FoG Inaugural WW

[Trigger]

I wouldn't be advocating for a seer reveal but if they did peek a wolf then vig could take their shot so no issues with wagonomics

And how would the vig know who the wolf was unless the seer reveals?

I thibk she's saying that the seer should reveals so the vig can take a shot, that leaves it open for us to then lynch and use wagonomics

[Ectoplasm]

I wouldn't be advocating for a seer reveal but if they did peek a wolf then vig could take their shot so no issues with wagonomics

And how would the vig know who the wolf was unless the seer reveals?

I read it that if seer has a wolf they *could* reveal to give vig guidance, but that JGF isn't suggesting they do. From reading OP vig has a single bullet to use whenever. I'd suggest they keep it holstered until they have a very strong candidate based on Neo's numbers.

[HeyV]

It is, you weren't really on the thread at that stage so I was poking you to see what the reaction was. 
Leg End Reject came straight back with suspecting me, which I didn't like, and tbh I would have had them top of my wolf pile for today as a result. 
@JohnGreenFan is very quiet. As is @"HeyV"

The only reason I am being quiet is because I really don't know what I'm meant to be posting here or what I should be looking out for in other peoples posts. 

[nothing]

Also, morning all. Nothing, I can't believe you killed off the newbie. Bad form.

Having been that newbie mere months ago I would never. There's the fun of the chaos, but I wouldn't find that fun personally.

[JohnGreenFan]

I wouldn't be advocating for a seer reveal but if they did peek a wolf then vig could take their shot so no issues with wagonomics

And how would the vig know who the wolf was unless the seer reveals?

Obviously he wouldn't. I was just pointing out that we wouldn't have the issue with wagonomics that Trigs mentioned.

[Clarabel]

Morning. Always wary of overly long discussions about roles. Seer and vig should play roles best they know how. I know newbies can use guidance but focusing too much on mechanics can be a safe place for wolves to talk. Not saying that's what's happening here, just advocating for moving on. So far nothing and Clara seeming wolfiest to me but I'm not overly attached to those reads.

OMG.  LIKE.

How?  What?

[Clarabel]

Clara always seems Wolfy to me.
A few posters staying below the radar at the moment, at least with 10 players there isn't really anywhere to hide and they will hopefully come out to play later.

I should hopefully be able to play and post a bit more this game!

[Clarabel]

Even if they get the result right after the lynch, they could hold off telling us until a more opportune time.

Ecto I think you might be onto something here.  Though I don't think both trig and qb are wolves

[Clarabel]

Morning dawned on the FoGgers and as they awoke they saw the body of Leg End Reject in pieces beside them.

Leg End Reject has been munched, they were an NRV

Lynch at 9pm tonight folks!

You killed a newbie and made the game shorter.  MONSTER.

I mean, thanks game mod.

[Clarabel]

I understand the words you're all using but I've no idea what they mean!

Why is it bad if the seer reveals themself?
Why is post count relevant?
And why am I suspicious of Clarabel again????

Shush, you're dead!

That was an odd munch choice tbh, and unfair too

[Trigger]

Also, morning all. Nothing, I can't believe you killed off the newbie. Bad form.

Having been that newbie mere months ago I would never. There's the fun of the chaos, but I wouldn't find that fun personally.

I think that's just easy reasoning to use.

[Clarabel]

soz that post is a formatting thing. let me try again

[Clarabel]

That was an odd munch choice tbh, and unfair too

yes it really was

(better it's hard to edit/remove quotes)

[Ectoplasm]

It is, you weren't really on the thread at that stage so I was poking you to see what the reaction was. 
Leg End Reject came straight back with suspecting me, which I didn't like, and tbh I would have had them top of my wolf pile for today as a result. 
@JohnGreenFan is very quiet. As is @"HeyV"

The only reason I am being quiet is because I really don't know what I'm meant to be posting here or what I should be looking out for in other peoples posts. 

It's tough at the start (and even sometimes when you've played many times) You are looking for inconsistencies...does someone say one thing and do another? Does someone seem to be hiding something based on how they are posting? You can learn different things based on how people react.

[Clarabel]

Hmmm, I do remember Clara posting that and thinking - Why make it obvious if a wolf might not have noticed the first time.  I thought it was a bad move by Clara, but never actually thought that a wolf probably wouldn't do that.

to be honest I thought it was a newbie slip, which it turns out it was.  
I think leg thought that being village was a "role".  I was trying to get some chat out of that.

