Round Table Discussion Thread

[Necro]

Good evening contestants and welcome to the Round Table discussion thread. This is how you will attempt to band together as Faithfuls and banish the Traitors.

Some rules regarding the Round Table:

1. Discussion is highly encouraged, there's no room for hiding at the Round Table.

2. Please be respectful in your discussions, you can call a player out but do so in a manner that is not insulting or abusive.

3. Voting Period: The voting will take place between 9 and 10pm tonight (this may be subject to change but players will have ample notice of said changes). Votes can be made in two ways - via proxy to myself before 9pm or on thread directly by yourself. Votes are final and LOCKED once cast, so think carefully before voting. Proxy votes will be posted at 9pm or as close to it as I can.
Once everyone has voted Necro will announce the player who has been banished, and their alignment. The main game thread and the Round Table thread will then close until the following morning's announcements and the witching hours will begin.

4. Any questions can be asked via PM - I won't respond to any queries on the Roundtable thread in order to continue the discussion flow.

[Necro]

ROUND TABLE DISCUSSION IS OPEN

[William the Grave Robber]

For me, it's between 3 tonight. Amy is MIA and thus useless to us as a Faithful. Gordan and Edward seem most traitorous to me.

[Lilly the Millennial]

Twenty minutes and this is it?

Wow

Vote; wetland

[Lilly the Millennial]

Votes are final and LOCKED once cast, so think carefully before voting.

Fyi

[William the Grave Robber]

Votes are final and LOCKED once cast, so think carefully before voting.

Fyi

Was that a reminder for yourself for voting with no discussion?!

[Necro]

Votes also don't count until 9pm when the voting phase starts. It's right there in the rules if you READ them

[Friar Tuck]

I'm confused about which thread we should be posting in

[Gordon the Cook]

I'm confused about which thread we should be posting in

me too, we seem to be split between two threads at the moment.

[Necro]

Main thread now closed. Round Table discussion goes here

[Lilly the Millennial]

Votes are final and LOCKED once cast, so think carefully before voting.

Fyi

Was that a reminder for yourself for voting with no discussion?!

NO.  I did not vote without reading the rules.  I would never do that ever ever ever.   I did state my reasons previously though

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Whats everyones beef with Wetters, Im not seeing it yet?

I was on the fence with lily but she voted instantly, did she know it didnt count?

Im leaning towards Billy tonight

[Countess Markievicz]

This is the round table?

@William the Grave Robber are there no mechanics to resolve inactive players? What is it about Gordon and Edward that has them in your sights? Gordon did the whole coin toss thing, Edward’s been very forthcoming with reads and poking others.

@Lilly the Millennial why Weyland? Switching between two threads on mobile is annoying.

[William the Grave Robber]

Was that a reminder for yourself for voting with no discussion?!

NO.  I did not vote without reading the rules.  I would never do that ever ever ever.   I did state my reasons previously though

[Edward the Barber]

For me, it's between 3 tonight. Amy is MIA and thus useless to us as a Faithful. Gordan and Edward seem most traitorous to me.

[Countess Markievicz]

@Necro we may have cross-posted. I chose 2

[Friar Tuck]

What happens if Amy doesn't post? Dormant players give me the jitters, could be a low lying wolf.

Weyland seemed to pocket Gordon, that's why he's come to attention.

[William the Grave Robber]

Im leaning towards Billy tonight

Can I ask why?

[Countess Markievicz]

What happens if Amy doesn't post? Dormant players give me the jitters, could be a low lying wolf.

Weyland seemed to pocket Gordon, that's why he's come to attention.

Just re-read the news. It’s up to us at the round table to deal with non-posters. I don’t think there’s much info to gain from evicting Amy toDay though.

[Lilly the Millennial]

This is the round table?

@William the Grave Robber are there no mechanics to resolve inactive players? What is it about Gordon and Edward that has them in your sights? Gordon did the whole coin toss thing, Edward’s been very forthcoming with reads and poking others.

@Lilly the Millennial why Weyland? Switching between two threads on mobile is annoying.

Cause it was a very clear pocket attempt and there was no need for it.  I didn't see any story build up or previous interaction that called for it.

[Lilly the Millennial]

What happens if Amy doesn't post? Dormant players give me the jitters, could be a low lying wolf.

Weyland seemed to pocket Gordon, that's why he's come to attention.

Just re-read the news. It’s up to us at the round table to deal with non-posters. I don’t think there’s much info to gain from evicting Amy toDay though.

Ive already put a proxy vote in but non posters wreck my head. Don't join if you can't post.  Also many a wolf has slide into end game by not posting.
But you're right we learn nothing.

[William the Grave Robber]

@William the Grave Robber are there no mechanics to resolve inactive players? What is it about Gordon and Edward that has them in your sights? Gordon did the whole coin toss thing, Edward’s been very forthcoming with reads and poking others.

