The Rookie Werewolf - Game Thread

[Ina May the Midwife]

Ah Kevin. Stop forgetting about me. That's today and yesterday.

I think Ben's list if 4 is correct

[Kevin the Armorer]

Feels like Dexter could have been the target. Big player with valuable powers.

[Kevin the Armorer]

Ah Kevin. Stop forgetting about me. That's today and yesterday.

I think Ben's list if 4 is correct

Sorry Ina.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

As I mentioned earlier, I've done a review of Benji's posts:

Saturday & Sunday (6-7 posts):
Says that he's a newbie (mentions setting up a support group with Amy) - I think he later clarifies that he's a relative newbie rather than a complete newbie
Proposes throwing accusations and posts a read list of:
Likes: Countess & Moe for working through the rules and roles
Dislikes: Mick & jacob for a couple of "icky" posts

Monday (14 posts):
Throws a little shade (validly IMO) at Robin for missing some things in their read-through and follows this up a couple of times
After the failed kidnap & shot, throwing strong shade at Dora for posting several times after the kidnap attempt ("panicing"), mentions Moe, Countess & Amy here also - Friar laters picks him up on this point i.e. why he mentions Amy but not others who were posting
Strongest "icks" are Jacob & Dora (and Mick to a lesser extent)
Votes Jacob (but also mentions Dora)

Tuesday (20 posts):
Pulls Magda up on saying that Countess was playing a good game and was on a wolf's tail (I like this)

Wednesday(10 posts):
Asks Edward for examples of how Gordon is different
Doesn't want a landslide on Ina as it gives us less info (I like this)
Still wants to shoot Dora
Thinks Jacob may have been the traitor

During the readback, after Monday I'd have had Benji on my list of possible wolves but having completed it, I now have a village lean on him - good questioning of Magda on Tuesday and today questioning Edward and also not wanting a runaway wagon on Ina are my main reasons for this.

Benji won't be on my FFA today

[Amy the Singer]

Morning all. Just wondering are there any "trips to the armoury" type contests in this game? They were always mid-morning in Traitors and I usually missed them.
Hoping that the fact that I can post this means I haven't been munched.

i've gone through amy's post and this is the only thing that stood out to me.

references being munched by the wolves but nothing of being kidnapped by the SK

That was before the kidnap announcement.

[Ina May the Midwife]

As the SK is still in play we can hopefully safely enough work on the basis that the two munch victims were villagers - that's Countess and Jacob. So I've pulled out the votes by or for them.

N1
Countess voted for William
Jacob voted for Benjamin

Mick voted for Countess
Edward and Benjamin voted for Jacob.

N2
Jacob voted for Moe

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

This is the list of posters and their posts:

Boris the Fool 67
Friar Tuck 59
Dora the Explorer 58
Magda the Maid 56
Robin the Jester 49
Kevin the Armorer 48
Benjamin the Alchemist 42
Vincent the Artist 40
Dexter the Dragoon 38
Ina May the Midwife 38
Gordon the Cook 37
Lilly the Millennial 34
Edward the Barber 30
Mick the Drunk 26
Weyland the Blacksmith 25
Jacob the Tailor 19
Amy the Singer 16

I'm going to pick 3 to analyse - anyone care to join me in taking 3?

I'll look at Boris, Benji and Jacob

Replying to myself here but with Jacob dead, I'll replace him with Edward; waiting on Boris to check in since the kidnapping before I look at him

[Robin the Jester]

As the SK is still in play we can hopefully safely enough work on the basis that the two munch victims were villagers - that's Countess and Jacob. So I've pulled out the votes by or for them.

N1
Countess voted for William
Jacob voted for Benjamin

Mick voted for Countess
Edward and Benjamin voted for Jacob.

N2
Jacob voted for Moe

any conclusions?

[Kevin the Armorer]

i've gone through amy's post and this is the only thing that stood out to me.

references being munched by the wolves but nothing of being kidnapped by the SK

That was before the kidnap announcement.

