The Traitors- Boards/FOG Edition

[William the Grave Robber]

What the hell is the 5th one! Are the letters correct lorc?

[Laura the Lace Mistress]

Is a "read", your judgement or opinion on another player? If so, 19 is a lot especially so early.

All I have to go on is the list of 5 which may or may not include 1 or more traitors. I also agree with @William the Grave Robber in watching the high posters as there is likely a traitor in that group. All that is to say, I have nothing to go on.

[lorcand1990]

What the hell is the 5th one! Are the letters correct lorc?

Yes all are laid out correctly

[William the Grave Robber]

What the hell is the 5th one! Are the letters correct lorc?

Ignore got it

[Prada the Seamstress]

Same thoughts as everyone, are the 5 all faithful or is it a bluff hiding one of their own in plain sight... or is it a double bluff. Things get interesting when you consider the triple bluff.

This is always what messes the most with my head on werewolf. Trying to predict what the wolves have actually done.
My take is 5 players are up for trial, which seems to be just narrowing down the pool of players up for murder tonight.
We need to not let it distract us too much, and focus on players posts and actions in the first instance, rather than try figure out if they would/would not have included a wolf on the list.
There is so little to go on as of now, it felt like the first half of the day yesterday was just hi, how are you posts for instance. Getting bogged down on which of the 5 is a traitor won't help.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

What the hell is the 5th one! Are the letters correct lorc?

Ignore got it

clever boy. or too clever?

if a traitor you'd ask in your backroom for the answers. did you ask on thread knowing someone might think this?

[Prada the Seamstress]

Answers gone in from me also, PM sent at 11:11 just before I wrote my post above.

[Pat the Baker]

Answers gone in

[Pat the Baker]

Ignore got it

clever boy. or too clever?

if a traitor you'd ask in your backroom for the answers. did you ask on thread knowing someone might think this?

As per the rules the traitors can’t confer on the answers

[Friar Tuck]

My years of Wordle finally paid off! I was sweating trying to get a couple of them though 😌

[Vincent the Artist]

Answers in now! Some of those were hard!!

[Betty the Beggar]

Seems to be a lot of theories flying around already, not sure how much we can take out of anything yet.
Boris is the only one who stood out, his interaction felt a bit forced. Not saying there’s anything in it yet, but it’s probably the only thing that felt slightly off so far.
Otherwise I’d be wary of overreading things this early, most of this is just people filling space

[McDonald the Farmer]

I'd say there's likely a traitor in the 5 of us listed. @McDonald the Farmer post about Lilly the Millenial is sticking out to me as a possible task.

We're more than likely going to banish a faithful at this stage of the game so if we banish one of the 5 and another is murdered that only leaves 3 unknowns.

Fancy a race McDonald?

No thanks, Amy. I’d rather put some work in having reads on all players and should I be murdered or banished then at least my fellow faithfuls have some of my thoughts to work with. 

The Lilly thing was a mistake on my part. I have no task to do.

[Friar Tuck]

For clarity I sent them in a little while ago, just posting about it now cos ai didnt realise that was a thing

[Laura the Lace Mistress]

You have to post here too after you PM the answers? Ooops
Consider this my "answers in" post so

[Betty the Beggar]

Answers in

[Betty the Beggar]

Seems to be a lot of theories flying around already, not sure how much we can take out of anything yet.
Boris is the only one who stood out, his interaction felt a bit forced. Not saying there’s anything in it yet, but it’s probably the only thing that felt slightly off so far.
Otherwise I’d be wary of overreading things this early, most of this is just people filling space

Obviously Benji, not Boris. Lorcans is the only head scrambled

[Prada the Seamstress]

Welcome @Betty the Beggar With that, I think the players left to post are:
@Frank the Tank
@Kevin the Armorer
@Lilly the Millennial
@Magda the Maid
@Rhoda the Spinster

[McDonald the Farmer]

Answer in at 11:20

[lorcand1990]

Congratulations to:

Benjamin the Alchemist
Ina May the Midwife
Prada the Seamstress
Friar Tuck
Laura the Lace Mistress
McDonald the Farmer
Betty the Beggar
Pat the Baker
Vincent the Artist
William the Graverobber

who answered the quickest and have won a trip to the Armoury. I will PM winner(s) shortly. For clarity, I will randomise the 10 correct entries in order to determine who wins a prize(s)

[Vincent the Artist]

What strikes me as interesting is that @Betty the Beggar suddenly appeared when the task was announced. Prompted to jump in by a fellow traitor perhaps??

