The Gang Solves The Werewolf Crisis

[Magda the Maid]

Is it here? No, have i made an assumption based on mechanics, absolutely yes. You're about as subtle as an 1980s Dublin bus driver

once you get to your destination on time is all that matters

You've never been on a Dublin bus with a reply like that! On time 🤣🤣🤣

[lorcand1990]

@Benjamin the Alchemist has had an empty vodka bottle thrown at them. It smashed on their head and killed them.

@Benjamin the Alchemist was a Jabroni

[Magda the Maid]

A
Declared votes in alphabetical order - I would need to get time to go back over the thread to do in order of declaration, but meetings probably won't allow for this today. 

Interesting things that I am still mulling over: 

• the wolves really did spread their votes on D1
  
• Kevin voted Prada 2 nights in a row
  
• Laura voted Robin 2 nights in a row
  
• Frank switched off Laura to Prada 
  
• Amy switched from Kevin to Benjamin
  

Happy to clarify my move. My main suspicion on D1 was Benjamin. When he said he was a newbie (rather than other players saying it for him) I moved off because of the amnesty.

Voted Kevin and then moved back to Benjamin when the amnesty ended.

Giving a pass to known and suspected newbies Frank and Benjamin (particularly after explicitly saying newbie in #361), and Vernon for tonight. Ignoring the no posters.

That means my attention turns to Kevin. Couple of things standing out to me at the minute - suggests voting for Frank on a couple of occasions after Frank had stated he was new (post #44 and #134). In post #123 claimed Benjamin outed an RV but quoted the post which draws more attention to the post. In post #166 said that Donald the Spoofer was an enemy to the wolves even though it was a flavour kill and then went on to suggest that what read to me as a joke by Prada on lynching based on the name was starting a bandwagon on Donald.

I didn't get a response to my suspicions on Kevin since this post but happy to take them now @Kevin the Armorer

The timing here is funny

[Magda the Maid]

Well fuck that anyway, anyone got the numbers handy?

[Laura the Lace Mistress]

Well fuck that anyway, anyone got the numbers handy?

10 left.

[Laura the Lace Mistress]

and night 1 votes

[Laura the Lace Mistress]

i'm going doing a few hours work. laters

[Magda the Maid]

I mean its 4 or 5 bad players left, the odds are getting slightly more in our favour of hitting a wolf/sk tonight. In an ideal world, we dont want to take out the sk. Need some cross fire to land there to salvage something in this game.

My positive side out of the way, we are banjoed

[Boris the Fool]

I mean its 4 or 5 bad players left, the odds are getting slightly more in our favour of hitting a wolf/sk tonight. In an ideal world, we dont want to take out the sk. Need some cross fire to land there to salvage something in this game.

My positive side out of the way, we are banjoed

SK has had their kill today so they won't be able to help us until tomorrow. My concern here is Ryan - he has killed each day so i would be expecting another one today - if he hits the SK we are screwed as working on the assumption of 4 wolves we are 5 v 4 v 1

[Frank the Tank]

Oh shit Ben was village as well. I still think Prada is who we need to lynch tonight no matter what. After that, maybe Laura based on the odd voting patterns.

[Boris the Fool]

Oh shit Ben was village as well. I still think Prada is who we need to lynch tonight no matter what. After that, maybe Laura based on the odd voting patterns.

We need to be as certain as reasonably possible for tonight lynch as it could be near end game so I think we should have a consensus on thread before anyone starts voting.

[Gordon the Cook]

Yea I'm here today. Won't have time to read back. So there are 10 left? No wolves or sk killed yet? So there are only 5 or 6 vilagers left? Look on the bright side, chances of lynching a non villager is getting better

[Boris the Fool]

Yea I'm here today. Won't have time to read back. So there are 10 left? No wolves or sk killed yet? So there are only 5 or 6 vilagers left? Look on the bright side, chances of lynching a non villager is getting better

Do you have any suspiscions?

[Robin the Jester]

[Gordon the Cook]

Yea I'm here today. Won't have time to read back. So there are 10 left? No wolves or sk killed yet? So there are only 5 or 6 vilagers left? Look on the bright side, chances of lynching a non villager is getting better

Do you have any suspiscions?

