(14-10-2025, 09:38 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote:

(13-10-2025, 11:53 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: There are some really quiet posters on here. Tom, William, Frank, Vernon and I am sure a few others. Calpol or not, you have to ask why are they laying so low? Maeve appeared right before the vote and disappeared right after it. However, it does appear she is genuinely busy. Then again, Betty claimed she was a newbie- not necc a lie- and it turned out she was a wolf, so...shows you what a good judge of charachter I am!

 A bit cryptic

(13-10-2025, 08:37 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote:

(13-10-2025, 08:25 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote: Who are you voting for?

In my opinion, voting for someone cause they don't have a lot of posts, and not many of substance (aside from your long post), is more productive than trying to clear someone based on a handful of posts.  Unless the handfull of posts are helpful, giving reads, insight etc

Ok fair enough. I do think a lot of posters posting ability/timing and so on, comes down to their ability to contribute during the working day. Usually I would have a bit more freedom during office hours, but today I didn't, hence the jumbo post.
I never know when to read into people's posting times or not. All I can say is in my case, it is a misconstruel. 

I am really torn here. There are a lot of players being helpful and then unhelpful and then helpful again. 
Peek: Pat or Magda
Shoot: Wendy or Laura on reflection. Coz i am not sure on the others. And Vernon gets a pass tonight. As does Betty if she is being truthful.
Protect: Me. Or perhaps Vern or Betty given my reasoning above.
I am going to read back one more time and then vote.

(13-10-2025, 09:50 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote:

(13-10-2025, 08:57 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: Vote in for Wendy. I am not happy about it. My peeks might be a better vote but hey ho.

Probably should have gone with my peeks like I said, lol.
I voted you because of all the accusations you had flying about. Not much more than that tbh.

(13-10-2025, 09:54 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: Omg what is wrong with me and names. Jfc.
I shouldn't have gone with my peeks...
"Rolleyes"
Can someone do a spreadsheet that we can download. HRT isn't working clearly.

(14-10-2025, 08:22 AM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: Good morrow fellow travellers, I pray you all had a restful night.
The clouds darken and I worry what lies ahead of us.

I also feel like there is something brewing from thr GMs. This is definitely not going to be ordinary straightforward gameplay.

Thanks for helping me get my loaf straight last evening @Pat the Baker
If my old wizened bones survive the morning, I think we should look at @Laura the Lace Mistress for a re read on characters to see where her head is at.
I would also be interested to hear from Ina and William anything they have found in the ancient texts that could be of use.

I think there was some definite odd flurry gameplay last night and we need to see clearly who and why

(14-10-2025, 09:22 AM)Magda the Maid Wrote: Anyways we can chat about me, if Rhoda flips village or SK, then ye will see, and you can all focus on the other 2 on that wagon, if she is Vil or SK.

(14-10-2025, 09:29 AM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: Indeed Magda.

(14-10-2025, 12:07 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 12:05 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: I stand corrected. I just noticed my time on the posts was an hour earlier.
The above post by Prada is 9:45pm. However it is 2 players she is calling out. Edward and Rhoda. Not just Edward here. 
The whoosh whoosh post really makes me think they checked Rhoda.

There you go then.

Still would like Laura to come back on here and do another round up. Why was her read the way it was in the beginning. She is very informed I feel.

(14-10-2025, 01:42 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 01:36 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: Took some time away there to reflect.

Question: what would Gollum's alignment be?

To himself? Or am I misunderstanding the question?

@Ina May the Midwife I agree with you on Edward, MAgda, Laura. THink you need to throw Wendy in the mix there. I feel like there is tag teaming going on and Pat and I is getting caught up in the cross fire.
Interesting read on Frank but I would need more info. Were they just stopping MAeve from oscaring?

(14-10-2025, 03:09 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: I really don't know why Prada would have said that. I'm neither SK nor wolf. You will have to believe me on that. Or not- but to our detriment.
That whole thing about the morning thing about Edward is super weird.
That aside, I am not wholly convinced they are SK necessarily. I do think there are some posters on here deflecting away from them onto other random people or just moving the conversation along. For reasons best known either to themselves, or between themselves.

@Wendy the Wench why are you asking only about Ben and not about the other low posters/ one voters? And why are you asking only MAgda?

(14-10-2025, 03:33 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: I urge you, Pat, pause.

(14-10-2025, 03:56 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: No pockets in this cloak @Pat the Baker

(14-10-2025, 05:14 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: Why would a roled person ever not complete an action?
In my view, if you have power, you should always use it- albeit carefully.

(14-10-2025, 07:33 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 07:02 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote: What does wom mean?

