Round Table Discussion Thread

[Countess Markievicz]

Exactly, I thought we were all speculating on what could have happened N1, since only the traitors know what actually happened.

[Gordon the Cook]

weyland declared countess
i proxied weyland

countess and moe are just dancing around, don't know where they are at yet.

[Moe the Innkeeper]

weyland declared countess
i proxied weyland

countess and moe are just dancing around, don't know where they are at yet.

If trying to figure things out within the timerame is dancing around then ill keep dancing! It's the whole point of the game

[Countess Markievicz]

I voted Weyland by proxy also, in case I didn’t get back, but just saw the time changed, so it’s in 2 minutes, right?

[Necro]

Correct!

[Necro]

Voting is now OPEN

[Necro]

Countess Markievicz casts a proxy vote for Weyland the Blacksmith

[Necro]

Weyland the Blacksmith casts a proxy vote for Countess Markievicz

[Moe the Innkeeper]

No more proxy votes?
You took yours back gordon?

[Gordon the Cook]

No more proxy votes?
You took yours back gordon?

On thread must not count, i never pm’ed.

[Moe the Innkeeper]

No more proxy votes?
You took yours back gordon?

On thread must not count, i never pm’ed.

@Necro can you clarify that? Do on thread proxy votes count?

[Necro]

Aye as per the OP in Rule 4

If you are not available for the voting hour, you can PM Necro with a proxy vote which will then be announced on thread for you. On thread votes before the voting hour are not counted.

[Gordon the Cook]

Vote weyland

[Moe the Innkeeper]

I had to wait and see if you were lying

Vote weyland

[Necro]

Weyland the Blacksmith has forged his last sword.

The players have voted to drop an anvil on his head and he has been Banished.

Weyland

Was

Faithful

[Necro]

Once again the question needs to be asked...

Do you wish to end the game?

Vote Yes or No

[Gordon the Cook]

I had to wait and see if you were lying

Vote weyland

No worries, i have the same paranoia.

me thinking more and counters are last two.

[Moe the Innkeeper]

Well bollox to that

Vote no

[Gordon the Cook]

Vote no

[Necro]

Countess Markievicz has voted to Continue the Game by proxy vote

[Necro]

And on we trek folks!!

The next vote will be between 9 and 10 pm.

See you then

[Gordon the Cook]

If it’s me vs two traitors, why we waiting until 9.


Have to believe i have a chance, so my intention is to vote countess

[Countess Markievicz]

So who’s left? Moe, Gordon, and me? I presume this is game over if you’re both traitors, well played!

[Moe the Innkeeper]

If it’s me vs two traitors, why we waiting until 9.


Have to believe i have a chance, so my intention is to vote countess

So who’s left? Moe, Gordon, and me? I presume this is game over if you’re both traitors, well played!

If this is ye messing with me can ye just end it please?

[Countess Markievicz]

You both voted Friar D3, you knew he was going down sooner or later, so playing for a tie was a good look, but cost you nothing, smart.

Looking back, if only one of you is scum, then the split vote D2 points to Moe, and the one-off vote on vote 4, off Friar setting up Zeena, points to Gordon.

I got a strong early village lean from Gordon D1, he would have been a good NK or conversion target.

Let me dig up my ISO of Moe, I was leaning north of neutral, cannot recall why.

[Countess Markievicz]

Team 1:
Moe the Innkeeper
Lilly the Millennial
Amy the Singer
William the Grave Robber
Dora the Explorer
Edward the Barber

Team 2:
Zeena Warrior Princess
Weyland the Blacksmith
Friar Tuck
Countess Markievicz
Gordon the Cook

Random, I know, but chances of zero scum on team 1?