Everyone apart from me, lets see how today plays out

[Prada the Seamstress]

Gordon said they voted Vernon

[Gordon the Cook]

I voted Vernon last night, my first vote as the cook. His name was mentioned a few times and I had to pick someone.

[lorcand1990]

@Magda the Maid has been given poisoned milk

They are deaded

@Magda the Maid was A Jabroni

[Prada the Seamstress]

twas wondering that myself. think kevin started the cfd, and a few followed suit.

if it was a wolf mechanic, then there would be at least 1 wolf on the prada 'voters'.

Why you lie?
Vernon moved first, i moved with 2 minutes to go.
I was voting dex up until 5 minutes to go, then by time i wanted to move to prada there was only two minutes left.
Cfd consisted entirely of me and the bodyguard, if you can call it a cfd
Two never moved, two others shored up from dex to prad, but were happy for dex or prada, so we’re trying to make sure of one of them.
Otherwise a 3 vote on somebody else beats both dex and prada.

Wolf mechanic, absolutely no reason for it to be a village one, intentionally delaying information which is useful to us is 100% wolf mechanic imo

how do you know the info is delayed rather than not coming?

I dont but removing a full nights voting history from the game would be mental. Its 50% of all information available to villagers currently. I could be wrong, If I am we are even more fucked than I originally thought

intentionally delaying information which is useful to us is 100% wolf mechanic imo.

you seem pretty certain here.

Do you want to offer an alternative opinion here or just reiterate my stance? I am pretty certain as I dont see an upside to it being a villager power, do you?

Can we lynch the obvious wolf tonight

After the catastrophic events of the previous day, @Kevin the Armorer had a few too many at the bar. Feeling a little worse for wear, they went to use the Paddy’s Pub Toilets (not recommended at the best of times). Thankfully, they managed to avoid the glory hole in the wall and whatever lay behind it. Distracted by said hole, they stepped straight through a trapdoor.

Quick as a flash, in ran Dee & the McPoyles ran in and closed the trapdoor shut. @Kevin the Armorer was never to be seen again

@Kevin the Armorer is dead

@Kevin the Armorer was a Jabroni

@Magda the Maid has been given poisoned milk

They are deaded

@Magda the Maid was A Jabroni

Vote in for Laura. Occams Razor folks.

[Robin the Jester]

@Prada the Seamstress see my post above and try not to take offense my dear. It's just a numbers game.

In fact @Magda the Maid @Amy the Singer @Prada the Seamstress @Laura the Lace Mistress if any of you want to visit with me later and prove you're all woman, please do! I'll show you mine if you show me yours. 😉

@Dexter the Dragoon if you were certain @Prada the Seamstress is a wolf, why didn't you vote there last night?

[Prada the Seamstress]

Where the hell is everyone.

[Laura the Lace Mistress]

Where the hell is everyone.

sup

[Laura the Lace Mistress]

Why you lie?
Vernon moved first, i moved with 2 minutes to go.
I was voting dex up until 5 minutes to go, then by time i wanted to move to prada there was only two minutes left.
Cfd consisted entirely of me and the bodyguard, if you can call it a cfd
Two never moved, two others shored up from dex to prad, but were happy for dex or prada, so we’re trying to make sure of one of them.
Otherwise a 3 vote on somebody else beats both dex and prada.

Can we lynch the obvious wolf tonight

After the catastrophic events of the previous day, @Kevin the Armorer had a few too many at the bar. Feeling a little worse for wear, they went to use the Paddy’s Pub Toilets (not recommended at the best of times). Thankfully, they managed to avoid the glory hole in the wall and whatever lay behind it. Distracted by said hole, they stepped straight through a trapdoor.

Quick as a flash, in ran Dee & the McPoyles ran in and closed the trapdoor shut. @Kevin the Armorer was never to be seen again

@Kevin the Armorer is dead

@Kevin the Armorer was a Jabroni

@Magda the Maid has been given poisoned milk

They are deaded

@Magda the Maid was A Jabroni

Vote in for Laura. Occams Razor folks.

you'll have to explain the occams razor here.

1. i mixed up kevin vs vernon starting the move to yourself. how is that actually a reason to vote me? 

