The Rookie Werewolf - Game Thread

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Best of luck Robin. The wolves want us gone.

well gordon will clearly change onto me, leaving me with 6. my hand has been forced.

i'm harper so you best change off me.

Well I did switch to you but realise they just shoot me tomorrow!
I’m Bradford. I protected myself today and assume that’s why so many missed shots.
I’ll switch back to Gordon now.  I suggest others do the same or you’ll lose 2 main good guys.

Sorry switch back to Dexter!

You probably could have switched if Robin didn't come out in the manner he did. Switching late after Robin claimed would have been an awful look.
He claimed Harper, forcing you to claim Bradford. And then you tried to lump onto Dex instead, the only other player who has made a claim.
Before that though, you said "Best of luck Robin. The wolves want us gone."

Were you that sure Robin was good? That spoke like you knew Robin was good? How?

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Tell me how your protection works Gordon?

[Robin the Jester]

for me, peek candidate needs to be one of the below to try find the wolf priest:

amy
benjamin
edward
kevin
mick
vincent

[Gordon the Cook]

I protected Friar Tuck Monday, Dora Tuesday and Myself today.

If what you claim is true, then you protected Dora from my shot.
How much more proof do you need?
You are confirming one of my claims yourself!

did you attempt to shoot me today?

[Amy the Singer]

Woah … plot twist. I just checked in now expecting to see Gordon gone. I didn’t get a chance to change my vote.

[Dexter the Dragoon]

If what you claim is true, then you protected Dora from my shot.
How much more proof do you need?
You are confirming one of my claims yourself!

did you attempt to shoot me today?

You first, since I asked above. Tell me how your protection works. Give me the protection timeline specifically.

[Gordon the Cook]

Tell me how your protection works Gordon?

Eh no thanks mr trigger happy. You’re working on your own, taking shots without consulting anyone.

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Tell me how your protection works Gordon?

Eh no thanks mr trigger happy. You’re working on your own, taking shots without consulting anyone.

Non answer, thought as much.
You keep on protecting people, you're doing a great job so far, I'm sure they'll be along shortly to thank you.......oh wait

[Robin the Jester]

right, fukkit. i'm peeking gordon

[Gordon the Cook]

Eh no thanks mr trigger happy. You’re working on your own, taking shots without consulting anyone.

Non answer, thought as much.
You keep on protecting people, you're doing a great job so far, I'm sure they'll be along shortly to thank you.......oh wait

The fact you won’t admit if you took a shot at me makes me believe you are a wolf. If you did take a shot that proves I’m telling the truth. How else would I have guessed you tried it. You’re the only one who knows you took a shot, and I’m the only one who knows I had protection. Hence the failed attempt.

[Gordon the Cook]

right, fukkit. i'm peeking gordon

Yessss!!

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

@Weyland the Blacksmith you were voting Edward?

Yes, blocked by the looks of it

Lots to unlock here, we'll need to work through all the vote switches and claims in the morning

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Any chance Gordon & Robin are both wolves and knew there'd be no counter claim?

[Lilly the Millennial]

right, fukkit. i'm peeking gordon

I believe Gordon, I think the peek can be better used on someone else

[Gordon the Cook]

Any chance Gordon & Robin are both wolves and knew there'd be no counter claim?

[Lilly the Millennial]

Any chance Gordon & Robin are both wolves and knew there'd be no counter claim?

Both can’t be the wolf priest so if we killed the one who was then the other one would be exposed.

[Robin the Jester]

Any chance Gordon & Robin are both wolves and knew there'd be no counter claim?

Both can’t be the wolf priest so if we killed the one who was then the other one would be exposed.

there is a scenario where neither of us is the wolf priest

[Lilly the Millennial]

Both can’t be the wolf priest so if we killed the one who was then the other one would be exposed.

there is a scenario where neither of us is the wolf priest

As baddies?

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Non answer, thought as much.
You keep on protecting people, you're doing a great job so far, I'm sure they'll be along shortly to thank you.......oh wait

The fact you won’t admit if you took a shot at me makes me believe you are a wolf. If you did take a shot that proves I’m telling the truth. How else would I have guessed you tried it. You’re the only one who knows you took a shot, and I’m the only one who knows I had protection. Hence the failed attempt.

Wow. You packed in a lot of misinformation into this post.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

Any chance Gordon & Robin are both wolves and knew there'd be no counter claim?

Both can’t be the wolf priest so if we killed the one who was then the other one would be exposed.

That's a fair point - maybe they thought they were both in trouble and it was worth a shot? Just throwing it out there though, it wouldn't be my main theory at the moment. 

If one of them is lying, I presume it'll be easy enough to see where their story doesn't stack up. I'll read back in the morning

[Kevin the Armorer]

Hey, first... wtf happened with the swapping votes before close. Gonna need time to disect that. And Gordon and Robin are claiming roles. I'll try to read in more detail later and in the morning. Car was hit in the carpark at the pool so had a fun evening dealing with that.

[Gordon the Cook]

The fact you won’t admit if you took a shot at me makes me believe you are a wolf. If you did take a shot that proves I’m telling the truth. How else would I have guessed you tried it. You’re the only one who knows you took a shot, and I’m the only one who knows I had protection. Hence the failed attempt.