Also, at the time the kidnap had already happened (Friar) and was not yet resolved so why would she fear having been kidnapped. TBH the two of you are consistently mixing up how this works. Are ye both just trying to create confusion or misdirection? On the timing of your post Amy (around 7:30am), it's in the OP that it's 10am it happens and we went through a munch yesterday at 10am so why acting dumb (no offense) with the rules?

[Ina May the Midwife]

As the SK is still in play we can hopefully safely enough work on the basis that the two munch victims were villagers - that's Countess and Jacob. So I've pulled out the votes by or for them.

N1
Countess voted for William
Jacob voted for Benjamin

Mick voted for Countess
Edward and Benjamin voted for Jacob.

N2
Jacob voted for Moe

any conclusions?

Currently just putting info on the thread as I try to sort out my thoughts. Haven't reached a conclusion yet, some of the people that I was going to look closely at today are no longer an option so I'm back at the drawing board.

[Dexter the Dragoon]

My thoughts and I can be a little bit more clear now.

I aimed a shot at Dora yesterday before lynch, just after I posted about using my protect on myself. I didn't protect myself by the way.

I was suss on Jacob and didn't respond to his question about who I'd shoot this morning on purpose.

Magda I was leaning good on.
Re multiple shots. Is it possible the SK and vig both chose her to shoot?

Any other questions from Boris and whoever else was holding off, send them my way.

Moe was alpha for sure, no doubts on that one.

Knew you hadn't protect yourself 🤣🤣 got away with it.
Why did your shot fail on Dora? Was she protected or was it randed?

None the wiser why my shot failed. If it was randed, I didn't know about it

Was Elijah at work blocking his team?
Was it no friendly fire, as in I couldn't shoot a fellow officer? Our vig might think around that if that's plausible.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Here's my take after a review of Edward's posts:

Saturday & Sunday (3 posts):
Nothing of note

Monday (17 posts):
Lots of fluff
Mentions Jacob as possible traitor and then votes for him based on this
No opinion on Amy or Lily

Tuesday (10 posts):
"Countess was an insightful player for us. Gonna miss her"
Asks Magda if it would be better to shoot Ina rather than Moe (and then lynch Moe)
No posts after saying that he has "no other option but to vote Moe" at ~6pm

Wednesday(10 posts):
Wonmders if Gordon has changed playing style; when questioned by Benji as to what he means: "They just seemed very quiet and then the read list they produced had nothing on it then the kitchen is closed post"

So that one thought about Gordon having changed styles is pretty much the sum of Edward's contribution so far and that's enough to have Edward on my FFA for tonight - he's skating along posting a reasonable but bascially hasn't offered anything in the way of direct questioning (even the questiont o Gordon was a general question rather than a pointed one).

In the interests of giving @Edward the Barber a chance to reply, I'd be interested to know what insights from Countess in particular you thought were interesting?

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Here's my take after a review of Edward's posts:

Saturday & Sunday (3 posts):
Nothing of note

Monday (17 posts):
Lots of fluff
Mentions Jacob as possible traitor and then votes for him based on this
No opinion on Amy or Lily

Tuesday (10 posts):
"Countess was an insightful player for us. Gonna miss her"
Asks Magda if it would be better to shoot Ina rather than Moe (and then lynch Moe)
No posts after saying that he has "no other option but to vote Moe" at ~6pm

Wednesday(10 posts):
Wonmders if Gordon has changed playing style; when questioned by Benji as to what he means: "They just seemed very quiet and then the read list they produced had nothing on it then the kitchen is closed post"

So that one thought about Gordon having changed styles is pretty much the sum of Edward's contribution so far and that's enough to have Edward on my FFA for tonight - he's skating along posting a reasonable but bascially hasn't offered anything in the way of direct questioning (even the questiont o Gordon was a general question rather than a pointed one).

In the interests of giving @Edward the Barber a chance to reply, I'd be interested to know what insights from Countess in particular you thought were interesting?

