Disney Classics Werewolf

[Boris the Fool]

My problem with Oprah is if they aren't lynched tonight and offer the same type of thing tomorrow ill be voting there anyway

[Necro]

A laser beam has been fired! PEW PEW!



@Friar Tuck is dead

[Necro]

@Friar Tuck was...



Elsa - Village Frostbinder

[Gordon the Cook]

Honestly feeling a bit pissed off at myself. I'd usually take notes as I play but for some reason the early interactions made me play differently, so I'm just going to do a full reads list based on my current feeling. My memory is pants so without notes it can be hard to keep on top of my thoughts.

Player List:
Amy the Singer - no read
Boris the Fool - pain in the hole villager
Countess Markievicz - no read
Dexter the Dragoon - village lean, good posts and questioning
Dora the Explorer - reads seem decent. Could be pocketing me tho.
Friar Tuck - bad feeling from this morning hasn't gone away.
Jacob the Tailor - no read
Lilly the Millennial - no read
McDonald the Farmer - early on I thought he was a bit off. Not sure now
Moe the Innkeeper - low posts with not much use?
Oprah the Gossip - seems very defensive and hasn't seemed to contribute a lot
Raymond the Shoemaker - early feelings still hold true, bad feeling
Vincent the Artist -no read
Zeena Warrior Princess -no read.

Yes. I know it's a shit list with very little context but that's what I have to play with right now. I spent too much time fuming and then trying to gather consensus to absorbe what the rest were saying.

I haven't voted yet, but it will be likely going on Raymond, Moe, tuck, or Oprah. Will try to get better reads on them while I do the kids bedtime and post before I put my vote in.

[Gordon the Cook]

Oh shit.

Well that was bad timing for my list!

[Lilly the Millennial]

I said i dont like the defensiveness. It's not an indicator of being bad though.
I gave my reason, my read off your initial posts seemed off. Can't give anything more specific and am not going to make something up.

Your opinion is they aren't stellar. I've only posted sparingly but am happy with the purpose they've served.

And what purpose is that?

[Raymond the Shoemaker]

My posts are not filler/fluffy. I was posting about people who's posts felt off to me. Not much else to go on early in the game. My other main posts were disagreeing with Gordon's idea of declaring two potential votes on thread and I stand by that. I also didn't like your reply telling me to read the OP, when there was no reason to think I hadn't.

Ok so then you would know what I was refering to in the OP with that, I was hoping you would reply, but you didn't and are only bringing it up now when I put you on my FFA. What do you think I was referring to when I directed you to the OP?

I knew what you were referring to. I have read the OP and when I criticised Gordon earlier regarding the pickle shite he said the whole discussion came about because of the Cruella thing. There was no reason at all for anyone to think I hadn't read the OP and didn't know about the vote tieing condition. 
I didn't reply to you because I was at work and my posting was concentrated on arguing against Gordon's two votes strategy.

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Countess M is going up my list tbh, they are not helping the village whatsoever, they "don't do" FFA's, their vote is just going on someone because that person was suspicious of them. Offering no insight really at all..

I'm on Oprah don't think I'll be moving unless absolutely required, but that's the other person I would prefer to vote for if needs be.

[Dora the Explorer]

Are we declaring who we actually voted for or just 2 possible names?

I thought it was the latter and then just confirmation of vote time?

Declare who you are voting for, the two possible names is useless to the village to keep a tally

[Dexter the Dragoon]

Ok so then you would know what I was refering to in the OP with that, I was hoping you would reply, but you didn't and are only bringing it up now when I put you on my FFA. What do you think I was referring to when I directed you to the OP?

I knew what you were referring to. I have read the OP and when I criticised Gordon earlier regarding the pickle shite he said the whole discussion came about because of the Cruella thing. There was no reason at all for anyone to think I hadn't read the OP and didn't know about the vote tieing condition. 
I didn't reply to you because I was at work and my posting was concentrated on arguing against Gordon's two votes strategy.

What I was referring to is nothing to do with the tie voting..

[Boris the Fool]

I said i dont like the defensiveness. It's not an indicator of being bad though.
I gave my reason, my read off your initial posts seemed off. Can't give anything more specific and am not going to make something up.

Your opinion is they aren't stellar. I've only posted sparingly but am happy with the purpose they've served.

And what purpose is that?

Not gonna get an answer now obviously

[Gordon the Cook]

Consensus seems to be to fully declare voting, so I will follow suit when the time comes

[Dora the Explorer]

My problem with Oprah is if they aren't lynched tonight and offer the same type of thing tomorrow ill be voting there anyway

Not seeing the push on Oprah tbh, confusing and not much help maybe. That however doesnt mean they are a wolf. I never like defending other players but Oprah feels a lazy vote tbh

[Gordon the Cook]

Who shot the Lazer?

Anyone want to own up. Surprising weapon for the theme no?

[Lilly the Millennial]

A laser beam has been fired! PEW PEW!



