The Gang Solves The Werewolf Crisis

[Moe the Innkeeper]

No, I don't manage Paddy's bar, I run Moe's, home of the flaming Moe.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

@Wendy the Wench does that mean your boss is dead? Are you now self-employed?

[Boris the Fool]

Who served poisoned milk? The Waitress? @Moe the Innkeeper  was it you? And how has it affected them? are they dead??

Going by the OP I would say it was Ryan as he has milk

[lorcand1990]

Maeve the Madam was.....



Artemis- Village Interigator

[Dexter the Dragoon]

But she never got to touch my sword!!!!!

Nooooooooo!!!!!

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

No, I don't manage Paddy's bar, I run Moe's, home of the flaming Moe.

Who's recipe did you steal?

[Prada the Seamstress]

No, I don't manage Paddy's bar, I run Moe's, home of the flaming Moe.

A rival bar. Hmmm...

(Am I allowed joke anymore at all    )

[Betty the Beggar]

Yes it did say Ryan had the milk but who knows the waitress could have served it either? A loss now to lose Maeve as she was asking questions.

I would say only 4 wolves aswell.

@Wendy the Wench where were you at the time?

[Boris the Fool]

Wonder what was in Maeve's posts that put her in the firing line.

Bye Maeve

[Chris the Carpenter]

Maeve the Madam was.....



Artemis- Village Interigator

What does an interigator do? Sounds like an RV.
Do we think that Ryan the wolf had an extra kill?Hopefully just the one

[Boris the Fool]

Yes it did say Ryan had the milk but who knows the waitress could have served it either? A loss now to lose Maeve as she was asking questions.

I would say only 4 wolves aswell.

@Wendy the Wench where were you at the time?

Never thought of that - good point but I wonder would the waitress have to be able to steal it from the wolves in order to use it. Otherwise it would be like the wolves and SK are working together.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

so sorry now, does that mean the poisoned milk person is the SK? i.e. whoever is Ryan is the SK?

[Boris the Fool]

Maeve the Madam was.....



Artemis- Village Interigator

What does an interigator do? Sounds like an RV.
Do we think that Ryan the wolf had an extra kill?Hopefully just the one

Not sure what it can do in this game as it sometimes varies between actually getting a backroom with someone and interrogating them and just pretending to have them locked up for the night therefore blocking any night power they may have.

But she was definitely a rolled villager otherwise she would have been called a Jabroni

[Boris the Fool]

so sorry now, does that mean the poisoned milk person is the SK? i.e. whoever is Ryan is the SK?

No Ryan is a wolf

[Frank the Tank]

So hold on now... there was a Munch/kill this morning and it was some kind of fake player to ease us into being murdered.... but now someone's actually dead but randomly during the day?


As a newbie this is all kinds of exciting I suppose but erm

[Prada the Seamstress]

Wonder what was in Maeve's posts that put her in the firing line.

Bye Maeve

She has 14 posts, which while not massive it's still in top 5 posters. I'll go back through them myself shortly and see if there's anything of note

(so much handier to do it here than Boards btw)

[Edward the Barber]

I feel discriminated against coz I can't see this weapon 

Your name should have been Boris the Tool hehe

One of Maeve's last posts. Did Maeve hurt your feelings @Boris the Fooland you decided to take her out?

[Boris the Fool]

Your name should have been Boris the Tool hehe

One of Maeve's last posts. Did Maeve hurt your feelings @Boris the Fooland you decided to take her out?

No if you keep reading I actually agreed with her - I am a tool 

[Edward the Barber]

Maeve had a very good handle on the game, 14 posts, with a lot of wisdom and good reading there. A great loss to us. She even seemed to have actually read the OP!
It would indicate to me that the wolves are experienced players.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

so sorry now, does that mean the poisoned milk person is the SK? i.e. whoever is Ryan is the SK?

No Ryan is a wolf

Ok well then how does he just randomly get to kill during the day though? I thought they are only allowed kill once a day unless they are the SK? 

[Betty the Beggar]

Maeve was the first one to post up a list of suspected roles. @Benjamin the Alchemist why did you say she was on you list to vote for?

[Amy the Singer]

so sorry now, does that mean the poisoned milk person is the SK? i.e. whoever is Ryan is the SK?

The generally accepted read so far is that the Waitress is the SK. The OP was clear that Ryan McPoyle had the milk so those are two different people. Is the Alchemist deliberately mixing things up?

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Maeve was the first one to post up a list of suspected roles. @Benjamin the Alchemist why did you say she was  on you list to vote for?

Purely on her name- anyone who a name that could be a waitress / server "ye olde bar wench (Sorry @Wendy the Wench ) was my reasoning. I don't think the names are related to the roles though, are they? Like, Frank the Tank doesn't mean he is actually Frank from the OP, for example.  

[Betty the Beggar]

I am beginning to think Prada, Kevin and Pat are all related.
On voting, I am thinking Wendy, or Maeve, albeit we have not heard from Laura yet. One of those is on my radar.

I am beginning to think Prada, Kevin and Pat are all related.
On voting, I am thinking Wendy, or Maeve, albeit we have not heard from Laura yet. One of those is on my radar.

What about me makes you think that way?

