The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf

[Magda the Maid]

To give everyone a chance to contribute prior to munch/SK.. thought that was obvious.. 


Also why the fook not?

i mean , you seem sure you'll be alive till the next lynch

What part of discuss prior to the munch, makes me sure that I will be here till the next lynch..


You are reaching now Willie, trying to save your buddy Laura?

[Pat the Baker]

Bit suss of William post munch

Seemed put out that I said I thought rhoda peeked me good, while immediately taking it as true.

I said it cause I knew I'd be under scrutiny tomorrow anyway from my d1 vote, so trying to save everyone time trawling back through my million posts, and save myself getting pissed off fighting my corner 🤣

Not a slam dunk by any means and id definitely be looking at Laura and Edward alongside. Feels like there are a few going under the radar today

[William the Grave Robber]

You can take this at face value.. if you go ahead and lynch me then that's the villages fault and not mine. I'm giving you the information, the SK is still out there, and if we think that there is still a wolf on the Rhoda votes, I would start with Laura, they are dodge as fuck

i mean , you seem sure you'll be alive till the next lynch

What part of discuss prior to the munch, makes me sure that I will be here till the next lynch..


You are reaching now Willie, trying to save your buddy Laura?

what am i missing here?

talking about yourself being lynched tomorrow night. how do you know you live that long?


i missed a few posts in the interaction cos i'm lazy and half way drunk. but the point stands...how do you know you'll be alive for tomorrow's lynch?

[Magda the Maid]

You can take this at face value.. if you go ahead and lynch me then that's the villages fault and not mine. I'm giving you the information, the SK is still out there, and if we think that there is still a wolf on the Rhoda votes, I would start with Laura, they are dodge as fuck

What part of discuss prior to the munch, makes me sure that I will be here till the next lynch..


You are reaching now Willie, trying to save your buddy Laura?

what am i missing here?

talking about yourself being lynched tomorrow night. how do you know you live that long?


i missed a few posts in the interaction cos i'm lazy and half way drunk. but the point stands...how do you know you'll be alive for tomorrow's lynch?

If I survive the morning munch, I thought that much was obvious, I stated it in my main post that I think one of them will be me. But again that's not certain is it, the only people who know that is the wolves/SK

[Magda the Maid]

I'm off, I've 2 sick kids and haven't slept so, I'll be back on from early enough tomorrow

[Frank the Tank]

Have we lost Maeve? Will she be modkilled?

[William the Grave Robber]

what am i missing here?

talking about yourself being lynched tomorrow night. how do you know you live that long?


i missed a few posts in the interaction cos i'm lazy and half way drunk. but the point stands...how do you know you'll be alive for tomorrow's lynch?

If I survive the morning munch, I thought that much was obvious, I stated it in my main post that I think one of them will be me. But again that's not certain is it, the only people who know that is the wolves/SK

that's not what you said.

you said if you lynch me tomorrow, which implies you wont be dead come lynch time tomorrow. ie: you wont be killed overnight. 

below is your full post:


You can take this at face value.. if you go ahead and lynch me then that's the villages fault and not mine. I'm giving you the information, the SK is still out there, and if we think that there is still a wolf on the Rhoda votes, I would start with Laura, they are dodge as fuck

[Pat the Baker]

Have we lost Maeve? Will she be modkilled?

Derp clear attempt?

Maeve got munched

[William the Grave Robber]

Have we lost Maeve? Will she be modkilled?

maeve is dead. she was killed this morning. 



Merry Brandybuck, The Whisperer, Hobbit of The Shire

[William the Grave Robber]

to add, killed by wolves this morning

[William the Grave Robber]

Have we lost Maeve? Will she be modkilled?

Derp clear attempt?

Maeve got munched

whats the derp?

[Pat the Baker]

Derp clear attempt?

Maeve got munched

whats the derp?

Frank asking is maeve alive. Distancing from wolves as Frank is forgetting their actions 

Probably nothing,  but just in case, worth mentioning.....

[Wendy the Wench]

Have we lost Maeve? Will she be modkilled?

eh, the wolves killed mauve this morning.

