The Rookie Werewolf - Game Thread

[Edward the Barber]

I’m still here. I’m flat out driving today so it’s going to be a few more hours at least till I can answer my questions, Weyland.

[Ina May the Midwife]

My current theory is that Elijah might be gone.

Three shots hit today so that could be the two previous  "diverted" shots and a successful one from today, if he was the one blocking them. Obviously can't confirm with the wolf priest in play which is a head wreck

What you think previously fired shots would work once the role is dead? Ive never seen that happen before 

Did you fire a shot Ina?

Then maybe it wouldn't but I don't see where else 3 shots would have come from this morning. Do you have an alternative explanation for it?

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Morning all,

Just reading the OP and on the traitors piece:

"be on your toes as we have been informed that there is a traitor in our ranks. Try to take them down before the criminals find them"

I presume that the traitor knows that they're a traitor and if so, I think they'll be trying to send some sort of signal (may already have done so?) to the wolves to come and get them - worth keeping in mind when you're reading through posts.

The Aplha wolf Oscar "is hard to track down and even harder to kill" - I presume this means he peeks village and needs more than one shot to be killed. Anyone who survives an attack will need to be a policy lynch (although this may be tricky as only our vig will know who they took the shot on so they'll need to be wary about exposing themselves)

Starting Weyland, im trying to do a reads list on players, keep getting errors which is a disaster when trying to do this most of his posts day 0 are around mechanics 

On the alpha, I could see it working either way i.e. two kill attempts (including lynch) required to kill (which is Friar's reading of it) or that 2 shots are needed but the lynch would take him out in one go. It probably doesn't really matter until we get to the point of a failed lynch / shot though

On this piece: 
"Simlilarly, if the wolves use a vote block to save a villager, it would look like they are saving their own so the vig would target them? Would it not be incredibly obvious that the wolves would use that tactic so therefore whomever they save is probably more likely than not, a villager (or the SK)."

Not really - if a wolf was up for lynch, the wolves would definitely use that power to buy that wolf another day. They could of course use it as a diversionary tactic as you describe; how they use it may depend on how many uses of it they have IMO

Is @Benjamin the Alchemist a newbie? He replied to Amy's post with "we need to start a support group" (post # 34) which I read as him being a newbie but maybe not based on subsequent posts?

I'd probably shoot in the low posters (Wesley or Lieutenant Grey), peek a fairly active poster (without checking exact post counts, Moe or Benji I think), protect myself and I don't think we should say who we'd track as it may give the wolves unnecessary info (e.g. if Player A gets mentioned a lot for tracking, they're less likely to put in the munch order tonight)

I have a kids' football match ~ an hour away so I won't be around much this evening but it should be over by 8 and I'll catch up here on the bus journey home in time to vote.

Folks, just back on now, anyone able to share the current state of play?

Weyland was absent from the afternoon before the first lynch and returned with this post

That's what  trying to figure out - if there are 2-3 wagons already, I'll decide amongst those. I actually thought yeet was at 9pm so I'm not under as much pressure as I thought

I didn't have any strong leans earlier but I'll try to skim the failed actions from earlier

There was 1 fairly clear wagon formed on William when this post came in

Yeah, I saw that alright 😂 tbf, I did say that I'd shoot a low poster and he was just an example of one

Owned his kill the mods/low poster mistake

I'd read the failed actions as the wolves trying to recruit and then trying to kill. The responding officer was the same both time, don't know if that's significant or not

Based off not much, I'll probably vote for William for his negative opening post and an earlier post about killing the priest wolf first

Vote going in now

Making the point again that it's wolf actions he believes happened when its now known it was SK

My opinion that they're wolf actions and the same responding officer aren't linked. I'm thinking though that it could have been the same player targeted

Interacting with CM before she was then munched the next morning. One more interaction later

This post was part of why I voted for William 🙈🙈 As someone pointed out earlier, I got mixed up on who posted this. Apologies William

After voting for William he then actually says he was supposed to vote for me (just noticed this) 

Maybe it's nothing but I think it'll be worth checking to see what the responding officer number is whenever the next such action happens

What's your thoughts on the attempted kidnapping?

