The Traitors- Boards/FOG Edition

[McDonald the Farmer]

and me

d1 yeetShow Content

zeena - prada, gordon, mcdonald, william, rhoda, amy
ben - laura, dora, tuck, boris, magda, betty
betty - vincent, chris, ben, ina
amy - maeve, count
william - weyland
vincent - donald
mauve - pat
dora - zeena

Betty got the last vote? So Ben gone

My spidey senses tell me traitor Betty did win a prize but it wasn’t an alignment peek but a double vote at banishment.

[Magda the Maid]

There could have been a dagger in the armoury which would have given someone a double vote.

[Boris the Fool]

@Boris the Fool something just off about Boris and also being one to want to vote out the few in the murder pool. I know others have defended this stance but it doesn't work for me.

Nothing I can defend on the "off" side of things. But I specifically said that voting out the murder pool folks didn't make sense. I said it might be relevant later.

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Which makes the double vote theory for Betty plausible. 
@Betty the Beggar was that it? Or are you not allowed say?

She claimed an alignment check, she hardly won two prizes

Claimed being the operative word.

[Gordon the Cook]

and me

d1 yeetShow Content

zeena - prada, gordon, mcdonald, william, rhoda, amy
ben - laura, dora, tuck, boris, magda, betty
betty - vincent, chris, ben, ina
amy - maeve, count
william - weyland
vincent - donald
mauve - pat
dora - zeena

Betty got the last vote? So Ben gone

Thats not how ties work in this game, as per the rules on page 1.

8) In the event of a tie at the Banishment Phase, there will be 1 round of re-voting. If there is still a tie the player banished will be selected by fate.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Or last vote if there is a tie. Is that what you're saying @Weyland the Blacksmith

I was wrong, OP says revotete and then chance if still a tie

[Rhoda the Spinster]

Well this is a mess.

Betty def needs to be booted out tomorrow. I will lay out a few thoughts before I finish up as there's a 1/3 chance I won't be here for breakfast.

@Betty the Beggar is my prime suspect based in sudden appearance during the task and now thus weird jump on benji which shows her to be untrustworthy.

@Rhoda the Spinster the earlier "I'll give my thoughts later" message is classic wolf behaviour to buy time.

@Boris the Fool something just off about Boris and also being one to want to vote out the few in the murder pool. I know others have defended this stance but it doesn't work for me.

All of the above could be complete crap in the long run but just in case I'm murdered later this is where I'm at.

Was busy yesterday and I was up to my eyeballs in work today so hadn't time to look at the thread. Lorc mesaged to ask if I was playing, so I posted to show I was. As soon as I had a chance I interacted with the game.

[Pat the Baker]

Not with Betty under suspicion now. If Vinnie is a faithful leaving him would make him look suspicious.

If betty and vincent are alive tomorrow, betty is being flipped next.

Well Betty will defo be alive as she isn’t on the list.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

There could have been a dagger in the armoury which would have given someone a double vote.

A dagger? Specific wording there

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Can you explain this like I'm an idiot please? I don't follow your logic.

If Betty was a Traitor and did win the prize - she picks two faithfuls and declares on thread to try gain village credit. She has a choice between Zeena and Benji to save herself and goes Benji as she knows he will be a faithful even though it looked like this would have brought us to a tie. If she went for Zeena she would still have been saved but was she worried about Zeena flipping red?

Surely she doesn't need to if it's between me and Ben? It could have been either of us, and neither flips red so it does make her look super suss.

[William the Grave Robber]

So 10 players won.

3 claimed prizes.

Is there a traitor in the other 7 who won a double vote prize and kept it quiet!?

[Amy the Singer]

There's likely more than one traitor in the last 3 Benji voters if Zeena is a traitor.

[Vincent the Artist]

Will @lorcand1990 be offering us any clarification on the votes or are we to be left stewing 😆

[Magda the Maid]

There could have been a dagger in the armoury which would have given someone a double vote.

A dagger? Specific wording there

Yeah it's a game mechanic in the Traitors. Also not the first time it's been mentioned in the thread.

[McDonald the Farmer]

So 10 players won.

3 claimed prizes.

Is there a traitor in the other 7 who won a double vote prize and kept it quiet!?

10 got the chance to win prizes. 3 claimed prizes. Mine and William’s were corroborated by Lorcan on thread. Betty’s wasn’t. And tonight it looks like votes manipulated in some way.

[Pat the Baker]

I suspect another prize earlier.

I say this is most likely rather than Betty lying about what prize she would as she would be quickly found out.