[Countess Markievicz]

Moe
#8 offers beer
#29 looking for volunteers to sit out competition
#37 fluff re: scissors
#45 re: anagrams, working on them
#50 to Gordon, coin flip would only determine winning team, not prize-winner(s)
#57 clarifies to Gordon
#78 to Edward, is waiting to hear from Amy
#87 has solved anagrams
#100 shares reads - one of Lilly/Weyland, Edward, Zeena, 5 low posters - basically everyone except themself, Gordon and William, and maybe not Amy due to RL issues
#102 mod query
#104 selects Amy - good choice
#111 picks on on Edward's contradicting posts on anagrams - feels like authentic solving

#47 "My reads from earlier on today haven't changed too much, Edward seemed a bit more suspicious after he doubled down on not being bothered by doing the task cause it was boring even though they strongly hinted earlier they were bad at them


Edward, lily or weyland for me"

Moe is neutral for me - the wide-reaching wolf reads is offset by the gotcha solving.

This. Moe later clarified he wasn't scum reading the low posters, just calling them out. Still, 0/4. Need to re-read d1.

[Countess Markievicz]

Gordon's suggestion to share the anagram answers and leave it to a coin flip takes on a little more depth, if he's traitor, with Friar on his team, would he propose this? And risk giving the prize(2) to Team 1 which has no traitors? (still assuming only 1 left, if there are 2 it's game over so I'm just wasting my time).

[Gordon the Cook]

You both voted Friar D3, you knew he was going down sooner or later, so playing for a tie was a good look, but cost you nothing, smart.

Looking back, if only one of you is scum, then the split vote D2 points to Moe, and the one-off vote on vote 4, off Friar setting up Zeena, points to Gordon.

I got a strong early village lean from Gordon D1, he would have been a good NK or conversion target.

Let me dig up my ISO of Moe, I was leaning north of neutral, cannot recall why.

Looking back, if only one of you is scum, then the split vote D2 points to Moe, and the one-off vote on vote 4, off Friar setting up Zeena, points to Gordon.


my vote on zeena on day 4 was after it mattered, it was already decided that friar was gone. 

i even said it while voting.
 Countess used post numbers in her post count posts, so you can quickly find it.

[Countess Markievicz]

I am Countess

I know it was came when Friar was already a done deal, looking for the motivation, and a possible traitor motivation for the vote.

Both of you, if there is only one traitor left, it's not me, but whatever, that's for you to work out, but if you're faithful, please do some legwork. Following logic and mechanics has not got us into a very good place, if we have one chance left, let's try to get it right.

[Moe the Innkeeper]

Right well we play on so.. My thoughts at the moment

Gordon
Looked village to me early on to me, rattled cages, asks question. Smart player though and I'm sure they could bus frier and make it look genuine, frier was fecked anyway but sure you'll say the same against me. Very certain in their views, but is that the certainty of a wolf or just confident villager? Can't remember the post but they replied to dora when dora was saying a wolf won't reply to this (it was before they were lynched) If a wolf that's going to go down as the best post I've seen from a wolf.

Countess
Prize claim we can't verify, only other one we can't verify is friers. Votes to save frier to get an extra day or two from them and hide behind the prize? Asked some very brash questions when zeena won their prize, traitor looking for info?

[Gordon the Cook]

Gordon's suggestion to share the anagram answers and leave it to a coin flip takes on a little more depth, if he's traitor, with Friar on his team, would he propose this? And risk giving the prize(2) to Team 1 which has no traitors? (still assuming only 1 left, if there are 2 it's game over so I'm just wasting my time).

When friar asked for help, i have none. Go relook.

[Countess Markievicz]

What happens if Amy doesn't post? Dormant players give me the jitters, could be a low lying wolf.

Weyland seemed to pocket Gordon, that's why he's come to attention.

Wording implies Gordon is village here.

My thoughts at this stage:

Amy the Singer - an inactive player always makes me suspicious so wolf lean here
Countess Markievicz - not enough to go on here
Dora the Explorer - neutral at the minute
Edward the Barber - the gifs put me off but post #91 suggests village
Friar Tuck - im village
Gordon the Cook - village
Lilly the Millennial - wolf lean
Mick the Drunk - dead village
Moe the Innkeeper - neutral at the minute
Weyland the Blacksmith - wolf lean
William the Grave Robber - wolf lean
Zeena Warrior Princess - village

For ease I copied and pasted this from the other thread. The consensus seems to be to ignore amy for the mo, so that leaves

Lilly - nothing concrete, just seems to be posting mostly fluff
Weyland - the pocketing post
William - seems to be coasting

They're currently my 3 most likely to be traitors

Village lean on Gordon, neutral on Moe, the latter feels like an appropriate stance on a teammate so early.

