Sheep Rustling 3 - Revenge of the Reds

[Spears]

I deliberately didn't say David Tennant because he always sheeps. 😁

Pretty sure he was low down the list the last time out, which is why I chose him

I'm obviously losing the few marbles I have, I was sure he always sheeped.

He is the only cast member of the whole show that I knew of 

So I was sure he'd Sheep, therefore I thought he might be put forward as the Rustle answer. That's why I didn't choose him in my own answer. So I was 50% on the right track with my thinking.. for once!