Round Table Discussion Thread

[Gordon the Cook]

I think it's somewhat town-telling that both Edward and William suggested to banish within their own team, while Dora pushed back, strangely Dora pushed back against just William who agreed with the plan, and not Edward. Amy is MIA, Moe is neutral for me, Dora is leaning traitor, need to get a read on Lilly, who voted Weyland off the bat, has a proxy vote also, is it also on Weyland?

The proxy vote will come in at 9pm, we will have a whole hour to discuss their vote.

[Dora the Explorer]

I'd probably put Xena as more likely to be village at the minute. A wolf could have easily just kept the prize to themselves.

I'm leaning towards Lily as a wolf for the moment. I think they've made a lot of the "pocketing". What are your thoughts on lily?

Well I did want you to explain why myself and Moe were at 60% compared to 50% elsewhere but I'm guessing now it was more of a gut feeling that we were more likely to be wolves.

[Countess Markievicz]

Those are the losing team from today's challenge, who have no chance of a shield.

I think it was the Australian one where the shield protected from both banishment and murder.

I've retracted that accusation. I really must watch the traitors at some point.

But have you retracted it? Sorry, I see you still said that if William is a traitor, there are likely two traitors on team 2. So you still suspect something fishy about the suggestion?

[Dora the Explorer]

I also think I'd agree that Gordon is likely village.

[Dora the Explorer]

I've retracted that accusation. I really must watch the traitors at some point.

But have you retracted it? Sorry, I see you still said that if William is a traitor, there are likely two traitors on team 2. So you still suspect something fishy about the suggestion?

Yes, I said that doesn't make much sense. I thought it was odd that William agreed with the idea because of the greater chance of hitting 1 in 5 than 1 in 6 but then i realised that if he was a villager it would be 1 in 5 in both teams from their perspective. So no as things stand I don't think there is anything suspicious about it. However, if William (or Edward) come up as traitor I might revisit that. 

If either is a traitor then they'd either be trying to make themselves look good or trying to get votes away from 2 traitors in the other team. However, the clear hole in my idea became clear to me almost as I posted. And they are probably more likely to be village given they're trying to get people to vote in team 1.

[Countess Markievicz]

Lilly
#6 fluff, going back to bed
#9 Calls Gordon a boomer for finding her entrance suspicious
#19 fluff? tiktok with the deets?
#69 fluff, what's up?
#71 to Gordon, who wants input on his suggestion, asks what he wants from her
#73 to Moe, is happy to sit this out
#74 agrees with Edward's analysis of Gordon's ploy
#79 will not have time to do anagrams
#90 points out Weyland's thanks post to Gordon, says it's pocketing
#96 will vote Weyland, thinks Gordon is village
#98 to Friar, who posts a reads list, asks why they're a wolf-lean
#99 finds Edward villagery for finding her villagery and going against the thread sentiment

#4 complains about lack of content, votes Weyland
#5 warns that votes are final
#11 not sure if this is humor, but gave reasons for voting Weyland
#20 to me, still finds the pocketing attempt suspicious, with no prior contact or context
#21 to me, on Amy MIA, has already proxy voted

I guess not taking part in the anagram competition hurt her team, but unless she knew scores were not going to be public, I'd imagine she'd have kept that to herself rather than warning everyone. Read on Edward is fair, from her perspective. Dislike the tunneling on Weyland though, seems like a gimme vote.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

@Necro does the vote need to be in any particular format?

