The Rookie Werewolf - Game Thread

[Dora the Explorer]

Wagon forming on Moe but Friar's logic is worth considering for sure.: that if Dexter had a power, would he be that clear about it.
And to elaborate on his theory slightly. Why would TWO roled people be that clear about it?

Friar? We haven't seen him all day. Is he on your mind a lot?

Boris' logic.

[Kevin the Armorer]

Ok sorry, what's priority now. I can't look past Dora being the SK. But Moe is pinned as the Alpha thanks to Dexter.

[Dora the Explorer]

Aside from Moe and me, has anyone got any other theories bar Magda's one on Ina?

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Aside from Moe and me, has anyone got any other theories bar Magda's one on Ina?

I'd worried about Magda, cause it felt she was super quick off the mark to start pushing about how Marki wanted you dead.

Though if Dex is correct about Moe, I'm far less concerned about that. And I have huge worries about you.

Also still have worries how Jacob seems to constantly be bringing up the traitor.

[Dora the Explorer]

That was the first thing he said. Is that THREE people saying stright out who they are then?
What do we think about Mick now? It was all a bit down in the dumps on Day 1...maybe he was hungover.
There are others, apart from the missing 2 folks, that are being fairly quiet. I am never as suspicious of that necessarily though as people post when they can although I know it can be a tactic!

[Magda the Maid]

Ok sorry, what's priority now. I can't look past Dora being the SK. But Moe is pinned as the Alpha thanks to Dexter.

Priority hasn't change, Moe has got to go.

[Jacob the Tailor]

Aside from Moe and me, has anyone got any other theories bar Magda's one on Ina?

I'd worried about Magda, cause it felt she was super quick off the mark to start pushing about how Marki wanted you dead.

Though if Dex is correct about Moe, I'm far less concerned about that. And I have huge worries about you.

Also still have worries how Jacob seems to constantly be bringing up the traitor.

Constantly bringing up the traitor? I talked about it at the start and after the failed kidnapping, like others did, its an important game mechanic. Have I mentioned it today?

[Robin the Jester]

hey dora, how goes the exploring?

[Jacob the Tailor]

My vote is in for Moe

[Robin the Jester]

Ok sorry, what's priority now. I can't look past Dora being the SK. But Moe is pinned as the Alpha thanks to Dexter.

Priority hasn't change, Moe has got to go.

poor moe

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Working on the assumption that Moe is a wolf, I've had a look back at his interactions since the start of the game:

Saturday & Sunday:
Mostly fluff & mechanics;
Interacts with:
Countess
Kevin
Jacob
Amy
Mick
Friar x 6
Magda
Ben

Yesterday:
Interacts with or references:
Lilly
Magda, Vincent, Robin & Mick (#100)
Vincent x 2
Mick, Kevin & Countess
Gordon
William (RIP)
Dora x 2
Ina & Magda
Magda x 4
Benji
Magda x 2
Edward
Vincent & Countess
Dexter x 4
Friar
Vincent (vote)
Boris
Dexter
Vincent
Robin
Dora
Ina
Robin
Magda
Boris
Countess

Today:
Interacts with or references:
Dora
Jacob
Magda
Vincent
Dexter (after Dexter's post at 0957)
Dexter
Benji
Robin
Weyland
Vincent
Kevin
Jacob
Dexter
Jacob
Dexter x 2
Magda
Dexter & Magda
Magda
Boris
Magda
Kevin

Tallying those (open to corrections on these):

Magda x 14
Dexter x 11
Vincent x 8
Friar x 7
Countess (RIP) x 4
Dora x 4
Jacob x 4
Kevin x 4
Mick x 4
Robin x 4
Benji x 3
Boris x 3
Ina x 2
Amy x 1
Edward x 1
Gordon x 1
Lilly x 1
Weyland x 1
William (RIP) x 1


So he's had at least one interaction with everyone and a lot with Magda, Vincent & Friar (excluding Dexter for now on the assumption he's green. I'd wager that one of those three are a wolf team mate of Moe's and if I were pushed on it, I'd probably go with Magda

[Magda the Maid]

Working on the assumption that Moe is a wolf, I've had a look back at his interactions since the start of the game:

Saturday & Sunday:
Mostly fluff & mechanics;
Interacts with:
Countess
Kevin
Jacob
Amy
Mick
Friar x 6
Magda
Ben

Yesterday:
Interacts with or references:
Lilly
Magda, Vincent, Robin & Mick (#100)
Vincent x 2
Mick, Kevin & Countess
Gordon
William (RIP)
Dora x 2
Ina & Magda
Magda x 4
Benji
Magda x 2
Edward
Vincent & Countess
Dexter x 4
Friar
Vincent (vote)
Boris
Dexter
Vincent
Robin
Dora
Ina
Robin
Magda
Boris
Countess