Again wolf not sk

Reading back on last night and actually I no longer think it was 2 wolf actions - the wolves don't seem to have the capacity for a shot so that's most likely our vig which as Boris says either hit Oscar or could have been randed; a 3rd option would be that our vig hit our BG who had protection on themselves?

Changes his mind the next morning about 90 mins before CM was munched 

Since the SK is still alive, it looks like Countess was definitely villager. I wouldn't read too much into the wolves killing her as an attempt to frame someone, mostly they'd be role hunting as that benefits them far more IMO.

Based on the flavour, it seems clear that yesterday's failed kidnapping was the SK and I'd say the most likely reason for failure is that they targeted Oscar (assuming others are correct in saying that protection is a night time power) - if that is the case, would they have targeted the same person again today on the assumption that it take s two goes to kill Oscar? If everyone reading can post, we'll be able to see who's missing. I'd say that whoever it is pretty much already dead and the kidnapping is just flavour to match with the mention of torture in the OP although maybe if our vig took out the SK today, the kidnapped person would survive?

This line stands out thought, why wouldn't you worry it was an attempt to frame someone? She'd interacted briefly with a few people and more with others. I find this line weird in the context of all your posts

Good to see that you're doing some digging and I agree that the errors make it a right pain in the ass!! 

I'll reply to your various questions in a different post but what's your conclusion from all of this?

[Vincent the Artist]

I'm here. I've been having a nightmare with the site this morning. This is the 4th or 5th time I've tried posting.

[Lilly the Millennial]

He is self resolving once we find the wolf priest. If he is the wolf priest then he has fooled us for now but we can relocate at home closer to end game if we still have no auto priest

There's one caveat to that - if Dexter is the wolf priest.

It's not something that needs resolving immediately but if we were to get down to the last few players and Dexter is still alive, it's worth considering (either the wolves or SK should have targeted him by then - by now even)

Which is what I said!

[Mick the Drunk]

What you think previously fired shots would work once the role is dead? Ive never seen that happen before 

Did you fire a shot Ina?

Then maybe it wouldn't but I don't see where else 3 shots would have come from this morning. Do you have an alternative explanation for it?

No but i just seen Magdas post where she called you and Dora out not long before she died. And then posting about the bullets being from previous days seems odd to me. I dont have an explanation but id say yours is far fetched

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

There's one caveat to that - if Dexter is the wolf priest.

It's not something that needs resolving immediately but if we were to get down to the last few players and Dexter is still alive, it's worth considering (either the wolves or SK should have targeted him by then - by now even)

Which is what I said!

Apologies, I obviously only read the first half of your post! 

[Ina May the Midwife]

I'm here. I've been having a nightmare with the site this morning. This is the 4th or 5th time I've tried posting.

On that basis it looks like Boris is the kidnap victim.

The errors seem to have gotten worse today alright

[Lilly the Millennial]

I'm here. I've been having a nightmare with the site this morning. This is the 4th or 5th time I've tried posting.

It’s so painful!!

[Mick the Drunk]

Starting Weyland, im trying to do a reads list on players, keep getting errors which is a disaster when trying to do this most of his posts day 0 are around mechanics 




Weyland was absent from the afternoon before the first lynch and returned with this post
There was 1 fairly clear wagon formed on William when this post came in
Owned his kill the mods/low poster mistake
Making the point again that it's wolf actions he believes happened when its now known it was SK
Interacting with CM before she was then munched the next morning. One more interaction later
After voting for William he then actually says he was supposed to vote for me (just noticed this) 
Again wolf not sk
Changes his mind the next morning about 90 mins before CM was munched 
This line stands out thought, why wouldn't you worry it was an attempt to frame someone? She'd interacted briefly with a few people and more with others. I find this line weird in the context of all your posts

Good to see that you're doing some digging and I agree that the errors make it a right pain in the ass!! 

I'll reply to your various questions in a different post but what's your conclusion from all of this?