[Necro]

Format is simply (for example):

Vote: Necro (don't vote me though, I'm like a bad smell I cannot be banished )

[Edward the Barber]

Lilly
#6 fluff, going back to bed
#9 Calls Gordon a boomer for finding her entrance suspicious
#19 fluff? tiktok with the deets?
#69 fluff, what's up?
#71 to Gordon, who wants input on his suggestion, asks what he wants from her
#73 to Moe, is happy to sit this out
#74 agrees with Edward's analysis of Gordon's ploy
#79 will not have time to do anagrams
#90 points out Weyland's thanks post to Gordon, says it's pocketing
#96 will vote Weyland, thinks Gordon is village
#98 to Friar, who posts a reads list, asks why they're a wolf-lean
#99 finds Edward villagery for finding her villagery and going against the thread sentiment

#4 complains about lack of content, votes Weyland
#5 warns that votes are final
#11 not sure if this is humor, but gave reasons for voting Weyland
#20 to me, still finds the pocketing attempt suspicious, with no prior contact or context
#21 to me, on Amy MIA, has already proxy voted

I guess not taking part in the anagram competition hurt her team, but unless she knew scores were not going to be public, I'd imagine she'd have kept that to herself rather than warning everyone. Read on Edward is fair, from her perspective. Dislike the tunneling on Weyland though, seems like a gimme vote.

Do me

[Gordon the Cook]

I think I'll be voting from the following three.

Amy: We have to get rid of her sometime, doing it tonight allows us to find more info on folks before getting rid of somebody who is posting and giving us info to work off of.

Lily: Comes in and votes weyland for pocketing, with no discussion. doesn't want to discuss anybody else,

Twenty minutes and this is it?

Wow

Vote; wetland

Votes are final and LOCKED once cast, so think carefully before voting.

Fyi

William: narrows down their voting to the two highest posters and the no show. The reasons for me don't convince me.


My mind is not closed to only these three, this is just where i've landed after I narrowed my suspects down to three, i'll be keeping an eye on others thoughts too and reevaluating if i find others arguments convincing

[Edward the Barber]

I think I'll be voting from the following three.

Amy: We have to get rid of her sometime, doing it tonight allows us to find more info on folks before getting rid of somebody who is posting and giving us info to work off of.

Lily: Comes in and votes weyland for pocketing, with no discussion. doesn't want to discuss anybody else,

Twenty minutes and this is it?

Wow

Vote; wetland

Votes are final and LOCKED once cast, so think carefully before voting.

Fyi

William: narrows down their voting to the two highest posters and the no show. The reasons for me don't convince me.


My mind is not closed to only these three, this is just where i've landed after I narrowed my suspects down to three, i'll be keeping an eye on others thoughts too and reevaluating if i find others arguments convincing

Amy is no sense at this time, we get essentially infinite lunches later on and she can go then, William ok I see it.

Lily I can see as a wolf as well but I re read my posts and I have a hard on for Welland from like his second post, they are all those I'm gonna do this so I'll be doing that type posts that wolves use 
Read his yokamajig you'll see

[Edward the Barber]

Iso read his iso

[Gordon the Cook]

Iso read his iso

I'll read weyland now.

[Dora the Explorer]

I don't think we should get rid of amy yet. Maybe they couldn't join at the start.

My vote is going for Lily anyway.

[Necro]

The time for talk is over, time to vote on who you think is the traitor.

[Necro]

Lilly the Milennial proxy vote for Weyland the Blacksmith

[Gordon the Cook]

Yeah, read all 12 posts by weyland, 6 in main, and 6 in here. I've no idea why you have a hard on for them, but that's your prerogative. I'm not convinced enough to join you though.

[Friar Tuck]

Vote for Lilly, the weird voting posts and disappearing act clinched it for me.

[Friar Tuck]

@Necro, the time is out by an hour here.

[Edward the Barber]

@Necro, the time is out by an hour here.

Its in your settings,

[Edward the Barber]

Yeah, read all 12 posts by weyland, 6 in main, and 6 in here. I've no idea why you have a hard on for them, but that's your prerogative. I'm not convinced enough to join you though.

