Disney Classics Werewolf

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Gordon and Oprah are dead, only the top three wagons count, so you are included and so is she.

Yes, I know this. My point was about Lily specifically naming my wagon and not hers.

Ah I get ya now 👍 yeah I'd agree that it's a bit odd there

[Dexter the Dragoon]

No she didn't 😂 when you include the dreaded posters, you are the only one left on the Amy wagon, so she called you a wolf. You didn't like it so you are disgarding the whole post.. even though she specifically says that there could be 2 on Oprah, one on Amy and one on Lilly, so 2 from a fuckload, 1 from 1 and 1 from 2. So instead of disregarding what she said, maybe look at the off wagon votes. and I agree with her btw, I would be looking first at the 3 posters left off Oprah, mainly because I can't see all 4 wolves voting together.

So there could be 1(or possibly 2) in Amy, you and Countess.

No, she specifically did NOT say that bit in bold. That was the point I was making.

Yeah I get you, it's odd alright, but that doesn't discount the rest of my post

[Boris the Fool]

If I had to guess id say scar is probably in the Oprah wagon somewhere

[Raymond the Shoemaker]

I gave a pretty detailed reason to Dora last night.
Basically reading on mobile I thought the ISOs Dexter did on me and Lilly were done by Amy as she mentioned us as most suspicious based on her ISO. 

Dexter pointed out to me that he had done the ISO not Amy, so that made it look a bit more like she had cribbed someone else's work rather than genuinely wolf hunting. 
Then she was quick to support Gordon's rubbish two named votes thing which only benefitted wolves. 

She told you she would post her ISOs, notes in an hour at half three, but then claimed way later than that she was still taking notes. 

I think her posts last night were a bit more reassuring to me, but not sure whether she's just gone in to damage limitation mode.

I dont really understand your reasoning for voting amy, it just reads as very confusing to me

Ill check back if I have time but it just seems like you got confused and used it as a reason to vote amy

Id agree amy wasn't very helpful yesterday but their posts last night were a little better so im happy to hear them out today rather than rush to vote their

I voted Amy fairly early, so I'm not sure why you are saying I am confused. They claimed they had taken detailed notes at half three and would post them at half four but when I questioned them far later than that they said they were still compiling notes. I also didn't like their support for the Gordon two votes plan, which could have led to an inadvertent tie.

[Raymond the Shoemaker]

I'm not discounting wagonomics but Lily basically named everyone as possible wolf with that post. That's not helpful in narrowing the field.

No she didn't 😂 when you include the dreaded posters, you are the only one left on the Amy wagon, so she called you a wolf. You didn't like it so you are disgarding the whole post.. even though she specifically says that there could be 2 on Oprah, one on Amy and one on Lilly, so 2 from a fuckload, 1 from 1 and 1 from 2. So instead of disregarding what she said, maybe look at the off wagon votes. and I agree with her btw, I would be looking first at the 3 posters left off Oprah, mainly because I can't see all 4 wolves voting together.

So there could be 1(or possibly 2) in Amy, you and Countess.

You are reaching. Lilly just made a post saying some wolves on one wagon, one on another wagon and one off wagon which pretty much encompasses everyone, so doesn't narrow the field and provides no reasoning whatsoever for this assertion of hers. 

I don't know why anyone would give it any credence, as she has given no supporting evidence for how the wolves would be distributed.

[Moe the Innkeeper]

Jesus, I was convinced Oprah was a wolf, the game play was so off.

How did the sk spot Dora? Must read back on her posts.

Were you convinced Oprah was a wolf though? You said you were between Oprah and countess yesterday

I thought she was a likely wolf because her posts were fluffy and she kept speculating about the Cruella power. She later backed away from her speculation that more than one tied player could be lynched.

What convinced me was her posts after the wagon had formed, she didn't try to convince us she wasn't a wolf, she didn't really contribute any reads of other players so didn't look like she was wolf hunting.

[Amy the Singer]

I dont really understand your reasoning for voting amy, it just reads as very confusing to me

Ill check back if I have time but it just seems like you got confused and used it as a reason to vote amy

Id agree amy wasn't very helpful yesterday but their posts last night were a little better so im happy to hear them out today rather than rush to vote their

I voted Amy fairly early, so I'm not sure why you are saying I am confused. They claimed they had taken detailed notes at half three and would post them at half four but when I questioned them far later than that they said they were still compiling notes. I also didn't like their support for the Gordon two votes plan, which could have led to an inadvertent tie.

To clarify this again...I did do ISOs early on but I had very limited time yesterday so I was going back over thread to see if anything had changed. You can actually see it in the notes I posted that I added to them and my thinking progressed. You seem hung up on this idea that I didn't do the ISOs early on. I did, I just didn't post a wall of quotes along with it because I don't actually think they're very helpful.  
Based on early reads you and Lilly were suspicious to me. Based on later reads, you fell down the suspicious pecking order. 
On the Gordon's idea thing - I didn't spend a whole lotta time thinking about it but it was based on the idea that declaring and tallying votes wasn't the best idea, which had been a running theme. In the end, majority decided against it, and I went with that. As I recall, I might've been the most vocal about going along with that plan but I don't think I was the only - going back to read that now to be sure.

