The Gang Solves The Werewolf Crisis

[Chris the Carpenter]

My thinking is that being second on a person is a nice safe place to hide for a wolf

I was the third

Second or third in your case. Wendy had said she was voting for Ina, it was safe to jump in there

[Chris the Carpenter]

First off to address the fireball thing: I actually am not 100% sure what I meant here. But I appreciate it isn't a good look. I think I am thinking that the shiled thing kills more than one person at once the same way that there was supposition that if (sorry Lorcan if this isnt allowed) that if Aladdin was killed then others would suffer. It was just from reading the initial narrative on page 1 of here.

Secondly: I have SO many questions
1) How did you know that is was only 3 votes that got Ina @Chris the Carpenter How does one even work something like that out?
2) Is post count coming up to lynch significant? I would have thought it just speaks to what people might be doing in real life. For example, it was far quiter during the day, as people prob in work
3) How are you sure that those that havent voted/ posted are villagers? Could they be anything, or is it generally accepted that they are villagers? It is a shame they haven't posted. The more the merrier!

I have more questions but telly awaits.

Guessed three votes based on the thread activity

[Chris the Carpenter]

Id say wolves were confident of not being voted out so we could have a wolf on wolf vote too

Id agree with this

[Betty the Beggar]

I was very clear who I was voting for.

I did have my doubts about@Edward the Barber which were obviously wrong.

We need to get our act together. The wolves are sitting back laughing because we are getting nowhere. I'm not impressed with the non players/ non voters.

[Betty the Beggar]

We need to reread @Ina May the Midwife posts. To see if there is a genuine reason why someone would have voted her out.

[Kevin the Armorer]

Did a quick look back at the declared (or intended) votes. I think that all those that declared voted in line with their declaration. This is what I can make out -

Declared/Intended votes:
Ina May - Wendy, Vernon
Benjamin - Betty, Dexter
Kevin - Chris, Amy
Betty - William
Magda - Moe
Chris - Boris
Laura - Pat
Wendy - Benjamin

Undeclared: Prada, Frank, Kevin, Ina May, Laura.

I declared my vote, so either you or lazy or you are lying.

[Amy the Singer]

Also, Kevin did declare earlier in the day. There was a whole back and forth between the two of us over it.

Yeah, he did declare for you. I had only gone back as far as when Moe asked if we were declaring and that conversation was earlier.

Declared/Intended votes:
Ina May - Wendy, Vernon
Benjamin - Betty, Dexter
Kevin - Chris, Amy
Betty - William
Magda - Moe
Chris - Boris
Laura - Pat
Wendy - Benjamin
Prada - Kevin

Undeclared: Prada, Frank, Ina May, Laura.

[Amy the Singer]

I declared my vote, so either you or lazy or you are lying.

I was trying to do it quickly and made a mess. You declared earlier and I missed it on my lookback. I've updated above.

[Betty the Beggar]

@Prada the Seamstress @Wendy the Wench @Vernon the Ranger can the three of you please tell us why you voted for @Ina May the Midwife

[Prada the Seamstress]

@Prada the Seamstress @Wendy the Wench @Vernon the Ranger  can the three of you please tell us why you voted for @Ina May the Midwife

Sure so I felt this post by Ina was odd. Referring to jabronis in the third person.

Jabronies will be in the dark at this point. We won't know much until at least tonights yeeting. Unless some one has slipped up and we missed it, not a whole lot to go on

Yes i think that post by Ina was a slip.

You think differently, that's fine.

Who you thinking as of now?

If ye are going to call out such small things as slips, no wonder players might be reluctant to post. 

I'm an experienced player, I would never slip. 

Happy to go up against anyone tonight though

Ina responded to Wendy directly and I replied to her then below

If ye are going to call out such small things as slips, no wonder players might be reluctant to post. 

I'm an experienced player, I would never slip. 

Happy to go up against anyone tonight though

That's a fair enough comment but could be said as any alignment tbf Ina. I think the lack of posting from a lot is highlighting stuff like that to me more than it normally would. As you know, it's hard day 1 especially with very little info bar Maeves death.