[Gordon the Cook]

Right well we play on so.. My thoughts at the moment

Gordon
Looked village to me early on to me, rattled cages, asks question. Smart player though and I'm sure they could bus frier and make it look genuine, frier was fecked anyway but sure you'll say the same against me. Very certain in their views, but is that the certainty of a wolf or just confident villager? Can't remember the post but they replied to dora when dora was saying a wolf won't reply to this (it was before they were lynched) If a wolf that's going to go down as the best post I've seen from a wolf.

Countess
Prize claim we can't verify, only other one we can't verify is friers. Votes to save frier to get an extra day or two from them and hide behind the prize? Asked some very brash questions when zeena won their prize, traitor looking for info?

The last post in the other thread.
 Still not a traitor.

[Countess Markievicz]

Gordon's suggestion to share the anagram answers and leave it to a coin flip takes on a little more depth, if he's traitor, with Friar on his team, would he propose this? And risk giving the prize(2) to Team 1 which has no traitors? (still assuming only 1 left, if there are 2 it's game over so I'm just wasting my time).

When friar asked for help, i have none. Go relook.

I guess there's a typo here? You shared a link to help Weyland and Friar said this: "Thanks to Gordon for the link but I'm still stuck on 3.", you're wanted to say you did not help him any further?

[Moe the Innkeeper]

You both voted Friar D3, you knew he was going down sooner or later, so playing for a tie was a good look, but cost you nothing, smart.

Looking back, if only one of you is scum, then the split vote D2 points to Moe, and the one-off vote on vote 4, off Friar setting up Zeena, points to Gordon.

I got a strong early village lean from Gordon D1, he would have been a good NK or conversion target.

Let me dig up my ISO of Moe, I was leaning north of neutral, cannot recall why.

Do you think Gordon was converted? Or is this more speculation

[Gordon the Cook]

Team 1:
Moe the Innkeeper
Lilly the Millennial
Amy the Singer
William the Grave Robber
Dora the Explorer
Edward the Barber

Team 2:
Zeena Warrior Princess
Weyland the Blacksmith
Friar Tuck
Countess Markievicz
Gordon the Cook

Random, I know, but chances of zero scum on team 1?

We are now working under the assumption of 2 scum only. 

don’t see why they need to be distributed even across teams.

[Countess Markievicz]

Objectively speaking.
I see I'm picking up votes from the slots I accused, literally the worst part of this game is omgus

Other than saying you have a wolf lean on me you haven't accused me of anything and you certainly haven't given reasons.  I have given my reasons for voting you and I stand by them

This is wolfy, wolves hate being suspected without a case or accusation they can respond to, it's frustrating as hell when people suspect you and you can't argue against gut.

[Gordon the Cook]

When friar asked for help, i have none. Go relook.

I guess there's a typo here? You shared a link to help Weyland and Friar said this: "Thanks to Gordon for the link but I'm still stuck on 3.", you're wanted to say you did not help him any further?

Yes.

[Countess Markievicz]

You both voted Friar D3, you knew he was going down sooner or later, so playing for a tie was a good look, but cost you nothing, smart.

Looking back, if only one of you is scum, then the split vote D2 points to Moe, and the one-off vote on vote 4, off Friar setting up Zeena, points to Gordon.

I got a strong early village lean from Gordon D1, he would have been a good NK or conversion target.

Let me dig up my ISO of Moe, I was leaning north of neutral, cannot recall why.

Do you think Gordon was converted? Or is this more speculation

Speculation, I think he was the widest town read D1. There's been no indication of recruitment, and if he was recruited, it's certainly game over as I doubt Friar started off alone.