You'd have to ask Necro about inactive mechanics. 

For Gordon, exactly as you mentioned, didn't feel his logic was favouring us Faithful, and felt more like a Traitor trying to manipulate things already. 

For Edward, his very first comment on the main thread was about a good man needing a mask. 

There's claims that they were "fishing" for Traitors but it seems completely counterintuitive to me to do that.

[Edward the Barber]

This is the round table?

@William the Grave Robber are there no mechanics to resolve inactive players? What is it about Gordon and Edward that has them in your sights? Gordon did the whole coin toss thing, Edward’s been very forthcoming with reads and poking others.

@Lilly the Millennial why Weyland? Switching between two threads on mobile is annoying.

HERE IS A LIST OF P[EOPLE  thadidnt win a prize today
possqaibly it might be better to flip one of them as then we dont have to worry about funny business

the prizeson the show were shields and cash and i dont think necro is handing out cash

Moe the Innkeeper wl
Lilly the Millennial vl
Amy the Singer nl
William the Grave Robber wl
Dora the Explorer nl
Edward the Barber vl


wl= wolf lean vl = village lean nl = no lean
sooo i'm thinking moe or william


feedbacks?/

[William the Grave Robber]

Ah I see the inactive issue is figured out, I should have gone back to the rules!

[Edward the Barber]

@William the Grave Robber are there no mechanics to resolve inactive players? What is it about Gordon and Edward that has them in your sights? Gordon did the whole coin toss thing, Edward’s been very forthcoming with reads and poking others.

You'd have to ask Necro about inactive mechanics. 

For Gordon, exactly as you mentioned, didn't feel his logic was favouring us Faithful, and felt more like a Traitor trying to manipulate things already. 

For Edward, his very first comment on the main thread was about a good man needing a mask. 

There's claims that they were "fishing" for Traitors but it seems completely counterintuitive to me to do that.

yes my very first comment was slightly suss, deliberetly seeing wou would bite
its a brave wolf that dose that, wolves act nice and kill you at night villagers are mean accusitory and often wrong

its counteriuntuitive until you realise it isnt

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Im leaning towards Billy tonight

Can I ask why?

You showed up yesterday with very little, today you analyse the comp and give the player post count. Now are tou trying to be just about notice and helpfull but not too noticed?

[Edward the Barber]

Ah I see the inactive issue is figured out, I should have gone back to the rules!

which rule exactly?

[Gordon the Cook]

What happens if Amy doesn't post? Dormant players give me the jitters, could be a low lying wolf.

Weyland seemed to pocket Gordon, that's why he's come to attention.

Just re-read the news. It’s up to us at the round table to deal with non-posters. I don’t think there’s much info to gain from evicting Amy toDay though.

While trying to figure out where the news was, I came across rule 3 which i believe you are referring to.

Code:

3) Please all try to reasonably contribute to the game thread and always remember to get a vote in as a minimum. There is no post minimum. Players will have to deal with non-posters themselves at the Round Table….

[Edward the Barber]

Just re-read the news. It’s up to us at the round table to deal with non-posters. I don’t think there’s much info to gain from evicting Amy toDay though.

While trying to figure out where the news was, I came across rule 3 which i believe you are referring to.

Code:

3) Please all try to reasonably contribute to the game thread and always remember to get a vote in as a minimum. There is no post minimum. Players will have to deal with non-posters themselves at the Round Table….

no need to banish non poeters at tghis point

[William the Grave Robber]

Can I ask why?

You showed up yesterday with very little, today you analyse the comp and give the player post count. Now are tou trying to be just about notice and helpfull but not too noticed?

What was there to go on yesterday? At least I showed up, others didn't. Isn't analysing everyone the whole point of the game? I have absolutely no idea what this nonsense opinion is. Damned if you do, damned if you don't.

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

This is the round table?

@William the Grave Robber are there no mechanics to resolve inactive players? What is it about Gordon and Edward that has them in your sights? Gordon did the whole coin toss thing, Edward’s been very forthcoming with reads and poking others.

@Lilly the Millennial why Weyland? Switching between two threads on mobile is annoying.

HERE IS A LIST OF P[EOPLE  thadidnt win a prize today
possqaibly it might be better to flip one of them as then we dont have to worry about funny business

the prizeson the show were shields and cash and i dont think necro is handing out cash

Moe the Innkeeper wl
Lilly the Millennial vl
Amy the Singer nl
William the Grave Robber wl
Dora the Explorer nl
Edward the Barber vl


wl= wolf lean vl = village lean nl = no lean
sooo i'm thinking moe or william


feedbacks?/

I have won a prize, and I dont think Im the only one

[William the Grave Robber]

You'd have to ask Necro about inactive mechanics. 