And who would be on your bad list?

I am using speech to text.So if it goes a bit wonky , apologies. The fighting irish thing was directed at william , and I wonder what he mean.
In relation to w o m I meant world of men william didn't speak much today , and then comments in a very obscure manner about a football match in the world of men as opposed to all of the happenings on the threa. Tread.
In relation to my suspicions, I see that everyone is going for Edward. I don't believe his protestations, but I am also deeply suspicious of those who voted for me last night because I know who I am and therefore I am looking at Laura or Magda. Their posting has been peculiar in 2 different ways. Today, Laura, for only popping in now, but that could be wom related and Magda, for the back-and-forth with Wendy over and over.

(14-10-2025, 07:36 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: I have a placeholder home. One of the women currently nighter at the moment, and if I finish training on time, I will see what else has come to light in the thread and whether I need to change before the cutoff time for voting. Again, this is speech 2 text.So apologies , if the syntax is off , us , old people are not used to technology

(14-10-2025, 07:37 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: That should read magda

(14-10-2025, 07:39 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: OK last post, because I am sitting in the car park now. If you are short votes for Edward, please let me know and tag me and I will switch my vote.

(14-10-2025, 07:41 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: No, Pat, I am not suspicious of you.. I believe you to be a good man.
Well, it\n Is a toss up between Wendy and Magda? And if looking at the voting, I would have to go-between Laura and Magda and so the cross over in the pie chart there for me, is Magda.

(14-10-2025, 09:03 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: Driving home so speech to text again. But think about it, if I was really trying to save myself, I would have voted Edward, and I didn't, I voted Magda.

(14-10-2025, 09:44 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote: I think i need a lie down after that..

(14-10-2025, 09:45 PM)Vincent the Artist Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 09:38 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote:  A bit cryptic

Did we ever find out who Tom was ? Could it be a reference to someone or something?

(14-10-2025, 09:29 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote: now you've outted yourself as being good

(14-10-2025, 09:54 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 09:29 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote: now you've outted yourself as being good

You believed she peeked me very quickly 

Almost as if you know im good already

(14-10-2025, 08:31 AM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 08:26 AM)Edward the Barber Wrote: I voted about 2 hours before deadline. Great result but I don't want any plaudits, it was a complete fluke on my part, I wasn't here much to have any read on anyone

How many of us revealed on thread who we were voting for? Was it common knowledge that Betty was up? If so then there could be wolves in the votes for the other high voted player trying to save Betty

There were declared votes but there wasn't really a consensus at all. In fact Rhoda would have probably been lynched but for Maeve's vote and Wendy switching last minute. Magda had an 8.58 vote on Rhoda

@Wendy the Wench who did you switch off last min to move onto Betty?

(14-10-2025, 08:56 AM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote:

(13-10-2025, 08:56 PM)Maeve the Madam Wrote: I'll go with Betty then

So Maeve hops on the thread and after a little bit of discussion hops on Betty, this means at this point the wagons are:

Betty - Ina, Edward, Maeve

Rhoda - Pat, Laura

One minute later, Rhoda posts the following:

(13-10-2025, 08:57 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: Vote in for Wendy. I am not happy about it. My peeks might be a better vote but hey ho.

That doesn't change the top wagons at all, Betty is still in the lead by a vote.

(13-10-2025, 08:58 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: Jaysus the hint of wolf off this.. switching to Rhoda

Magda then pops onto Rhoda at 8.58, tying the top wagons so it looks like this:


Rhoda - Pat, Laura, Magda*

Betty - Ina, Edward, Maeve

*Magda has last vote so if this was final vote count Rhoda would have been lynched

(13-10-2025, 09:12 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote: i switched back to betty in last few seconds.

This post from Wendy comes post lynch closure - which confirms the top wagon and Wendy's last minute vote the killing blow on Betty.

Betty - Ina, Edward, Maeve, Wendy

Rhoda - Pat, Laura, Magda.

Last vote no longer matters as Betty has more votes, but Wendy likely would have gotten it anywho.

Two things I can't quite understand.

Why no self pres on Rhoda from Betty. Also, Rhoda doesn't self pres onto Betty either. Red flag to me there in terms of alignment, it indicates that both may be wolves and didn't want to vote each other.

Instead, Rhoda and Betty both end up voting Wendy together. Possible that they thought Wendy would have more votes and tried to make her the counter wagon? Can't answer that question firmly until we know Rhoda's alignment though.


If Rhoda is village or the SK, Magda becomes a highly priority possibility for wolf based on the timing of her voting Rhoda, as it tied the wagons with Betty.

