The Gang Solves The Werewolf Crisis

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

How about this for a theory? All the wolves are people who are waving tools, have tools or are interested in tools, or in Boris' case, openly admit to being a tool?

I am suss of the following:
Wendy
Betty
Boris
Dexter
Chris maybe?

And then Ina May and Moe for the reasons Prada cited above.

Yes, I know that is too many people... I've a meeting (a real one) at 2 so will do some more notes after that.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

You also say that Donald taught you all you know. 
And Dexter hinted that he knew something wasn't right with Donald- how did you know that @Dexter the Dragoon

Donald wasn't a real player though, he was a fake player to facilitate the flavour munch

ok, I am terrible at this. 

[Kevin the Armorer]

An experienced player like you would you say?

Without putting myself in the lynching line, didn't Maeve also say that the players were randed so even new players could end up as wolves?

All games are randed.
New players have same chance as anybody else of getting any role in the game, or any of the anon names.
anon names will not be linked in any way to game roles.

[Ina May the Midwife]

Why are players thinking the anon names are related to the game roles. From my experience, these are randed.

[Kevin the Armorer]

Why are players thinking the anon names are related to the game roles. From my experience, these are randed.

I suspect this is ben's first game. So just doesn't know any better. 🤷‍♂️

[Prada the Seamstress]

Why are players thinking the anon names are related to the game roles. From my experience, these are randed.

I suspect this is ben's first game. So just doesn't know any better. 🤷‍♂️

Yeah I had the same thought tbh

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Yes and you also called me stupid @Kevin the Armorer

[Moe the Innkeeper]

When should we do a FFA? Or is that dangerous?

If you have suspicions you can do it at any stage. 

For instance, I'm a little suss of Ina May and Moe over comments that might be seen as a perspective slip.

And Pat the Baker is suss for marrying his cousin.

Despite my little spat with Kevin I'm not that bothered about him right now, he either finds my jokes about Trump and Boris deeply offensive or he's reading too much into it. He's doing something though, at least even if it is at my expense.

There was no perspective slip from me. I was roleplaying as Moe the innkeeper, you're reading to much into a jokey comment.

[Kevin the Armorer]

Yes and you also called me stupid @Kevin the Armorer

Which was a good thing for you. Being seen as 'Too Stupid to be a wolf' is something the wolves would love to pull, but i'll let you have that one for today

[Dexter the Dragoon]

How about this for a theory? All the wolves are people who are waving tools, have tools or are interested in tools, or in Boris' case, openly admit to being a tool?

I am suss of the following:
Wendy
Betty
Boris
Dexter
Chris maybe?

And then Ina May and Moe for the reasons Prada cited above.

Yes, I know that is too many people... I've a meeting (a real one) at 2 so will do some more notes after that.

I'm a Dragoon! Of course I have a sword! Do you have a problem with my horse too!? *shouts* Digby cover your ears!!  

Personally I think @Amy the Singerhas a good read on you. She's more than just beautiful, she's insightful too.

[Pat the Baker]

100% wolf it's understood in the OP that wolves have the poisoned milk. We have a vig so hopefully they hit well first day but it's very difficult so expect village on village with their first hit. Godspeed vig

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

How about this for a theory? All the wolves are people who are waving tools, have tools or are interested in tools, or in Boris' case, openly admit to being a tool?

I am suss of the following:
Wendy
Betty
Boris
Dexter
Chris maybe?

And then Ina May and Moe for the reasons Prada cited above.

Yes, I know that is too many people... I've a meeting (a real one) at 2 so will do some more notes after that.

I'm a Dragoon! Of course I have a sword! Do you have a problem with my horse too!? *shouts* Digby cover your ears!!  

Personally I think @Amy the Singerhas a good read on you. She's more than just beautiful, she's insightful too.

Absolutely not. I love all animals, except wolves.

Amy is off her head, as usual. Prada and Kevin are on the mark.

[Wendy the Wench]

@Wendy the Wench  does that mean your boss is dead? Are you now self-employed?

I serve no ones needs, only my own

[William the Grave Robber]

Haven’t seen it either so those defences are going over my head right now.

 References not defences

Could the wolves have thought Maeve was the BG?

[Wendy the Wench]

Yes it did say Ryan had the milk but who knows the waitress could have served it either? A loss now to lose Maeve as she was asking questions.

I would say only 4 wolves aswell.

@Wendy the Wench where were you at the time?

Asleep of course. Busy night as always, lots of customers. Didn't see you on the streets Betty, were you busy prepping milk?

[William the Grave Robber]

Donald, true to form, has nothing of note to say. Just soundbites. Is that the only type of bites?

@Maeve the Madam You needed a haircut. That is about it.
So many haven't posted that TBH it is v hard to get a sense of it.

I would hazard that the wolves would be early to the party, and post early and often- like Donald voters- so everyone who has posted here is 1) experiencesd 2) probably a wolf..... except me, of course

So you completely overlooked my second post?