For Gordon, exactly as you mentioned, didn't feel his logic was favouring us Faithful, and felt more like a Traitor trying to manipulate things already. 

For Edward, his very first comment on the main thread was about a good man needing a mask. 

There's claims that they were "fishing" for Traitors but it seems completely counterintuitive to me to do that.

yes my very first comment was slightly suss, deliberetly seeing wou would bite
its a brave wolf that dose that, wolves act nice and kill you at night villagers are mean accusitory and often wrong

its counteriuntuitive until you realise it isnt

A "brave" Traitor isn't beyond the realms of possiblity, you openly admit it was a suss post, yet you're attacking my lean because I also think it was suss?!

[Gordon the Cook]

@William the Grave Robber are there no mechanics to resolve inactive players? What is it about Gordon and Edward that has them in your sights? Gordon did the whole coin toss thing, Edward’s been very forthcoming with reads and poking others.

You'd have to ask Necro about inactive mechanics. 

For Gordon, exactly as you mentioned, didn't feel his logic was favouring us Faithful, and felt more like a Traitor trying to manipulate things already. 

For Edward, his very first comment on the main thread was about a good man needing a mask. 

There's claims that they were "fishing" for Traitors but it seems completely counterintuitive to me to do that.

That line where you are discussing me feels awkward. 'us Faithful' did you copy and paste faithful?
Do you really believe that it felt more like a traitor or are you just saying that as it fit your narrative?

[Edward the Barber]

I love the idea that the wolves are not currently communicating

[Edward the Barber]

yes my very first comment was slightly suss, deliberetly seeing wou would bite
its a brave wolf that dose that, wolves act nice and kill you at night villagers are mean accusitory and often wrong

its counteriuntuitive until you realise it isnt

A "brave" Traitor isn't beyond the realms of possiblity, you openly admit it was a suss post, yet you're attacking my lean because I also think it was suss?!

do you feel attacked? I'm sorry isuppose its how fishies feel when the hook goes in

[Friar Tuck]

My thoughts at this stage:

Amy the Singer - an inactive player always makes me suspicious so wolf lean here
Countess Markievicz - not enough to go on here
Dora the Explorer - neutral at the minute
Edward the Barber - the gifs put me off but post #91 suggests village
Friar Tuck - im village
Gordon the Cook - village
Lilly the Millennial - wolf lean
Mick the Drunk - dead village
Moe the Innkeeper - neutral at the minute
Weyland the Blacksmith - wolf lean
William the Grave Robber - wolf lean
Zeena Warrior Princess - village

For ease I copied and pasted this from the other thread. The consensus seems to be to ignore amy for the mo, so that leaves

Lilly - nothing concrete, just seems to be posting mostly fluff
Weyland - the pocketing post
William - seems to be coasting

They're currently my 3 most likely to be traitors

[William the Grave Robber]

I do agree with @Edward the Barber that we should be voting within the losing team. I think there's a chance there's 1 Traitor on each team. Of course, there's a chance more than 1 on either team, or none on one team!

Amy the Singer - Inactive thus far
Dora the Explorer - Either
Edward the Barber - Traitor
Lilly the Millennial - Either
Moe the Innkeeper - Either
William the Grave Robber - Faithful

[Edward the Barber]

I do agree with @Edward the Barber that we should be voting within the losing team. I think there's a chance there's 1 Traitor on each team. Of course, there's a chance more than 1 on either team, or none on one team!

Amy the Singer - Inactive thus far
Dora the Explorer - Either
Edward the Barber - Traitor
Lilly the Millennial - Either
Moe the Innkeeper - Either
William the Grave Robber - Faithful

how am i a traiutor>?

[Edward the Barber]

HERE IS A LIST OF P[EOPLE  thadidnt win a prize today
possqaibly it might be better to flip one of them as then we dont have to worry about funny business

the prizeson the show were shields and cash and i dont think necro is handing out cash

Moe the Innkeeper wl
Lilly the Millennial vl
Amy the Singer nl
William the Grave Robber wl
Dora the Explorer nl
Edward the Barber vl


wl= wolf lean vl = village lean nl = no lean
sooo i'm thinking moe or william


feedbacks?/

I have won a prize, and I dont think Im the only one

what did you win?

[William the Grave Robber]

I do agree with @Edward the Barber that we should be voting within the losing team. I think there's a chance there's 1 Traitor on each team. Of course, there's a chance more than 1 on either team, or none on one team!

Amy the Singer - Inactive thus far
Dora the Explorer - Either
Edward the Barber - Traitor
Lilly the Millennial - Either
Moe the Innkeeper - Either
William the Grave Robber - Faithful

how am i a traiutor>?

I've already explained my thoughts on that.