The Rookie Werewolf - Game Thread

[Boris the Fool]

Let us know what your thoughts are when you take your head out of the oven

Jaysus, that escalated quickly!

Welcome to werewolf 🤣🤣

[Lilly the Millennial]

And going back to an earlier theory, that means that would mean that the SK can post while the person is kidnapped.

 Why wouldn’t the SK be able to post?

[Ina May the Midwife]

And going back to an earlier theory, that means that would mean that the SK can post while the person is kidnapped.

 Why wouldn’t the SK be able to post?

Dora was wondering if the phrasing of the kidnap post meant that both would be unable to post while the kidnap was active. This was when we were down to two non-posters post-kidnap. I figured it unlikely but now that we're down to one non-poster it doesn't work as a theory.

"7-Lincoln-200 to all units... Kidnapping in progress on the corner of seventh and Main. All units to Location."

....
...

"7-Adam-100 to 7-Lincoln-200.. At location, suspect and victim gone. spoke to witness. Suspect fits the description of Rosalind Dyer"

Hang on. I have just thought of something. If both Amy AND Friar are gone, is one the suspect and one is the victim?

[Gordon the Cook]

 Why wouldn’t the SK be able to post?

Dora was wondering if the phrasing of the kidnap post meant that both would be unable to post while the kidnap was active. This was when we were down to two non-posters post-kidnap. I figured it unlikely but now that we're down to one non-poster it doesn't work as a theory.

Hang on. I have just thought of something. If both Amy AND Friar are gone, is one the suspect and one is the victim?

Amy’s back

[Ina May the Midwife]

Thanks Gordon. You'll see from my previous posts that I'm aware of that.
I was quoting earlier posts for context in answering Lilly's question.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Vote gone in on moe

[Kevin the Armorer]

Why do you think Amy will be back and not Friar?

@Kevin the Armorer can you answer this?

I said very clearly earlier on why I thought this, before it even got to the final two. Of the last 6 or so left to post, Friar is (on appearances) the most helpful villager. Also, they were active around the same time yesterday, but not today. Those two things led me to believe Friar was the person kidnapped.

[Vincent the Artist]

Dora was wondering if the phrasing of the kidnap post meant that both would be unable to post while the kidnap was active. This was when we were down to two non-posters post-kidnap. I figured it unlikely but now that we're down to one non-poster it doesn't work as a theory.

Amy’s back

Back again....tell a friend.

I got caught up in work all afternoon, I have voted Moe at 19:10.

Re: me being on the same team as Moe, I can say I am not. The only reason I have engagement with him was because I was calling out inconsistencies in his posts.
His lack of mention of Ina in the post I called out is a lot more suss than me engaging with him!

[Mick the Drunk]

@Kevin the Armorer can you answer this?

I said very clearly earlier on why I thought this, before it even got to the final two. Of the last 6 or so left to post, Friar is (on appearances) the most helpful villager. Also, they were active around the same time yesterday, but not today. Those two things led me to believe Friar was the person kidnapped.

A lot of people assumed the same thing on read back, Benji and Dexter too

[Lilly the Millennial]

Vote gone in on Moe

[Moe the Innkeeper]

If someone has verifiable evidence that dexter is lying, keep it hidden till at least 09.59 tomorrow morning. Don't do it at 09.57 or you'll be munched most likely.

I doubt there is someone tbh, but just in case

[Amy the Singer]

Okay so I'm caught up. Really sorry about the long absence today - day from hell workwise. I read the 5 new pages and I went back to find #281. Thanks for pointing it out. Really cool clue! Great catch.
This game is way more complicated than I expected. Traitors is so straightforward in comparison. Anyway I will be able to post more over the next few days so bear with me.
On the basis of what I've seen, I'm going to throw a vote on Moe.

[Amy the Singer]

On the kidnap thing ... surely a kidnap would be a temporary absence? Why call it a kidnap and not a murder otherwise?

[Lilly the Millennial]

Being the GOAT that I am, I'll be using my protect this evening on myself naturally. It buys me a bit more time but I'm a sitting duck after it unfortunately.

Talk me through this - you previous posts imply you are the seer and peeked Moe. If that is the case how do you have a protect?

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

On the kidnap thing ... surely a kidnap would be a temporary absence? Why call it a kidnap and not a murder otherwise?

