The Gang Solves The Werewolf Crisis

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

That first post of Benjis is literally quoting the OP. How would it be a slip. Apart from the fact that I'm not Dee🤣

Well. If you flip Dee, it looks bad for ben, but flipping you b4 ben would be the plan.

What does flipping mean, please?

[Prada the Seamstress]

Well. If you flip Dee, it looks bad for ben, but flipping you b4 ben would be the plan.

What does flipping mean, please?

Killing me via lynch/shot/whatever other methods may or may not exist.

[Kevin the Armorer]

I didn't cop at the start that Dennis was a seer and therefore good. I thought a seer could be on either side. Obviously I realise now that the wolves know who they all are, ergo, they don't need a seer. The only one they dont know who it is is the SK. 
Furthermore, in my initial supposition, I think that Dee and Dennis are related. Dee: (from outside) I can hear you guys!! Dennis you know your system doesn’t work on me, I’m your sister Goddammit!
I think I was running with Prada's theory that two were related and therefore

This one @Kevin the Armorer

The formatting is off on the original post as it's a direct quote from the OP

To me, it’s a leap that can only happen if they know prada is dee.
Then calling Pat Dennis based on the op makes sense.
That’s why i called it a slip by Ben.
But it’s only a real slip if you’re flip Dee.
Let’s flip you and find out
Of course you will deny it, lol.
What else can you do?

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

I don't understand, sorry. Noone can actually kill Dee as she is just in the OP? I know she correlates to someone here but what does Kevin mean?

[Dexter the Dragoon]

But they were away, they said. I mean sure they didnt even vote. (Magda that is).

I do think it looks weird who Laura Lacemaker voted.

And are we any closer to finding out who keeps shooting and poisoning people? Could that be the same person? Is the ham smell significant, and if so, how?

Gosh, i feel like Joanna on this thread a bit.

The fact that Betty and Dexter both voted for me, even though it was agreed to give an amnesty is interesting to me. They considered that the other players would stick by that for tonight, and so I was a "safe" vote, in the same way Laura's vote for Robin was.

Amy and Dexter both oddly not voted for at all. And Wendy on noone's radar bar mine.

Wendy (sorry WEndy) is still on my radar. She would have known Ina was a villager so easy to get rid of her while backing up the whole idea of her (Ina) being a wolf.

I also am going to go back and see who called Chris' behaviour wolfie after the vote.

Frank, the village vig, took the shot that killed ed. (friendly fire, but more than likely it was a use it or lose it bullet, I'd have risked a shot too)
The wolves, specifically ryan, if i recall correctly, who poisioned a rolled villager.

What if... Dee is a McPoyle and her brother is Dennis, who is Pat the Baker. Quite a few in the mix for wolves for me now.

Caught up on the thread and remembered this from my notes, why did you say Pat the Baker was Dennis? Bit odd that he was.

And what made you think he was a wolf?

FFA for the moment:
- Dexter. His mentioing of one lady wolf twice on the thread has me interested as to why he thinks (knows?) that.
- On re-reading, and I know that I thought to protect Prada this morning, but now I think she is sewing (ho ho) confusion deliberately
- Based on my earlier theory in relation to the SK, I think Magda and Vernon. Not totally sure why but leaning towards Vernon.

Also on my radar are Laura and Magda, esp if there is "one female wolf".

If there are a larger number of wolves, like was supposed by Kevin and William early on- both said 5 (why?), we are in a spot of bother. If Rhonda becomes a mod kill and is a villager, then we are running out of people. Folks, we NEED to get a wolf.

Simple math Benjamin. There were 23 players to begin with, of which 14 were male and only 9 were female. Assuming there are 4 wolves, this put the likely number of female wolves at 1.57. Since there are no half people here I surmised that there was a good chance of 3 males and 1 female.

[Kevin the Armorer]

Having a Frank player and a Frank character was a bad idea.
I think Ben may have confused me talking about Frank character with me talking about Frank player.


Frank, the character is dee and dennis dad.

[Kevin the Armorer]

I don't understand, sorry. Noone can actually kill Dee as she is just in the OP? I know she correlates to someone here but what does Kevin mean?

Dee is the alpha wolf. as seer is dead, that power does not really do anything anymore

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

It's worse than we thought folks, there are not just wolves in here, there are accountants!



(Just kidding folks, I work with a tonne of them, lovely people!)

[Kevin the Armorer]

Well. If you flip Dee, it looks bad for ben, but flipping you b4 ben would be the plan.

What does flipping mean, please?

It’s reference to flipping over there role card so we can all see it. With auto-priest, that happens when they are dead.

[Prada the Seamstress]

Having a Frank player and a Frank character was a bad idea.
I think Ben may have confused me talking about Frank character with me talking about Frank player.


Frank, the character is dee and dennis dad.

Benji has done the same thing with my joking about Pat marrying his cousin and applied it to the OP. Are there even cousins in Its Always Sunny? I haven't watched it.

[William the Grave Robber]

How many votes were declared on thread.

Id be suspicious of anyone who voted for someone already nominated on thread.