I was looking for the SK but if I was to say my thoughts currently would be that you lean more towards a wolf than an sk. Timing of your interaction with CM is fine in isolation but changing your mind to essentially agree with her shortly before she's munched is notable. Could be a setup but the follow up after she dies puts you firmly as a wolf lean

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Good to see that you're doing some digging and I agree that the errors make it a right pain in the ass!! 

I'll reply to your various questions in a different post but what's your conclusion from all of this?

I was looking for the SK but if I was to say my thoughts currently would be that you lean more towards a wolf than an sk. Timing of your interaction with CM is fine in isolation but changing your mind to essentially agree with her shortly before she's munched is notable. Could be a setup but the follow up after she dies puts you firmly as a wolf lean

Did you stop at my posts from yesterday morning once you had something you could point to or did you continue going with it?


Anyway, as promised here's some replies to some comments from your review:

Making the point again that it's wolf actions he believes happened when its now known it was SK

My post that you're referring to was at 2113, was it known at that point that it was the SK that did the kidnapping? Can you point me to where this had become "known" because at the time and again now on readback, I can't see where it's clearly known to anyone (other than the wolves and SK)

Again wolf not sk

If you re-read that interaction, it was in reference to the call sign of the responding office being the same for both the failed kidnap and failed shot and my theory here was that that may have meant that the same player was the target in both instances.

This line stands out thought, why wouldn't you worry it was an attempt to frame someone? She'd interacted briefly with a few people and more with others. I find this line weird in the context of all your posts

This was an indirect reply to Kevin's posts contemplating why Countess was targeted (I should have quoted him to be clearer):

Any thoughts on why Countess was targeted? I looked back through her posts there. She didn't really suss anyone until late last night, which was Dora. That feels like a set up to make it look like Dora took her out. I've found Dora to be a bit of a chaotic player in the mix so I did have her flagged as one to watch... but now I think maybe it's all too obvious and Dora isn't a wolf... maybe the SK?

[Mick the Drunk]

I was looking for the SK but if I was to say my thoughts currently would be that you lean more towards a wolf than an sk. Timing of your interaction with CM is fine in isolation but changing your mind to essentially agree with her shortly before she's munched is notable. Could be a setup but the follow up after she dies puts you firmly as a wolf lean

Did you stop at my posts from yesterday morning once you had something you could point to or did you continue going with it?


Anyway, as promised here's some replies to some comments from your review:

Making the point again that it's wolf actions he believes happened when its now known it was SK

My post that you're referring to was at 2113, was it known at that point that it was the SK that did the kidnapping? Can you point me to where this had become "known" because at the time and again now on readback, I can't see where it's clearly known to anyone (other than the wolves and SK)

Again wolf not sk

If you re-read that interaction, it was in reference to the call sign of the responding office being the same for both the failed kidnap and failed shot and my theory here was that that may have meant that the same player was the target in both instances.

This line stands out thought, why wouldn't you worry it was an attempt to frame someone? She'd interacted briefly with a few people and more with others. I find this line weird in the context of all your posts

This was an indirect reply to Kevin's posts contemplating why Countess was targeted (I should have quoted him to be clearer):

Any thoughts on why Countess was targeted? I looked back through her posts there. She didn't really suss anyone until late last night, which was Dora. That feels like a set up to make it look like Dora took her out. I've found Dora to be a bit of a chaotic player in the mix so I did have her flagged as one to watch... but now I think maybe it's all too obvious and Dora isn't a wolf... maybe the SK?

Im jumping around a bit due to these errors, so your running theory is same player was targeted twice. So Friar on both occasions, was the call sign different today?

I'll go back and read the interactions around that time. The post about framing was on its own with no quote and looked odd on its own

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Im jumping around a bit due to these errors, so your running theory is same player was targeted twice. So Friar on both occasions, was the call sign different today?