Today:
Interacts with or references:
Dora
Jacob
Magda
Vincent
Dexter (after Dexter's post at 0957)
Dexter
Benji
Robin
Weyland
Vincent
Kevin
Jacob
Dexter
Jacob
Dexter x 2
Magda
Dexter & Magda
Magda
Boris
Magda
Kevin

Tallying those (open to corrections on these):

Magda x 14
Dexter x 11
Vincent x 8
Friar x 7
Countess (RIP) x 4
Dora x 4
Jacob x 4
Kevin x 4
Mick x 4
Robin x 4
Benji x 3
Boris x 3
Ina x 2
Amy x 1
Edward x 1
Gordon x 1
Lilly x 1
Weyland x 1
William (RIP) x 1


So he's had at least one interaction with everyone and a lot with Magda, Vincent & Friar (excluding Dexter for now on the assumption he's green. I'd wager that one of those three are a wolf team mate of Moe's and if I were pushed on it, I'd probably go with Magda

So you think the person looking to shoot Moe since Day 1 is also a wolf... riiiight....

Why would I bring that much focus onto myself and Moe?

I called Moe out right off and stuck with it today as well long before he was revealed to be the Alpha by Dexter.

[Mick the Drunk]

Working on the assumption that Moe is a wolf, I've had a look back at his interactions since the start of the game:

Saturday & Sunday:
Mostly fluff & mechanics;
Interacts with:
Countess
Kevin
Jacob
Amy
Mick
Friar x 6
Magda
Ben

Yesterday:
Interacts with or references:
Lilly
Magda, Vincent, Robin & Mick (#100)
Vincent x 2
Mick, Kevin & Countess
Gordon
William (RIP)
Dora x 2
Ina & Magda
Magda x 4
Benji
Magda x 2
Edward
Vincent & Countess
Dexter x 4
Friar
Vincent (vote)
Boris
Dexter
Vincent
Robin
Dora
Ina
Robin
Magda
Boris
Countess

Today:
Interacts with or references:
Dora
Jacob
Magda
Vincent
Dexter (after Dexter's post at 0957)
Dexter
Benji
Robin
Weyland
Vincent
Kevin
Jacob
Dexter
Jacob
Dexter x 2
Magda
Dexter & Magda
Magda
Boris
Magda
Kevin

Tallying those (open to corrections on these):

Magda x 14
Dexter x 11
Vincent x 8
Friar x 7
Countess (RIP) x 4
Dora x 4
Jacob x 4
Kevin x 4
Mick x 4
Robin x 4
Benji x 3
Boris x 3
Ina x 2
Amy x 1
Edward x 1
Gordon x 1
Lilly x 1
Weyland x 1
William (RIP) x 1


So he's had at least one interaction with everyone and a lot with Magda, Vincent & Friar (excluding Dexter for now on the assumption he's green. I'd wager that one of those three are a wolf team mate of Moe's and if I were pushed on it, I'd probably go with Magda

This is really good, my only note on it is I would go at the other end. I would say wolves briefly interact at best. Its a bigger pool mind you. Id be surprised if Magda and Moe (Alpha Wolf) were both wolves with that level of interaction. The context of the interactions is as important too. I'll have a look and see if anything stands out

[Edward the Barber]

There is another possible reason there was only one kill this morning, they are staggered, where only one of the wolves or SK get to kill each morning. It is possible an on thread task was completed to see who kills first? Probably not the case but it is possible

Im just reading back the thread and I wasn’t looking at your posts in particular but in hindsight it’s piqued my interest because we have had a kidnapping since. 

Have you been looking for on thread tasks?

[Kevin the Armorer]

Working on the assumption that Moe is a wolf, I've had a look back at his interactions since the start of the game:

Saturday & Sunday:
Mostly fluff & mechanics;
Interacts with:
Countess
Kevin
Jacob
Amy
Mick
Friar x 6
Magda
Ben

Yesterday:
Interacts with or references:
Lilly
Magda, Vincent, Robin & Mick (#100)
Vincent x 2
Mick, Kevin & Countess
Gordon
William (RIP)
Dora x 2
Ina & Magda
Magda x 4
Benji
Magda x 2
Edward
Vincent & Countess
Dexter x 4
Friar
Vincent (vote)
Boris
Dexter
Vincent
Robin
Dora
Ina
Robin
Magda
Boris
Countess

