

Why would a faithful use an insta banishment at this stage with nothing to go on? That's my thought process here.

[Gordon the Cook]

Kevin the Armourer was.....

A Faithful

That was me by the way. Sorry Kev

Had to insta banish someone, had to be used today.

I wanted to keep it in the pool of 5, 4 once McDonald removed themselves. Chose Kevin as they hadn't posted and wanted to check why a non poster was chosen.

hopefully not a new player

a decent look for you william.

[McDonald the Farmer]

Answers in

I sent my answers at 11.20, then came back and saw I needed to post here. 
The timing of my first post with the prizes is a coincidence, I wouldn't read too much into it. I actually thought i had put in an hello earlier before I read the thread but obviously didn't hit post

Quote “I sent my answers at 11.20, then came back and saw I needed to post here.”

11.20 quiz answers submitted
11.26 you posted about Boris’s posts being forced. 
11.33 declares in thread that quiz answers submitted 
11.35 quotes your own 11.26 post saying you obviously meant benji not Boris. 


Why would it be obvious you meant benji not Boris?
why doesn’t your quote above align with what you actually did?

[Amy the Singer]

@Amy the Singer (me)
@Pat the Baker
@Vincent the Artist

One of us three will be murdered, @Betty the Beggar did you include any of us three in your alignment check?

[Gordon the Cook]

This does not make sense. Please run me your thought process to coming up with this, or fix the typo

Why would a faithful use an insta banishment at this stage with nothing to go on? That's my thought process here.

Because they won one.
William owned up to it, a traitor would not. imho.

a traitor takes out somebody they think is harmful to them, and says nothing. not a zero poster.

[Amy the Singer]

Kevin the Armourer was.....

A Faithful

That was me by the way. Sorry Kev

Had to insta banish someone, had to be used today.

I wanted to keep it in the pool of 5, 4 once McDonald removed themselves. Chose Kevin as they hadn't posted and wanted to check why a non poster was chosen.

Why didn't you wait until later to see how today played out?

[Amy the Singer]

@McDonald the Farmer, did you win a prize to remove yourself from the murder list?

[Amy the Singer]

Why would a faithful use an insta banishment at this stage with nothing to go on? That's my thought process here.

Because they won one.
William owned up to it, a traitor would not. imho.

a traitor takes out somebody they think is harmful to them, and says nothing. not a zero poster.

Or that's what a traitor wants us to think.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

I missed a fair bit by the looks of the last couple of hours

[McDonald the Farmer]

I already said I did, Amy.

[Dora the Explorer]

Buenas tardes

Hey was working this morning so only catching up.

Kevin being faithful makes the insta banish feel more like a safe play, it removes a quiet player but doesn’t really give us any info.

@McDonald the Farmer using his power on himself makes sense.

@Betty the Beggar showing up around the task has been covered and seems to check out, so probably not much in that now.

@Benjamin the Alchemist getting mentioned a couple of times now too it would be good to hear where he’s actually at.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Kevin the Armourer was.....

A Faithful

That was me by the way. Sorry Kev

Had to insta banish someone, had to be used today.

I wanted to keep it in the pool of 5, 4 once McDonald removed themselves. Chose Kevin as they hadn't posted and wanted to check why a non poster was chosen.

This isnt a good look other than owning up to it, you'd plenty of time to sit with it surely?

I thought it was interesting Kevin was picked, my thoughts, which ill air now, were there was a no poster wolf who hadn't arrived yet. You've at least narrowed the pool if im correct on that one

[Donald the Spoofer]

Kevin the Armourer was.....

A Faithful

That was me by the way. Sorry Kev

Had to insta banish someone, had to be used today.

I wanted to keep it in the pool of 5, 4 once McDonald removed themselves. Chose Kevin as they hadn't posted and wanted to check why a non poster was chosen.

Could you not confer with everyone here who to pick? Seems strange that you would do it without mentioning you have the power first. You did own up to it though, I guess you could have said nothing so that make you look good

[Gordon the Cook]

Because they won one.
William owned up to it, a traitor would not. imho.

a traitor takes out somebody they think is harmful to them, and says nothing. not a zero poster.

Or that's what a traitor wants us to think.

You think a traitor takes a risk like that day 1, when there is zero suspicion on them?
Maybe build up a few things that make them sus, before checking if they can fly by throwing them off cliff

[William the Grave Robber]

That was me by the way. Sorry Kev

Had to insta banish someone, had to be used today.

I wanted to keep it in the pool of 5, 4 once McDonald removed themselves. Chose Kevin as they hadn't posted and wanted to check why a non poster was chosen.

Why didn't you wait until later to see how today played out?

Could have waited of course.
Gave my reasons why I didn't.

If you had an insta banishment who would you go with?

[Donald the Spoofer]

Also, someone said they got 2 alignments? I dont see any reason they should keep it to themselves. The more we know the better.

[Ina May the Midwife]

Buenas tardes

Hey was working this morning so only catching up.

Kevin being faithful makes the insta banish feel more like a safe play, it removes a quiet player but doesn’t really give us any info.

@McDonald the Farmer  using his power on himself makes sense.

@Betty the Beggar showing up around the task has been covered and seems to check out, so probably not much in that now.

@Benjamin the Alchemist  getting mentioned a couple of times now too it would be good to hear where he’s actually at.

@Betty the Beggar showing up around the task has been covered and seems to check out, so probably not much in that now.

Why would you say there's not much in it? If anything, it seems to me like one of the few items of interest so far