I'll go back and read the interactions around that time. The post about framing was on its own with no quote and looked odd on its own

Just following up on the call signs thing actually now that you mention it:

- both the failed kidnap and failed shot on Monday were responded to by 7-Adam-19 (this was why I thought that maybe the same person was targeted along with that fact that both failed i.e the target had some sort of protection
- yesterday's failed shot was also from 7-Adam-19

However, news of both the successful kidnappings (i.e. Friar & Boris) came from 7-Adam-100 so it would seem from that, that there's nothing in it.

Even if there was a link to the call signs, I'm not sure what value it would be to us, it was just something I noticed and the time and commented on

[Mick the Drunk]

Im jumping around a bit due to these errors, so your running theory is same player was targeted twice. So Friar on both occasions, was the call sign different today?

I'll go back and read the interactions around that time. The post about framing was on its own with no quote and looked odd on its own

Just following up on the call signs thing actually now that you mention it:

- both the failed kidnap and failed shot on Monday were responded to by 7-Adam-19 (this was why I thought that maybe the same person was targeted along with that fact that both failed i.e the target had some sort of protection
- yesterday's failed shot was also from 7-Adam-19

However, news of both the successful kidnappings (i.e. Friar & Boris) came from 7-Adam-100 so it would seem from that, that there's nothing in it.

Even if there was a link to the call signs, I'm not sure what value it would be to us, it was just something I noticed and the time and commented on

The value is if someone is targeted twice we'd know if the call sign was the same. Doesn't look it based on your examples.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Out of curiosity, I googled the call signs. Both 19 and 100 seem to be the call signs of the officers on the show.

[Mick the Drunk]

Ok... any thoughts on why Countess was targeted? I looked back through her posts there. She didn't really suss anyone until late last night, which was Dora. That feels like a set up to make it look like Dora took her out. I've found Dora to be a bit of a chaotic player in the mix so I did have her flagged as one to watch... but now I think maybe it's all too obvious and Dora isn't a wolf... maybe the SK?

Only one kill? And the message says about Monica, who is listed as a wolf.

So, does that add credence to the idea the kidnapping was the serial killer, who failed?

I lean more to the recruitment theory that it was an attempt by the wolves to find the traitor. I guess if it happens again today then that might confirm it... though it could also be SK failed again. Also, shouldn't there be two deaths? Again, I assume that if there was an attempt that was blocked, we would get an update.

ok as I've been typing the above Lietenant Grey posted about a new kidnapping. So it is the SK.

Since the SK is still alive, it looks like Countess was definitely villager. I wouldn't read too much into the wolves killing her as an attempt to frame someone, mostly they'd be role hunting as that benefits them far more IMO.

Based on the flavour, it seems clear that yesterday's failed kidnapping was the SK and I'd say the most likely reason for failure is that they targeted Oscar (assuming others are correct in saying that protection is a night time power) - if that is the case, would they have targeted the same person again today on the assumption that it take s two goes to kill Oscar? If everyone reading can post, we'll be able to see who's missing. I'd say that whoever it is pretty much already dead and the kidnapping is just flavour to match with the mention of torture in the OP although maybe if our vig took out the SK today, the kidnapped person would survive?

Ok, explanation checks out, the lack of quote made it stand out.

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Shoot
Peek
Protect

Be great if everyone could get their views on this on thread as of now.
I'm withholding my own thoughts for the time being.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Since Boris is MIA, I've reviewed Robin's posts instead


Saturday & Sunday (2 posts):
N/A

Monday (29 posts):
A few filler posts
Questions Friar on how he knew Benji was going to start throwing accusations
"i think thats a bit reckless wanting to blast moe so early" - stands out assuming Moe is as Dexter says
"too late now with the amounts of votes, but why is everyone voting him?" - sent at 2129 this post stands out, esp considering they haven't done much yet in the game themselves

Tuesday (17 posts):
Comments on Vincent's "lateral" thinking (I also like Vincent's comment here)
Out of nowhere seems to target Dora "classic wolf play here", maybe trying to get a reaction but doesn't follow it up

Wednesday(9 posts):
Read through Amy's posts and picked out one where she knew she hadn't been kidnapped (although I think it's clear at this stage that kidnapping is not a night event)
Presses Ina for a conclusion to her brief post about the votes (I think this is the first one of their posts that I really like)

Overall, I'd have @Robin the Jester as a slight wolf lean, no real questioning of anyone despite being one of the top posters; they could easily make my FFA for today.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Shoot
Peek
Protect

Be great if everyone could get their views on this on thread as of now.
I'm withholding my own thoughts for the time being.