 
Here is the post and Maeve response

[Prada the Seamstress]

Maeve had a very good handle on the game, 14 posts, with a lot of wisdom and good reading there. A great loss to us. She even seemed to have actually read the OP!
It would indicate to me that the wolves are experienced players.

Yeah it's prob why she was hit tbh, trying to work things out and it was picked up on. This post below is a good example.

As one of the players that hasn’t watched the show could those that have explain what type of characters the McPoyles are? And how many there are too.

There’s some silly shenanigans going on in the thread already and I’d like to work out why.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

so sorry now, does that mean the poisoned milk person is the SK? i.e. whoever is Ryan is the SK?

The generally accepted read so far is that the Waitress is the SK. The OP was clear that Ryan McPoyle had the milk so those are two different people. Is the Alchemist deliberately mixing things up?

oh right ok. thanks.Nope, not deliberate. Just the chemicals going to my head and confusing me. 
The Waitress could have served it though, right? Like how can someone just die in the middle of the day like that?

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

I am beginning to think Prada, Kevin and Pat are all related.
On voting, I am thinking Wendy, or Maeve, albeit we have not heard from Laura yet. One of those is on my radar.

What about me makes you think that way?

 
Here is the post and Maeve response

thanks. I replied in #224 above.

[Betty the Beggar]

Maeve had a very good handle on the game, 14 posts, with a lot of wisdom and good reading there. A great loss to us. She even seemed to have actually read the OP!
It would indicate to me that the wolves are experienced players.

An experienced player like you would you say?

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Maybe you're all reading too deeply into this kill.

Maeve openly flirted with me on thread. I'm certain there is just one female wolf.
Could simple jealousy have been the motive for her murder?

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

When should we do a FFA? Or is that dangerous?

[Boris the Fool]

No Ryan is a wolf

Ok well then how does he just randomly get to kill during the day though? I thought they are only allowed kill once a day unless they are the SK? 

Along with the lynch and the munch there is also what is known as powers in the game - these happen throughout the game and can lead to deaths. Both the village and the wolves can have powers.

Are you a new player? If so, feel free to ask anything you are unsure of.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Would a villager kill another villager, or would only a wolf kill a villager like the way Maeve (RIP) got killed?

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Maeve had a very good handle on the game, 14 posts, with a lot of wisdom and good reading there. A great loss to us. She even seemed to have actually read the OP!
It would indicate to me that the wolves are experienced players.

An experienced player like you would you say?

Without putting myself in the lynching line, didn't Maeve also say that the players were randed so even new players could end up as wolves?

[Boris the Fool]

Would a villager kill another villager, or would only a wolf kill a villager like the way Maeve (RIP)  got killed?

Maeve was killed by the wolves as they have the milk but yes village has been known to kill other villagers but this is not on purpose - it is because the village doesn't play with perfect information like the wolves do. The wolves know who is village but the village don't know who is wolves so can hit a villager while trying to hit a wolf.

[Amy the Singer]

The generally accepted read so far is that the Waitress is the SK. The OP was clear that Ryan McPoyle had the milk so those are two different people. Is the Alchemist deliberately mixing things up?

oh right ok. thanks.Nope, not deliberate. Just the chemicals going to my head and confusing me. 
The Waitress could have served it though, right? Like how can someone just die in the middle of the day like that?

You must be working with some heady chemicals so. No poisons though, right?

Looks like the wolves have powers/items that give an extra kill to them. The main question now is whether there was just one glass of milk or whether there's more going around.

[Chris the Carpenter]

Would a villager kill another villager, or would only a wolf kill a villager like the way Maeve (RIP)  got killed?

This is almost definitely a wolf kill. We're told Ryan has milk and this is poisoned milk.

If we have a vig then they could hit a villager or a wolf

[Prada the Seamstress]

When should we do a FFA? Or is that dangerous?

If you have suspicions you can do it at any stage. 

For instance, I'm a little suss of Ina May and Moe over comments that might be seen as a perspective slip.

And Pat the Baker is suss for marrying his cousin.

Despite my little spat with Kevin I'm not that bothered about him right now, he either finds my jokes about Trump and Boris deeply offensive or he's reading too much into it. He's doing something though, at least even if it is at my expense.

[Kevin the Armorer]

Maeve had a very good handle on the game, 14 posts, with a lot of wisdom and good reading there. A great loss to us. She even seemed to have actually read the OP!
It would indicate to me that the wolves are experienced players.

This is bad thinking. The wolves are in a room together. It only takes one experienced player to be in that room to give this impression. So, the comment would be more accurate if it were to say, there is at least one experienced player on the wolf team.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

One of Maeve's last posts. Did Maeve hurt your feelings @Boris the Fooland you decided to take her out?

No if you keep reading I actually agreed with her - I am a tool 

You also say that Donald taught you all you know. 
And Dexter hinted that he knew something wasn't right with Donald- how did you know that @Dexter the Dragoon

[Boris the Fool]

No if you keep reading I actually agreed with her - I am a tool 

You also say that Donald taught you all you know. 
And Dexter hinted that he knew something wasn't right with Donald- how did you know that @Dexter the Dragoon

Donald wasn't a real player though, he was a fake player to facilitate the flavour munch