One minor correction there - Edward's Wednesday posts are 5 rather than 10

[Gordon the Cook]

Knew you hadn't protect yourself 🤣🤣 got away with it.
Why did your shot fail on Dora? Was she protected or was it randed?

None the wiser why my shot failed. If it was randed, I didn't know about it

Was Elijah at work blocking his team?
Was it no friendly fire, as in I couldn't shoot a fellow officer? Our vig might think around that if that's plausible.

How many shots have you had Dexter?

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

I'm postponing my review of Boris until he checks in (as top remaining poster, he's a likely candidate for kidnap IMO) so I had a look at Ina instead and here's my take on here:

Saturday & Sunday (1 post):
N/A

Monday (12 posts):
Responds to Vincent who had pointed out that Moe didn't mention Ina along with other one-post players
Replies to William's post about one-post players
Votes William and provides decent rationale
Checks who declared their votes on thread and who didn't
Calls out Magda for inconsistencies in her posts (I like this)

Tuesday (25 posts):
Good few posts about mechanics but also checks what time post # 281 was and comments on the context of that (I like this level of detail)

Wednesday(4 posts):
Posts a little bit about who voted for whom but no conclusion from it (don't like this)

Overall, I'd have Ina as neutral - she's doing some good things but not really proactively questioning anyone. Unlikely to be on my FFA today though

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Unrelated to Ina but on my review of her posts. I noticed this from Amy:

"My only hmmm (I wouldn’t go so far as an ick) was Ina posting full on and then crickets yesterday"

At this point Ina had made exactly 1 post so I'm curious as to what you meant here @Amy the Singer?

[Kevin the Armorer]

You did a much deeper read on Ina. Only post of note...

Post 186: Not what she said, but observing that Moe didn't mention her as someone to check when she fit the same criteria as Vincent. So if we go with Moe was the alpha, is that him trying to distract from her?

There's not a lot of useful posts to go on with here. Like you said with Edward (who I've not looked at yet, only had time to read over Ina so far), she's sort of coasting along without sticking their neck out. Reads to me as someone with a roll (either good or bad) that is trying to stay just under the radar.

[Robin the Jester]

the OP is a bit sketchy on nolan's powers:

Officer Nolan, you will lead the task force and I will expect you to use all of your various skills to hunt these down. I've equipped your shop with the most modern facial recognition software to help you, shoot to kill if necessary but remember to protect your team first and foremost.

is there a world where he is dead, and dexter is claiming him and just using wolf powers?

[Amy the Singer]

That was before the kidnap announcement.

Also, at the time the kidnap had already happened (Friar) and was not yet resolved so why would she fear having been kidnapped. TBH the two of you are consistently mixing up how this works. Are ye both just trying to create confusion or misdirection? On the timing of your post Amy (around 7:30am), it's in the OP that it's 10am it happens and we went through a munch yesterday at 10am so why acting dumb (no offense) with the rules?

Yeh also in fairness it says in rule 7 that announcements are made at 10am, but from my experience in traitors, faithful who had been murdered overnight were not heard from in the morning before the announcement. It would be weird if people who had been munched the night before could participate in the morning discussions. If that’s how it is then fine, but there’s no need to accuse me of being dumb.

[Dexter the Dragoon]

the OP is a bit sketchy on nolan's powers:

Officer Nolan, you will lead the task force and I will expect you to use all of your various skills to hunt these down. I've equipped your shop with the most modern facial recognition software to help you, shoot to kill if necessary but remember to protect your team first and foremost.

is there a world where he is dead, and dexter is claiming him and just using wolf powers?

🤣🤣🤣

[Lilly the Millennial]

the OP is a bit sketchy on nolan's powers:

Officer Nolan, you will lead the task force and I will expect you to use all of your various skills to hunt these down. I've equipped your shop with the most modern facial recognition software to help you, shoot to kill if necessary but remember to protect your team first and foremost.

is there a world where he is dead, and dexter is claiming him and just using wolf powers?

