The Traitors- Boards/FOG Edition

[Laura the Lace Mistress]

Sorry to see you go McDonald. I'll obviously be sticking with my Friar suspicion tomorrow. The voting pattern does throw Dora in the mix properly for me now, but first the good Friar Tuck needs a thorough inspection.

[Betty the Beggar]

Both voted together all three nights. Any chance that's the mechanism? If they vote together they get an extra vote?

That might work as a mechanism. It can't be a prize for it to happen twice with the same people.

Seems a bit overpowered for the wolves to have prizes and powers. Lorcan said anyone can win them right?

Maybe they have a backroom together?Ina and Gordon didn't seem to know whether they were faithful or traitor

[Dora the Explorer]

TBH the ha ha response of both is odd too. Caught rapid.

I'm laughing because I know exactly how it looks and I can't defend it and even tonight me waiting and trying to decide who I was gonna vote on it played right into it. 

One thing I will say is I'm not playing WW long enough but in the past year and half or so I can't remember any other game that two wolves had to vote together to get an extra vote it makes no sense but that's where we are at.

[Dora the Explorer]

That might work as a mechanism. It can't be a prize for it to happen twice with the same people.

Seems a bit overpowered for the wolves to have prizes and powers. Lorcan said anyone can win them right?

Maybe they have a backroom together?Ina and Gordon didn't seem to know whether they were faithful or traitor

Rhoda is absolute correct it would be massively over powered.

[Rhoda the Spinster]

That might work as a mechanism. It can't be a prize for it to happen twice with the same people.

Seems a bit overpowered for the wolves to have prizes and powers. Lorcan said anyone can win them right?

Maybe they have a backroom together?Ina and Gordon didn't seem to know whether they were faithful or traitor

I was a lover in a former game and we had a backroom. We were both villagers. I think Gordon did know the alignment of Ina, the.... at the end of his reveal post was to allow Ina to reveal.
If wolves were paired they wouldn't need a backroomas they already have one. I hope they are properly paired and one dies with other.

[Rhoda the Spinster]

Maybe they have a backroom together?Ina and Gordon didn't seem to know whether they were faithful or traitor

Rhoda is absolute correct it would be massively over powered.

It doesn't matter, you're a policy lynch now.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Maybe they have a backroom together?Ina and Gordon didn't seem to know whether they were faithful or traitor

Rhoda is absolute correct it would be massively over powered.

You would say that though 🤣

[Betty the Beggar]

okay. not double banishment
triple banishment.
at least i find out if my missus was a good one or not

He didn't know if you believe this

[Betty the Beggar]

Maybe they have a backroom together?Ina and Gordon didn't seem to know whether they were faithful or traitor

Rhoda is absolute correct it would be massively over powered.

Not if there was only three traitors to begin with, which i believe is the case.
The two left tonite will have a choice between recruiting or murder. If there is only two left then they could be wiped out if they murder with an insta banish and a banishment.

[Dora the Explorer]

Rhoda is absolute correct it would be massively over powered.

It doesn't matter, you're a policy lynch now.

I know I am and accept it like I said I can argue against it. If anyone gets a peek tomorrow peek me before killing me. Or just kill friar first at least. I'm not gonna be able change anyones mind.

[Dora the Explorer]

It doesn't matter, you're a policy lynch now.

I know I am and accept it like I said I can argue against it. If anyone gets a peek tomorrow peek me before killing me. Or just kill friar first at least. I'm not gonna be able change anyones mind.

Can't argue against it.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

okay. not double banishment
triple banishment.
at least i find out if my missus was a good one or not

He didn't know if you believe this

They never voted together either

[Rhoda the Spinster]

okay. not double banishment
triple banishment.
at least i find out if my missus was a good one or not

He didn't know if you believe this

That's odd, but in other games I've seen with lovers I think they knew. It may have been in the OP in some of them (not that I would read that).

[Dora the Explorer]

Rhoda is absolute correct it would be massively over powered.

Not if there was only three traitors to begin with, which i believe is the case.
The two left tonite will have a choice between recruiting or murder. If there is only two left then they could be wiped out if they murder with an insta banish and a banishment.

Over 20 players started the game you're guaranteed there's more than 3 traitors.

[lorcand1990]

Players, you have Banished another Faithful tonight. To make matters worse, The Traitors will strike next.

