The Rookie Werewolf - Game Thread

[Edward the Barber]

I need a magnifying glass to read that on my phone 😂

[Friar Tuck]

Not all votes declared either.

[Edward the Barber]

Have you a tally Friar?

[Wesley Evers]

I need a magnifying glass to read that on my phone 😂

Click on the image, open in new tab 

[Boris the Fool]

Votes for William

Kevin the Armorer
Boris the Fool (
Lilly the Millennial
Weyland the Blacksmith
Ina May the Midwife
Dexter the Dragoon
Countess Markievicz
Dora the Explorer

[Friar Tuck]

Have you a tally Friar?

Nope, will read back after I'm a Celeb.

[Boris the Fool]

Votes for Vincent

Moe the Innkeeper
William the Grave Robber

[Boris the Fool]

Votes for Jacob

Jacob the Tailor — 2
Edward the Barber
Benjamin the Alchemist

[Boris the Fool]

Actually that's stupid way of doing it.

[Edward the Barber]

If that was for my benefit Boris then thank you but I was talking about the tally for those who declared on thread who they voted for 😂

[Robin the Jester]

suppose there's no way to know if any wolves on the william wagon till we kill monica.

[Robin the Jester]

Votes for Jacob

Jacob the Tailor — 2
Edward the Barber
Benjamin the Alchemist

[Kevin the Armorer]

For the record, I didn't declare on the thread. I voted before going to pick up the kids and thought (like the "don't say you're an nrv' thing) you don't reveal your votes in case it gives the wolves an advantage. I think it was probably obvious enough from my posts that I was going to vote for William though.

[Vincent the Artist]

suppose there's no way to know if any wolves on the william wagon till we kill monica.

I think it goes without saying there are wolves on that wagon.

[Boris the Fool]

William: Kevin the Armorer, Boris the Fool, Lilly the Millennial, Weyland the Blacksmith, Ina May the Midwife, Dexter the Dragoon, Countess Markievicz, Dora the Explorer

Vincent: Moe the Innkeeper, William the Grave Robber

Lilly: Robin the Jester, Friar Tuck

Ina: Magda the Maid

Magda: Gordon the Cook

Benjamin: Jacob the Tailor

Countess: Mick the Drunk

Friar: Amy the Singer

Mick: Vincent the Artist

[Robin the Jester]

suppose there's no way to know if any wolves on the william wagon till we kill monica.

I think it goes without saying there are wolves on that wagon.

what if william is a wolf?

[Moe the Innkeeper]

suppose there's no way to know if any wolves on the william wagon till we kill monica.

Regardless of Williams alignment I'd say there's at least a wolf in there. Twas a pile on

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

I think it goes without saying there are wolves on that wagon.

what if william is a wolf?

Presuming wolves can vote for wolves, given how many people had declared and how Willy was obviously screwed, those two don't seem exclusive?

[Jacob the Tailor]

suppose there's no way to know if any wolves on the william wagon till we kill monica.

I think it goes without saying there are wolves on that wagon.

There could be at least 2 wolves/sk there but not much you can take from it until we can use wagonomics

[Boris the Fool]

There's definitely at least two on William whether he is a wolf or not. It was fairly clear early on that he was gone.

What about late voters would there be anything to be taken from them? Because people didn't declare we don't know much apart from Dora tallying up to voting late.

[Jacob the Tailor]

William: Kevin the Armorer, Boris the Fool, Lilly the Millennial, Weyland the Blacksmith, Ina May the Midwife, Dexter the Dragoon, Countess Markievicz, Dora the Explorer

Vincent: Moe the Innkeeper, William the Grave Robber

Lilly: Robin the Jester, Friar Tuck

Ina: Magda the Maid

Magda: Gordon the Cook

Benjamin: Jacob the Tailor

Countess: Mick the Drunk

Friar: Amy the Singer

Mick: Vincent the Artist

You missed my name, I had 2 votes.

[Boris the Fool]

William: Kevin the Armorer, Boris the Fool, Lilly the Millennial, Weyland the Blacksmith, Ina May the Midwife, Dexter the Dragoon, Countess Markievicz, Dora the Explorer

Vincent: Moe the Innkeeper, William the Grave Robber

Lilly: Robin the Jester, Friar Tuck

Ina: Magda the Maid

Magda: Gordon the Cook

Benjamin: Jacob the Tailor

Countess: Mick the Drunk

Friar: Amy the Singer

Mick: Vincent the Artist

You missed my name, I had 2 votes.

My bad, sorry

[Friar Tuck]

Votes for William

Kevin the Armorer
Boris the Fool (
Lilly the Millennial
Weyland the Blacksmith
Ina May the Midwife
Dexter the Dragoon
Countess Markievicz
Dora the Explorer

I think it goes without saying there are wolves on that wagon.

what if william is a wolf?

Did you declare your vote?

[Countess Markievicz]

I'd agree with Jacob that until we know William's alignment there is not much wagonomics, and even then with 8 on William I'd question how useful knowing his alignment will be in that respect. At least we know we do get vote tallies though, so should make it easier to notice things if there are close vote races or voting manipulation.

[Lilly the Millennial]

suppose there's no way to know if any wolves on the william wagon till we kill monica.

How would Monica dying tell us if there is wolves on the wagon? As other have said there is guaranteed to be at least one wolf on the wagon

[Lilly the Millennial]

There's definitely at least two on William whether he is a wolf or not. It was fairly clear early on that he was gone.