I find Benjamin suspicious but I also think they're a new player based off their posting so I'm not particularly comfortable voting them tonight if that makes sense.

So in the absence of that train of thought, I'm left with my own thoughts in relation to how you phrased that post, and also Moe's as I brought up earlier. And I'm also completely aware that it very well could be innocently posted. But I have to be honest, I've got nothing else right now.

They never responded to me so I voted for them. That's basically it. Shite reasoning but twas either Ina or Moe and I felt Moe at least responded directly to me calling them out before so I went with Ina.

[Betty the Beggar]

Thanks @Prada the Seamstress I can see where your reasoning was coming from even if it wasn't correct.

[Vernon the Ranger]

Ina May ignored Benjamin’s question even though she was on the thread and responding to others. It’s what I picked up on on my read through.

I highlighted it, got no response, so voted there.

[Wendy the Wench]

@Prada the Seamstress @Wendy the Wench @Vernon the Ranger  can the three of you please tell us why you voted for @Ina May the Midwife

It was between you and her. I thought her slip was slightly stronger reasoning than your initial posting that I am suss of so went with it.

[Wendy the Wench]

@Boris the Fool - why Chris?

@Moe the Innkeeper - why Magda?

@Betty the Beggar why Ben?

Apologies if I missed reasoning, but feel free to repeat or point to their specific posts why

[Betty the Beggar]

@Wendy the Wench Im not outlining all my reasons again for Ben, go reread all my posts its clearly highlighted.

He is acting too much like a 'newbie' for my linking.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

What is this chart, please?

[Betty the Beggar]

There's my suss list as of now

Ima...i think you slipped
Betty...initial posts
Chris...posts linked too much with Pat
Pat...posts linked to much with Chris

Discuss?

Ima? Do you mean @Ina May the Midwife ? I've just had a quick look back, what have I missed in their 3 posts to date?

See I agree here with Edward, not enough in Ina post to suspect them, yet you did Wendy and Edward now dead aswell and he said W stands for Wolve for you.

Maeve had a very good handle on the game, 14 posts, with a lot of wisdom and good reading there. A great loss to us. She even seemed to have actually read the OP!
It would indicate to me that the wolves are experienced players.

are you experienced? this post seems a bit disingenuous

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

What is this chart, please?

Never mind, I figured it out. First column is vote and next columns are voters.


@Betty the Beggar what do you mean "Edward now dead aswell and he said W stands for Wolve for you." Did he say that to Wendy?

[Moe the Innkeeper]

@Boris the Fool - why Chris?

@Moe the Innkeeper - why Magda?

@Betty the Beggar  why Ben?

Apologies if I missed reasoning, but feel free to repeat or point to their specific posts why

I gave my reasoning. Their three posts were absolutely fine/good but were more general game points rather than looking at posters. Felt may be a low lying wolf as clearly an experienced player. I have no good reads on anyone so felt low not no poster in the absence of a better option.

[Betty the Beggar]

Sometimes roled do. It's very rare though that at least one wolf isn't in low posters.

Who's on the chopping block for you Mr Scissorhands?

Right !now? It's W for Wolf.
You and William the Grave Robber.

However, I forgot I was even playing until lunch time today so I will try get a proper read back shortly.

Yep

Maeve had a very good handle on the game, 14 posts, with a lot of wisdom and good reading there. A great loss to us. She even seemed to have actually read the OP!
It would indicate to me that the wolves are experienced players.

are you experienced? this post seems a bit disingenuous

@Boris the Fool - why Chris?

@Moe the Innkeeper - why Magda?

@Betty the Beggar  why Ben?

Apologies if I missed reasoning, but feel free to repeat or point to their specific posts why

[Wendy the Wench]

Ima? Do you mean @Ina May the Midwife ? I've just had a quick look back, what have I missed in their 3 posts to date?