[Gordon the Cook]

Answers gone in 45 minutes after completion opens.
If you not in, you can’t win.
Don’t taste my chances though

[Gordon the Cook]

Is a "read", your judgement or opinion on another player? If so, 19 is a lot especially so early.

All I have to go on is the list of 5 which may or may not include 1 or more traitors. I also agree with @William the Grave Robber in watching the high posters as there is likely a traitor in that group. All that is to say, I have nothing to go on.

More likely to be traitors at the bottom of the barrel, struggling to post because they frozen and don’t know what to post.
 Finding the loud power wolf is not something you should try straight out as a newbie, as you will hit a lot of innocents that way.
 Having people talk is good for the game/ thread.
 If we kill all the high posters, the thread becomes dead and the traitors lurk to end game in a dead thread.

[Maeve the Madam]

Answers sent I think. I know it's too late but can you confirm they went through. I'm not used to this interface so had to make a couple of attempts.
Thanks.

[Friar Tuck]

Ooh a trip to the Armoury, sounds dangerous 😆 thanks @lorcand1990

[lorcand1990]

@McDonald the Farmer has been removed from being on trial for murder.

[lorcand1990]

Answers sent I think. I know it's too late but can you confirm they went through. I'm not used to this interface so had to make a couple of attempts.
Thanks.

Have PM'd you now

[Gordon the Cook]

Ooh a trip to the Armoury, sounds dangerous 😆 thanks @lorcand1990

I think you said you don’t know the shoe.
Trip to armoury = random chance of getting a shields. Protection from the traitors kill this night

[Friar Tuck]

Ooh a trip to the Armoury, sounds dangerous 😆 thanks @lorcand1990

I think you said you don’t know the shoe.
Trip to armoury = random chance of getting a shields. Protection from the traitors kill this night

Yes I've only watched one series so not overly familiar with all the terms. Thanks @Gordon the Cook

[Vincent the Artist]

@McDonald the Farmer has been removed from being on trial for murder.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

@McDonald the Farmer has been removed from being on trial for murder.

mcdonald was one on the shortlist to go to the armoury. wonder did he win and this was his prize?

[Maeve the Madam]

The time is an hour out on all the posts on mine. Probably no point in messing with it though until the clocks change next week.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

The time is an hour out on all the posts on mine. Probably no point in messing with it though until the clocks change next week.

same as. an hour fast for me, presume its a website thing

[Lilly the Millennial]

Morning all. How unfortunate to be given a name like this in a game of traitors

Good morning I think I win on the name front.

[lorcand1990]

The time is an hour out on all the posts on mine. Probably no point in messing with it though until the clocks change next week.

The time is an hour out on all the posts on mine. Probably no point in messing with it though until the clocks change next week.

same as. an hour fast for me, presume its a website thing

That should be fixed for you both now

Anyone else with that issue pm me and it will get sorted

[lorcand1990]

An Insta Banishment has been used. No, this has nothing to do with Instragram, before all you horrible influencers get excited! 

A player has been banished from the castle immediately. One moment please....

[McDonald the Farmer]

I removed myself from list just incase I’m banished.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

I removed myself from list just incase I’m banished.

can you explain that please

[McDonald the Farmer]

I removed myself from list just incase I’m banished.

can you explain that please

I won the power to remove a player from trial. Of course I chose myself

[lorcand1990]

@Kevin the Armorer you have been banished from the castle immediately

Please reveal now if you are a traitor or faithful, or else I will reveal it for you shortly.