We shall cross that bridge if necessary but worth bearing in mind. I'm not convinced that Rhoda's a villager though but I thought it best to include this in my post.

(14-10-2025, 09:02 AM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: That's interesting insight Ina. I actually had in my head that made Magda safer and Laura was the voter on me I was most suspicious if.
On Wendy, and perhaps she can clarify. She said early on Berry or Edward and then went Betty. Why? Hopefully she can clarify

(14-10-2025, 09:22 AM)Magda the Maid Wrote: Anyways we can chat about me, if Rhoda flips village or SK, then ye will see, and you can all focus on the other 2 on that wagon, if she is Vil or SK.

(14-10-2025, 09:29 AM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: Indeed Magda.

(14-10-2025, 10:00 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: Come out of hiding Edward

(14-10-2025, 09:52 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 09:45 PM)Vincent the Artist Wrote: Did we ever find out who Tom was ? Could it be a reference to someone or something?

Off memory I think someone replied there is no Tom but best bet is to read on from that post

(14-10-2025, 10:01 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 08:31 AM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: There were declared votes but there wasn't really a consensus at all. In fact Rhoda would have probably been lynched but for Maeve's vote and Wendy switching last minute. Magda had an 8.58 vote on Rhoda

@Wendy the Wench who did you switch off last min to move onto Betty?

(14-10-2025, 08:56 AM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: So Maeve hops on the thread and after a little bit of discussion hops on Betty, this means at this point the wagons are:

Betty - Ina, Edward, Maeve

Rhoda - Pat, Laura

One minute later, Rhoda posts the following:


That doesn't change the top wagons at all, Betty is still in the lead by a vote.



Magda then pops onto Rhoda at 8.58, tying the top wagons so it looks like this:


Rhoda - Pat, Laura, Magda*

Betty - Ina, Edward, Maeve

*Magda has last vote so if this was final vote count Rhoda would have been lynched


This post from Wendy comes post lynch closure - which confirms the top wagon and Wendy's last minute vote the killing blow on Betty.

Betty - Ina, Edward, Maeve, Wendy

Rhoda - Pat, Laura, Magda.

Last vote no longer matters as Betty has more votes, but Wendy likely would have gotten it anywho.

Two things I can't quite understand.

Why no self pres on Rhoda from Betty. Also, Rhoda doesn't self pres onto Betty either. Red flag to me there in terms of alignment, it indicates that both may be wolves and didn't want to vote each other.

Instead, Rhoda and Betty both end up voting Wendy together. Possible that they thought Wendy would have more votes and tried to make her the counter wagon? Can't answer that question firmly until we know Rhoda's alignment though.


If Rhoda is village or the SK, Magda becomes a highly priority possibility for wolf based on the timing of her voting Rhoda, as it tied the wagons with Betty.

We shall cross that bridge if necessary but worth bearing in mind. I'm not convinced that Rhoda's a villager though but I thought it best to include this in my post.

(14-10-2025, 09:02 AM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: That's interesting insight Ina. I actually had in my head that made Magda safer and Laura was the voter on me I was most suspicious if.
On Wendy, and perhaps she can clarify. She said early on Berry or Edward and then went Betty. Why? Hopefully she can clarify

(14-10-2025, 09:22 AM)Magda the Maid Wrote: Anyways we can chat about me, if Rhoda flips village or SK, then ye will see, and you can all focus on the other 2 on that wagon, if she is Vil or SK.

(14-10-2025, 09:29 AM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: Indeed Magda.

And we are now back here then I guess?

(14-10-2025, 10:11 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 10:01 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: And we are now back here then I guess?

Yup Magda looking pretty hairy over that vote now

(14-10-2025, 10:13 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 10:11 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: Yup Magda looking pretty hairy over that vote now

can you check your lore there and see if Hobbits are hairy

(14-10-2025, 09:18 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 09:03 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: Driving home so speech to text again. But think about it, if I was really trying to save myself, I would have voted Edward, and I didn't, I voted Magda.

Gandalf's last words.
Can Rhoda now come back as Gandalf the White?

(14-10-2025, 10:17 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote: now the question is, is magda trying to induce a hobbit to come out? cos the seer fingered you good

(14-10-2025, 10:17 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote: now the question is, is magda trying to induce a hobbit to come out? cos the seer fingered you good

(14-10-2025, 10:24 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 10:17 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote: now the question is, is magda trying to induce a hobbit to come out? cos the seer fingered you good

The seer can only have half one peek.
I think that peek was used on Pat, not Magda.