See I agree here with Edward, not enough in Ina post to suspect them, yet you did Wendy and Edward now dead aswell and he said W stands for Wolve for you.

Well let's be honest here. There's not much to go on for anyone. That's the problem. We don't have enough info. I put my vote where I had the most reason to.

You disagree. No problem.

I can't be a wolf and have shot Edward btw.

You went for Ben because you don't believe he is a newbie. I could say there's enough in his posting to suggest otherwise.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

But they were away, they said. I mean sure they didnt even vote. (Magda that is).

I do think it looks weird who Laura Lacemaker voted.

And are we any closer to finding out who keeps shooting and poisoning people? Could that be the same person? Is the ham smell significant, and if so, how?

Gosh, i feel like Joanna on this thread a bit.

The fact that Betty and Dexter both voted for me, even though it was agreed to give an amnesty is interesting to me. They considered that the other players would stick by that for tonight, and so I was a "safe" vote, in the same way Laura's vote for Robin was.

Amy and Dexter both oddly not voted for at all. And Wendy on noone's radar bar mine.

Wendy (sorry WEndy) is still on my radar. She would have known Ina was a villager so easy to get rid of her while backing up the whole idea of her (Ina) being a wolf.

I also am going to go back and see who called Chris' behaviour wolfie after the vote.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

I also am going to go back and see who called Chris' behaviour wolfie after the vote.

Wendy did. And for some reason, this comes across as wolf on wolf to me.

Sure, you didnt shoot Edward, that is the vigilante's role, is it not? "Frank"- are they a RV then? One who makes mistakes, clearly.

[Kevin the Armorer]

But they were away, they said. I mean sure they didnt even vote. (Magda that is).

I do think it looks weird who Laura Lacemaker voted.

And are we any closer to finding out who keeps shooting and poisoning people? Could that be the same person? Is the ham smell significant, and if so, how?

Gosh, i feel like Joanna on this thread a bit.

The fact that Betty and Dexter both voted for me, even though it was agreed to give an amnesty is interesting to me. They considered that the other players would stick by that for tonight, and so I was a "safe" vote, in the same way Laura's vote for Robin was.

Amy and Dexter both oddly not voted for at all. And Wendy on noone's radar bar mine.

Wendy (sorry WEndy) is still on my radar. She would have known Ina was a villager so easy to get rid of her while backing up the whole idea of her (Ina) being a wolf.

I also am going to go back and see who called Chris' behaviour wolfie after the vote.

Frank, the village vig, took the shot that killed ed. (friendly fire, but more than likely it was a use it or lose it bullet, I'd have risked a shot too)
The wolves, specifically ryan, if i recall correctly, who poisioned a rolled villager.

[Vernon the Ranger]

Good morning 😊

[Moe the Innkeeper]

Brah??? Prada and Moe, are you guys related?

I said that to Kevin. I dunno aren't we all related in a way?

The McPoyles are inbred, is this a hint that you're a McPoyle Prada?

[Prada the Seamstress]

I said that to Kevin. I dunno aren't we all related in a way?

The McPoyles are inbred, is this a hint that you're a McPoyle Prada?

No more a wider comment on Irish society. Google tells me I'm right too.

[Amy the Singer]

Morning all

[Moe the Innkeeper]

The McPoyles are inbred, is this a hint that you're a McPoyle Prada?

No more a wider comment on Irish society. Google tells me I'm right too.

Yet you keep talking about Pat marrying his cousin, is this to deflect from your inbred comment?

[Prada the Seamstress]

No more a wider comment on Irish society. Google tells me I'm right too.

Yet you keep talking about Pat marrying his cousin, is this to deflect from your inbred comment?

No it's because Pat hasn't denied marrying his cousin. If you've read the thread you'll notice I mentioned this before I made that post. Some deflection to mention it first then make that comment and keep drawing attention to it!

[Moe the Innkeeper]

The McPoyles are inbred, is this a hint that you're a McPoyle Prada?

No more a wider comment on Irish society. Google tells me I'm right too.