[Rhoda the Spinster]

Some kind of vote manipulation if count is correct. Either a Zeena vote was blocked or someone who voted for Benjamin got two votes. Other alternative is that Zeena was immune from banishment, but I don't think that is a thing in Traitors.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

If Betty was a Traitor and did win the prize - she picks two faithfuls and declares on thread to try gain village credit. She has a choice between Zeena and Benji to save herself and goes Benji as she knows he will be a faithful even though it looked like this would have brought us to a tie. If she went for Zeena she would still have been saved but was she worried about Zeena flipping red?

Surely she doesn't need to if it's between me and Ben? It could have been either of us, and neither flips red so it does make her look super suss.

You're the biggest beneficiary of Betty's late vote tbf

[Betty the Beggar]

and me

d1 yeetShow Content

zeena - prada, gordon, mcdonald, william, rhoda, amy
ben - laura, dora, tuck, boris, magda, betty
betty - vincent, chris, ben, ina
amy - maeve, count
william - weyland
vincent - donald
mauve - pat
dora - zeena

Betty got the last vote? So Ben gone

The OP has a mechanism for a tie so its not that.To the person who asked about me coming on, I set an alarm for 9.20 to give me time to read the thread and vote. I was always going to vote late as my name was in the mixer, that's just common sense.


Im struggling to understand why people would think I wouldn't vote for Benji given a straight choice between him and Zeena. Benji gives twice the information. Again, that's just common sense to go for him. 
For the people saying i HAVE to go, I won a prize, announced it on thread when asked and voted to get the most information. I'm not sure what else you'd have me do?

[Pat the Baker]

If Betty was a Traitor and did win the prize - she picks two faithfuls and declares on thread to try gain village credit. She has a choice between Zeena and Benji to save herself and goes Benji as she knows he will be a faithful even though it looked like this would have brought us to a tie. If she went for Zeena she would still have been saved but was she worried about Zeena flipping red?

Surely she doesn't need to if it's between me and Ben? It could have been either of us, and neither flips red so it does make her look super suss.

She would if you and her are Traitors as voting Benji saves you

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Ah OK, I get you. Thanks

[Boris the Fool]

@Boris the Fool something just off about Boris and also being one to want to vote out the few in the murder pool. I know others have defended this stance but it doesn't work for me.

Nothing I can defend on the "off" side of things. But I specifically said that voting out the murder pool folks didn't make sense. I said it might be relevant later.

post #314

[McDonald the Farmer]

Congratulations to:

Benjamin the Alchemist
Ina May the Midwife
Prada the Seamstress
Friar Tuck
Laura the Lace Mistress
McDonald the Farmer
Betty the Beggar
Pat the Baker
Vincent the Artist
William the Graverobber

who answered the quickest and have won a trip to the Armoury. I will PM winner(s) shortly. For clarity, I will randomise the 10 correct entries in order to determine who wins a prize(s)

 the ten with the opportunity to win a prize.

[Rhoda the Spinster]

So 10 players won.

3 claimed prizes.

Is there a traitor in the other 7 who won a double vote prize and kept it quiet!?

10 got the chance to win prizes. 3 claimed prizes. Mine and William’s were corroborated by Lorcan on thread. Betty’s wasn’t. And tonight it looks like votes manipulated in some way.

The other two prizes were corroborated because they had immediate ramifications. If an unknown prize caused this voting result then not all prizes are notified.

Is there a possibility someone's vote wasn't counted? Too early or too late or not in the right format?

[Chris the Carpenter]

Defintely something off about that count, I've gone back there on posts and counted votes, no mistaking it should be a tie.

[Prada the Seamstress]

10 got the chance to win prizes. 3 claimed prizes. Mine and William’s were corroborated by Lorcan on thread. Betty’s wasn’t. And tonight it looks like votes manipulated in some way.

The other two prizes were corroborated because they had immediate ramifications. If an unknown prize caused this voting result then not all prizes are notified.

Is there a possibility someone's vote wasn't counted? Too early or too late or not in the right format?

Unless it's mine? I misspelled Zeena as Xena. Just cause they ALWAYS come up with weird and wonderful spellings in the show. But I think it was very clear who I was voting for.

[Amy the Singer]

Congratulations to:

Benjamin the Alchemist
Ina May the Midwife
Prada the Seamstress
Friar Tuck
Laura the Lace Mistress
McDonald the Farmer
Betty the Beggar
Pat the Baker
Vincent the Artist
William the Graverobber

who answered the quickest and have won a trip to the Armoury. I will PM winner(s) shortly. For clarity, I will randomise the 10 correct entries in order to determine who wins a prize(s)

 the ten with the opportunity to win a prize.