[Frank the Tank]

Have we lost Maeve? Will she be modkilled?

Derp clear attempt?

Maeve got munched

Sorry. They did. It's late. Not distancing myself from wolves. Just a mistake due to tiredness.

[Pat the Baker]

Derp clear attempt?

Maeve got munched

Sorry. They did. It's late. Not distancing myself from wolves. Just a mistake due to tiredness.

Thats probably the more likely scenario tbf to ya

Could still be the sk I suppose 😉

[William the Grave Robber]

right, later troops. i'm to bed.

i think what magda meant was that she is safe tonight.

[William the Grave Robber]

i never knew this existed. if you like nirvana its worth a watch.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Morning

[Pat the Baker]

right, later troops. i'm to bed.

i think what magda meant was that she is safe tonight.

You get annoyed I say I think seer peeked me good.. then you post this for all to see, that magda is protected. Im trying to figure out why a good player does this and im struggling . Obviously based on last night bg needs to protect magda, as that claim is a death sentence. Im good but dont protect me, im expendable.

Another slightly outside the box thought.  Why in gods name was Maeve munched night 1 over Ina or Wendy? Can anyone give me a thought on that?

[Ina May the Midwife]

Morning Benjamin, what we thinking after that shitshow last night.

[Ina May the Midwife]

right, later troops. i'm to bed.

i think what magda meant was that she is safe tonight.

You get annoyed I say I think seer peeked me good.. then you post this for all to see, that magda is protected. Im trying to figure out why a good player does this and im struggling . Obviously based on last night bg needs to protect magda, as that claim is a death sentence. Im good but dont protect me, im expendable.

Another slightly outside the box thought.  Why in gods name was Maeve munched night 1 over Ina or Wendy? Can anyone give me a thought on that?

Am I allowed answer? Likely because they feared a BG protect on either myself or Wendy so went for the least likely to be protected

[Pat the Baker]

You get annoyed I say I think seer peeked me good.. then you post this for all to see, that magda is protected. Im trying to figure out why a good player does this and im struggling . Obviously based on last night bg needs to protect magda, as that claim is a death sentence. Im good but dont protect me, im expendable.

Another slightly outside the box thought.  Why in gods name was Maeve munched night 1 over Ina or Wendy? Can anyone give me a thought on that?

Am I allowed answer? Likely because they feared a BG protect on either myself or Wendy so went for the least likely to be protected

Yeah of course you're allowed answer and to be honest it had crossed my mind too, but still its a bit odd, no?

One more question for ya actually. A few people have posted some rhoda breadcrumbs as gandalf. I'll be first to admit i missed these as I've very poor info on Lord of the Rings. You clearly know it well and seem to know the game quite well. Did you miss the hints too?

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Morning Benjamin, what we thinking after that shitshow last night.

Im thinking we may have made a mistake not voting Edward. Here me out…..

Gollum in the movie follows the fellowship around. Another word for following is tracking. Gollum is also looking to get the ring so perhaps they are selecting players each night and that’s what Prada spotted in their investigation?

Wish I’d thought of this last night as a discussion point.

[Magda the Maid]

If I survive the morning munch, I thought that much was obvious, I stated it in my main post that I think one of them will be me. But again that's not certain is it, the only people who know that is the wolves/SK

that's not what you said.

you said if you lynch me tomorrow, which implies you wont be dead come lynch time tomorrow. ie: you wont be killed overnight. 

below is your full post:


You can take this at face value.. if you go ahead and lynch me then that's the villages fault and not mine. I'm giving you the information, the SK is still out there, and if we think that there is still a wolf on the Rhoda votes, I would start with Laura, they are dodge as fuck

Did you read my initial post? that was a follow on for that. i said i may be gone in the morning and i think that they will target me.

Obviously the eyes are going to fall on my day one vote, RL issues hindered me from getting on thread till just before lynch that day and I seen something that made me change my mind. I make no excuses for that and I own that vote.

So with that in mind. I am going to come out here. And get ahead of ye all so you can get ahead of the munch/kill in the morning and discuss other potentials before 2 players are killed off, one of which will probably be me.

So come on down to Hobbiton, where the people are always tiny..