Actually incorrect. Inbreeding was never a major feature of Irish society, if you exclude travellers. We had a less mixed pool of people to choose from due to geographical and economic isolation which is a distinct phenomenon from inbreeding.

[Moe the Innkeeper]

Yet you keep talking about Pat marrying his cousin, is this to deflect from your inbred comment?

No it's because Pat hasn't denied marrying his cousin. If you've read the thread you'll notice I mentioned this before I made that post. Some deflection to mention it first then make that comment and keep drawing attention to it!

So you made up a rumour about Pat and keep bringing it up as evidence they are a wolf. Learned a lot from Donald didn't you?

[Prada the Seamstress]

No more a wider comment on Irish society. Google tells me I'm right too.

Actually incorrect. Inbreeding was never a major feature of Irish society, if you exclude travellers. We had a less mixed pool of people to choose from due to geographical and economic isolation which is a distinct phenomenon from inbreeding.

Hang on, where are you drawing the inbreeding reference from, your own head?

Irish people share a common ancestry, I never mentioned inbreeding.

This is a weird line of thinking anyways.

[Prada the Seamstress]

No it's because Pat hasn't denied marrying his cousin. If you've read the thread you'll notice I mentioned this before I made that post. Some deflection to mention it first then make that comment and keep drawing attention to it!

So you made up a rumour about Pat and keep bringing it up as evidence they are a wolf. Learned a lot from Donald didn't you?

Pat has not denied he married his cousin. I see no reason to let it go. What harm is it doing anyways, you'd swear the thread was super busy.

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Good morning all and sundry!

I was riding this morning 😉 and pondering yesterday's events. I must say, I'm very concerned about the loss of two lovely ladies, when the women here are already so underrepresented!

Men, we must do everything we can to protect the women today. I know one she-wolf hides among them (but she doesn't hide from me!), however I think it's best to concentrate on finding the males. Or it's going to become a veritable penis fest in here!

[Boris the Fool]

I am giving Frank and Benji a pass as new players (have my doubts on Benji but won’t lynch tonight just in case).

Also gonna ignore the no posters and Vernon as he has only entered the game.

My vote is gonna go for Chris for not bothering to read the thread even though we were only on page 3 when he entered. He’s not a new player but doesn’t seem to know what the amnesty is but knew day 0 not much happens.

@Boris the Fool - why Chris?

@Moe the Innkeeper - why Magda?

@Betty the Beggar  why Ben?

Apologies if I missed reasoning, but feel free to repeat or point to their specific posts why

Morning all!

@Wendy the Wench - already gave my reasoning on thread.

[Moe the Innkeeper]

Good morning all and sundry!

I was riding this morning 😉 and pondering yesterday's events. I must say, I'm very concerned about the loss of two lovely ladies, when the women here are already so underrepresented!

Men, we must do everything we can to protect the women today. I know one she-wolf hides among them (but she doesn't hide from me!), however I think it's best to concentrate on finding the males. Or it's going to become a veritable penis fest in here!

Have you anything else to contribute apart from your attempting to single-handedly resurrect the me too movement.

[Magda the Maid]

I'll be looking into Vernon and Moe on my first read back, briefly skimmed the thread yesterday and that's my initial two names.

On a side note, anyone any suggestions on getting around a work firewall for this site? Painful on the phone

[Frank the Tank]

So you made up a rumour about Pat and keep bringing it up as evidence they are a wolf. Learned a lot from Donald didn't you?

Pat has not denied he married his cousin. I see no reason to let it go. What harm is it doing anyways, you'd swear the thread was super busy.

Maybe Pats cousin is very attractive Prada, can't blame a fella for that can you?

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Not much else to say until more join us. It's very quiet in here this morning. Must have been a late night at the inn.

Personally I had an early night. Looks like these don't happen by accident. Sleep is imperitive to maintain this youthful, gorgeous face of mine.

You wouldn't know much about that @Moe the Innkeeper. Very hairy aren't you? Very snappy too. Interesting.