The Traitors- Boards/FOG Edition

[Gordon the Cook]

Ladies and Gentlemen...

@Benjamin the Alchemist has recieved the most votes and has been banished from the castle

Benjamin, could you please stand up and reveal if you are a Faithful or Traitor

👋🙋‍♂️ben

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Poo.
Fwiw. Amy and Gordon

Elaberate while you can. This is no benifit to anyone.

Did do in post 511.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Well benji is out, this could prove I'm faithful which is great but Betty looks super suspicious now

If Betty is a traitor her alignment check is likely bollocks

Its an extremely weird vote in my eyes

[McDonald the Farmer]

Vote manipulation?

I blame Zeena personally. Her posts have become cheekier so it’s either because she k ew she’d survive or she’s on the schnapps

[Amy the Singer]

Betty voting Benji could mean she isn’t worried about him flipping red so either knows he’s a faithful (which means she’s a traitor)

Can you explain this like I'm an idiot please? I don't follow your logic.

[Gordon the Cook]

Betty voting Benji could mean she isn’t worried about him flipping red so either knows he’s a faithful (which means she’s a traitor)

Can you explain this like I'm an idiot please? I don't follow your logic.

that means you and pat are safe tonight, right?

[McDonald the Farmer]

Farewell Benjamin the faithful. Gonna miss your dry wit that wasn’t being appreciated enough in here.

[Amy the Singer]

Looks like I'm voted out.
So before I take my leave (as Faithful btw), I think Amy is being weird and also a bit you.
Previous sessions have taught me to look at who votes for a faifhful

How am I being weird? Is this your explanation for the "fwiw Gordon and Amy poo" comment?

[lorcand1990]

Players, you have banished an innocent Faithful, one of your own. The Traitors will be laughing heading back to their turret. 

What’s more, they will strike next, as they have the chance to murder a Faithful tonight. Sleep well, if you can. Thread remains open until 11pm.

[Amy the Singer]

Can you explain this like I'm an idiot please? I don't follow your logic.

that means you and pat are safe tonight, right?

How?

[Pat the Baker]

Betty voting Benji could mean she isn’t worried about him flipping red so either knows he’s a faithful (which means she’s a traitor)

Can you explain this like I'm an idiot please? I don't follow your logic.

If Betty was a Traitor and did win the prize - she picks two faithfuls and declares on thread to try gain village credit. She has a choice between Zeena and Benji to save herself and goes Benji as she knows he will be a faithful even though it looked like this would have brought us to a tie. If she went for Zeena she would still have been saved but was she worried about Zeena flipping red?

[Chris the Carpenter]

@Betty the Beggar just a coincidence yet again about your timing is it?

[McDonald the Farmer]

Where the official vote count?

[Pat the Baker]

Can you explain this like I'm an idiot please? I don't follow your logic.

that means you and pat are safe tonight, right?

No still in danger along with Vincent.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Where the official vote count?

There hasn't been one, on count back it looks a tie to me

[Donald the Spoofer]

Well with ben flipping faithful, I would be inclined to say vincent and betty are also faithful for now

[Amy the Singer]

Can you explain this like I'm an idiot please? I don't follow your logic.

If Betty was a Traitor and did win the prize - she picks two faithfuls and declares on thread to try gain village credit. She has a choice between Zeena and Benji to save herself and goes Benji as she knows he will be a faithful even though it looked like this would have brought us to a tie. If she went for Zeena she would still have been saved but was she worried about Zeena flipping red?

If Betty is a traitor she'd know if Zeena was too, unless this is a roundabout way to say she saved a fellow traitor?

[Dora the Explorer]

Benjamin flipping faithful puts huge focus back on Betty for me. She told us Benji and Vincent were aligned and then voted Benji with no clear reasoning, if she believed her own result that vote makes very little sense. Was she trying to save Zeena?

Also fully aware I was one of first on benji I stand by my reasoning for it and for first day of the game you have to go on hunch.

Sorry Benjamin

[Magda the Maid]

By my count we've 22 declared votes on the thread.

I don't think we've a declared vote from Lilly or Frank.

[McDonald the Farmer]

Can you explain this like I'm an idiot please? I don't follow your logic.

If Betty was a Traitor and did win the prize - she picks two faithfuls and declares on thread to try gain village credit. She has a choice between Zeena and Benji to save herself and goes Benji as she knows he will be a faithful even though it looked like this would have brought us to a tie. If she went for Zeena she would still have been saved but was she worried about Zeena flipping red?

This makes lots of sense right now. TBH I don’t think any of the 5 are traitors and sorry one of you is gone in the morning but rest of the faithfuls have to do their best to win the prizes.

[Gordon the Cook]

that means you and pat are safe tonight, right?

How?

Because betty said that ben and vin are same alignment. so vin is faithful.
why would they leave wincent alive?
making you and pat safe.
no?

[Pat the Baker]

If Betty was a Traitor and did win the prize - she picks two faithfuls and declares on thread to try gain village credit. She has a choice between Zeena and Benji to save herself and goes Benji as she knows he will be a faithful even though it looked like this would have brought us to a tie. If she went for Zeena she would still have been saved but was she worried about Zeena flipping red?

If Betty is a traitor she'd know if Zeena was too, unless this is a roundabout way to say she saved a fellow traitor?

Yea that’s what I meant about being worried about Zeena flipping red.

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Looks like I'm voted out.
So before I take my leave (as Faithful btw), I think Amy is being weird and also a bit you.
Previous sessions have taught me to look at who votes for a faifhful

How am I being weird? Is this your explanation for the "fwiw Gordon and Amy poo" comment?