There was a whole discussion at the start of the game about this. It’s possible but would be found out as soon as we kill the wolf priest

[Lilly the Millennial]

Also, at the time the kidnap had already happened (Friar) and was not yet resolved so why would she fear having been kidnapped. TBH the two of you are consistently mixing up how this works. Are ye both just trying to create confusion or misdirection? On the timing of your post Amy (around 7:30am), it's in the OP that it's 10am it happens and we went through a munch yesterday at 10am so why acting dumb (no offense) with the rules?

Yeh also in fairness it says in rule 7 that announcements are made at 10am, but from my experience in traitors, faithful who had been murdered overnight were not heard from in the morning before the announcement. It would be weird if people who had been munched the night before could participate in the morning discussions. If that’s how it is then fine, but there’s no need to accuse me of being dumb.

That was because that is how it is in the show. In a regular werewolf game players killed can post on thread until the mods say they are dead

[Kevin the Armorer]

Also, at the time the kidnap had already happened (Friar) and was not yet resolved so why would she fear having been kidnapped. TBH the two of you are consistently mixing up how this works. Are ye both just trying to create confusion or misdirection? On the timing of your post Amy (around 7:30am), it's in the OP that it's 10am it happens and we went through a munch yesterday at 10am so why acting dumb (no offense) with the rules?

Yeh also in fairness it says in rule 7 that announcements are made at 10am, but from my experience in traitors, faithful who had been murdered overnight were not heard from in the morning before the announcement. It would be weird if people who had been munched the night before could participate in the morning discussions. If that’s how it is then fine, but there’s no need to accuse me of being dumb.

Not accusing you of being dumb. Really, no offence intended. I'm just wondering if you're playing it that way to look like a non-threat. There was a whole big thing with Moe yesterday about munching Dexter at 9:57 if he was a wolf so it seems pretty clear from the OP and what the experienced players are saying that 10am is munch-time.

Again, really not trying to have a go at you personally. I just think there's a chance you're making yourself out to be a non-threat.

[Amy the Singer]

Unrelated to Ina but on my review of her posts. I noticed this from Amy:

"My only hmmm (I wouldn’t go so far as an ick) was Ina posting full on and then crickets yesterday"

At this point Ina had made exactly 1 post so I'm curious as to what you meant here @Amy the Singer?

I explained this before. “Full on” related to the content of her post when most people just said hi, she came in with a big story about delivering quadruplets or something which was fine in and of itself (leaning in to the role etc) but weird in that she didn’t post anything after that for ages. I explained this yesterday too if you’re looking at my other posts. On my phone here so fiddly as hell to seek out message numbers or links.

[Lilly the Millennial]

Given we have had 3 shots today I assume our big has used their power for the day so we are just left with lynch.

I believe Dexter so he is in my village pile.

Robins erratic style I can’t figure out if he is just being himself or there is another reason.

I am trying to believe Amy’s confusion is just because it’s only her second game but I think if she is a wolf then her fellow wolves would be encourage her to play into the newness

[Amy the Singer]

Yeh also in fairness it says in rule 7 that announcements are made at 10am, but from my experience in traitors, faithful who had been murdered overnight were not heard from in the morning before the announcement. It would be weird if people who had been munched the night before could participate in the morning discussions. If that’s how it is then fine, but there’s no need to accuse me of being dumb.

Not accusing you of being dumb. Really, no offence intended. I'm just wondering if you're playing it that way to look like a non-threat. There was a whole big thing with Moe yesterday about munching Dexter at 9:57 if he was a wolf so it seems pretty clear from the OP and what the experienced players are saying that 10am is munch-time.

Again, really not trying to have a go at you personally. I just think there's a chance you're making yourself out to be a non-threat.

Yup I get that. Would be good cover.

[Ina May the Midwife]

the OP is a bit sketchy on nolan's powers:

Officer Nolan, you will lead the task force and I will expect you to use all of your various skills to hunt these down. I've equipped your shop with the most modern facial recognition software to help you, shoot to kill if necessary but remember to protect your team first and foremost.

is there a world where he is dead, and dexter is claiming him and just using wolf powers?