That's ok I can follow you into William

[Countess Markievicz]

Lilly
#6 fluff, going back to bed
#9 Calls Gordon a boomer for finding her entrance suspicious
#19 fluff? tiktok with the deets?
#69 fluff, what's up?
#71 to Gordon, who wants input on his suggestion, asks what he wants from her
#73 to Moe, is happy to sit this out
#74 agrees with Edward's analysis of Gordon's ploy
#79 will not have time to do anagrams
#90 points out Weyland's thanks post to Gordon, says it's pocketing
#96 will vote Weyland, thinks Gordon is village
#98 to Friar, who posts a reads list, asks why they're a wolf-lean
#99 finds Edward villagery for finding her villagery and going against the thread sentiment

#4 complains about lack of content, votes Weyland
#5 warns that votes are final
#11 not sure if this is humor, but gave reasons for voting Weyland
#20 to me, still finds the pocketing attempt suspicious, with no prior contact or context
#21 to me, on Amy MIA, has already proxy voted

I guess not taking part in the anagram competition hurt her team, but unless she knew scores were not going to be public, I'd imagine she'd have kept that to herself rather than warning everyone. Read on Edward is fair, from her perspective. Dislike the tunneling on Weyland though, seems like a gimme vote.

Do me

I have a town vibe from you, stopping for now, time is short as it is.

SpoilerShow Content

Edward
#14 "good man must wear mask"
#33 volunteers to sit out the game
#35 to Weyland, who says the game will be frustrating and asks for help on finding latest post, posts fluff gif
#36 to Gordon, who helps Weyland, posts fluff gif
#41 to Moe, the scissors do less damage than attempting to solve anagrams
#42/43 to Dora, who asks if anyone has submitted answers, posts running away gif
#46 to Gordon, who questions the tie-break rule, posts fluff gif
#72 to Gordon, who pushes his ploy, suggests his motivation is wifom via gif
#75 to William, who questions Gordon's ploy, adds the wine
#76 to Lilly, who is happy to sit out the game, is sitting out the game also, team will lose, but he's find with that
#80 posts Where is Amy? jpg
#81 anagram related fluff jpg
#85 thanks Gordon for help with game
#86 waiting gif
#91 posts reads list, suspects 3 wolves currently, up to 4 to find
#92 to Lilly, agrees that Weyland's post is pocketing Gordon
#105 to Dora, explains percentages indicate degree of scumminess
#106 to Moe, who questions the contradiction on anagrams, just finds them boring
#108 to all, asks to discuss Weyland being wolf
#112 joke to mod
#115 to Moe, again, was happy to sit out the game, but they were easy
#116 to William, who thinks 3 traitors is too many, replies No.
#118 finds Weyland, Zeena and William wolf, mask was just fishing
#119 adds Moe to the suspect list
#120 will return when there are others posting
#123 to Friar, thinks Weyland and William are solid wolves

[Gordon the Cook]

Amy is no sense at this time, we get essentially infinite lunches later on and she can go then, William ok I see it.

Lily I can see as a wolf as well but I re read my posts and I have a hard on for Welland from like his second post, they are all those I'm gonna do this so I'll be doing that type posts that wolves use 
Read his yokamajig you'll see

How do we get infinte lunches?


If the only choice was banish Amy or banish Ed, would you still think it makes no sense banish Amy?

If Amy flips Traitor, will you stand by your defense of a traitor?

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Sticking to my guns and hopefully read him right

Vote: William

[Dora the Explorer]

Vote: Lily

[Edward the Barber]

Amy is no sense at this time, we get essentially infinite lunches later on and she can go then, William ok I see it.

Lily I can see as a wolf as well but I re read my posts and I have a hard on for Welland from like his second post, they are all those I'm gonna do this so I'll be doing that type posts that wolves use 
Read his yokamajig you'll see

How do we get infinte lunches?


If the only choice was banish Amy or banish Ed, would you still think it makes no sense banish Amy?

If Amy flips Traitor, will you stand by your defense of a traitor?

Strange logic! I know what I am so if it's me or a not poster then she can go 
If Amy flips traitor it's not like I read her wrong, you can't get a read on six posts from wetland how you get a read from 0 posts from Amy ?

[Moe the Innkeeper]

Vote: Edward

[Edward the Barber]

@Necro is there any proxy voting

[Gordon the Cook]

@Necro is there any proxy voting

it was done at 9

[Gordon the Cook]

Code:

lilly: 2 : friar, dora
weyand: 1 : lilly
william: 1 : xena
edward: 1 : moe
6 votes left to play

think this is where we at

[Countess Markievicz]

@Gordon the Cook is the suspicion on you and Edward, plus Amy, the crux of your case on William?