2. calling out magda for a very solid reason - saying the vote info was delayed. this implies she had knowledge that it was delayed. again, how is this a reason to vote me?

3. in both your reasons above you also left out my last replies to both kevin and magda. why?


4. i suppose they both died shortly after our interactions.

[Prada the Seamstress]

Vote in for Laura. Occams Razor folks.

you'll have to explain the occams razor here.

1. i mixed up kevin vs vernon starting the move to yourself. how is that actually a reason to vote me? 

2. calling out magda for a very solid reason - saying the vote info was delayed. this implies she had knowledge that it was delayed. again, how is this a reason to vote me?

3. in both your reasons above you also left out my last replies to both kevin and magda. why?


4. i suppose they both died shortly after our interactions.

It's the oldest trick in the book isn't it, kill your accusers.

[Laura the Lace Mistress]

you'll have to explain the occams razor here.

1. i mixed up kevin vs vernon starting the move to yourself. how is that actually a reason to vote me? 

2. calling out magda for a very solid reason - saying the vote info was delayed. this implies she had knowledge that it was delayed. again, how is this a reason to vote me?

3. in both your reasons above you also left out my last replies to both kevin and magda. why?


4. i suppose they both died shortly after our interactions.

It's the oldest trick in the book isn't it, kill your accusers.

that would be the 1D move.

2D would be you doing it (the killing that is) and calling me out, trying to drive a wagon on me.

3D would be you doing it (the killing that is) and hope a villager calls me out for you then to jump on the wagon.

i think we be in a 2D scenario right now.

[Prada the Seamstress]

It's the oldest trick in the book isn't it, kill your accusers.

that would be the 1D move.

2D would be you doing it (the killing that is) and calling me out, trying to drive a wagon on me.

3D would be you doing it (the killing that is) and hope a villager calls me out for you then to jump on the wagon.

i think we be in a 2D scenario right now.

Nope, it's just the 1D scenario Laura, hence the Occam's Razor comment. Interesting how you've suddenly come to life to get busy over it though when we didn't get much out of you prior to this other than random votes and voting over song lyrics.

Shake that thing, Laura Laura, shake that thing.

[Laura the Lace Mistress]

that would be the 1D move.

2D would be you doing it (the killing that is) and calling me out, trying to drive a wagon on me.

3D would be you doing it (the killing that is) and hope a villager calls me out for you then to jump on the wagon.

i think we be in a 2D scenario right now.

Nope, it's just the 1D scenario Laura, hence the Occam's Razor comment. Interesting how you've suddenly come to life to get busy over it though when we didn't get much out of you prior to this other than random votes and voting over song lyrics.

Shake that thing, Laura Laura, shake that thing.

the song lyrics is a completely legit reason to call out robin, as is questioning magda over the delay results comments.

[Laura the Lace Mistress]

as for the suddenly come to life thing, i am the 3rd highest posted on thread

[Prada the Seamstress]

as for the suddenly come to life thing, i am the 3rd highest posted on thread

And yet the only thing I can genuinely remember of your posting is your voting. And the charts, which are helpful granted but completely non-alignment indicative.

[Laura the Lace Mistress]

as for the suddenly come to life thing, i am the 3rd highest posted on thread

And yet the only thing I can genuinely remember of your posting is your voting. And the charts, which are helpful granted but completely non-alignment indicative.

and the main thing about you.....how the feck did you survive last nights lynch at the expense of a villager (roled as well)?

[Prada the Seamstress]

And yet the only thing I can genuinely remember of your posting is your voting. And the charts, which are helpful granted but completely non-alignment indicative.

and the main thing about you.....how the feck did you survive last nights lynch at the expense of a villager (roled as well)?

I haven't a clue, genuinely. Not a notion. Went away at 5.30 for the game and came back to carnage.

Right so we're kinda fucked here if I'm honest. How many of us are left in total, 9?

I've made my thoughts on you clear and that's where I'm probably going to be voting but there's more wolves out there. Rather than us doing this dance back and forth all day I'm going to review other players too. 

Gonna start with the randy Dexter.

[Dexter the Dragoon]

@Prada the Seamstress  see my post above and try not to take offense my dear. It's just a numbers game.