I also had a question on that but the timing of the MOE post would have left it open for a counter claim because no one had left the game at that point.

In terms of the likelihood of Dexter being a bad actor. I've checked the time of the #281 post and that was 6.33pm yesterday evening, so pre-lynch.

I think whatever chance there could be that a wolf would make a claim like that especially with the wolf priest in play, they'd be less likely to when a counter claim could be made. No players had left the game at that stage.

I don't recall anyone really going against it either apart from Moe and even then he seemed split between Dexter being a wolf and Elijah's power interfering.

The only reservation I have is around the Alpha part because the OP mentioned that Oscar/Alpha had stolen officer uniforms and that would suggest that either Oscar alone or (based on the use of uniforms plural and giving them to escapees) that all wolves peek good.

That being said in the absence of something stronger to the contrary I'm taking Dexter at face value.

[Amy the Singer]

Why is my username changed to “Bamy the Singer” in post #982 ?

[Lilly the Millennial]

Why is my username changed to “Bamy the Singer” in post #982  ?

Because I hit off your name accidentally when typing

[Lilly the Millennial]

the OP is a bit sketchy on nolan's powers:

Officer Nolan, you will lead the task force and I will expect you to use all of your various skills to hunt these down. I've equipped your shop with the most modern facial recognition software to help you, shoot to kill if necessary but remember to protect your team first and foremost.

is there a world where he is dead, and dexter is claiming him and just using wolf powers?

I also had a question on that but the timing of the MOE post would have left it open for a counter claim because no one had left the game at that point.

In terms of the likelihood of Dexter being a bad actor. I've checked the time of the #281 post and that was 6.33pm yesterday evening, so pre-lynch.

I think whatever chance there could be that a wolf would make a claim like that especially with the wolf priest in play, they'd be less likely to when a counter claim could be made. No players had left the game at that stage.

I don't recall anyone really going against it either apart from Moe and even then he seemed split between Dexter being a wolf and Elijah's power interfering.

The only reservation I have is around the Alpha part because the OP mentioned that Oscar/Alpha had stolen officer uniforms and that would suggest that either Oscar alone or (based on the use of uniforms plural and giving them to escapees) that all wolves peek good.

That being said in the absence of something stronger to the contrary I'm taking Dexter at face value.

He is self resolving once we find the wolf priest. If he is the wolf priest then he has fooled us for now but we can relocate at home closer to end game if we still have no auto priest

[Dexter the Dragoon]

the OP is a bit sketchy on nolan's powers:

Officer Nolan, you will lead the task force and I will expect you to use all of your various skills to hunt these down. I've equipped your shop with the most modern facial recognition software to help you, shoot to kill if necessary but remember to protect your team first and foremost.

is there a world where he is dead, and dexter is claiming him and just using wolf powers?

I also had a question on that but the timing of the MOE post would have left it open for a counter claim because no one had left the game at that point.

In terms of the likelihood of Dexter being a bad actor. I've checked the time of the #281 post and that was 6.33pm yesterday evening, so pre-lynch.

I think whatever chance there could be that a wolf would make a claim like that especially with the wolf priest in play, they'd be less likely to when a counter claim could be made. No players had left the game at that stage.

I don't recall anyone really going against it either apart from Moe and even then he seemed split between Dexter being a wolf and Elijah's power interfering.

The only reservation I have is around the Alpha part because the OP mentioned that Oscar/Alpha had stolen officer uniforms and that would suggest that either Oscar alone or (based on the use of uniforms plural and giving them to escapees) that all wolves peek good.

That being said in the absence of something stronger to the contrary I'm taking Dexter at face value.

Read my role, I don't just peek

[Ina May the Midwife]

Read my role, I don't just peek

I'm just showing my thinking. As I said, it would have been a bizarrely risky move for a wolf at the time and I'm taking you at face value. I trust roled villagers to understand their powers and act accordingly.

