The Traitors- Boards/FOG Edition

[Donald the Spoofer]

I hope the prize format stays the same tomorrow. That way we’ll know who the top ten are and that we have an insta ban, a save from murder and (probably) a dagger double vote.

You might have to kill one of your own tomorrow, traitors, if you win that prize, for thread cred. Whoever wins the ban one please will you consult with thread tomorrow?

I dont think it is allowed, traitors to kill traitors, not in the tv show anyway.

[Amy the Singer]

Goodnight folks, I hope to see you tomorrow. 😬

[McDonald the Farmer]

I hope the prize format stays the same tomorrow. That way we’ll know who the top ten are and that we have an insta ban, a save from murder and (probably) a dagger double vote.

You might have to kill one of your own tomorrow, traitors, if you win that prize, for thread cred. Whoever wins the ban one please will you consult with thread tomorrow?

I dont think it is allowed, traitors to kill traitors, not in the tv show anyway.

the prize is instant banishment not murder. Traitors banish traitors in the show.

[Boris the Fool]

post #314

https://forumofgames.com/showthread.php?...7#pid97477
You did think there was likely a traitor there though.

Yeah, I think that's a pretty standard expectation and a common tactic.

[Laura the Lace Mistress]

Good night all. Got it wrong on Benji but didn't have much to go on and went with my gut and gave my reasons.

[lorcand1990]

Thread is now closed. No more posting please until 8am

[McDonald the Farmer]

Morning all

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Morning all. 🌄

[Vincent the Artist]

Still here for now! Have to assume any dieing will occur at 10am.

[Prada the Seamstress]

Still here for now! Have to assume any dieing will occur at 10am.

Morning! Yeah the OP says morning actions are announced on thread at 10am

[Prada the Seamstress]

Folks I think we are clutching at straws to suggest there were spoiled votes due to mispelling

A double vote, for anyone who has watched the tv show, is the most plausible

I was thinking more about this last night, and I agree with this. I think it was obvious my post was voting for Zeena. So there was definitely something up with the voting.

[Rhoda the Spinster]

Morning all. Interested to see what today brings.

[Boris the Fool]

Morning all. I’ll be on the move at 10 today - hope I dont miss too much.

[Maeve the Madam]

Good morning all.
I was able to try and read back during the night and figured out why it looks to me why Amy had so many posts about being a Faithful.
When somebody quoted her AND when she quoted anybody who quoted her quote, her original post still stands out prominently when I was scrolling through which made it look like they were different posts so apologies for the confusion.
That's not saying I won't vote for her again if I have my suspicions though 😉.
Is there any way of collapsing quotes until you want to read them on this site as it's very difficult to follow otherwise?

[Laura the Lace Mistress]

ben - laura, dora, tuck, boris, magda, betty

Chance to enter the Armoury
Benjamin the Alchemist
Ina May the Midwife
Prada the Seamstress
Friar Tuck
Laura the Lace Mistress
McDonald the Farmer
Betty the Beggar
Pat the Baker
Vincent the Artist
William the Graverobber

Laura, Friar and Betty on both lists.

Morning. So, not a great place to be. I can only say that I did not get anything in the armoury, and I made my case against Benji with the limited evidence there is. I got it wrong. Day 1, very little to go on.

Adding another dimension to the above.... now I may have missed the posts (so please do show the quote if I'm getting it wrong), but neither Betty nor Friar made their intention to vote for Benji known before the vote. They never had any suspicion on him.... yet they voted for him. To me, that feels suss.

[Boris the Fool]

I voted for benjy probably swayed mostly by the newbie/not a newbie “confusion”.
I’ll keep an eye on things today but might revert to my other suspect from yesterday which was betty.
I guess all of us newbies are out of immunity from now on 😟

[Rhoda the Spinster]

This is the first time I've played traitors. Is it similar to werewolf were the traitors have a backroom were they can talk all day or can they only chat at night?

[Lilly the Millennial]

Morning

[Dora the Explorer]

Good morning all.
I was able to try and read back during the night and figured out why it looks to me why Amy had so many posts about being a Faithful.
When somebody quoted her AND when she quoted anybody who quoted her quote, her original post still stands out prominently when I was scrolling through which made it look like they were different posts so apologies for the confusion.
That's not saying I won't vote for her again if I have my suspicions though 😉.
Is there any way of collapsing quotes until you want to read them on this site as it's very difficult to follow otherwise?

Wasn't it just two people that pushed it tho with similar posts or am I wrong?

I read back and I didn't feel like there was much of a mention of faithful from her until them two them it because a topic where propel were quoting each other.

[Prada the Seamstress]

Morning

Good morning @Lilly the Millennial you missed the round table last night. What do you make of it all?

[Vincent the Artist]

[lorcand1990]

Good morning everyone. At your first breakfast there was no murder to announce, however today it is a very different case. Not all of you have posted this morning, but for poor Amy the Singer, they were unable to. Last night, the Traitors murdered Amy.

Oh by the way, there’s not just one player who isn’t with us this morning. The Traitors were very busy yesterday. They killed poor Magda the Maid, by Murder in Plain Sight.

You don’t need me to tell you that both Amy and Magda were Faithful.

I can also announce that tonight there will be a double banishment! The 2 players with the most votes will be eliminated. If there is a tie between the top 2 players, they will both be eliminated. If there is a tie between 3 or more players there will be a re-vote. If there is a tie between the 2nd & 3rd placed players there will be a re-vote between those two players.