Today:
Interacts with or references:
Dora
Jacob
Magda
Vincent
Dexter (after Dexter's post at 0957)
Dexter
Benji
Robin
Weyland
Vincent
Kevin
Jacob
Dexter
Jacob
Dexter x 2
Magda
Dexter & Magda
Magda
Boris
Magda
Kevin

Tallying those (open to corrections on these):

Magda x 14
Dexter x 11
Vincent x 8
Friar x 7
Countess (RIP) x 4
Dora x 4
Jacob x 4
Kevin x 4
Mick x 4
Robin x 4
Benji x 3
Boris x 3
Ina x 2
Amy x 1
Edward x 1
Gordon x 1
Lilly x 1
Weyland x 1
William (RIP) x 1


So he's had at least one interaction with everyone and a lot with Magda, Vincent & Friar (excluding Dexter for now on the assumption he's green. I'd wager that one of those three are a wolf team mate of Moe's and if I were pushed on it, I'd probably go with Magda

Thanks for putting that together. If I was to pick from your top 3, I'd go with Vincent. No on anything in particular against Vincent, but I've better vibes from Magda and Friar. It was Vincent post 116 who said about wolves keeping their distance.... while quoting Moe.

[Kevin the Armorer]

Sorry I hit send before finishing my thought above... I was going to add that it is probably looking who Moe "wasn't" interacting with.

[Dora the Explorer]

I have my vote in on Moe for now. I can't particualrly see myself changing it before the cut off time unles something mad happens on the thread.

[Magda the Maid]

No surprise my vote is in for Moe.

Moe has got to go.

[Boris the Fool]

Working on the assumption that Moe is a wolf, I've had a look back at his interactions since the start of the game:

Saturday & Sunday:
Mostly fluff & mechanics;
Interacts with:
Countess
Kevin
Jacob
Amy
Mick
Friar x 6
Magda
Ben

Yesterday:
Interacts with or references:
Lilly
Magda, Vincent, Robin & Mick (#100)
Vincent x 2
Mick, Kevin & Countess
Gordon
William (RIP)
Dora x 2
Ina & Magda
Magda x 4
Benji
Magda x 2
Edward
Vincent & Countess
Dexter x 4
Friar
Vincent (vote)
Boris
Dexter
Vincent
Robin
Dora
Ina
Robin
Magda
Boris
Countess

Today:
Interacts with or references:
Dora
Jacob
Magda
Vincent
Dexter (after Dexter's post at 0957)
Dexter
Benji
Robin
Weyland
Vincent
Kevin
Jacob
Dexter
Jacob
Dexter x 2
Magda
Dexter & Magda
Magda
Boris
Magda
Kevin

Tallying those (open to corrections on these):

Magda x 14
Dexter x 11
Vincent x 8
Friar x 7
Countess (RIP) x 4
Dora x 4
Jacob x 4
Kevin x 4
Mick x 4
Robin x 4
Benji x 3
Boris x 3
Ina x 2
Amy x 1
Edward x 1
Gordon x 1
Lilly x 1
Weyland x 1
William (RIP) x 1


So he's had at least one interaction with everyone and a lot with Magda, Vincent & Friar (excluding Dexter for now on the assumption he's green. I'd wager that one of those three are a wolf team mate of Moe's and if I were pushed on it, I'd probably go with Magda

This is really good, my only note on it is I would go at the other end. I would say wolves briefly interact at best. Its a bigger pool mind you. Id be surprised if Magda and Moe (Alpha Wolf) were both wolves with that level of interaction. The context of the interactions is as important too. I'll have a look and see if anything stands out

I've already been looking myself because I'm sus on Magda. The main focus of Magda is her saying she woudk shoot Moe for calling out low posters. It's entirely possible that Magda was doing this so if she was killed off and revealed wolf on a read back it would look good for Moe. Who would suspect she been wanting to kill a wolf from day one.

[Kevin the Armorer]

Since every is declaring. I voted for Moe earlier.

[Dora the Explorer]

Yes but to the point of organising a wagon on him? That seems excessive! Albeit she is determined- if there are ulterior motives I wouldnt necessarily suspect wolf on wolf though as it is a lot of focus on him from her.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Sorry I hit send before finishing my thought above... I was going to add that it is probably looking who Moe "wasn't" interacting with.

That's true but also harder to do - 5 with only one interaction and nearly everyone with 4 or less

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

So you think the person looking to shoot Moe since Day 1 is also a wolf... riiiight....

Why would I bring that much focus onto myself and Moe?

I called Moe out right off and stuck with it today as well long before he was revealed to be the Alpha by Dexter.

You're familiar with the concept of faked interactions though, right? So when one wolf is revealed, the other can point to the arguments and use that to gain village points. 