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Read my role, I don't just peek

I'm just showing my thinking. As I said, it would have been a bizarrely risky move for a wolf at the time and I'm taking you at face value. I trust roled villagers to understand their powers and act accordingly.

Just clarifying. Making show there's no misinformation.

Ask what you need to ask today.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

He is self resolving once we find the wolf priest. If he is the wolf priest then he has fooled us for now but we can relocate at home closer to end game if we still have no auto priest

There's one caveat to that - if Dexter is the wolf priest.

It's not something that needs resolving immediately but if we were to get down to the last few players and Dexter is still alive, it's worth considering (either the wolves or SK should have targeted him by then - by now even)

[Ina May the Midwife]

I'm just showing my thinking. As I said, it would have been a bizarrely risky move for a wolf at the time and I'm taking you at face value. I trust roled villagers to understand their powers and act accordingly.

Just clarifying. Making show there's no misinformation.

Ask what you need to ask today.

All good. I'm trying not to delve into the village powers so I can't see me asking anything on those lines. I figure that can only help the wolves and SK.

[Kevin the Armorer]

Dexter's still here!

Left to check in...
Boris the Fool
Vincent the Artist
Edward the Barber

[Kevin the Armorer]

By virtue of him posting the most out of those 3, it's odd not to have heard from Boris by now.

[Mick the Drunk]

Morning all,

Just reading the OP and on the traitors piece:

"be on your toes as we have been informed that there is a traitor in our ranks. Try to take them down before the criminals find them"

I presume that the traitor knows that they're a traitor and if so, I think they'll be trying to send some sort of signal (may already have done so?) to the wolves to come and get them - worth keeping in mind when you're reading through posts.

The Aplha wolf Oscar "is hard to track down and even harder to kill" - I presume this means he peeks village and needs more than one shot to be killed. Anyone who survives an attack will need to be a policy lynch (although this may be tricky as only our vig will know who they took the shot on so they'll need to be wary about exposing themselves)

Starting Weyland, im trying to do a reads list on players, keep getting errors which is a disaster when trying to do this most of his posts day 0 are around mechanics 

Sorry just walk me through that a second. If we lynch the alpha... would that not take them out of the game or is it that you think they have "two lives", so the lynch is one... we'd see they are still in the game, so the vig shoots to kill?

Simlilarly, if the wolves use a vote block to save a villager, it would look like they are saving their own so the vig would target them? Would it not be incredibly obvious that the wolves would use that tactic so therefore whomever they save is probably more likely than not, a villager (or the SK).

On the alpha, I could see it working either way i.e. two kill attempts (including lynch) required to kill (which is Friar's reading of it) or that 2 shots are needed but the lynch would take him out in one go. It probably doesn't really matter until we get to the point of a failed lynch / shot though

On this piece: 
"Simlilarly, if the wolves use a vote block to save a villager, it would look like they are saving their own so the vig would target them? Would it not be incredibly obvious that the wolves would use that tactic so therefore whomever they save is probably more likely than not, a villager (or the SK)."

Not really - if a wolf was up for lynch, the wolves would definitely use that power to buy that wolf another day. They could of course use it as a diversionary tactic as you describe; how they use it may depend on how many uses of it they have IMO

Just Amy so to confirm, since Kev said they've played Traitors

Is @Benjamin the Alchemist a newbie? He replied to Amy's post with "we need to start a support group" (post # 34) which I read as him being a newbie but maybe not based on subsequent posts?

I'd probably shoot in the low posters (Wesley or Lieutenant Grey), peek a fairly active poster (without checking exact post counts, Moe or Benji I think), protect myself and I don't think we should say who we'd track as it may give the wolves unnecessary info (e.g. if Player A gets mentioned a lot for tracking, they're less likely to put in the munch order tonight)

I have a kids' football match ~ an hour away so I won't be around much this evening but it should be over by 8 and I'll catch up here on the bus journey home in time to vote.