[Neowise]

And how would the vig know who the wolf was unless the seer reveals?

I thibk she's saying that the seer should reveals so the vig can take a shot, that leaves it open for us to then lynch and use wagonomics

It’s also a death sentence for the seer. I’d understand them holding off until lylo to do that.

[nothing]

Having been that newbie mere months ago I would never. There's the fun of the chaos, but I wouldn't find that fun personally.

I think that's just easy reasoning to use.

It's also accurate reasoning.

[cee_jay]

It is, you weren't really on the thread at that stage so I was poking you to see what the reaction was. 
Leg End Reject came straight back with suspecting me, which I didn't like, and tbh I would have had them top of my wolf pile for today as a result. 
@JohnGreenFan is very quiet. As is @"HeyV"

The only reason I am being quiet is because I really don't know what I'm meant to be posting here or what I should be looking out for in other peoples posts. 

You need to remember werewolf is a team game... Even though if you are village you don't know who is on your team. I am posting this under the presumption you are a lost new village player. 

We need to find the wolves. How do we do that? Ask a lot of questions. Ask why a player thinks another is suspicious. Ask another player what they think about a third player. By calling you out there, my aim was to get people talking. Wolves like a quiet village, it means they can also not post and stay hidden (they already know who is on their team!)

If you are a wolf, you can ask your wolf mate in your backroom. They might say play the innocent new player who is lost which could be a great strategy for staying under the radar and not being caught out for example.

[Trigger]

Morning. Always wary of overly long discussions about roles. Seer and vig should play roles best they know how. I know newbies can use guidance but focusing too much on mechanics can be a safe place for wolves to talk. Not saying that's what's happening here, just advocating for moving on. So far nothing and Clara seeming wolfiest to me but I'm not overly attached to those reads.

OMG.  LIKE.

How?  What?

Clara always seems Wolfy to me.
A few posters staying below the radar at the moment, at least with 10 players there isn't really anywhere to hide and they will hopefully come out to play later.

I should hopefully be able to play and post a bit more this game!

Even if they get the result right after the lynch, they could hold off telling us until a more opportune time.

Ecto I think you might be onto something here.  Though I don't think both trig and qb are wolves

Morning dawned on the FoGgers and as they awoke they saw the body of Leg End Reject in pieces beside them.

Leg End Reject has been munched, they were an NRV

Lynch at 9pm tonight folks!

You killed a newbie and made the game shorter.  MONSTER.

I mean, thanks game mod.

soz that post is a formatting thing. let me try again

That was an odd munch choice tbh, and unfair too

yes it really was

(better it's hard to edit/remove quotes)

So now that we have seen you can post more, do you have any thoughts on anyone, have you seen anything in particular. Or just replying to everyone to appear active?

[Clarabel]

And how would the vig know who the wolf was unless the seer reveals?

I thibk she's saying that the seer should reveals so the vig can take a shot, that leaves it open for us to then lynch and use wagonomics

I think we should stop telling the vig and the seer what to do.

[HeyV]

The only reason I am being quiet is because I really don't know what I'm meant to be posting here or what I should be looking out for in other peoples posts. 

It's tough at the start (and even sometimes when you've played many times) You are looking for inconsistencies...does someone say one thing and do another? Does someone seem to be hiding something based on how they are posting? You can learn different things based on how people react.

Thanks Ecto... but I think I'll stick to MS Paint from now on!! 

[Ectoplasm]

It's tough at the start (and even sometimes when you've played many times) You are looking for inconsistencies...does someone say one thing and do another? Does someone seem to be hiding something based on how they are posting? You can learn different things based on how people react.

Thanks Ecto... but I think I'll stick to MS Paint from now on!! 

Ah it's only day 1! Just chat away, ask as many questions as you want to. Feeling confused is a normal part of ww

[Trigger]

I still feel confused most of the time

[cee_jay]

It's tough at the start (and even sometimes when you've played many times) You are looking for inconsistencies...does someone say one thing and do another? Does someone seem to be hiding something based on how they are posting? You can learn different things based on how people react.

Thanks Ecto... but I think I'll stick to MS Paint from now on!! 

No you'll get the hang of it, and it is actually a lot of fun! 
To start you off, maybe try focus on just one poster and read their posts and see how they are asking questions and interacting with others. There can be many different conversations happening on the thread at one time, so concentrate on one. Pick out some of their accusations or declarations, and just ask them why or to back up their reasoning. 
Later today, you will be asked to vote for lynching someone you think is a wolf, start having a think about who that might be and why.