Peek Vincent
Shoot Edward
Protect Dexter

[Gordon the Cook]

Out of curiosity, I googled the call signs. Both 19 and 100 seem to be the call signs of the officers on the show.

Thanks. I was wondering about that also.

[Gordon the Cook]

Shoot
Peek
Protect

Be great if everyone could get their views on this on thread as of now.
I'm withholding my own thoughts for the time being.

Hi Dexter I asked you earlier how many shots you’ve taken and got no reply.

[Mick the Drunk]

Out of curiosity, I googled the call signs. Both 19 and 100 seem to be the call signs of the officers on the show.

Interesting anything below 99 seems to beat cops, 100 or above sergeant level

Not sure if its at all relevant in this but given the mods, there's usually info in the detail

[Gordon the Cook]

Shoot Don’t know
Peek Dexter
Protect Gordon

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Shoot
Peek
Protect

Be great if everyone could get their views on this on thread as of now.
I'm withholding my own thoughts for the time being.

Hi Dexter I asked you earlier how many shots you’ve taken and got no reply.

Would you believe me if I said I had 2?

Can I ask if your arse is sore from sitting on the fence for such a long period of time?

[Vincent the Artist]

Then maybe it wouldn't but I don't see where else 3 shots would have come from this morning. Do you have an alternative explanation for it?

No but i just seen Magdas post where she called you and Dora out not long before she died. And then posting about the bullets being from previous days seems odd to me. I dont have an explanation but id say yours is far fetched

Shoot
Peek
Protect

Be great if everyone could get their views on this on thread as of now.
I'm withholding my own thoughts for the time being.

Shoot Mick - mick ignored my post from last night. I'm behind in reading the thread today but it seems he is again not making any conclusions of his own.

Peek Dexter - to satisfy myself your claim is 100%

Protect Vincent - the only thing I can 100% trust right now is me.

[Vincent the Artist]

Hi Dexter I asked you earlier how many shots you’ve taken and got no reply.

Would you believe me if I said I had 2?

Can I ask if your arse is sore from sitting on the fence for such a long period of time?

Mick is there with him.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Shoot Don’t know
Peek Dexter
Protect Gordon

Ah Gordon, it's Day 3, if you don't know who you'd shoot by now, when will you know?

[Kevin the Armorer]

Shoot - Robin (though close call with Mick)
Peek - Gordon
Protect - if I had to pick someone other than myself... Dexter

[Mick the Drunk]

Shoot
Peek
Protect

Be great if everyone could get their views on this on thread as of now.
I'm withholding my own thoughts for the time being.

Shoot Ina
Peek Lilly
Protect Dexter

[Mick the Drunk]

No but i just seen Magdas post where she called you and Dora out not long before she died. And then posting about the bullets being from previous days seems odd to me. I dont have an explanation but id say yours is far fetched

Shoot
Peek
Protect

Be great if everyone could get their views on this on thread as of now.
I'm withholding my own thoughts for the time being.

Shoot Mick - mick ignored my post from last night. I'm behind in reading the thread today but it seems he is again not making any conclusions of his own.

Peek Dexter - to satisfy myself your claim is 100%

Protect Vincent - the only thing I can 100% trust right now is me.

What post?

[Vincent the Artist]

Do you not see how this isnt helpful to the village in isolation?

I am a villager gives the same vibe without the same detail. In a game like this, first task is finding wolves/sk and eliminating them. Second task for an NRV in my mind is to draw a kill and keep the power roles in play

Hi folks, im still here and not kidnapped, Real Life got in my way yesterday. Speed reading and caught up a little

A fair bit of activity to dissect. I see Countess was munched which is where I voted yesterday.