[Boris the Fool]

Were you convinced Oprah was a wolf though? You said you were between Oprah and countess yesterday

I thought she was a likely wolf because her posts were fluffy and she kept speculating about the Cruella power. She later backed away from her speculation that more than one tied player could be lynched.

What convinced me was her posts after the wagon had formed, she didn't try to convince us she wasn't a wolf, she didn't really contribute any reads of other players so didn't look like she was wolf hunting.

Yeah id agree she was a good candidate based on her posts but I don't think id have gone so far to say i was convinced,  especially on d1 nothing is set in stone

[Dexter the Dragoon]

No she didn't 😂 when you include the dreaded posters, you are the only one left on the Amy wagon, so she called you a wolf. You didn't like it so you are disgarding the whole post.. even though she specifically says that there could be 2 on Oprah, one on Amy and one on Lilly, so 2 from a fuckload, 1 from 1 and 1 from 2. So instead of disregarding what she said, maybe look at the off wagon votes. and I agree with her btw, I would be looking first at the 3 posters left off Oprah, mainly because I can't see all 4 wolves voting together.

So there could be 1(or possibly 2) in Amy, you and Countess.

You are reaching. Lilly just made a post saying some wolves on one wagon, one on another wagon and one off wagon which pretty much encompasses everyone, so doesn't narrow the field and provides no reasoning whatsoever for this assertion of hers. 

I don't know why anyone would give it any credence, as she has given no supporting evidence for how the wolves would be distributed.

Why lie, she didn't use the word some..

She said 4 wolves 

A couple (2) on Oprah.. that's not the same as some..

Do you agree with my breakdown of it? Or are you going to disregard that too?

[Lilly the Millennial]

No she didn't 😂 when you include the dreaded posters, you are the only one left on the Amy wagon, so she called you a wolf. You didn't like it so you are disgarding the whole post.. even though she specifically says that there could be 2 on Oprah, one on Amy and one on Lilly, so 2 from a fuckload, 1 from 1 and 1 from 2. So instead of disregarding what she said, maybe look at the off wagon votes. and I agree with her btw, I would be looking first at the 3 posters left off Oprah, mainly because I can't see all 4 wolves voting together.

So there could be 1(or possibly 2) in Amy, you and Countess.

No, she specifically did NOT say that bit in bold. That was the point I was making.

Because at the time before the lynch, there were 2 wagons. Oprah and Amy, I wasn't a counter wagon based on the tallies by Jacob and Mc.
Wolves are known to spread across the wagons.

[Amy the Singer]

I thought she was a likely wolf because her posts were fluffy and she kept speculating about the Cruella power. She later backed away from her speculation that more than one tied player could be lynched.

What convinced me was her posts after the wagon had formed, she didn't try to convince us she wasn't a wolf, she didn't really contribute any reads of other players so didn't look like she was wolf hunting.

Yeah id agree she was a good candidate based on her posts but I don't think id have gone so far to say i was convinced,  especially on d1 nothing is set in stone

But you voted there?

[Amy the Singer]

No, she specifically did NOT say that bit in bold. That was the point I was making.

Because at the time before the lynch, there were 2 wagons. Oprah and Amy, I wasn't a counter wagon based on the tallies by Jacob and Mc.
Wolves are known to spread across the wagons.

But you were working with the vote counts AFTER the lynch. It's literally in your post.

[Boris the Fool]

Time for wagonomics.
4 wolves. There will be a couple on Oprah, and possibly one on Amy, and one off wagon.

Lilly sprang into action last night after the lynch but I'm not sure how helpful any of it was. Particularly liked this gem which narrowed the wolves down to the main wagon, the other wagons and off wagon, which basically encompasses all players.

I dont agree that lily sprung into action last night.. I had a fair bit of back and forth with them during the day

They were on my ffa but I did like some of the fight they put up when I questioned them yesterday, so im unsure there tbh

[Boris the Fool]

Yeah id agree she was a good candidate based on her posts but I don't think id have gone so far to say i was convinced,  especially on d1 nothing is set in stone

But you voted there?

Yeah i sure did, hence why I said they were a good candidate for the lynch.. was i convinced? No

I said it at some stage yesterday,  if Oprah survived yesterday and had they same type of gameplay today, id just be voting there today anyway

[Raymond the Shoemaker]

@Dexter the Dragoon not much to go on with either of those, but I agree with not discounting them. What stands out the most to me is is the Vincent quote about the strike rate.

Also in the low posters is Moe, who I keep nearly forgetting about.

sup raymond

Could you explain to me why you were so unbothered by Tuck's death that you failed to notice they were village?

Because I can't think of any non innocent explanation for that.