I’ll be back later to give you details on today’s task. I hope you're thirsty for more. In the meantime, feel free to chat amongst yourself. You should have plenty to discuss…..

[Vincent the Artist]

But also, what the fuck. How did the murder in plain sight work and goodbye Amy 😥

[McDonald the Farmer]

Amy, Magda rest in peace 😢

Guess we need to go over Magda and all interactions that mentioned her.

[Rhoda the Spinster]

Murder in plain sight. There must be clues in whoever interacted with Magda.

Sorry Amy is gone, but glad to know she was faithful.

[McDonald the Farmer]

Would the murder in plain sight be after last nights lynch?

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Magda is an odd one, Amy somewhat too. Id have thought Vinny was a goner of those on the list

[Vincent the Artist]

Amy, Magda rest in peace 😢

Guess we need to go over Magda and all interactions that mentioned her.

This is it, there has to be something there that we can lean on.

[Vincent the Artist]

Magda is an odd one, Amy somewhat too. Id have thought Vinny was a goner of those on the list

Might be as well to keep me for the moment as I'm linked with Betty so to speak so probably keeps me in the mix for banishment whereas Amy was not in contention in that sense.

[Rhoda the Spinster]

Might be as well to keep me for the moment as I'm linked with Betty so to speak so probably keeps me in the mix for banishment whereas Amy was not in contention in that sense.

Not necessarily. If a safe traitor (eg you) was murdered it throws suspicion on the two who weren't. 
Not saying you are a traitor, but you weren't necessarily immune from being murdered.

[Laura the Lace Mistress]

Magda is an odd one, Amy somewhat too. Id have thought Vinny was a goner of those on the list

Is it odd? Amy that is. I had her in my "faithful vibe" list and her posts were quite strong. Seems a good choice to kill. Strong faithful. I'll have to look back over her posts as to who she was pointing the finger at but that can either be misdirection by the traitors or maybe one of them feeling she was on the right track.

[Vincent the Artist]

Might be as well to keep me for the moment as I'm linked with Betty so to speak so probably keeps me in the mix for banishment whereas Amy was not in contention in that sense.

Not necessarily. If a safe traitor (eg you) was murdered it throws suspicion on the two who weren't. 
Not saying you are a traitor, but you weren't necessarily immune from being murdered.

It keeps me in the mix either way as neither Betty nor myself have been cleared with Benjis reveal.

There could have been a dagger in the armoury which would have given someone a double vote.

A dagger? Specific wording there

This is about all I could see post voting that might be interesting but it's a stab in thr dark (pun fully intended)

[Donald the Spoofer]

Would the murder in plain sight be after last nights lynch?

Usually on the tv show, yes, would be a good place to start

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Magda is an odd one, Amy somewhat too. Id have thought Vinny was a goner of those on the list

Is it odd? Amy that is. I had her in my "faithful vibe" list and her posts were quite strong. Seems a good choice to kill. Strong faithful. I'll have to look back over her posts as to who she was pointing the finger at but that can either be misdirection by the traitors or maybe one of them feeling she was on the right track.

Odd to me in the context of Betty alignment checking Vincent and Benjamin. Vincent somewhat confirmed good, or at least more to argue good that the other two (in my mind anyway). Amy was my most village lean so I can see the logic to it and also top poster.

[Laura the Lace Mistress]

There could have been a dagger in the armoury which would have given someone a double vote.

A dagger? Specific wording there

On the plain sight murder... this is the most recent thing last night that pops out at me. "Dagger" is fairly well known mechanism in the game. So why this query and "specific wording". Or might a traitor have had to mention a weapon or one of the task key words in response to the target?

[Dora the Explorer]

Is there anything that stands out from magda? Did anyone thank her posts or interact with her oddly?

I had a scan I can't really see anything. Only thing is she was onto the double vote and dagger pretty quick. Would her "killed in plain sight" be linked to that?

Maybe I'm grasping but maybe she want picked as such it coukd be been get sokeien to mention dagger or double vote and the first person that's not a traitor receives a dagger that's murder in plain sight?

[Betty the Beggar]

Magda is an odd one, Amy somewhat too. Id have thought Vinny was a goner of those on the list

Might be as well to keep me for the moment as I'm linked with Betty so to speak so probably keeps me in the mix for banishment whereas Amy was not in contention in that sense.

I think you're in the clear, if anyone has to go it would be me, when I flip green it would clear you. Very strange they didn't get rid of you. You're also probably No. 1 candidate for recruitment. Will try and have a look at the Magda stuff

[Dora the Explorer]

A dagger? Specific wording there

On the plain sight murder... this is the most recent thing last night that pops out at me. "Dagger" is fairly well known mechanism in the game. So why this query and "specific wording". Or might a traitor have had to mention a weapon or one of the task key words in response to the target?

Snap I'm thinking same as you.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

A dagger? Specific wording there

On the plain sight murder... this is the most recent thing last night that pops out at me. "Dagger" is fairly well known mechanism in the game. So why this query and "specific wording". Or might a traitor have had to mention a weapon or one of the task key words in response to the target?

A dagger didnt register to me as a double vote, I thought she slipped which is why I queried

[Vincent the Artist]

Certainly the dagger discussion looks like a possible link here and worth reviewing, in the tv show there's always a level of risk to the Traitors being rumbled but often the act is so innocuous and mild that it's near indistinguishable from regular behaviour... except maybe when Alan Carr had to recite that specific phrase, so could well lend credence to the specific wording used by weyland