This is really good, my only note on it is I would go at the other end. I would say wolves briefly interact at best. Its a bigger pool mind you. Id be surprised if Magda and Moe (Alpha Wolf) were both wolves with that level of interaction. The context of the interactions is as important too. I'll have a look and see if anything stands out

Hey @Mick the Drunk how did that read back go?
Now Moe has been lynched who are your top suspects? And why?

Here you go @Mick the Drunk

[Lilly the Millennial]

Shoot - Robin
Peek - Gordon
Protect - Dexter

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Shoot Robin
Peek Dexter (if Dexter is lying, just to see why). Otherwise, peek Robin.
Protect Dexter

I'm leaning towards my vote being on Robin right now. Given my main suspects were all downed this morning, I'm a little lost overall, but I feel Robin's overall style has been giving me the ick. I know some said his day one random vote was apparently how he usually played? But his inability to give a straight time when I asked him about his second vote worries me too. I was also reading back and noticed that on Monday afternoon, when the discussions were about shooting Moe, Robin actually argued against it too. If we're assuming (right or wrong) that Moe was bad, it feels like a potential ally trying to ease off Moe?

See above, already answered.

i think thats a bit reckless wanting to blast moe so early

[Vincent the Artist]

OK these are some of the posts I tried to comment on earlier.

“Okay Wednesday roll-call folks, settle down. Thanks everyone for their support yesterday and through the night.


We are missing someone. Where is @Jacob the Tailor?


Another business card on the floor here…


“Monica Stevens - Attorney at Law”


Looks like there is something scribbled on the back again.


“@Jacob the Tailor is dead, I told you to leave us alone. Now, more will fall. Prepare for war.”


Everyone gear up, get out there and leave no stone unturned! Prepare for anything that they might throw at you. It's time for these scum to feel the heat.”

Lynch/Yeet form is now open!

Hands up here, Jacob was joint top of my list as possible baddie. I'm surprised at this choice, as there are others who are leaning more village for me as a more obvious choice.

Like Ina said, this would be too damaging an effect on the SK to have them be forced off thread for the rest of the day too. I think Amy is just offline. They will hopefully give a good account of themselves later.

Hopefully there's a mechanism to release Friar and he isn't suffering a slow painful death. If he returns, will he have flipped and be corrupted. He may need to be resolved anyway.

All shots fired have been unsuccessful. I know it says Moe is hard to kill and we have nothing to say that he has been the target each time, but I suspect something more at play here.

"Hopefully there's a mechanism to release Friar and he isn't suffering a slow painful death."

Is there a chance he'd be released if we killed the serial killer, do you think the kidnap was the SK. 

These 3 presumed it was Friar coming back when Amy hadnt posted, Kevin has addressed why he thought that

These were all posted before Amy came back. 

I need to go back and look at day 1, ive notes that multiple players didnt think the kidnap was the SK. Need to cross reference those with those above

@Mick the Drunk how did that look back go? What did you turn up?

“7-Lincoln-200 to Wesley, reports of multiple shots fired in the vicinity of Mid-Wilshire station. Intel has advised that there is a shootout among the factions with our officers caught in the middle. I will update when I get on scene.

…

“7-Lincoln-200 to Wesley. On Scene, Multiple wounded. Multiple dead.

@Magda the Maid been shot twice and is dead
@Dora the Explorer has been shot and is dead”

Is it possible that Magda first shot was day one? And the shot was randed? Rather than her being Alpha wolf?

I'm asking this if we take Dexter's Intel as gospel and Moe was Alpha.

“7-Lincoln-200 to Wesley, reports of multiple shots fired in the vicinity of Mid-Wilshire station. Intel has advised that there is a shootout among the factions with our officers caught in the middle. I will update when I get on scene.

…

“7-Lincoln-200 to Wesley. On Scene, Multiple wounded. Multiple dead.

@Magda the Maid been shot twice and is dead
@Dora the Explorer has been shot and is dead”

Shot twice, Alpha?