So Betty, Amy & Vernon

I'm the only one who declared and voted for Betty, does that make me suspicious?

My thinking is that being second on a person is a nice safe place to hide for a wolf

All 3 were village, this could be an easy way for a wolf to throw suspicion on villagers.


I've looked back at you posts because you said the SK was a sub and got an extra kill today as a result, when I asked you about it you said it was poorly worded.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

I don't understand, sorry. Noone can actually kill Dee as she is just in the OP? I know she correlates to someone here but what does Kevin mean?

Dee is the alpha wolf. as seer is dead, that power does not really do anything anymore

How so? Can a seer check if someone is the alpha wolf? Or just whether or not they are a wolf? Also, what is special about being an alpha, please, or does that vary?

[Prada the Seamstress]

I don't understand, sorry. Noone can actually kill Dee as she is just in the OP? I know she correlates to someone here but what does Kevin mean?

Dee is the alpha wolf. as seer is dead, that power does not really do anything anymore

You don't think there's a back up/apprentice role then?

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Having a Frank player and a Frank character was a bad idea.
I think Ben may have confused me talking about Frank character with me talking about Frank player.


Frank, the character is dee and dennis dad.

Benji has done the same thing with my joking about Pat marrying his cousin and applied it to the OP. Are there even cousins in Its Always Sunny? I haven't watched it.

Ah jasys lads, is this related to an actual TV show? I. can. not. keep. up! When people were talking about not having watched  the show, I thought they meant The Traitors. I am as thick!!

[Prada the Seamstress]

Benji has done the same thing with my joking about Pat marrying his cousin and applied it to the OP. Are there even cousins in Its Always Sunny? I haven't watched it.

Ah jasys lads, is this related to an actual TV show? I. can. not. keep. up! When people were talking about not having watched  the show, I thought they meant The Traitors. I am as thick!!

Yeah, the theme of this game is It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

I thought it was just a name to be funny, not like ACTUALLY related to the show. Now I get refereces to "googling the shield", and "I haven't watched the show" and stuff. I swear Lorcan and co will never let me on another game, I am so slow on the uptake.

Anyway, I can allay your fears Kevin, I was quoting the OP and referencing Prada's thoughts on all things marriage. Now I am going to go to google the show and see if that can help me at all.

[Prada the Seamstress]

I have voted Laura just there, for the record. Out again this evening for the football. Will be offline from about 5.30 till after the game so any questions launch em my way now

[Laura the Lace Mistress]

i went thru frank's posts and nothing really there. new player so some questions regarding the seer.

could be a ploy - get the newbie to ask questions on the seer so more experienced wolves can evaluate answers?

[Prada the Seamstress]

I thought it was just a name to be funny, not like ACTUALLY related to the show. Now I get refereces to "googling the shield", and "I haven't watched the show" and stuff. I swear Lorcan and co will never let me on another game, I am so slow on the uptake.

Anyway, I can allay your fears Kevin, I was quoting the OP and referencing Prada's thoughts on all things marriage. Now I am going to go to google the show and see if that can help me at all.

Especially cousin marriage 😎

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

oh right I see now that IN THE SHOW Dennis and Dee are twins, so I see where you are coming from on that.
Why did you ask Wendy were she and Pat married though?

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Now I have to go and re-read the entire thread again.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

TBH at this stage you should just shoot me for being really, really bad at this game.

[William the Grave Robber]

Seems we can't vote yet, but i think voting frank the tank would be a safe vote for now.
Can't wait to see what others think about this plan.
Lot's of time left.

Having a Frank player and a Frank character was a bad idea.
I think Ben may have confused me talking about Frank character with me talking about Frank player.


Frank, the character is dee and dennis dad.

So when you mentioned Frank the Tank you actually meant the character Frank? Why did you want ro yeet the village vig?

Have I missed something?

[Prada the Seamstress]

Are you Pat's cousin/wife?

Yes you did though. You asked Wendy was she Pat's cousin/wife.

I know I am a slow learner, but I thought this was fairly straightforward, no?

Je suis perdu!

Oh, lol. So I did. More joking around. I tend to do that a lot, as you might have figured by now

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Are you though? Feels to me like you're playing a Paudie. (This is a reference to the TV show The Traitors)

[Chris the Carpenter]

My wording was poor there,  I meant that yesterday's kill was left until 9.59 this morning

Nope, this is what you said:

"That reads to me that the SK has been given a second kill this morning because they missed out on one yesterday morning."

I didn't deny I said it, i said my wording was poor

[Dexter the Dragoon]

I have faced down many an enemy in battle so I know well how a nervous man acts.

I will be voting for Benjamin again tonight. 
His 'I'm new and I'm confused' act just doesnt ring true. He was the first to mention FFAs. He is overly defensive. He was very put out to have been fingered as a liar while Frank was believed to be a newbie. He wants to be seen as TSTBAW. And yet the wolves have killed 3 people, all of whom hes taken issue with. Pat, Wendy, Maeve.

On the other hand he could be our SK. Betty and Moe were also players he had on his radar. 