Folks, just back on now, anyone able to share the current state of play?

Weyland was absent from the afternoon before the first lynch and returned with this post

Everyone is deciding who they voting for. What's your thoughts?

That's what  trying to figure out - if there are 2-3 wagons already, I'll decide amongst those. I actually thought yeet was at 9pm so I'm not under as much pressure as I thought

I didn't have any strong leans earlier but I'll try to skim the failed actions from earlier

There was 1 fairly clear wagon formed on William when this post came in

You want to shoot the games mods.

Yeah, I saw that alright 😂 tbf, I did say that I'd shoot a low poster and he was just an example of one

Owned his kill the mods/low poster mistake

I'd read the failed actions as the wolves trying to recruit and then trying to kill. The responding officer was the same both time, don't know if that's significant or not

Based off not much, I'll probably vote for William for his negative opening post and an earlier post about killing the priest wolf first

Vote going in now

Making the point again that it's wolf actions he believes happened when its now known it was SK

I don't get the reasoning for thinking both actions are wolf actions based on the responding officer. It doesn't really line up with the roles described in the OP that the wolves could do both actions IMO.

My opinion that they're wolf actions and the same responding officer aren't linked. I'm thinking though that it could have been the same player targeted

Interacting with CM before she was then munched the next morning. One more interaction later

Hi folks,

Dont know the theme at all. Op looks fairly interesting. An alpha and a wolf priest make this tough in my opinion. Potential conversion metric in play too

This post was part of why I voted for William 🙈🙈 As someone pointed out earlier, I got mixed up on who posted this. Apologies William

After voting for William he then actually says he was supposed to vote for me (just noticed this) 

I don't see the logic in that. I think the mod flair for specific outcomes is already largely written and not tailored to specific characters.

Maybe it's nothing but I think it'll be worth checking to see what the responding officer number is whenever the next such action happens

What's your thoughts on the attempted kidnapping?

Again wolf not sk

I'd read the failed actions as the wolves trying to recruit and then trying to kill. The responding officer was the same both time, don't know if that's significant or not

Based off not much, I'll probably vote for William for his negative opening post and an earlier post about killing the priest wolf first

Vote going in now

Reading back on last night and actually I no longer think it was 2 wolf actions - the wolves don't seem to have the capacity for a shot so that's most likely our vig which as Boris says either hit Oscar or could have been randed; a 3rd option would be that our vig hit our BG who had protection on themselves?

Changes his mind the next morning about 90 mins before CM was munched 

Since the SK is still alive, it looks like Countess was definitely villager. I wouldn't read too much into the wolves killing her as an attempt to frame someone, mostly they'd be role hunting as that benefits them far more IMO.

Based on the flavour, it seems clear that yesterday's failed kidnapping was the SK and I'd say the most likely reason for failure is that they targeted Oscar (assuming others are correct in saying that protection is a night time power) - if that is the case, would they have targeted the same person again today on the assumption that it take s two goes to kill Oscar? If everyone reading can post, we'll be able to see who's missing. I'd say that whoever it is pretty much already dead and the kidnapping is just flavour to match with the mention of torture in the OP although maybe if our vig took out the SK today, the kidnapped person would survive?

This line stands out thought, why wouldn't you worry it was an attempt to frame someone? She'd interacted briefly with a few people and more with others. I find this line weird in the context of all your posts

[Ina May the Midwife]

My current theory is that Elijah might be gone.

Three shots hit today so that could be the two previous "diverted" shots and a successful one from today, if he was the one blocking them. Obviously can't confirm with the wolf priest in play which is a head wreck

[Mick the Drunk]

My current theory is that Elijah might be gone.

Three shots hit today so that could be the two previous  "diverted" shots and a successful one from today, if he was the one blocking them. Obviously can't confirm with the wolf priest in play which is a head wreck

What you think previously fired shots would work once the role is dead? Ive never seen that happen before 

Did you fire a shot Ina?