Cross referencing that with the Benji voters might be a start, unless a traitor voted elsewhere and used a second vote to boot Benji?

[Donald the Spoofer]

So 10 players won.

3 claimed prizes.

Is there a traitor in the other 7 who won a double vote prize and kept it quiet!?

This is quite posible. I mean the chances of a traitor or multiple traitors being in the 10 winners is quite high in any case

[Rhoda the Spinster]

The other two prizes were corroborated because they had immediate ramifications. If an unknown prize caused this voting result then not all prizes are notified.

Is there a possibility someone's vote wasn't counted? Too early or too late or not in the right format?

Unless it's mine? I misspelled Zeena as Xena. Just cause they ALWAYS come up with weird and wonderful spellings in the show. But I think it was very clear who I was voting for.

People mispell names in the real Traitors, I don't think that matters.

[Amy the Singer]

ben - laura, dora, tuck, boris, magda, betty

Chance to enter the Armoury
Benjamin the Alchemist
Ina May the Midwife
Prada the Seamstress
Friar Tuck
Laura the Lace Mistress
McDonald the Farmer
Betty the Beggar
Pat the Baker
Vincent the Artist
William the Graverobber

Laura, Friar and Betty on both lists.

[Prada the Seamstress]

Congratulations to:

Benjamin the Alchemist - Betty
Ina May the Midwife - Betty
Prada the Seamstress - Zeena
Friar Tuck - Ben
Laura the Lace Mistress - Ben
McDonald the Farmer - Zeena
Betty the Beggar - Ben
Pat the Baker - Maeve
Vincent the Artist - Betty
William the Graverobber - Zeena

who answered the quickest and have won a trip to the Armoury. I will PM winner(s) shortly. For clarity, I will randomise the 10 correct entries in order to determine who wins a prize(s)

Betty: Vincent, Chris, Benji, Ina
Vincent: Donald
Ben: Laura, Dora, Tuck, Boris, Magda, Betty
Zeena: Prada, Gordon, MacDonald, William, Rhoda, Amy
Amy: Maeve, Countess
William: Weyland
Maeve: Pat
Dora: Zeena

The armoury and who they voted for:
Benjamin the Alchemist - Betty
Ina May the Midwife - Betty
Prada the Seamstress - Zeena
Friar Tuck - Ben
Laura the Lace Mistress - Ben
McDonald the Farmer - Zeena 
Betty the Beggar - Ben
Pat the Baker - Maeve
Vincent the Artist - Betty
William the Graverobber - Zeena

My thoughts are either Betty got 2 votes and jumped on Ben to save Zeena, or my vote didn't count due to the misspelling. I'm more inclined to go with the first though.

[Vincent the Artist]

Nothing I can defend on the "off" side of things. But I specifically said that voting out the murder pool folks didn't make sense. I said it might be relevant later.

post #314

Christ you're right, Apologies I mist have mixed you up with someone else and nightmare trying to find the post on phone. Either way it wasn't you so sorry about the accusation!

[lorcand1990]

Before I leave you tonight I regret to inform you that Frank the Tank will not be joining us and has been removed from the game. Frank was a Faithful

@Lilly the Millennial did not vote tonight, one more missed vote will result in their removal from the game

[Vincent the Artist]

Can someone post the players up for murder?

With nothing else really to go on and the chance their are traitors on the list, my mind is on banishing one of them tonight. That list will linger for the rest of the game

Not really, by morning one will be gone for certain and that'll leave only 3. It'd suit the Traitors to have attention focused on us. Plus interesting the few who seem keen to dash the Murder pool on the rocks.

@Boris the Fool it was actually @Donald the Spoofer meant to tag in the other post as my other suspect for being a traitor.

[Donald the Spoofer]

Folks I think we are clutching at straws to suggest there were spoiled votes due to mispelling

A double vote, for anyone who has watched the tv show, is the most plausible

[Amy the Singer]

Nothing I can defend on the "off" side of things. But I specifically said that voting out the murder pool folks didn't make sense. I said it might be relevant later.

post #314

https://forumofgames.com/showthread.php?...7#pid97477
You did think there was likely a traitor there though.

[Amy the Singer]

So 3 faithfuls down with Frank not playing and another by morning.

[Vincent the Artist]

Until tomorrow fellow players... maybe!

[McDonald the Farmer]

I hope the prize format stays the same tomorrow. That way we’ll know who the top ten are and that we have an insta ban, a save from murder and (probably) a dagger double vote.

You might have to kill one of your own tomorrow, traitors, if you win that prize, for thread cred. Whoever wins the ban one please will you consult with thread tomorrow?

[McDonald the Farmer]

God speed final 3 xxx