Round Table Discussion Thread

[Edward the Barber]

Do wolves vote late ? Or is it just people that are worried that they will be banished?

I think it might be both

Aren't votes locked in? Or was that a joke?
I'm between Lilly and William, not seeing you, indifferent on Weyland, but would be happy to  vote for Dora, who's voting Lilly, and giving me pause there.

Votes are locked in so a voting block of three (or 2) can swing the results. Vote in haste repent in leisure

[Gordon the Cook]

lilly: 2 : friar, dora
edward: 2 : moe , weyland
weyand: 1 : lilly
william: 1 : xena

ed has more votes than william

I meant I don't have a wolf read on Edward.

sorry, i read it's, instead of i'm. my mistake.

[Edward the Barber]

Once the murders stop it's just lynch lynch lynch There is no info from flipping Amy I'd literally flip myself befor Amy

This makes sense to me, when the final banishment stage is announced, except for the last part...

Objectively speaking.
I see I'm picking up votes from the slots I accused, literally the worst part of this game is omgus

[Gordon the Cook]

@Gordon the Cook is the suspicion on you and Edward, plus Amy, the crux of your case on William?

Yes, the suspicion that comes from nowhere.
The cases are junk IMO, but there is not much no go go, and i'm not sure, so i don't have much confidence in it.

[Gordon the Cook]

@Gordon the Cook is the suspicion on you and Edward, plus Amy, the crux of your case on William?

Yes, the suspicion that comes from nowhere.
The cases are junk IMO, but there is not much no go go, and i'm not sure, so i don't have much confidence in it.

*not much to go on*

[Countess Markievicz]

Well Amy is unlikely to be in to vote, that leaves 4 of us: Edward, Gordon, William and me. Lilly's opting out of the anagram game seems an unlikely ploy for a traitor so I'll just go with my strongest read

vote Dora

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Strange logic! I know what I am so if it's me or a not poster then she can go 
If Amy flips traitor it's not like I read her wrong, you can't get a read on six posts from wetland how you get a read from 0 posts from Amy ?

12, not 6.

i didn't get a read from amy, only the traitors would know if amy was a traitor slot or not.
10 other folks have come to play, and one of my 3 vote out slots was to vote out a slot that has given us faithfuls 0 reasons not to vote for them.

You never answered how we have infinite chances to vote out the amy slot. the traitors kill a faithful every night, and they wont be getting rid of amy, so we'll have to do it. the later we leave it, the more pain it'll be for us.

If it is like the show - when we get to the final banishment stage after each banishment we will have to decide if we want to end the game because we think we have found all the traitors. If we decide not to then we banish another person and so on.

[Gordon the Cook]

This makes sense to me, when the final banishment stage is announced, except for the last part...

Objectively speaking.
I see I'm picking up votes from the slots I accused, literally the worst part of this game is omgus

I'm hoping that its more than just omgus that has me on william.
like, i believe thats the case, but omgus can be strong.

lilly has me as villager, so that would be my 100% not omgus, but i think william is the better play.

[Gordon the Cook]

lilly: 2 : friar, dora
edward: 2 : moe , weyland
weyand: 1 : lilly
william: 1 : xena
dora: 1 : countess
3+1 votes left to play

[Moe the Innkeeper]

This makes sense to me, when the final banishment stage is announced, except for the last part...

Objectively speaking.
I see I'm picking up votes from the slots I accused, literally the worst part of this game is omgus

Other than saying you have a wolf lean on me you haven't accused me of anything and you certainly haven't given reasons.  I have given my reasons for voting you and I stand by them

[Friar Tuck]

Well Amy is unlikely to be in to vote, that leaves 4 of us: Edward, Gordon, William and me. Lilly's opting out of the anagram game seems an unlikely ploy for a traitor so I'll just go with my strongest read

vote Dora

Did Lilly not say she got them all and Moe questioned her on it?I thought she did actually answer them.

[Lilly the Millennial]

Lily ,  what ddi you mean when you called me a Boomer?

Boomer so Boomer doesn't even know what a Boomer is.

[Gordon the Cook]

okay, going to
vote : william


so its up to william and edward now.

[Lilly the Millennial]

Well Amy is unlikely to be in to vote, that leaves 4 of us: Edward, Gordon, William and me. Lilly's opting out of the anagram game seems an unlikely ploy for a traitor so I'll just go with my strongest read

vote Dora

Did Lilly not say she got them all and Moe questioned her on it?I thought she did actually answer them.

No..I said I wouldn't get a chance to.do it.
Yoire my wolf 2.

[Edward the Barber]

Objectively speaking.
I see I'm picking up votes from the slots I accused, literally the worst part of this game is omgus

I'm hoping that its more than just omgus that has me on william.
like, i believe thats the case, but omgus can be strong.

lilly has me as villager, so that would be my 100% not omgus, but i think william is the better play.

I'm happy with either, you can force my vote as I'll be self pressing because instead of defending or discussing the slots I suspect have omgus
William hasn't voted yet I assume he's dropping on me so I probably need a vote on lilly from one of you or the countess if I'm to live . That's assuming Amy hasn't decided to enter the arena

[Gordon the Cook]

I'm hoping that its more than just omgus that has me on william.
like, i believe thats the case, but omgus can be strong.

lilly has me as villager, so that would be my 100% not omgus, but i think william is the better play.