@Friar Tuck is dead

Well I'm going to have to stew on that now I guess. Is that one of Jafar's powers?

In relation to my vote tonight, I was between Friar and Oprah. I'm going to have another read now to see. I was obviously very wrong on Friar.

[Raymond the Shoemaker]

Much as I don't like Gordon's declare two votes plan, which completely contradicts his earlier  devils advocating of an ongoing tally of votes, I don't see a wolf being that noisy and drawing that much heat early on.

Can you share where I contradicted myself? Fairly sure my stance has been pretty consistent.

Yes, as I said earlier in the day you were putting it out there that maybe we should do the on thread vote tallying to avoid a tie situation were the Cruella condition could activate. I know you were not 100% advocating it, but wondering whether worth it as a strategy. But then later you went to the idea that we all declare two possible votes and a time, which means no one has any idea whether a tie could happen or not as we have no definitive voting information.

That to me is completely contradictory because you went from wondering whether to adopt a strategy to avoid a tie situation at the possible cost of giving wolves voting info to a situation were there is no concrete voting info for anyone, hence greater chance of the Cruella condition being fulfilled.

[Dora the Explorer]

@Friar Tuck was...



Elsa - Village Frostbinder

What the hell is a Frostbinder. Really didnt think Friar was good
Is this a wolf or village shot?

[Raymond the Shoemaker]

Can you share where I contradicted myself? Fairly sure my stance has been pretty consistent.

I feel like Raymond is somewhat parroting something I said earlier to Dexter. Basically I didnt like your plan as it was potentially advantagous towards the Wolves. Then I said Amy pinged by jumping on agreeing with you immediately which in itself felt more wolfy to me. 

Interested to see Raymonds reply to you here.

Right away I argued to Amy and Gordon regarding that plan. How is that parroting anyone? I declared at the time I thought that strategy only helped the wolves, and I was suspicious of anyone advocating for it.

[Lilly the Millennial]

Who shot the Lazer?

Anyone want to own up. Surprising weapon for the theme no?

Theme is Disney, Lucas Studios is owned by Disney now so maybe not so surprising. I definitely wouldn't expect it to be a Jafar power though theme wise.

From the OP:
Jafar is one of the greatest and most villainous sorcerers in the land. His powers will be deadly, ruthless, and are numerous. Aladdin should steer clear of his fireball…

[Boris the Fool]

Flavour of the kill post suggests buzz lightyear to that shot

[Raymond the Shoemaker]

Could Laser be Buzz Armstrong. That's what it reminded me of.

[Raymond the Shoemaker]

Could Laser be Buzz Armstrong. That's what it reminded me of.

Buzz Armstrong, what us wrong with me.

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Im going to have to go for Oprah aswell.

Just didnt think her first post to me was very helpful to a newbie.

I know I'll probably have to be able to take it more as the game goes on but that's my reasoning for now.

[Lilly the Millennial]

Flavour of the kill post suggests buzz lightyear to that shot

Lol. It looked like a stormtrooper to me I need my eyes checked.

[Raymond the Shoemaker]

I knew what you were referring to. I have read the OP and when I criticised Gordon earlier regarding the pickle shite he said the whole discussion came about because of the Cruella thing. There was no reason at all for anyone to think I hadn't read the OP and didn't know about the vote tieing condition. 
I didn't reply to you because I was at work and my posting was concentrated on arguing against Gordon's two votes strategy.

What I was referring to is nothing to do with the tie voting..

If it's to do with Gaston, I don't see how declaring or not declaring helps with that. Otherwise I'm at a loss as to what you mean despite having read the OP.

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

So what does this mean for the game, do we not vote now if someone is already killed?

[Dora the Explorer]

Reading back over thread.

Thoughts so far. Most likely village, Dexter, Mc, Boris and Jacob.
Amy likely good now. Was forgettable to me, but her ISOs redeemed her in my eyes even if she doesn't like me. Seems to be genuinely wolf hunting.
Vincent and Zeena newbies so not in consideration for tonight but I don't think would be anyway.

Neutral on Friar and Dora.

Didn't like Oprah harassing a newbie, it's not fair to someone finding their feet. Not sure it's enough for me to vote there.

Lilly the whole chaos thing seemed a bit overblown. There was something else I noticed on read back I didn't like.

Gordon don't like. Seems overdramatic and a lot of hot air. I don't understand an experienced player talking about not declaring votes, this always helps with wagonomics, if declared votes don't match actual votes post lynch. I also thought they spent too long on this topic, just seemed like posting for no real benefit. Also the anti Boris tone seemed a bit strong on day one with nothing to go on.

Am struggling a bit getting going if I'm honest. A bit busier than I thought I'd be so mostly monitoring thread and jumping in when I can. Happy to answer any questions though. 
Currently doing a redback and updating my notes.

You said you had an ISO done earlier and now you're taking more notes?