Did you answer this @Benjamin the Alchemist?

Just having a quick read now, will be back on later to have a proper read through but your interactions with Maeve stand out.

[Wendy the Wench]

There's my suss list as of now

Ima...i think you slipped
Betty...initial posts
Chris...posts linked too much with Pat
Pat...posts linked to much with Chris

Discuss?

[Prada the Seamstress]

There's my suss list as of now

Ima...i think you slipped
Betty...initial posts
Chris...posts linked too much with Pat
Pat...posts linked to much with Chris

Discuss?

I don't see the Chris/Pat thing tbh.

Sell me on Betty. Ina's post I highlighted already.

[Wendy the Wench]

There's my suss list as of now

Ima...i think you slipped
Betty...initial posts
Chris...posts linked too much with Pat
Pat...posts linked to much with Chris

Discuss?

I don't see the Chris/Pat thing tbh.

Sell me on Betty. Ina's post I highlighted already.

I thought they defensive very early in response to another poster. 
Thought they threw out too many possibilities around the OP, trying to sew confusion it read to me. Speculated on at least 4 wolves maybe 5. Ignored the SK altogether.

Thats enough for me to be suss, I'll leave others to come up with their own conclusions

[Kevin the Armorer]

There's my suss list as of now

Ima...i think you slipped
Betty...initial posts
Chris...posts linked too much with Pat
Pat...posts linked to much with Chris

Discuss?

what do you mean, 'posts linked too much with'?

[Prada the Seamstress]

I don't see the Chris/Pat thing tbh.

Sell me on Betty. Ina's post I highlighted already.

I thought they defensive very early in response to another poster. 
Thought they threw out too many possibilities around the OP, trying to sew confusion it read to me. Speculated on at least 4 wolves maybe 5. Ignored the SK altogether.

Thats enough for me to be suss, I'll leave others to come up with their own conclusions

So you reckon Betty might be the SK in other words? Ok thanks for explaining anyways. I'll have a read of their posts later. Just leaving work shortly.

[Chris the Carpenter]

There's my suss list as of now

Ima...i think you slipped
Betty...initial posts
Chris...posts linked too much with Pat
Pat...posts linked to much with Chris

Discuss?

How are you linking mine and Pats posts?
Aside from someone saying our first posts were close in time with each other i dont think there's been any link but maybe I'm wrong

[Frank the Tank]

Need to have a better read over all the posts to get my head around who might be our hairy intruders.

If someone is the seer, can they do alignment checks in advance of the lynching or is that more of a nightly check and do we plebs get to find out?

[Kevin the Armorer]

Need to have a better read over all the posts to get my head around who might be our hairy intruders.

If someone is the seer, can they do alignment checks in advance of the lynching or is that more of a nightly check and do we plebs get to find out?

If somebody is the seer, they know when the can action. They will be given the info only. It is up to them to use that info however they choose, but a role like that would not usually decide to give away that they are the seer with only one seer action used, they would squirrel away that info and get more daily actions to get a wider picture. The wolves will kill any player they suspect of being the seer with highest priority, so speculating whom is the seer etc, would be seen as very wolfie.

[Frank the Tank]

Need to have a better read over all the posts to get my head around who might be our hairy intruders.

If someone is the seer, can they do alignment checks in advance of the lynching or is that more of a nightly check and do we plebs get to find out?

If somebody is the seer, they know when the can action. They will be given the info only. It is up to them to use that info however they choose, but a role like that would not usually decide to give away that they are the seer with only one seer action used, they would squirrel away that info and get more daily actions to get a wider picture. The wolves will kill any player they suspect of being the seer with highest priority, so speculating whom is the seer etc, would be seen as very wolfie.


Ah that makes sense, and kind of a duh moment because of course the seer would be murdered straight away 😂 
Ill figure this game out eventually. Thank you for the clarification. Back to reading!!

[Kevin the Armorer]

4.5 hours until yeet and 4 players yet to post.

Player Post Count
Prada the Seamstress 41
Benjamin the Alchemist 37
Kevin the Armorer 30
Boris the Fool 21
Betty the Beggar 17
Wendy the Wench 16
Dexter the Dragoon 15
Maeve the Madam 14
Chris the Carpenter 10
Donald the Spoofer 8
Edward the Barber 8
Moe the Innkeeper 8
Amy the Singer 5
Pat the Baker 5
Frank the Tank 4
William the Grave Robber 4
Ina May the Midwife 3
Magda the Maid 3
Laura the Lace Mistress 1
Gordon the Cook 0
Rhoda the Spinster 0
Robin the Jester 0
Vernon the Ranger 0

[Frank the Tank]

If somebody is the seer, they know when the can action. They will be given the info only. It is up to them to use that info however they choose, but a role like that would not usually decide to give away that they are the seer with only one seer action used, they would squirrel away that info and get more daily actions to get a wider picture. The wolves will kill any player they suspect of being the seer with highest priority, so speculating whom is the seer etc, would be seen as very wolfie.