Yes Merry was a friend of mine. I'm one of the important rank of ring bearers,  The Rhoda vote will need to be looked at, personally I would be starting with Laura.

But not before I would be getting rid of Edward imo. I think he played the thread for a cod tonight. But I think there was some abling partners there.

I'm putting this out there now, cause I may be gone in the morning and if I do it closer to munch, it may be too late to get everyone involved in the discussion of who to look at next

[Magda the Maid]

Really can't tell if William is just playing the TWTBAW card or if his posts are just really that dodgy, especially the below.

You believed she peeked me very quickly 

Almost as if you know im good already

if the seer layed fake breadcrumbs we be truly fucked

Implying that The seer has peeked Pat green

now the question is, is magda trying to induce a hobbit to come out? cos the seer fingered you good

I think this is implying that the seer peeked me bad..

Which is it? it can only be one surely

You can take this at face value.. if you go ahead and lynch me then that's the villages fault and not mine. I'm giving you the information, the SK is still out there, and if we think that there is still a wolf on the Rhoda votes, I would start with Laura, they are dodge as fuck

there aint a lynch for another 23 hours. why talk of that now?

trying to shut down discussion again

Why were you excited to see the seer die?

cos i enjoy the chaos

It seems he enjoys creating it to.

Just saying, you took it as definite very quickly

yes, when the dead seer has laid some fairly concrete breadcrumbs on someone i will take that for gospel, certainly with autopriest.

Back to confirm that he thinks the seer peeked pat

[Magda the Maid]

What do we think the odds are on the village having 3 roles that are kind of similar. its possible but is it plausable?

Seer
investigator
visiter/tracker/watcher - whichever one Eddie falls on today

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Legolas is known for his bow and arrows - just saying

[Magda the Maid]

Its also quite possible that Edward was saved last night to take the heat off the real SK (if Eddie is good)

means that there are more people in the discussions for today, if they get through munch

[Magda the Maid]

Legolas is known for his bow and arrows -  just saying

He is, but we didnt see a kill on night 1 which is interesting. its very hard to hold off as a vig.

[Magda the Maid]

@Ina May the Midwife What made you switch your vote?

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Rhoda was one of our most valuable players and saving a player claiming to be a tracker was deemed more important than saving the player breadcrumbing the seer role
🤷🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Legolas is known for his bow and arrows -  just saying

He is, but we didnt see a kill on night 1 which is interesting. its very hard to hold off as a vig.

 
If there’s no arrow fired by 10am then there’s no vig this game.

[Ina May the Midwife]

Am I allowed answer? Likely because they feared a BG protect on either myself or Wendy so went for the least likely to be protected

Yeah of course you're allowed answer and to be honest it had crossed my mind too, but still its a bit odd, no?

One more question for ya actually. A few people have posted some rhoda breadcrumbs as gandalf. I'll be first to admit i missed these as I've very poor info on Lord of the Rings. You clearly know it well and seem to know the game quite well. Did you miss the hints too?

Nope didn't catch the hints tbh. I mean they're obvious enough now the identity has been revealed but I genuinely didn't twig it at all

[Magda the Maid]

Rhoda was one of our most valuable players and saving a player claiming to be a tracker was deemed more important than saving the player breadcrumbing the seer role
🤷🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️

Did you see the breadcrumbs? I dont think many did.. i didnt, its quiet possible if i had of got back online that i would have voted there also.

[Edward the Barber]

Morning all.

Why have I not been shot if I'm lying and Legolas has this power?

Because I am who I said I am and Legolas has no arrows

I picked a player last night to see if they completed an action, no result yet so it will be after munch

I will name the player I picked just before munch, we won't know the result though if I'm dead, so lets wait and see

[Ina May the Midwife]

@Ina May the Midwife What made you switch your vote?

Honestly? I believed Edward in spite of the mess he made of his claim. Nobody was heavily refuting the Legolas stuff either which would have been a strong indicator 😕 

As I said at the time when I switched, it was against my better judgement but that's how I genuinely felt. I've seen roled players lynched for screwing up the explanations of their powers before and I was concerned that was what we were doing again.