See you all in the morning! Thread closes at 11pm.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

He didn't know if you believe this

That's odd, but in other games I've seen with lovers I think they knew. It may have been in the OP in some of them (not that I would read that).

A game i played previously had lovers. They weren't both village but were linked so I can understand Gordon's hesitation.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Not if there was only three traitors to begin with, which i believe is the case.
The two left tonite will have a choice between recruiting or murder. If there is only two left then they could be wiped out if they murder with an insta banish and a banishment.

Over 20 players started the game you're guaranteed there's more than 3 traitors.

How many?

[Rhoda the Spinster]

He didn't know if you believe this

They never voted together either

I don't think lovers have to vote together in amy games I played. 
This might be a wolf thing were they are brothers or something and have to vote together for this power to work, rather than full on lover characters that are twinned.

Or else one of them is a wolf with two votes and the other an unluckily faithful.

Out of curiosity is there any commonality in voters on the 'losing' tied thread between the three nights. In case one person's vote doesn't count for some reason.

[Dora the Explorer]

Over 20 players started the game you're guaranteed there's more than 3 traitors.

How many?

I dont know so don't as me stupid questions but they have to be.

[William the Grave Robber]

Back from Abbotstown. Had to pull in to to speed read and vote.
Looks like Friar is the next one for the chop so. Had been suspicious of him but my focus was elsewhere today.
Resolve that one and go from there.

As I said earlier, I think traitors recruit if they feel they're in trouble and murder if they feel safe

[Dora the Explorer]

@Weyland the Blacksmith Sorry I'm actually annoyed

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Boris: Donald,
William: Rhonda,
Friar: McDonald, Laura, Betty
McDonald: Chris, Dora
Rhonda: Countess, William 
Donald: Weyland, Boris,

Friar yet to vote i think?

They never voted together either

I don't think lovers have to vote together in amy games I played. 
This might be a wolf thing were they are brothers or something and have to vote together for this power to work, rather than full on lover characters that are twinned.

Or else one of them is a wolf with two votes and the other an unluckily faithful.

Out of curiosity is there any commonality in voters on the 'losing' tied thread between the three nights. In case one person's vote doesn't count for some reason.

zeena - prada, gordon, mcdonald, william, rhoda, amy

No crossover

[Rhoda the Spinster]

At least we have a new lead. This looks promising anyway.

[William the Grave Robber]

Vincent, McDonald, Weyland & Rhoda I lean faithful on you all now. All posted within 5 minutes, sometimes multiple times, of lorc post about murder in plain sight.

I think a traitor is not online as they know what is coming or goes straight to their backroom with a WTF

I'll add Betty to this list so

So if I remove my newly established faithful core and subtract them from the 10 winners of yesterday's game, it leaves

Benji
Ina
Prada
Friar
Laura( won a seer prize today)
Pat.

I think one of Benji, Ina, Prada, Friar or Pat is a wolf and used a vote power won yesterday

Should have stuck with this line of thinking I had last night, especially once Pat was revealed faithful and Prada traitor. Should have voted Friar tonight.

[Rhoda the Spinster]

Boris: Donald,
William: Rhonda,
Friar: McDonald, Laura, Betty
McDonald: Chris, Dora
Rhonda: Countess, William 
Donald: Weyland, Boris,

Friar yet to vote i think?

I don't think lovers have to vote together in amy games I played. 
This might be a wolf thing were they are brothers or something and have to vote together for this power to work, rather than full on lover characters that are twinned.

Or else one of them is a wolf with two votes and the other an unluckily faithful.

Out of curiosity is there any commonality in voters on the 'losing' tied thread between the three nights. In case one person's vote doesn't count for some reason.

zeena - prada, gordon, mcdonald, william, rhoda, amy

No crossover

Mc Donald on both those, How was his vote yesterday? Just don't want to go down the wrong path.

[William the Grave Robber]

I'll leave you to the side Rhoda, ftm, no harm done sure😅

[Rhoda the Spinster]

I'll add Betty to this list so

So if I remove my newly established faithful core and subtract them from the 10 winners of yesterday's game, it leaves

Benji
Ina
Prada
Friar
Laura( won a seer prize today)
Pat.