In fact @Magda the Maid @Amy the Singer @Prada the Seamstress @Laura the Lace Mistress if any of you want to visit with me later and prove you're all woman, please do! I'll show you mine if you show me yours. 😉

@Dexter the Dragoon if you were certain @Prada the Seamstress is a wolf, why didn't you vote there last night?

My good fellow, you are very mistaken. I never said I was certain Prada was a wolf. 
What I said and you so carefully failed to add was that I would be voting for Benjamin as his confused act didn't ring true. (OK I got that wrong. It wasn't an act. He truly was too stupid to be a wolf!) 
On the women: I said I was certain there is a she-wolf. Which I was and still am. But I was unsure between two. Those were Prada and Laura. To be entirely honest I'm still unsure but leaning towards Prada. I spefically said since I wasn't sure which of them was the culprit I didn't yet feel comfortable calling them out. You forgot to quote that bit also. 
Prada than asked me a question and as she is the most prolific poster I knew she might guess I was talking about her and that is where my post which you quoted came into things. 
Women are complex creatures. We can all agree on that. Even a man of my impressive standing can find them difficult to read. All the same, if I was in charge of the village vote, as of right now I would recommend we vote Prada. But I admit Laura isn't exactly coming across as innocent herself. I will continue to monitor the situation and give my thoughts later.

[Laura the Lace Mistress]

i'm travelling now. will be back online at about 4pm.

[Boris the Fool]

Part of me can’t help but think is this back and forth between Laura and Prada a wolf on wolf debate? They know as numbers are getting lower we have a better chance of lynching a wolf. Therefore if we lynch one of those then the other will be able to say they are not a wolf because they went after the other one.

At the moment my vote will be on one of these - not sure which one yet. At the risk of sounding like Nick and Ben from The Traitors are we best keep in the one we are more certain on (Prada) and trying to find another one (Laura). Happy to go with the consensus of the village

[William the Grave Robber]

Why alphabetical order rather than in order of declared votes?

[William the Grave Robber]

Part of me can’t help but think is this back and forth between Laura and Prada a wolf on wolf debate? They know as numbers are getting lower we have a better chance of lynching a wolf. Therefore if we lynch one of those then the other will be able to say they are not a wolf because they went after the other one.

At the moment my vote will be on one of these - not sure which one yet. At the risk of sounding like Nick and Ben from The Traitors are we best keep in the one we are more certain on (Prada) and trying to find another one (Laura). Happy to go with the consensus of the village

If one wolf is trying to bus another wolf when they are under pressure which one do you think is likely to be more powerful?

Dexter is still leaning into his character shtick. Kevin thought both Dexter and Prada were wolves, Kevin is dead. Occam's razor that.

[William the Grave Robber]

Did anyone else notice the post Benjamin thought was a soft role claim? The only one I've noted is Prada asking another poster do they not think there's an apprentice seer.

[Boris the Fool]

Part of me can’t help but think is this back and forth between Laura and Prada a wolf on wolf debate? They know as numbers are getting lower we have a better chance of lynching a wolf. Therefore if we lynch one of those then the other will be able to say they are not a wolf because they went after the other one.

At the moment my vote will be on one of these - not sure which one yet. At the risk of sounding like Nick and Ben from The Traitors are we best keep in the one we are more certain on (Prada) and trying to find another one (Laura). Happy to go with the consensus of the village

If one wolf is trying to bus another wolf when they are under pressure which one do you think is likely to be more powerful?

Dexter is still leaning into his character shtick. Kevin thought both Dexter and Prada were wolves, Kevin is dead. Occam's razor that.

Do you mean out of the two of them - I have no idea! The most powerful wolf character is Ryan so I don't think either is him as it would be crazy to bus a wolf that has a kill power. 

Prada and Laura both being wolves does not mean Prada and Dexter can't both be wolves - there is minimum 3 wolves but likely 4 based on the unknown number comment in the OP.

[William the Grave Robber]

@Boris the Fool, would you care to get down off the fence and tell us your thoughts on the remaining players? You're not contributing any ideas at all.

[William the Grave Robber]

Dee is the alpha wolf. as seer is dead, that power does not really do anything anymore

You don't think there's a back up/apprentice role then?

This is post I referenced as a possibility for Ben thinking he spotted a soft role claim.