[Pat the Baker]

I have to run again just quickly checking in.

Gonna go against my better judgement and give @Edward the Barber the benefit of the doubt

Switched vote to Rhoda just there

Can anyone help me out here like I helped Maeve yesterday. What way are we voting ? Obvs I can see the Edward wagon. Have we any other shouts for wolf ?

Can anyone help me out here like I helped Maeve yesterday. What way are we voting ? Obvs I can see the Edward wagon. Have we any other shouts for wolf ?

Seems to be Edward or rhoda atm

I have to run again just quickly checking in.

Gonna go against my better judgement and give @Edward the Barber the benefit of the doubt

Switched vote to Rhoda just there

Whys that?

I’m going to make some dinner, will check in when done. Happy to move to Rhoda if that is the consensus as Prada also names her

Seems to be Edward or rhoda atm

Thanks Pat. 

Okay, I'll go Rhoda for the counter. I better get back into this training session. I'll try get back on before 9

Who do you think is/are bad? Preferably plural

Rhoda possibly. Fwiw, I think pradas reads were speculation as she read me wrong.

The Legolas claim is blooming obvious. Why would a SK be so bold to claim this role? It is one of the main characters and likely to be in the game. Too easy to catch themselves in a lie.

Need someone to explain the Legolas character to me. In my mind Legolas in this game would be a vigilante due to having a bow and arrow but does Legolas have more abilities than that?

There wasn’t a shot/arrow last night or so far today.

legolas is an elf character, who shoots bow and arrow. they would be a good character for the vig.
That in itself would be a reason to let ed off the lynch, as claiming legolas means that the real legolas will kill them, as well as the wolves will also try to kill them if they are not a wolf.
so, as they said earlier, they are screwed,
let them live, and everybody is out to kill them. They played terribly, as whatever they are, RV/SK/wolf.

I'm convincing myself to vote rhoda here, as ed will be a target for wolves if they are not a wolf, and a target for vig if the are not exactly legolas.

Im not against a rhoda yeet obviously, voted there yesterdayand havent changed my opinion. Im on Edward but not sure

Do we get any useful info if Edward is yeeted and is good?

If rhoda is yeeted and is good, we at least get info from their d1 wagon

Do we get any useful info if Edward is yeeted and is good?

If rhoda is yeeted and is good, we at least get info from their d1 wagon

I don't know if you can call it useful, but if ed turns out to be good, we learn the legolas had a shit role.

I've already moved to rhoda.

I don't know if you can call it useful, but if ed turns out to be good, we learn the legolas had a shit role.

I've already moved to rhoda.

Ok i think I'll be switching too so

Bit of a timeline of how things went to rhoda. Im guilty on that front obviously but damage was done by a few earlier. Vincent goes rhoda 'for the counter' is out there

[Edward the Barber]

Rhoda was one of our most valuable players and saving a player claiming to be a tracker was deemed more important than saving the player breadcrumbing the seer role
🤷🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️

Did you see the breadcrumbs? It is not like I was saved over the seer, nobody knew they were the seer before lynch

Who did you vote for?

[Mick the Drunk]

Morning all - no vig kill N1 or last night - makes me think the lynch is the only opportunity we have in this game to take out the wolves / SK. The only plus is that the evil teams haven’t had any extra kills either. A failed munch or SK this morning would be a great help

[Pat the Baker]

You get annoyed I say I think seer peeked me good.. then you post this for all to see, that magda is protected. Im trying to figure out why a good player does this and im struggling . Obviously based on last night bg needs to protect magda, as that claim is a death sentence. Im good but dont protect me, im expendable.

Another slightly outside the box thought.  Why in gods name was Maeve munched night 1 over Ina or Wendy? Can anyone give me a thought on that?

Am I allowed answer? Likely because they feared a BG protect on either myself or Wendy so went for the least likely to be protected

And just to follow on from this and its a slightly biased opinion cause its how I would play it as a wolf... im trying to munch the most important/dangerous villager.  D1 that was you.  Voted wolf,  good handle on the game and the lore.  Voted for a wolf.  If not you then Wendy.  If 1 is protected,  that's bad luck and kill em next time