I think one of Benji, Ina, Prada, Friar or Pat is a wolf and used a vote power won yesterday

Should have stuck with this line of thinking I had last night, especially once Pat was revealed faithful and Prada traitor. Should have voted Friar tonight.

So there was a faithful core  

[William the Grave Robber]

Should have stuck with this line of thinking I had last night, especially once Pat was revealed faithful and Prada traitor. Should have voted Friar tonight.

So there was a faithful core  

Looks like it👍 I'll own that one

[William the Grave Robber]

Doesn't mean I'm right though

[Boris the Fool]

Is it not just possible that someone won an armoury award that gave them a double vote or allowed them to cancel someone's vote? It could have been a different person each time and doesn't mean they were traitoring. Assuming that either one of those options is a legitimate armoury prize?

[Rhoda the Spinster]

Is it not just possible that someone won an armoury award that gave them a double vote or allowed them to cancel someone's vote? It could have been a different person each time and doesn't mean they were traitoring. Assuming that either one of those options is a legitimate armoury prize?

If they did it would have to be traitors who won it each time, as no one has owned up to it. At this stage a faithful who was manipulating votes would have to come forward as it looks like Dora and Friar are traitors now.

[William the Grave Robber]

Is it not just possible that someone won an armoury award that gave them a double vote or allowed them to cancel someone's vote? It could have been a different person each time and doesn't mean they were traitoring. Assuming that either one of those options is a legitimate armoury prize?

If I won that I would reveal I had it though. If not initially then at least at some point

[Dora the Explorer]

At least I know I'm not gonna be banished tonight anyway 🤣🤣

[William the Grave Robber]

At least I know I'm not gonna be banished tonight anyway 🤣🤣

Don't you mean murdered tonight? You obviously can't murder yourself

[Betty the Beggar]

Not if there was only three traitors to begin with, which i believe is the case.
The two left tonite will have a choice between recruiting or murder. If there is only two left then they could be wiped out if they murder with an insta banish and a banishment.

Over 20 players started the game you're guaranteed there's more than 3 traitors.

This isn't a normal game though,  we have the guaranteed option of a recruitment. Four plus a recruit would be fairly unstoppable

[Dora the Explorer]

Over 20 players started the game you're guaranteed there's more than 3 traitors.

This isn't a normal game though,  we have the guaranteed option of a recruitment. Four plus a recruit would be fairly unstoppable

Yeahh that's good point forgot ablut the recruitment. 

Only way ye can save this is by getting a peek or alignment check me and you, I'd be surprised if you not gone tonight tho. That's all I can say on it. Friar has to be first of us to go or else ye have no chance.

[lorcand1990]

Nighty night all

[Rhoda the Spinster]

Quick post, as I have a meeting at 8 and another at 10. I checked OP, morning post and prize posts by Lorcan.

Traitors are mentioned but it never says they are eligible to win.

If they aren't and only faithful can win we can make a pool of potential faithful and potential traitor.

This would have Betty, Laura and William as potential faithful.

I would be potential traitor as I went to armory but did not win prize twice.

Obviously Dora/Tuck need to be resolved first but can include/exclude other people as likely traitor/faithful IF this assumption is correct

[William the Grave Robber]

Morning all.
I will be busy cheering on the boys in green tonight, so won't be on thread from 7 onwards.
I'll send you a proxy vote beforehand lorc.
All with the caveat I'm not murdered obviously

[Donald the Spoofer]

Quick post, as I have a meeting at 8 and another at 10. I checked OP, morning post and prize posts by Lorcan.

Traitors are mentioned but it never says they are eligible to win.

If they aren't and only faithful can win we can make a pool of potential faithful and potential traitor.

This would have Betty, Laura and William as potential faithful.

I would be potential traitor as I went to armory but did not win prize twice.

Obviously Dora/Tuck need to be resolved first but can include/exclude other people as likely traitor/faithful IF this assumption is correct

Morning folks,

I was away all day yesterday and have was out last night. I voted for boris based on the voting on day1 as I believed there may have been a traitor with a double vote that day. I need to go back and check who else was possible, I think it was friar and dora and maybe more. Will go back and check today.

Regarding Rhoda's post here, this is unlikely imo. Traitors can win shields on the show so I dont see any reason they can't win prizes here. 
I won an insta banish on Tuesday and it was obvious I used it on Zeena