I'm happy with either, you can force my vote as I'll be self pressing because instead of defending or discussing the slots I suspect have omgus
William hasn't voted yet I assume he's dropping on me so I probably need a vote on lilly from one of you or the countess if I'm to live . That's assuming Amy hasn't decided to enter the arena

lilly: 2 : friar, dora
edward: 2 : moe , weyland
william: 2 : xena, gordon
weyand: 1 : lilly
dora: 1 : countess

2+1 votes left to play

if tie, it'll rand, right?

[Friar Tuck]

Did Lilly not say she got them all and Moe questioned her on it?I thought she did actually answer them.

No..I said I wouldn't get a chance to.do it.
Yoire my wolf 2.

It was Edward,I just checked am I a wolf because I voted for you?

[William the Grave Robber]

Sorry, git distracted with real life. I'm sticking to my gut

Vote: Edward

[Gordon the Cook]

I'm happy with either, you can force my vote as I'll be self pressing because instead of defending or discussing the slots I suspect have omgus
William hasn't voted yet I assume he's dropping on me so I probably need a vote on lilly from one of you or the countess if I'm to live . That's assuming Amy hasn't decided to enter the arena

lilly: 2 : friar, dora
edward: 2 : moe , weyland
william: 2 : xena, gordon
weyand: 1 : lilly
dora: 1 : countess

2+1 votes left to play

if tie, it'll rand, right?

spot on

8) In the event of a tie at the Banishment Phase, the player banished will be selected at random.

[Edward the Barber]

I'm not going out on a coin toss
@Amy the Singer now would be a good time to help 😜

[Lilly the Millennial]

I think I'll be voting from the following three.

Amy: We have to get rid of her sometime, doing it tonight allows us to find more info on folks before getting rid of somebody who is posting and giving us info to work off of.

Lily: Comes in and votes weyland for pocketing, with no discussion. doesn't want to discuss anybody else,

Twenty minutes and this is it?

Wow

Vote; wetland

Votes are final and LOCKED once cast, so think carefully before voting.

Fyi

William: narrows down their voting to the two highest posters and the no show. The reasons for me don't convince me.


My mind is not closed to only these three, this is just where i've landed after I narrowed my suspects down to three, i'll be keeping an eye on others thoughts too and reevaluating if i find others arguments convincing

 To be fair there wasn't much to discuss at that point.

[Lilly the Millennial]

No..I said I wouldn't get a chance to.do it.
Yoire my wolf 2.

It was Edward,I just checked am I a wolf because I voted for you?

 No it's cause you're throwing shade on a villager that's easily checked and absolutely not true.

[Gordon the Cook]

william : edward not T:T

[William the Grave Robber]

william : edward not T:T

What? Can you translate?

[Lilly the Millennial]

Vote for Lilly, the weird voting posts and disappearing act clinched it for me.

What disappearing act?

[Edward the Barber]

william : edward not T:T

Why not ? Noting like a bus to win a game, we could have said we'll go to a coin on a bus and see who get to be lock village. Bit drastic considering there will be a conversion and that all goes out the window.

[Edward the Barber]

william : edward not T:T

What? Can you translate?

He's saying we are either both village or we are village and wokf but not wolf and wolf 
I assume we are village and village so the only question is do I vote lilly and let chance decide or do I just accept my fate .

[Gordon the Cook]

Lily ,  what ddi you mean when you called me a Boomer?

Boomer so Boomer doesn't even know what a Boomer is.

Now look here you little bollox, you show some respect for you elders.

[Friar Tuck]

Vote for Lilly, the weird voting posts and disappearing act clinched it for me.

What disappearing act?

You went very quiet during round table until a few minutes ago or did I miss posts?

[William the Grave Robber]

What? Can you translate?

He's saying we are either both village or we are village and wokf but not wolf and wolf 
I assume we are village and village so the only question is do I vote lilly and let chance decide or do I just accept my fate .

Ah! I get you. Faithful or Traitor, don't give up, go for the coin toss!

[Edward the Barber]

Vote lilly

[Friar Tuck]

What? Can you translate?

He's saying we are either both village or we are village and wokf but not wolf and wolf 
I assume we are village and village so the only question is do I vote lilly and let chance decide or do I just accept my fate .

If you're village take a punt on killing a wolf

[Necro]

Ladies and Gentlemen...

We have a tie

Edward the Barber and Lilly the Milennial are tied on 3 votes each.

We now go to our randomisation studios to decide their fate...

[Edward the Barber]

He's saying we are either both village or we are village and wokf but not wolf and wolf 
I assume we are village and village so the only question is do I vote lilly and let chance decide or do I just accept my fate .

If you're village take a punt on killing a wolf

But late

[Lilly the Millennial]

Dopes

[Edward the Barber]

Dopes

Sorry

[Edward the Barber]

Kill wetland if lilly flips village

[Lilly the Millennial]

Look at who was after me! Dora came in out of no where

[Edward the Barber]

Like not now later

[Edward the Barber]

Look at who was after me! Dora came in out of no where

I wasn't gonna do it I hate having to self pres here