I’d presume it’s some time delayed murder.
If we took out the serial killer, it would save Friar.
If we don’t, friar is dead and the killer gets to pick again?

[Boris the Fool]

Being the GOAT that I am, I'll be using my protect this evening on myself naturally. It buys me a bit more time but I'm a sitting duck after it unfortunately.

Talk me through this - you previous posts imply you are the seer and peeked Moe. If that is the case how do you have a protect?

I alluded this a while ago but I'd suggest we talk about this tomorrow morning after munch. Give him benifit of doubt tonight.

[Vincent the Artist]

Being the GOAT that I am, I'll be using my protect this evening on myself naturally. It buys me a bit more time but I'm a sitting duck after it unfortunately.

Talk me through this - you previous posts imply you are the seer and peeked Moe. If that is the case how do you have a protect?

He isn't the seer. He even says so in the post you quoted.

[Ina May the Midwife]

You're still maintaining your innocence @Moe the Innkeeper, right?

What are your thoughts on who the wolves/SK are if not you?

[Moe the Innkeeper]

You're still maintaining your innocence @Moe the Innkeeper, right?

What are your thoughts on who the wolves/SK are if not you?

Im not maintaining anything,  I am innocent 

Call me a wolf for this if you want,  but anything I say regarding other players now will be looked at under the scope of me being a wolf. So ye will try to pick apart what im saying as bluffing or not and it will cause a distraction until the wolf priest is dead and that could be any time. And at the end of the day I have no additional insight than any other nrv at this stage

[Robin the Jester]

night 1 and 2 votes will both be landslides. will make for great wagonomics in the late game

[Lilly the Millennial]

You're still maintaining your innocence @Moe the Innkeeper, right?

What are your thoughts on who the wolves/SK are if not you?

Im not maintaining anything,  I am innocent 

Call me a wolf for this if you want,  but anything I say regarding other players now will be looked at under the scope of me being a wolf. So ye will try to pick apart what im saying as bluffing or not and it will cause a distraction until the wolf priest is dead and that could be any time. And at the end of the day I have no additional insight than any other nrv at this stage

When we get wolf priest if you are village then it will be shown, so do you want to give us your reads anyway so we can look back on them?

[Ina May the Midwife]

You're still maintaining your innocence @Moe the Innkeeper, right?

What are your thoughts on who the wolves/SK are if not you?

Im not maintaining anything,  I am innocent 

Call me a wolf for this if you want,  but anything I say regarding other players now will be looked at under the scope of me being a wolf. So ye will try to pick apart what im saying as bluffing or not and it will cause a distraction until the wolf priest is dead and that could be any time. And at the end of the day I have no additional insight than any other nrv at this stage

No offence was intended. I just wanted to give you the opportunity to advance a theory if you had one in case, as you've posited, there was some block on the seer action or something else going on.
I get not wanting to just throw stuff out there just for the sake of it though. A valid position.

[Mick the Drunk]

You're still maintaining your innocence @Moe the Innkeeper, right?

What are your thoughts on who the wolves/SK are if not you?

Im not maintaining anything,  I am innocent 

Call me a wolf for this if you want,  but anything I say regarding other players now will be looked at under the scope of me being a wolf. So ye will try to pick apart what im saying as bluffing or not and it will cause a distraction until the wolf priest is dead and that could be any time. And at the end of the day I have no additional insight than any other nrv at this stage

I gave a slim chance you might be good earlier based on your reaction, high post count and you're active and engaging. You've thrown the towel in though. Understandable given the evidence but any final thoughts?

[Mick the Drunk]

night 1 and 2 votes will both be landslides. will make for great wagonomics in the late game

Two freight trains on the votes

[Gordon the Cook]

Voting Results Night 1:

If Moe is guilty, can we assume Vincent is a good guy based off last nights vote?

[Moe the Innkeeper]

Im not maintaining anything,  I am innocent 

Call me a wolf for this if you want,  but anything I say regarding other players now will be looked at under the scope of me being a wolf. So ye will try to pick apart what im saying as bluffing or not and it will cause a distraction until the wolf priest is dead and that could be any time. And at the end of the day I have no additional insight than any other nrv at this stage

No offence was intended. I just wanted to give you the opportunity to advance a theory if you had one in case, as you've posited, there was some block on the seer action or something else going on.
I get not wanting to just throw stuff out there just for the sake of it though. A valid position.