[Edward the Barber]

Do wolves vote late ? Or is it just people that are worried that they will be banished?

I think it might be both

[Countess Markievicz]

Can I ask why?

You showed up yesterday with very little, today you analyse the comp and give the player post count. Now are tou trying to be just about notice and helpfull but not too noticed?

and, this has a little more flesh to it.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Vote Edward

[Gordon the Cook]

How do we get infinte lunches?


If the only choice was banish Amy or banish Ed, would you still think it makes no sense banish Amy?

If Amy flips Traitor, will you stand by your defense of a traitor?

Strange logic! I know what I am so if it's me or a not poster then she can go 
If Amy flips traitor it's not like I read her wrong, you can't get a read on six posts from wetland how you get a read from 0 posts from Amy ?

12, not 6.

i didn't get a read from amy, only the traitors would know if amy was a traitor slot or not.
10 other folks have come to play, and one of my 3 vote out slots was to vote out a slot that has given us faithfuls 0 reasons not to vote for them.

You never answered how we have infinite chances to vote out the amy slot. the traitors kill a faithful every night, and they wont be getting rid of amy, so we'll have to do it. the later we leave it, the more pain it'll be for us.

[Countess Markievicz]

Do wolves vote late ? Or is it just people that are worried that they will be banished?

I think it might be both

Aren't votes locked in? Or was that a joke?
I'm between Lilly and William, not seeing you, indifferent on Weyland, but would be happy to  vote for Dora, who's voting Lilly, and giving me pause there.

[Edward the Barber]

Strange logic! I know what I am so if it's me or a not poster then she can go 
If Amy flips traitor it's not like I read her wrong, you can't get a read on six posts from wetland how you get a read from 0 posts from Amy ?

12, not 6.

i didn't get a read from amy, only the traitors would know if amy was a traitor slot or not.
10 other folks have come to play, and one of my 3 vote out slots was to vote out a slot that has given us faithfuls 0 reasons not to vote for them.

You never answered how we have infinite chances to vote out the amy slot. the traitors kill a faithful every night, and they wont be getting rid of amy, so we'll have to do it. the later we leave it, the more pain it'll be for us.

Once the murders stop it's just lynch lynch lynch There is no info from flipping Amy I'd literally flip myself befor Amy

[Gordon the Cook]

Do wolves vote late ? Or is it just people that are worried that they will be banished?

I think it might be both

Aren't votes locked in? Or was that a joke?
I'm between Lilly and William, not seeing you, indifferent on Weyland, but would be happy to  vote for Dora, who's voting Lilly, and giving me pause there.

lilly: 2 : friar, dora
edward: 2 : moe , weyland
weyand: 1 : lilly
william: 1 : xena

ed has more votes than william

[Countess Markievicz]

12, not 6.

i didn't get a read from amy, only the traitors would know if amy was a traitor slot or not.
10 other folks have come to play, and one of my 3 vote out slots was to vote out a slot that has given us faithfuls 0 reasons not to vote for them.

You never answered how we have infinite chances to vote out the amy slot. the traitors kill a faithful every night, and they wont be getting rid of amy, so we'll have to do it. the later we leave it, the more pain it'll be for us.

Once the murders stop it's just lynch lynch lynch There is no info from flipping Amy I'd literally flip myself befor Amy

This makes sense to me, when the final banishment stage is announced, except for the last part...

[Countess Markievicz]

Aren't votes locked in? Or was that a joke?
I'm between Lilly and William, not seeing you, indifferent on Weyland, but would be happy to  vote for Dora, who's voting Lilly, and giving me pause there.

lilly: 2 : friar, dora
edward: 2 : moe , weyland
weyand: 1 : lilly
william: 1 : xena

ed has more votes than william

I meant I don't have a wolf read on Edward.