[JohnGreenFan]

It is, you weren't really on the thread at that stage so I was poking you to see what the reaction was. 
Leg End Reject came straight back with suspecting me, which I didn't like, and tbh I would have had them top of my wolf pile for today as a result. 
@JohnGreenFan is very quiet. As is @"HeyV"

The only reason I am being quiet is because I really don't know what I'm meant to be posting here or what I should be looking out for in other peoples posts. 

That's ok HeyV.
Lower posters can be seen as wolves because they are not drawing attention to themselves by posting things which can catch them out at a later stage.
There's nothing that you 'should' be posting. Just ask a few questions - if someone posts something you don't understand, ask them to explain or why they think something.
Sometimes it'll be just a gut feeling!

[cee_jay]

I still feel confused most of the time

Same. Werewolf is a powder keg of all the emotions... Confusion, betrayal, paranoia... The list goes on.

[Neowise]

I thibk she's saying that the seer should reveals so the vig can take a shot, that leaves it open for us to then lynch and use wagonomics

I think we should stop telling the vig and the seer what to do.

I don’t believe that was anyone’s intention, from what I’ve read. Talking through scenarios before they happen is guidance, not telling anyone what to do.  If one or both of those roles were inexperienced, then talking through the scenarios may help them.

[JohnGreenFan]

I still feel confused most of the time

Same. Werewolf is a powder keg of all the emotions... Confusion, betrayal, paranoia... The list goes on.

Imagine deliberately signing up to feel all those emotions for a week... Maybe we are all mad 

[nothing]

Same. Werewolf is a powder keg of all the emotions... Confusion, betrayal, paranoia... The list goes on.

Imagine deliberately signing up to feel all those emotions for a week... Maybe we are all mad 

It's an addictive rollercoaster!

[Ectoplasm]

Same. Werewolf is a powder keg of all the emotions... Confusion, betrayal, paranoia... The list goes on.

Imagine deliberately signing up to feel all those emotions for a week... Maybe we are all mad 

Maybe???

[Neowise]

It's tough at the start (and even sometimes when you've played many times) You are looking for inconsistencies...does someone say one thing and do another? Does someone seem to be hiding something based on how they are posting? You can learn different things based on how people react.

Thanks Ecto... but I think I'll stick to MS Paint from now on!! 

Do you normally paint or describe in mspaint?

[Clarabel]

OMG.  LIKE.

How?  What?

I should hopefully be able to play and post a bit more this game!

Ecto I think you might be onto something here.  Though I don't think both trig and qb are wolves

You killed a newbie and made the game shorter.  MONSTER.

I mean, thanks game mod.

soz that post is a formatting thing. let me try again

yes it really was

(better it's hard to edit/remove quotes)

So now that we have seen you can post more, do you have any thoughts on anyone, have you seen anything in particular. Or just replying to everyone to appear active?

[HeyV]

Thanks Ecto... but I think I'll stick to MS Paint from now on!! 

Do you normally paint or describe in mspaint?

I like to Paint if I have the time to do it, otherwise I'll describe 

[Clarabel]

Ecto I think you might be onto something here.  Though I don't think both trig and qb are wolves

[quote pid="2696" dateline="1628071625"]

soz that post is a formatting thing. let me try again

yes it really was

(better it's hard to edit/remove quotes)

So now that we have seen you can post more, do you have any thoughts on anyone, have you seen anything in particular. Or just replying to everyone to appear active?
[/quote]

[Trigger]

Not going to add anything there Clara?

[Ectoplasm]

Eh Clara?

[Trigger]

Ffs

[Clarabel]

OMG.  LIKE.

How?  What?

I should hopefully be able to play and post a bit more this game!

Ecto I think you might be onto something here.  Though I don't think both trig and qb are wolves

You killed a newbie and made the game shorter.  MONSTER.

I mean, thanks game mod.

soz that post is a formatting thing. let me try again

yes it really was

(better it's hard to edit/remove quotes)

So now that we have seen you can post more, do you have any thoughts on anyone, have you seen anything in particular. Or just replying to everyone to appear active?

[Clarabel]

Not going to add anything there Clara?

I can't

I'm deleting your quotes and add in my own comments and they not appearing.

[cee_jay]

@Clarabel are you ok there?