Wow. You packed in a lot of misinformation into this post.

Care to elaborate?

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Wow. You packed in a lot of misinformation into this post.

Care to elaborate?

Every sentence

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Let's see if we get any counter claims before the am

[Gordon the Cook]

Let's see if we get any counter claims before the am

How do you know you’ll be still be here in the morning. Have you protection also?

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Let's see if we get any counter claims before the am

How do you know you’ll be still be here in the morning. Have you protection also?

Eh munch announcement is 10am, so I'll be here until then when we find out who goes, so I'm free to discuss any counters up to that point. But you know all that already.

Any reasons for protecting Dora? 
Friar I can understand.

[Vincent the Artist]

Vincent and Amy didn’t move. I saw Gordon’s post, didn’t see Robins post and the SQL errors

I am only catching up on the thread now, I was out all evening as I mentioned earlier I would be.
Going by the thread this evening, if I switched I wouldn't have done to Ina. It would have been to Amy. Reading back her reason for voting Gordon seems off because thinks have moved on from that.

Let's see if we get any counter claims before the am

I'm not counter claiming anything here.
However, if they are wild, they will know who is dead and what rules. They don't need to be the wolf priest as wolves share a backroom and all info.

[Robin the Jester]

I protected Friar Tuck Monday, Dora Tuesday and Myself today.

do we believe this?

friar monday - dies tuesday
dora tuesday - dies wednesday
himself today 

not that i would expect the person who is protected to know about it. just there are no loose ends for that small possibility.

[Dexter the Dragoon]

I protected Friar Tuck Monday, Dora Tuesday and Myself today.

do we believe this?

friar monday - dies tuesday
dora tuesday - dies wednesday
himself today 

not that i would expect the person who is protected to know about it. just there are no loose ends for that small possibility.

Protection needs to be confirmed the cycle before, so I'm more interested in what Dora posted on Monday that led to that decision.
Gordon's posts yesterday were strange to say the least so I get why he might go into self protection mode.

I lean towards believing him tbh

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

On a quick reread, I'm less inclined to believe Gordon is telling the truth. The fact that he was "resigned" to him or Robin going (knowing full well he could switch to swing it his way) and only revealed 6 mins after Robin did so is telling IMO.

Robin's claim rings truer in the way it was delivered although we have no way of verifying at this stage

[Gordon the Cook]

I protected Friar Tuck Monday, Dora Tuesday and Myself today.

do we believe this?

friar monday - dies tuesday
dora tuesday - dies wednesday
himself today 

not that i would expect the person who is protected to know about it. just there are no loose ends for that small possibility.

You said you’re going to peak me. When will that be? You’ll have your proof then.

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

@Gordon the Cook, what would you have done if Robin didn't reveal when they did?

[Robin the Jester]

do we believe this?

friar monday - dies tuesday
dora tuesday - dies wednesday
himself today 

not that i would expect the person who is protected to know about it. just there are no loose ends for that small possibility.

You said you’re going to peak me. When will that be? You’ll have your proof then.

i'll peek someone in the morning

[Gordon the Cook]

On a quick reread, I'm less inclined to believe Gordon is telling the truth. The fact that he was "resigned" to him or Robin going (knowing full well he could switch to swing it his way) and only revealed 6 mins after Robin did so is telling IMO.

Robin's claim rings truer in the way it was delivered although we have no way of verifying at this stage

I believe Robin claim. Don’t make this into a who’s the baddy between us.

[Gordon the Cook]

@Gordon the Cook, what would you have done if Robin didn't reveal when they did?

Obviously the best option would have been to keep my vote on him and let him be killed. I was thinking I’d deal with the consequences tomorrow & just protect myself again. But I realised everyone would still be on a wagon for me & so decided to spill the beans and hopefully change the direction this is going.

[Gordon the Cook]

You said you’re going to peak me. When will that be? You’ll have your proof then.

i'll peek someone in the morning

Are you not sticking with me as you said?

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Vincent
Mick
Kevin
Amy
Benji
Edward

Most Village
Dexter
Boris
Robin
Gordon
Weyland
Lilly

[Dexter the Dragoon]

@Robin the Jester have you only had 2 peeks? Weyland and Lilly? I would have thought 3

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Vincent
Mick
Kevin
Amy
Benji
Edward

We need to look within this 6 for a peek and a shot.
I'm the absence of a counter claim, there are 2 wolves and the SK in here.

@Robin the Jester
A peek has a 50/50 chance of finding Wolf/SK.

If you don't hit one, we get to add to our village core from my above post.
Then our vig can hit into the 5.

Our SK also needs to hit some wolves as well to help their game too. No point in them targeting rolled village just yet as Gordon, Robin and myself will be resolved before end game.

@Gordon the Cook think well about who you want to protect for the next munch. If you are true village I trust your call. You just need to trust in me.

Wolves can't munch all of us.

[Amy the Singer]

I didn’t get to change my vote last night but reading back over the thread later, something about Gordon’s statement didn’t ring true. More like a last ditch to stay in the game.
I presume that if Robin and Gordon were both being honest, then one of them will have been munched overnight.
I can understand why I’m in the suss list above, but please don’t waste a peek on me.