He is just deflecting all the time. He was very active around the time Maeve was poisoned and then immediately pointed the finger at Moe before anyone could even consider him. 

Benjamin is up to something.. Of that I have no doubt. Or maybe he's just got the touch of death and those he mentions most just happen to die.

I'll be sending my vote in shortly. I need to exercise Digby before the rain takes hold so I might miss proceedings later.

If any ladies are looking for me I should back in my abode before 10. 😉

[Prada the Seamstress]

Are you though? Feels to me like you're playing a Paudie. (This is a reference to the TV show The Traitors)

Hahaha I'm watching the traitors alright. That feels like a backhanded compliment 🤣

[William the Grave Robber]

I have faced down many an enemy in battle so I know well how a nervous man acts.

I will be voting for Benjamin again tonight. 
His 'I'm new and I'm confused' act just doesnt ring true. He was the first to mention FFAs. He is overly defensive. He was very put out to have been fingered as a liar while Frank was believed to be a newbie. He wants to be seen as TSTBAW. And yet the wolves have killed 3 people, all of whom hes taken issue with. Pat, Wendy, Maeve.

On the other hand he could be our SK. Betty and Moe were also players he had on his radar. 

He is just deflecting all the time. He was very active around the time Maeve was poisoned and then immediately pointed the finger at Moe before anyone could even consider him. 

Benjamin is up to something.. Of that I have no doubt. Or maybe he's just got the touch of death and those he mentions most just happen to die.

I'll be sending my vote in shortly. I need to exercise Digby before the rain takes hold so I might miss proceedings later.

If any ladies are looking for me I should back in my abode before 10. 😉

Does anyone else make your big sword quiver?

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

More and more becoming clear as I read back....

[Chris the Carpenter]

How many votes were declared on thread.

Id be suspicious of anyone who voted for someone already nominated on thread.

So Betty, Amy & Vernon

My thinking is that being second on a person is a nice safe place to hide for a wolf

All 3 were village, this could be an easy way for a wolf to throw suspicion on villagers.


I've looked back at you posts because you said the SK was a sub and got an extra kill today as a result, when I asked you about it you said it was poorly worded.

Who are you talking about when you say all three are dead? Amy and Vernon are still alive

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

@Dexter the Dragoon When did I take issue with Maeve aside from when I incorrectly thought the names were linked to the OP?

[Robin the Jester]

Are you though? Feels to me like you're playing a Paudie. (This is a reference to the TV show The Traitors)

Hahaha I'm watching the traitors alright. That feels like a backhanded compliment 🤣

Are you a hugger?

[Prada the Seamstress]

I have faced down many an enemy in battle so I know well how a nervous man acts.

I will be voting for Benjamin again tonight. 
His 'I'm new and I'm confused' act just doesnt ring true. He was the first to mention FFAs. He is overly defensive. He was very put out to have been fingered as a liar while Frank was believed to be a newbie. He wants to be seen as TSTBAW. And yet the wolves have killed 3 people, all of whom hes taken issue with. Pat, Wendy, Maeve.

On the other hand he could be our SK. Betty and Moe were also players he had on his radar. 

He is just deflecting all the time. He was very active around the time Maeve was poisoned and then immediately pointed the finger at Moe before anyone could even consider him. 

Benjamin is up to something.. Of that I have no doubt. Or maybe he's just got the touch of death and those he mentions most just happen to die.

I'll be sending my vote in shortly. I need to exercise Digby before the rain takes hold so I might miss proceedings later.

If any ladies are looking for me I should back in my abode before 10. 😉

Any other suspicions Dexter or is Digby and that large sword of yours taking up too much time....

[Prada the Seamstress]

Hahaha I'm watching the traitors alright. That feels like a backhanded compliment 🤣

Are you a hugger?

That was class 😂

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Revised FFA:
Dexter
Vernon
Laura

Right now I am so confused, I am voting Vernon as SK as they are causing havoc.
I have worked out who one person is on here on reading back but I don't now have time to read over the whole thing again and remain gainfully employed.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

I meant the SK is causing havoc. Although Vernon's quote tangle is also havoc-wreaking.

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Does anyone else make your big sword quiver?

Well as I've said many times I am certain there is one she-wolf among us. I did believe it to be Wendy but I've had to rethink that since her passing.

With only 4 females left (I'm discounting Rhoda here as I assume she will be mod killed) I have strong suspicions towards two. One talks too much and the other not enough.

I am loathe to name them before I'm absolutely certain which is the culprit, as I'll be ruining my own chances with them if I'm wrong.

[Dexter the Dragoon]

@Prada the Seamstress see my post above and try not to take offense my dear. It's just a numbers game.

In fact @Magda the Maid @Amy the Singer @Prada the Seamstress @Laura the Lace Mistress if any of you want to visit with me later and prove you're all woman, please do! I'll show you mine if you show me yours. 😉

[Laura the Lace Mistress]

reading back on dexter, loads of posts tagging all female players - makes looking at interactions near enough pointless.

wolf lean, playing the over the top brash character.