Listen, I'm not hanging my hat on it being you but if I had to choose now, that's probably where I'd go

[Ina May the Midwife]

Vote in on Moe at 17:13

Based on Dexter's info.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

I'm at a kids' soccer match this evening so won't be around but like most people, I'll almost certainly be on Moe.

[Boris the Fool]

If Magda has a pew pew then why hasn't she pew pew? All we have is a kidnap from sk so if Magda has a pew pew then why not shoot Moe and get it out of the way so we can vote for someone else tonight.?

[Magda the Maid]

So you think the person looking to shoot Moe since Day 1 is also a wolf... riiiight....

Why would I bring that much focus onto myself and Moe?

I called Moe out right off and stuck with it today as well long before he was revealed to be the Alpha by Dexter.

You're familiar with the concept of faked interactions though, right? So when one wolf is revealed, the other can point to the arguments and use that to gain village points. 

Listen, I'm not hanging my hat on it being you but if I had to choose now, that's probably where I'd go

Wolf on wolf interactions on Day 1 is one hell of a ballsy move and a dumb one too.

I'd like to think my interactions encouraged Dexter to peek Moe. I essentially handed the village their first wolf and somehow trying to get scapedgoat for it. Laughable.

[Boris the Fool]

You're familiar with the concept of faked interactions though, right? So when one wolf is revealed, the other can point to the arguments and use that to gain village points. 

Listen, I'm not hanging my hat on it being you but if I had to choose now, that's probably where I'd go

Wolf on wolf interactions on Day 1 is one hell of a ballsy move and a dumb one too.

I'd like to think my interactions encouraged Dexter to peek Moe. I essentially handed the village their first wolf and somehow trying to get scapedgoat for it. Laughable.

You didn't tho, you gave a week reason for saying you would shoot but it's Dexter that "handed" them if Dexter is truthful.

[Ina May the Midwife]

Could be good reason for someone with a gun not shooting Moe. The Alpha is hard to track and even harder to kill. We know the shot fired yesterday failed. The shooter knows who they targetted. We'll have to trust them to make the right call.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Vote in for Moe @17.25

[Magda the Maid]

Wolf on wolf interactions on Day 1 is one hell of a ballsy move and a dumb one too.

I'd like to think my interactions encouraged Dexter to peek Moe. I essentially handed the village their first wolf and somehow trying to get scapedgoat for it. Laughable.

You didn't tho, you gave a week reason for saying you would shoot but it's Dexter that "handed" them if Dexter is truthful.

Weak or not....

[Dora the Explorer]

You have a lot of soccer matches Weyland!

Here is something I noticed when I went back to look at Dexter's post from yesterday evening.
At post 324 Benjamin calls CM, Marki
At post 382 Gordon calls her Markie

In all other interactions she is being called Countess (or CM in my case). Could be nothing, i just thought it was interesting.

[Dora the Explorer]

@Lilly the Millennial I would like to hear more from you, please, you have been very quiet

@Friar Tuck @Amy the Singer are you still with us? Surely if there was a kidnapping it was just one person.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

You have a lot of soccer matches Weyland!

Here is something I noticed when I went back to look at Dexter's post from yesterday evening.
At post 324 Benjamin calls CM, Marki
At post 382 Gordon calls her Markie

In all other interactions she is being called Countess (or CM in my case). Could be nothing, i just thought it was interesting.

It was U12 football last night, U13 soccer tonight

[Dora the Explorer]

"7-Lincoln-200 to all units... Kidnapping in progress on the corner of seventh and Main. All units to Location."

....
...

"7-Adam-100 to 7-Lincoln-200.. At location, suspect and victim gone. spoke to witness. Suspect fits the description of Rosalind Dyer"

Hang on. I have just thought of something. If both Amy AND Friar are gone, is one the suspect and one is the victim?

[Ina May the Midwife]

It's possible but as we're seeing today, that'd really narrow stuff down in terms of identifying the SK for both the village and the wolves with all bar those two posting. I can't see the SK action leaving them that exposed by design.

[Ina May the Midwife]

Amy said in her post this morning that she wouldn't be back until around 4pm. So the initial lack of posting was expected but by her own estimation she expected to be back by now.

[Robin the Jester]

Yes but to the point of organising a wagon on him? That seems excessive! Albeit she is determined- if there are ulterior motives I wouldnt necessarily suspect wolf on wolf though as it is a lot of focus on him from her.

who is the 'she' here you are talking about?

[Robin the Jester]

Vote in on Moe at 17:13

Based on Dexter's info.

great bit of clarification on your reason for voting moe

[Dora the Explorer]

True. Too obvious, I suppose.
Another thing I saw yesterday evening was Friar looking at Lily. And now he's gone.