I feel like Raymond is somewhat parroting something I said earlier to Dexter. Basically I didnt like your plan as it was potentially advantagous towards the Wolves. Then I said Amy pinged by jumping on agreeing with you immediately which in itself felt more wolfy to me. 

Interested to see Raymonds reply to you here.

Right away I argued to Amy and Gordon regarding that plan. How is that parroting anyone? I declared at the time I thought that strategy only helped the wolves, and I was suspicious of anyone advocating for it.

You said it wasnt a good plan, yes but you never accused her or Gordon of being wolfy. You have pivoted, at 1.30 today you said you thought Amy was no good because of her reads list and wolf hunting. Then you called her out for adding to her ISO? This to me feels like a bit of a change. You didnt accuse her of being a wolf up until that point.

Am I missing something because I feel like I am, you said you liked her ISO's then you seem to voting there because of ISOs

[Necro]

Reminder: Lynch at 9pm

[Boris the Fool]

So what does this mean for the game, do we not vote now if someone is already killed?

Nah we still vote as planned

[Dora the Explorer]

Reading back over thread.

Thoughts so far. Most likely village, Dexter, Mc, Boris and Jacob.
Amy likely good now. Was forgettable to me, but her ISOs redeemed her in my eyes even if she doesn't like me. Seems to be genuinely wolf hunting.
Vincent and Zeena newbies so not in consideration for tonight but I don't think would be anyway.

Neutral on Friar and Dora.

Didn't like Oprah harassing a newbie, it's not fair to someone finding their feet. Not sure it's enough for me to vote there.

Lilly the whole chaos thing seemed a bit overblown. There was something else I noticed on read back I didn't like.

Gordon don't like. Seems overdramatic and a lot of hot air. I don't understand an experienced player talking about not declaring votes, this always helps with wagonomics, if declared votes don't match actual votes post lynch. I also thought they spent too long on this topic, just seemed like posting for no real benefit. Also the anti Boris tone seemed a bit strong on day one with nothing to go on.

You said you had an ISO done earlier and now you're taking more notes?

Right away I argued to Amy and Gordon regarding that plan. How is that parroting anyone? I declared at the time I thought that strategy only helped the wolves, and I was suspicious of anyone advocating for it.

You said it wasnt a good plan, yes but you never accused her or Gordon of being wolfy. You have pivoted, at 1.30 today you said you thought Amy was no good because of her reads list and wolf hunting. Then you called her out for adding to her ISO? This to me feels like a bit of a change. You didnt accuse her of being a wolf up until that point.

Am I missing something because I feel like I am, you said you liked her ISO's then you seem to voting there because of ISOs

Cant edit my post but at 1.30 you said she Amy was good

[Dora the Explorer]

@Raymond the Shoemaker After saying all the above, I am currently voting for Amy, I dont have a problem with your direction of vote, more so how you got there

[Jacob the Tailor]

Looks like we have a train on Oprah with remnants on Amy, do we do a post like confirm to make sure we have the numbers right?

[Jacob the Tailor]

Like this post if you vote Oprah

[Jacob the Tailor]

Like this post if you vote Amy

[Jacob the Tailor]

Alternatively someone can do up the vote count by going back on posts

[McDonald the Farmer]

A laser beam has been fired! PEW PEW!



@Friar Tuck is dead

Well I'm going to have to stew on that now I guess. Is that one of Jafar's powers?

In relation to my vote tonight, I was between Friar and Oprah. I'm going to have another read now to see. I was obviously very wrong on Friar.

Disney own the rights to star wars, so could be village vig.

[Moe the Innkeeper]

Vote gone in 18.44.

Quoting myself here, my vote was for Oprah.

The time is wrong on posts for some reason so we all need to specify the time we vote at.

[Boris the Fool]

I didn't like Amy's replies to me earlier about happy to answer questions rather than ask it. They seem to be trying to hide and avoid confrontation

I dunno if I have enough to vote there tonight when they have said they are away amd cant defend themselves, but definitely will be on my list for tomorrow

[Dora the Explorer]

I am on Amy well, will be in the next couple of mins

Also, need to sign up to a spelling and grammar course after this game, can hardly read my own bloody posts

[Raymond the Shoemaker]

@Raymond the Shoemaker  After saying all the above, I am currently voting for Amy, I dont have a problem with your direction of vote, more so how you got there

I was speed reading lunch time on mobile (while eating). With all the multi quotes I got confused and thought Amy did the ISOs on Lilly and I, followed by saying we are most suspicious based on her ISOs. Then Dexter pointed out that Amy hadn't done the ISOs, so what I thought was someone doing due diligence and coming to a conclusion, seemed less so, and more like copying someone else's homework.
Then I really didn't like the jumping on the two votes plan as it is not helpful to village. Then Boris I think questioned Amy regarding her ISO as she just said she did one but hadn't posted it. She said she would be home in an hour to post it, which would be approx half four. But when I questioned over an hour after that she was taking notes.
So what initially seemed to me someone trying to figure things out seemed more like someone just coming up with a FFA for the sake of it.