Round Table Discussion Thread

[Countess Markievicz]

I was following up on my response to the earlier question, whether traitors thought she was bluffing, and discarded this option as she would have told us, so conclusion is they thought she was bluffing, not going to use the shield N1, or use it on someone else.

I've read this a few times & I can't understand it. Can you explain it to me again?

Sure.

You quoted Weyland's suggestion that traitors thought Zeena was lying and asked my opinion:

Traitors must have thought she was bluffing?

Gordon, Countess.. What do ye think?

I said that I agreed, since the other option - that she was a traitor and pretended she was the N1 target - has been eliminated:

Gordon, Countess.. What do ye think?

I could only see two options, and guess this is the only one left. That she was bluffing, or that she wouldn't use it N1, or would use it on someone else. I do not understand why traitors would have targeted her that Night.

I added another option that I'd considered, which has also been eliminated since she said she could use the shield on herself or pass it to someone else:

I can also imagine that the N1 shield was a team prize which protected the entire team, so someone else was targeted but protected by the shield, but a faithful Zeena would/should/could have clarified that.

You said my answer is not true and doesn't make sense:

Only a member of 
@Zeena Warrior Princess
@Weyland the Blacksmith
@Friar Tuck
@Countess Markievicz
@Gordon the Cook
thinks she bluffing, as they are who would also get a prize. Did friar also get a shield prize, so they though zeena was lying?

I can also imagine that the N1 shield was a team prize which protected the entire team, so someone else was targeted but protected by the shield, but a faithful Zeena would/should/could have clarified that.

Gordon's answer is speculative
Countess' answer isn't true and doesn't make sense because Zeena said they protected themself

And I explained I was continuing the thought from earlier, what other options apart from thinking Zeena was bluffing could have led traitors to attacking her:

Gordon's answer is speculative
Countess' answer isn't true and doesn't make sense because Zeena said they protected themself

I was following up on my response to the earlier question, whether traitors thought she was bluffing, and discarded this option as she would have told us, so conclusion is they thought she was bluffing, not going to use the shield N1, or use it on someone else.