See comment above. What are the different scenarios?

1. Dexter is lying, Moe was not alpha and that was Magda. 2. Magda is not alpha and was aimed at twice by different players today. Are there enough bullets for 3 today? Is one from the missed shot the other day?

[Vincent the Artist]

“7-Lincoln-200 to all units sighting of Rosalind Dyer in North Hollywood. I am en-route will update with further information.


….


7-Lincoln-200 to all units. Not conscious Not breathing body at scene, looks like it went through extensive torture and disfigurement. Looks like @Friar Tuck so en-route to morgue”

Damn, there goes my "Dora is Rosalind" theory then. Between that and Jacob and Magda, I've lost pretty much all my bad reads this morning.

Where were you suspicious of Jacob? I don't see it in your post history?

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

“7-Lincoln-200 to all units sighting of Rosalind Dyer in North Hollywood. I am en-route will update with further information.


….


7-Lincoln-200 to all units. Not conscious Not breathing body at scene, looks like it went through extensive torture and disfigurement. Looks like @Friar Tuck so en-route to morgue”

Damn, there goes my "Dora is Rosalind" theory then. Between that and Jacob and Magda, I've lost pretty much all my bad reads this morning.

Where were you suspicious of Jacob? I don't see it in your post history?

I literally voted for him on night one, and outlined it was cause of his comments about the traitor.

[Vincent the Artist]

Ah Kevin. Stop forgetting about me. That's today and yesterday.

I think Ben's list if 4 is correct

There seems to be a theme of players forgetting you. First Moe. Now Kevin.

As the SK is still in play we can hopefully safely enough work on the basis that the two munch victims were villagers - that's Countess and Jacob. So I've pulled out the votes by or for them.

N1
Countess voted for William
Jacob voted for Benjamin

Mick voted for Countess
Edward and Benjamin voted for Jacob.

N2
Jacob voted for Moe

any conclusions?

Any conclusions yourself? Where are your thoughts at?

the OP is a bit sketchy on nolan's powers:

Officer Nolan, you will lead the task force and I will expect you to use all of your various skills to hunt these down. I've equipped your shop with the most modern facial recognition software to help you, shoot to kill if necessary but remember to protect your team first and foremost.

is there a world where he is dead, and dexter is claiming him and just using wolf powers?

Dexter claimed before the first munch. Risky, risky move.
William was the first lynch, and it was after this, but if William was roled, he made no self pres attempts before the lynch.

[Robin the Jester]

shoot - mick i think
peek - dexter
protect - not dexter. will help resolve him.

[Dexter the Dragoon]

shoot - mick i think
peek - dexter
protect - not dexter. will help resolve him.

Resolve me how?

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Last review of the day before deciding on my FFA, having a look at Kevin's posts:

Saturday & Sunday (2 posts):
2nd time player.

Monday (18 posts):
Mentions Benji's minion gif
Disagrees with Moe & Mick when they're jumping on Countess about using the term "we" to descrive NRVs
Picks up that William didn't have his own post count in the list he posted
Doesn't declare William vote on thread but gives reasons afterwards

Tuesday (27 posts):
Mentions Dora after the munch
Questions Dora being active around the kidnapping
Posts a lot about the list of players checking in
"I'll try and take a closer look later. I'll also try and look at who Moe might have been sussing (or clearing) before Dexter made his post" - never gets to this step though
Prefers Vincent as a wolf over Magda

Wednesday(23 posts):
Questions Gordon not going on the Moe wagon
Lists Dora, Mick and Robin as his top 3 (I like this)
Lists Ina , Lilly & Edward as 3 that he's going to look at - provides a brief read of Ina and pulls out one post
Says that Robin's posts give him an odd vibe
Questions Amy about getting confused
Says he'll shoot Robin (Mick 2nd) and peek Gordon

Overall, I 'm largely liking Kevin and have him as a village lean - as a new player, he's doing some good questioning and was willing to give an FFA stright off the bat which shows he's at least thinking about who might be a wolf. Not on my FFA for today