[Moe the Innkeeper]

I thought she was a likely wolf because her posts were fluffy and she kept speculating about the Cruella power. She later backed away from her speculation that more than one tied player could be lynched.

What convinced me was her posts after the wagon had formed, she didn't try to convince us she wasn't a wolf, she didn't really contribute any reads of other players so didn't look like she was wolf hunting.

Yeah id agree she was a good candidate based on her posts but I don't think id have gone so far to say i was convinced,  especially on d1 nothing is set in stone

Oprah made no effort to save herself or to wolf hunting, she looked like a cornered wolf before lynch.

[McDonald the Farmer]

sup raymond

Could you explain to me why you were so unbothered by Tuck's death that you failed to notice they were village?

Because I can't think of any non innocent explanation for that.

Then why are you questioning?

[Raymond the Shoemaker]

Could you explain to me why you were so unbothered by Tuck's death that you failed to notice they were village?

Because I can't think of any non innocent explanation for that.

Then why are you questioning?

I don't understand. Why wouldn't I question why someone didn't notice what alignment a dead villager had?

[McDonald the Farmer]

Then why are you questioning?

I don't understand. Why wouldn't I question why someone didn't notice what alignment a dead villager had?

Because of what you said. If you can’t see a non innocent reason, then why ask?
Are you trying to trip a villager up?

Seems like weird logic to be questioning what you can’t conscience a wolf would post

[McDonald the Farmer]

Because of what you said. If you can’t see a non innocent reason, then why ask?
Are you trying to trip a villager up?

Seems like weird logic to be questioning what you can’t conscience a wolf would post

*concieve

[Raymond the Shoemaker]

Because of what you said. If you can’t see a non innocent reason, then why ask?
Are you trying to trip a villager up?

Seems like weird logic to be questioning what you can’t conscience a wolf would post

I'm questioning someone I think is a wolf or Scar. They would be the only people who wouldn't take note of Tuck's alignment.

[Necro]

@Boris the Fool has been munched by the wolves.

He was....



Aladdin - Village Role Thief who became...

Village Seer

[McDonald the Farmer]

Because of what you said. If you can’t see a non innocent reason, then why ask?
Are you trying to trip a villager up?

Seems like weird logic to be questioning what you can’t conscience a wolf would post

I'm questioning someone I think is a wolf or Scar. They would be the only people who wouldn't take note of Tuck's alignment.

The wolves know Ella ain’t with them, scar is loner. They are not making that mistake 😂
You said it yourself. You cant think of a non incident reason, so why ask?

[Amy the Singer]

Well balls to that.

[Dexter the Dragoon]

I'm questioning someone I think is a wolf or Scar. They would be the only people who wouldn't take note of Tuck's alignment.

The wolves know Ella ain’t with them, scar is loner. They are not making that mistake 😂
You said it yourself. You cant think of a non incident reason, so why ask?

Oh hi Jafar, how are you?

[McDonald the Farmer]

Will go iso boris from 9pm until now, they more than likely used a peek

[Necro]

LYNCH FORM IS OPEN - LYNCH AT 9

[Countess Markievicz]

what the actual fuck.

[Dexter the Dragoon]

So Mac, tell me, how did you know that there was a specific role "Role Thief" so soon into the game... There is no mention of it in the OP.

[McDonald the Farmer]

The wolves know Ella ain’t with them, scar is loner. They are not making that mistake 😂
You said it yourself. You cant think of a non incident reason, so why ask?

Oh hi Jafar, how are you?

I’m not jafar, what names you think that? Because i read the op?

[Necro]

@McDonald the Farmer has been incinerated by Jafar's fireball and is dead.

McDonald the Farmer was...




SCAR - Serial Killer

[McDonald the Farmer]

So Mac, tell me, how did you know that there was a specific role "Role Thief" so soon into the game... There is no mention of it in the OP.

because it was obvious. from the op.

[Countess Markievicz]

dont make for pretty reading

[Vincent the Artist]

Morning all

@Dexter the Dragoon not much to go on with either of those, but I agree with not discounting them. What stands out the most to me is is the Vincent quote about the strike rate.

Also in the low posters is Moe, who I keep nearly forgetting about.

Happy to explain my strike rate comment if that helps. My understanding coming into this was the majority of the village are NRVs so what happened yesterday with the baddies hitting 3 roled villagers and avoiding NRVs felt like a lot. And now Aladdin is gone too
I didn't include Oprah in that count because there was more of a collective role in that.

[Raymond the Shoemaker]

OK this is a mindfuck. So Mc was faking it, which means Jacob is not clear anymore.

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Well there goes that theory 😂

[Countess Markievicz]

OK this is a mindfuck. So Mc was faking it, which means Jacob is not clear anymore.

faking what? forgive me for not keeping up

[Amy the Singer]

[Amy the Singer]

5 v 4. Lylo of a Tuesday

[Jacob the Tailor]

OK this is a mindfuck. So Mc was faking it, which means Jacob is not clear anymore.

I was never clear, him saying he veto my vote is just that, him saying it.