(14-10-2025, 10:26 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 10:24 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: The seer can only have half one peek.
I think that peek was used on Pat, not Magda.

sup frank

(14-10-2025, 10:25 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: You can take this at face value.. if you go ahead and lynch me then that's the villages fault and not mine. I'm giving you the information, the SK is still out there, and if we think that there is still a wolf on the Rhoda votes, I would start with Laura, they are dodge as fuck

(14-10-2025, 10:27 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 10:25 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: You can take this at face value.. if you go ahead and lynch me then that's the villages fault and not mine. I'm giving you the information, the SK is still out there, and if we think that there is still a wolf on the Rhoda votes, I would start with Laura, they are dodge as fuck

there aint a lynch for another 23 hours. why talk of that now?

(14-10-2025, 10:27 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 10:25 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: You can take this at face value.. if you go ahead and lynch me then that's the villages fault and not mine. I'm giving you the information, the SK is still out there, and if we think that there is still a wolf on the Rhoda votes, I would start with Laura, they are dodge as fuck

there aint a lynch for another 23 hours. why talk of that now?

(14-10-2025, 09:56 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 09:54 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote: You believed she peeked me very quickly 

Almost as if you know im good already

if the seer layed fake breadcrumbs we be truly fucked

(14-10-2025, 10:11 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: Obviously the eyes are going to fall on my day one vote, RL issues hindered me from getting on thread till just before lynch that day and I seen something that made me change my mind. I make no excuses for that and I own that vote.

So with that in mind. I am going to come out here. And get ahead of ye all so you can get ahead of the munch/kill in the morning and discuss other potentials before 2 players are killed off, one of which will probably be me.

So come on down to Hobbiton, where the people are always tiny..

Yes Merry was a friend of mine. I'm one of the important rank of ring bearers,  The Rhoda vote will need to be looked at, personally I would be starting with Laura.

But not before I would be getting rid of Edward imo. I think he played the thread for a cod tonight. But I think there was some abling partners there.

I'm putting this out there now, cause I may be gone in the morning and if I do it closer to munch, it may be too late to get everyone involved in the discussion of who to look at next

(14-10-2025, 09:30 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote: well, its exciting at the very least. never underestimate the village's ability to fuck things up.

(14-10-2025, 10:33 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 10:11 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: Obviously the eyes are going to fall on my day one vote, RL issues hindered me from getting on thread till just before lynch that day and I seen something that made me change my mind. I make no excuses for that and I own that vote.

So with that in mind. I am going to come out here. And get ahead of ye all so you can get ahead of the munch/kill in the morning and discuss other potentials before 2 players are killed off, one of which will probably be me.

So come on down to Hobbiton, where the people are always tiny..

Yes Merry was a friend of mine. I'm one of the important rank of ring bearers,  The Rhoda vote will need to be looked at, personally I would be starting with Laura.

But not before I would be getting rid of Edward imo. I think he played the thread for a cod tonight. But I think there was some abling partners there.

I'm putting this out there now, cause I may be gone in the morning and if I do it closer to munch, it may be too late to get everyone involved in the discussion of who to look at next

Why do you say you might be gone in the morning? If people are talking about lynching you  then you are probably the least likely to be munched/killed

(14-10-2025, 10:33 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 10:11 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: Obviously the eyes are going to fall on my day one vote, RL issues hindered me from getting on thread till just before lynch that day and I seen something that made me change my mind. I make no excuses for that and I own that vote.

So with that in mind. I am going to come out here. And get ahead of ye all so you can get ahead of the munch/kill in the morning and discuss other potentials before 2 players are killed off, one of which will probably be me.

So come on down to Hobbiton, where the people are always tiny..

Yes Merry was a friend of mine. I'm one of the important rank of ring bearers,  The Rhoda vote will need to be looked at, personally I would be starting with Laura.

But not before I would be getting rid of Edward imo. I think he played the thread for a cod tonight. But I think there was some abling partners there.

I'm putting this out there now, cause I may be gone in the morning and if I do it closer to munch, it may be too late to get everyone involved in the discussion of who to look at next

Why do you say you might be gone in the morning? If people are talking about lynching you  then you are probably the least likely to be munched/killed

(14-10-2025, 10:29 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 10:27 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote: there aint a lynch for another 23 hours. why talk of that now?

To give everyone a chance to contribute prior to munch/SK.. thought that was obvious.. 


Also why the fook not?

(14-10-2025, 10:34 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 09:30 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote: well, its exciting at the very least. never underestimate the village's ability to fuck things up.

Why were you excited to see the seer die?

(14-10-2025, 10:31 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 09:56 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote: if the seer layed fake breadcrumbs we be truly fucked

Just saying, you took it as definite very quickly