Ive said it already. There are 2 possible scenarios for me

1. Dexter is lying. Improbable but not impossible 

2. Dexter is being truthful but wolves, probably elijah, messed with his power somehow and dexter got incorrect information that I'm the alpha. Probably more possible

[Mick the Drunk]

Voting Results Night 1:

If Moe is guilty, can we assume Vincent is a good guy based off last nights vote?

I would say no, clear runaway train and an easy place to hide a vote on a fellow wolf IMO

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

If Moe is guilty, can we assume Vincent is a good guy based off last nights vote?

I would say no, clear runaway train and an easy place to hide a vote on a fellow wolf IMO

Especially when it was clear so early in the day too.

[Moe the Innkeeper]

Im not maintaining anything,  I am innocent 

Call me a wolf for this if you want,  but anything I say regarding other players now will be looked at under the scope of me being a wolf. So ye will try to pick apart what im saying as bluffing or not and it will cause a distraction until the wolf priest is dead and that could be any time. And at the end of the day I have no additional insight than any other nrv at this stage

I gave a slim chance you might be good earlier based on your reaction, high post count and you're active and engaging. You've thrown the towel in though. Understandable given the evidence but any final thoughts?

I completely realise im for the chop tonight based on what's happened. There's no way realistically I can stay in the game. Ive given my thoughts there again on what I think happened

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

I gave a slim chance you might be good earlier based on your reaction, high post count and you're active and engaging. You've thrown the towel in though. Understandable given the evidence but any final thoughts?

I completely realise im for the chop tonight based on what's happened. There's no way realistically I can stay in the game. Ive given my thoughts there again on what I think happened

The focus on what you think has happened, with the lack of willingness to throw out a read list, makes it look like you're a wolf who is trying to make sure he doesn't give out any info that could be held against your teammates.

[Moe the Innkeeper]

I completely realise im for the chop tonight based on what's happened. There's no way realistically I can stay in the game. Ive given my thoughts there again on what I think happened

The focus on what you think has happened, with the lack of willingness to throw out a read list, makes it look like you're a wolf who is trying to make sure he doesn't give out any info that could be held against your teammates.

I said about 2 posts ago why me giving reads on players now is a bad idea.  Its an unnecessary distraction that will tried to be picked apart and time wasted on till the wolf priest is dead and im shown village

This isn't a normal game where i just flip village and ye know im good

[Lieutenant Grey]

MOD: VOTING CLOSES AT 9.30PM 

[Mick the Drunk]

The focus on what you think has happened, with the lack of willingness to throw out a read list, makes it look like you're a wolf who is trying to make sure he doesn't give out any info that could be held against your teammates.

I said about 2 posts ago why me giving reads on players now is a bad idea.  Its an unnecessary distraction that will tried to be picked apart and time wasted on till the wolf priest is dead and im shown village

This isn't a normal game where i just flip village and ye know im good

Info is a good thing readiness of when it becomes useful. Its still information that can swing a game or an opinion later in the game if you are revealed as legitimately good

[Dora the Explorer]

Robin, you're a man of few words.

[Dexter the Dragoon]

This is true but I'd add, not much has stuck out to me bar this erratic behaviour to warrant shooting them. I'll update later or when I get a chance to re read.
Suppose I could just say I'd shoot you

It does seem to be the cool thing to suggest at the moment!

Who you would shoot is an info point. Info points are good

Follow your own advice Moe, info points are good

[Boris the Fool]

Robin, you're a man of few words.

Needs to be looked at too. Random vote last night and just accepted.

[Moe the Innkeeper]

It does seem to be the cool thing to suggest at the moment!

Who you would shoot is an info point. Info points are good

Follow your own advice Moe, info points are good

I dont think they are in this situation for the reasons ive said.  And I trust my take on it more than yours

[Robin the Jester]

Robin, you're a man of few words.

right on

[Robin the Jester]

should be on more tomorrow. was busy today so found it hard to get stuck in

[Vincent the Artist]

Voting Results Night 1:

If Moe is guilty, can we assume Vincent is a good guy based off last nights vote?

It's werewolf. You don't assume anything.

However, I know I am not a wolf.