What about late voters would there be anything to be taken from them? Because people didn't declare we don't know much apart from Dora tallying up to voting late.

I am assuming votes are listed in time order, I voted at 8.20 so the others after me voted after that

[Robin the Jester]

Votes for William

Kevin the Armorer
Boris the Fool (
Lilly the Millennial
Weyland the Blacksmith
Ina May the Midwife
Dexter the Dragoon
Countess Markievicz
Dora the Explorer

what if william is a wolf?

Did you declare your vote?

i did not. i voted randomly, but avoiding william

[Robin the Jester]

suppose there's no way to know if any wolves on the william wagon till we kill monica.

How would Monica dying tell us if there is wolves on the wagon? As other have said there is guaranteed to be at least one wolf on the wagon

monica dies, we find out williams alignment. 

william = bad = less likely there are wolves on him.

[Ina May the Midwife]

All 20 votes were cast and distributed amongst 10 players (4 got 2+ votes and 6 got only 1 vote)
William (8) - Kevin, Boris, Lilly, Weyland, Ina May, Dexter, Countess, Dora
Vincent (2) - Moe, William
Jacob (2) - Edward, Benjamin
Lilly (2) - Robin, Friar
Ina May (1) - Magda
Magda (1) - Gordon
Benjamin (1) - Jacob
Countess (1) - Mick
Friar (1) - Amy
Mick (1) - Vincent

Based on my read back, I've seen 13 votes I'd describe as declared. I've not included those that said they'd probably vote a certain way where I didn't see a confirmation post of a vote going in but I have included a probably where there was a reference to a vote going in. We didn't really have a discussion about whether we'd declare on thread or not so that was left to everyone's personal preference. I haven't seen any difference between a declared vote and the final tally.

Declared (in the order I saw them)
Jacob - Edward, Benjamin
William - Boris, Lilly, Weyland, Ina May, Countess, Dora
Vincent - William, Moe
Mick - Vincent
Lilly - Friar
Ina May - Magda

[Lilly the Millennial]

I'd agree with Jacob that until we know William's alignment there is not much wagonomics, and even then with 8 on William I'd question how useful knowing his alignment will be in that respect. At least we know we do get vote tallies though, so should make it easier to notice things if there are close vote races or voting manipulation.

Just on the vote manipulation - there was talk earlier of Elijah’s power possibly being a vote block or manipulation - is there anyone’s vote that is wrong?

[Boris the Fool]

I'd agree with Jacob that until we know William's alignment there is not much wagonomics, and even then with 8 on William I'd question how useful knowing his alignment will be in that respect. At least we know we do get vote tallies though, so should make it easier to notice things if there are close vote races or voting manipulation.

Think it's why we need people declaring votes on thread time and who. I know it's helpful for wolves but it's Prob even more helpful for the rest of us to notice something wrong.

[Dora the Explorer]

As in just "Ip dip sky blue" or was there a reason behind it and /or why you avoided William?

[Lilly the Millennial]

How would Monica dying tell us if there is wolves on the wagon? As other have said there is guaranteed to be at least one wolf on the wagon

monica dies, we find out williams alignment. 

william = bad = less likely there are wolves on him.

Unfortunately it’s not that easy when there is a runaway wagon, I wouldn’t be clearing William voters if he flips green just on that alone

[Boris the Fool]

Did you declare your vote?

i did not. i voted randomly, but avoiding william

What and why?

[Dora the Explorer]

That last post was replying to @Robin the Jester

[Ina May the Midwife]

How would Monica dying tell us if there is wolves on the wagon? As other have said there is guaranteed to be at least one wolf on the wagon

monica dies, we find out williams alignment. 

william = bad = less likely there are wolves on him.

I've not played a game with a wolf priest before. Does this mean that we get the alignments retrospectively if we eliminate the wolf priest successfully and not just all subsequent alignments?

[Boris the Fool]

How would Monica dying tell us if there is wolves on the wagon? As other have said there is guaranteed to be at least one wolf on the wagon

monica dies, we find out williams alignment. 

william = bad = less likely there are wolves on him.

No wolves will still vote for another wolve it can be used to look good when alignments are revealed later in game. Even more reason to do it if they think it's gonna be a landslide.

[Lilly the Millennial]

monica dies, we find out williams alignment. 

william = bad = less likely there are wolves on him.

I've not played a game with a wolf priest before. Does this mean that we get the alignments retrospectively if we eliminate the wolf priest successfully and not just all subsequent alignments?

Yes the assumption is that once we get the wolf priest any information they have will be posted on thread and then the death notices going forward will tell alignment.

[Amy the Singer]

Do we find out? Is there any “I am and always have been ..’?
I had 10 minutes to vote during interval at a play - so I just voted for someone who seemed to be like a dog with bone about an observation I made on day 1 to the extent that I thought the might be protecting someone - so I voted Tuck.

[Ina May the Midwife]

Wesley here on the Lieutenants Call-sign. 7-Lincoln-200 to all units. As you know, the Mayor is giving a talk to the Captain in the Roll-Call room, so you have all been voting on the fly. 

This reads to me that the Roll-Call room is potentially something that could be used for voting on thread at some point in the game. And the below post was from when the form was shared earlier.

7-Lincoln-200 to all units, Roll-Call room is unavailable for vote. Vote form now open