Put my response inside the quote like a dope... my response below.


Ah that makes sense, and kind of a duh moment because of course the seer would be murdered straight away 😂 

Ill figure this game out eventually. Thank you for the clarification. Back to reading!!

[Wendy the Wench]

4.5 hours until yeet and 4 players yet to post.

Player Post Count
Prada the Seamstress 41
Benjamin the Alchemist 37
Kevin the Armorer 30
Boris the Fool 21
Betty the Beggar 17
Wendy the Wench 16
Dexter the Dragoon 15
Maeve the Madam 14
Chris the Carpenter 10
Donald the Spoofer 8
Edward the Barber 8
Moe the Innkeeper 8
Amy the Singer 5
Pat the Baker 5
Frank the Tank 4
William the Grave Robber 4
Ina May the Midwife 3
Magda the Maid 3
Laura the Lace Mistress 1
Gordon the Cook 0
Rhoda the Spinster 0
Robin the Jester 0
Vernon the Ranger 0

I would have 2 wolves in the posters with 5 posts or lower.

[Moe the Innkeeper]

Put my response inside the quote like a dope... my response below.


Ah that makes sense, and kind of a duh moment because of course the seer would be murdered straight away 😂 

Ill figure this game out eventually. Thank you for the clarification. Back to reading!!

One thing to bear in mind is that if you suspect someone is rolled village don't draw attention to that fact, the wolves try to get rolled village as priority over the non rolled villagers.

[Wendy the Wench]

Peek high, yeet low

[Frank the Tank]

Put my response inside the quote like a dope... my response below.


Ah that makes sense, and kind of a duh moment because of course the seer would be murdered straight away 😂 

Ill figure this game out eventually. Thank you for the clarification. Back to reading!!

One thing to bear in mind is that if you suspect someone is rolled village don't draw attention to that fact, the wolves try to get rolled village as priority over the non rolled villagers.

Makes total sense and that they keep that knowledge to themselves, assuming they can bring receipts when the time is right to out banish a wolf and that a wolf doesn't try and play seer to draw us in the wrong direction to save themselves.

[Frank the Tank]

Peek high, yeet low

In proper question mode now so assume you mean peak at most active players and vote out anyone not pulling their weight in terms of discussions.

[Wendy the Wench]

Peek high, yeet low

In proper question mode now so assume you mean peak at most active players and vote out anyone not pulling their weight in terms of discussions.

Exactly. Peek high to check alignment of the most active. Make sure they are not leading in any wrong direction.

Vote low. If village they weren't helpful anyway.

Could be a low lying wolf. There is usually at least one of these

[Moe the Innkeeper]

What is the stance regarding lynch votes? Are we declaring on thread?

[Edward the Barber]

There's my suss list as of now

Ima...i think you slipped
Betty...initial posts
Chris...posts linked too much with Pat
Pat...posts linked to much with Chris

Discuss?

Ima? Do you mean @Ina May the Midwife ? I've just had a quick look back, what have I missed in their 3 posts to date?

[Chris the Carpenter]

What is the stance regarding lynch votes? Are we declaring on thread?

I intend to

[Edward the Barber]

What is the stance regarding lynch votes? Are we declaring on thread?

Yes, it's a good tactic imo because you give a roled player a heads up if they are in trouble. But more importantly, it stops a wolf wagon at the last minute.
I don't fully agree with always yet low, sometimes roled villagers play a quieter game too. It's not as easy as 2 of the lowest 5 posters are wolves. If only it was.

[Moe the Innkeeper]

There's my suss list as of now

Ima...i think you slipped
Betty...initial posts
Chris...posts linked too much with Pat
Pat...posts linked to much with Chris

Discuss?

Ima? Do you mean @Ina May the Midwife ? I've just had a quick look back, what have I missed in their 3 posts to date?

Reading back the only post that I can see being likely called out is Jabronies being in the dark, but I don't see that post as suspicious myself.

[Wendy the Wench]

Ima? Do you mean @Ina May the Midwife ? I've just had a quick look back, what have I missed in their 3 posts to date?

Reading back the only post that I can see being likely called out is Jabronies being in the dark, but I don't see that post as suspicious myself.

Yes i think that post by Ina was a slip.

You think differently, that's fine.

Who you thinking as of now?

[Wendy the Wench]

What is the stance regarding lynch votes? Are we declaring on thread?

Yes, it's a good tactic imo because you give a roled player a heads up if they are in trouble. But more importantly, it stops a wolf wagon at the last minute.
I don't fully agree with always yet low, sometimes roled villagers play a quieter game too. It's not as easy as 2 of the lowest 5 posters are wolves. If only it was.

Sometimes roled do. It's very rare though that at least one wolf isn't in low posters.

Who's on the chopping block for you Mr Scissorhands?