I already said you were suss to me. In fact you gave out to me saying I was Omgus-ing you. So it's hardly news.

Poo was me thinking I'd been voted out on Day 1.
Someone who voted me/Ben are traitors. You each voted for one of us.
The Betty theory is also good. 
And also Ina disappeared before vote time. Why?

[McDonald the Farmer]

What if Betty winning a prize was real but it wasn’t alignment it was a double vote?

[Vincent the Artist]

Well this is a mess.

Betty def needs to be booted out tomorrow. I will lay out a few thoughts before I finish up as there's a 1/3 chance I won't be here for breakfast.

@Betty the Beggar is my prime suspect based in sudden appearance during the task and now thus weird jump on benji which shows her to be untrustworthy.

@Rhoda the Spinster the earlier "I'll give my thoughts later" message is classic wolf behaviour to buy time.

@Boris the Fool something just off about Boris and also being one to want to vote out the few in the murder pool. I know others have defended this stance but it doesn't work for me.

All of the above could be complete crap in the long run but just in case I'm murdered later this is where I'm at.

[Gordon the Cook]

Where the official vote count?

There hasn't been one, on count back it looks a tie to me

and me

d1 yeetShow Content

zeena - prada, gordon, mcdonald, william, rhoda, amy
ben - laura, dora, tuck, boris, magda, betty
betty - vincent, chris, ben, ina
amy - maeve, count
william - weyland
vincent - donald
mauve - pat
dora - zeena

[Pat the Baker]

By my count we've 22 declared votes on the thread.

I don't think we've a declared vote from Lilly or Frank.

Frank hasn’t posted and Lily has only 1 post so they didn’t vote.

[Amy the Singer]

How?

Because betty said that ben and vin are same alignment. so vin is faithful.
why would they leave wincent alive?
making you and pat safe.
no?

Not with Betty under suspicion now. If Vinnie is a faithful leaving him would make him look suspicious.

[Magda the Maid]

Yeah that's my read of it too. Also neither of them went into the armoury either to win a prize which could have been in use.

[Chris the Carpenter]

Benjamin flipping faithful puts huge focus back on Betty for me. She told us Benji and Vincent were aligned and then voted Benji with no clear reasoning, if she believed her own result that vote makes very little sense. Was she trying to save Zeena?

Also fully aware I was one of first on benji I stand by my reasoning for it and for first day of the game you have to go on hunch.

Sorry Benjamin

You have to go with your hunch and mine is Betty. No post but suddenly sees the game this morning when others who did post yesterday missed it. 

Then with 3 mins to go finally votes for Benji out of nowhere.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

There hasn't been one, on count back it looks a tie to me

and me

d1 yeetShow Content

zeena - prada, gordon, mcdonald, william, rhoda, amy
ben - laura, dora, tuck, boris, magda, betty
betty - vincent, chris, ben, ina
amy - maeve, count
william - weyland
vincent - donald
mauve - pat
dora - zeena

Betty got the last vote? So Ben gone

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

By my count we've 22 declared votes on the thread.

I don't think we've a declared vote from Lilly or Frank.

Frank hasn’t posted and Lily has only 1 post so they didn’t vote.

Which makes the double vote theory for Betty plausible. 
@Betty the Beggar was that it? Or are you not allowed say?

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

and me

d1 yeetShow Content

zeena - prada, gordon, mcdonald, william, rhoda, amy
ben - laura, dora, tuck, boris, magda, betty
betty - vincent, chris, ben, ina
amy - maeve, count
william - weyland
vincent - donald
mauve - pat
dora - zeena

Betty got the last vote? So Ben gone

Sorry no, tied vote leads to a revote 

Something fishy with the votes, mine tallies with the above

[William the Grave Robber]

and me

d1 yeetShow Content

zeena - prada, gordon, mcdonald, william, rhoda, amy
ben - laura, dora, tuck, boris, magda, betty
betty - vincent, chris, ben, ina
amy - maeve, count
william - weyland
vincent - donald
mauve - pat
dora - zeena

Betty got the last vote? So Ben gone

Usually yes, but this is traitors so tie means revote

[Amy the Singer]

By my count we've 22 declared votes on the thread.

I don't think we've a declared vote from Lilly or Frank.

Frank hasn’t posted and Lily has only 1 post so they didn’t vote.

So vote shenanigans somewhere.

[Prada the Seamstress]

I really need to not play on my phone. 
I have gone back and done this again to double check. 

Betty: Vincent, Chris, Benji, Ina
Vincent: Donald
Ben: Laura, Dora, Tuck, Boris, Magda, Betty
Zeena: Prada, Gordon, MacDonald, William, Rhoda, Amy
Amy: Maeve, Countess
William: Weyland
Maeve: Pat
Dora: Zeena

Didn't vote:

Frank the Tank
Lilly The Millennial

So by my count that's a tie for Ben and Zeena. 
The OP says that goes to a revote so there's some vote manipulation at play here.

[Gordon the Cook]

Because betty said that ben and vin are same alignment. so vin is faithful.
why would they leave wincent alive?
making you and pat safe.
no?

Not with Betty under suspicion now. If Vinnie is a faithful leaving him would make him look suspicious.

If betty and vincent are alive tomorrow, betty is being flipped next.

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Or last vote if there is a tie. Is that what you're saying @Weyland the Blacksmith

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Frank hasn’t posted and Lily has only 1 post so they didn’t vote.

Which makes the double vote theory for Betty plausible. 
@Betty the Beggar was that it? Or are you not allowed say?

She claimed an alignment check, she hardly won two prizes

[William the Grave Robber]

I suspect another prize earlier.