Round Table Discussion Thread

[Edward the Barber]

Jasus necro how long it take to fill a coin ?

[Lilly the Millennial]

The wait is killing me!

[Necro]

Lilly the Millennial has been banished at random. She was.... Faithful






   


Thread now closed. See you all for the morning announcements... but not all of you may make it.

The WITCHING HOUR is upon us

[Necro]

Round Table Discussion is now OPEN

[Friar Tuck]

No 5 please, Necro.

[Friar Tuck]

@William the Grave Robber, you stated in the last thread that there's 2 traitors. How do you know this?

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Number 3 please

[Edward the Barber]

@William the Grave Robber, you stated in the last thread that there's 2 traitors. How do you know this?

I thought he said there were three

[Gordon the Cook]

4 please

[Friar Tuck]

@William the Grave Robber, you stated in the last thread that there's 2 traitors. How do you know this?

I thought he said there were three

I checked back, he said 2 traitors and 3 possible culprits. I can't quote it from the other thread.

[William the Grave Robber]

@William the Grave Robber, you stated in the last thread that there's 2 traitors. How do you know this?

I don't know for sure, but given the number of players, 2 is most likely and very unlikely that there's been a conversion to 3.

[Gordon the Cook]

#273
Today, 06:00 PM
(Today, 05:53 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote:
If we believe Countess and she's Faithful, it's a waste of a banishment to target her, as we're still left with 2 Traitors and 3 possible culprits in which there might only be 1. Though we would know she hadn't lied.

If we don't believe Countess, and she's a Traitor, we banish her, and she's lied to protect her fellow Traitor, then we have 3 in the clear.

But there's also a possibility that she is a Traitor and is telling the truth!
How do you know there's 2 traitors?

@William the Grave Robber, you stated in the last thread that there's 2 traitors. How do you know this?

@William the Grave Robber, you stated in the last thread that there's 2 traitors. How do you know this?

I thought he said there were three

bringing the relevant quote into this thread.

[Edward the Barber]

If there was only 2 the I do t believe that the countess would take that risk
I think that with three they might but it's not indicative

2 would be indicative so if the countess flips wolf then at this stage of the game there are three wolves

[Friar Tuck]

@William the Grave Robber you seemed fairly sure in that post, Gordon posted it above.

[Gordon the Cook]

I don't see the downside to banishing countess.

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Ok all, I won another prize

[Friar Tuck]

If there was only 2 the I do t believe that the countess would take that risk
I think that with three they might but it's not indicative

2 would be indicative so if the countess flips wolf then at this stage of the game there are three wolves

That's what I said when I was asked what I made of course tesses claim. No way would a wolf do that if there was only 2. So does William know there's 2, or does countess know there's 3?

[Gordon the Cook]

Ok all, I won another prize

@Edward the Barber
If the prizes are attached to the number, they don't need to wait until weyland picks in order to receive a prize. (this is in relation to yesterday)

[William the Grave Robber]

@William the Grave Robber you seemed fairly sure in that post, Gordon posted it above.

If you say so, I've been clear on why I'm assuming 2 only previously, so wrongly assumed that I didn't need to spell it out in every single post. I said earlier that I didn't buy Edward saying there was a conversion.

[Friar Tuck]

I won a prize too.

[Gordon the Cook]

If there was only 2 the I do t believe that the countess would take that risk
I think that with three they might but it's not indicative

2 would be indicative so if the countess flips wolf then at this stage of the game there are three wolves

That's what I said when I was asked what I made of course tesses claim. No way would a wolf do that if there was only 2. So does William know there's 2, or does countess know there's 3?

william could be playing of the assumption that it's two, they said that around 6 yesterday.

[Edward the Barber]

Ok all, I won another prize

@Edward the Barber
If the prizes are attached to the number, they don't need to wait until weyland picks in order to receive a prize. (this is in relation to yesterday)

We can agree to differ but necro specifically states he's waiting on an answer 

He did give out the results to the competition at 17-59 and it finishes at 18-00 so I believe you could be right 
However I'm suspect

[Gordon the Cook]

That's what I said when I was asked what I made of course tesses claim. No way would a wolf do that if there was only 2. So does William know there's 2, or does countess know there's 3?

william could be playing of the assumption that it's two, they said that around 6 yesterday.

#114 this was it here.

[Amy the Singer]

Is one of the prizes another shield @Zeena Warrior Princess @Friar Tuck

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

@Edward the Barber  You mentioned earlier, I cant find the post now, that certain players should vote for one of the 3 who voted for lily last night, I think I was on the list of player you asked to vote, can you confirm please who needs to vote for who to test your theory?

[Friar Tuck]

william could be playing of the assumption that it's two, they said that around 6 yesterday.

#114 this was it here.

That was is speculating, the one from today seemed more definitive. William did post that he was assuming rather than stating a fact but it just stood out to me.

[Amy the Singer]

Movie Emojis:

The Godfather
Forrest Gump
Toy Story
The Dark Knight
Fight Club
The Blair Witch Project
Blade Runner
Wolf of Wall Street
Jungle Cruise
Frozen

@Necro  seriously you brute, curious did anyone get them all correct?

[Friar Tuck]

Is one of the prizes another shield @Zeena Warrior Princess  @Friar Tuck

I'll answer in the morning if I'm still in the game, I just said I'd won one to stop a false claim.

[Edward the Barber]

I don't see the downside to banishing countess.

The villager that revealed her prise to help the village ?

If she flips village are we then going to flip the three she has accused ?


Naw thisooks like communication to the other wolves

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Is one of the prizes another shield @Zeena Warrior Princess  @Friar Tuck

I think it is to the benefit of the village to know, yes I have won another shield which I can use on anyone

[Countess Markievicz]

I’ll take 1 please.

@Gordon the Cook you asked:
“ What is PIS?
Why do you believe so, Either you could or you couldn't, why do you not know the answer to this? ”
PIS is perfect information syndrome. Since I won a prize with a specific characteristic, I asked about the other prize to see if it matched mine. Had I not won a prize, like other players, I wouldn’t have had any reason to suspect the prize could be alignment indicative.

I cannot quote PM but it simple states I can use it on any banished player, but does not specify that I can use it on any Day.

[Gordon the Cook]

Movie Emojis:

The Godfather
Forrest Gump
Toy Story
The Dark Knight
Fight Club
The Blair Witch Project
Blade Runner
Wolf of Wall Street
Jungle Cruise
Frozen

@Necro  seriously you brute, curious did anyone get them all correct?

6/10
1 heat
2 forest gump
3 school of rock
4 the batman
5 fight club
6 blair witch project
7 I Am a Knife with Legs
8 the wolf of wall street
9 Jungle Cruise
10 frozen

[Edward the Barber]

Movie Emojis:

The Godfather
Forrest Gump
Toy Story
The Dark Knight
Fight Club
The Blair Witch Project
Blade Runner
Wolf of Wall Street
Jungle Cruise
Frozen

@Necro  seriously you brute, curious did anyone get them all correct?

I thought the godfather was resiour dogs And I put the batman instead of the dark knight 

Forrest stump was my favourite

[Countess Markievicz]

Movie Emojis:

The Godfather
Forrest Gump
Toy Story
The Dark Knight
Fight Club
The Blair Witch Project
Blade Runner
Wolf of Wall Street
Jungle Cruise
Frozen

@Necro  seriously you brute, curious did anyone get them all correct?

I did! Once I realised the first five were a little more cryptic.

[William the Grave Robber]

I don't see the downside to banishing countess.

Assuming we're at 8 Faithful plus 2 Traitors:

A) Banish Countess - she flips Faithful, we kniw she was truthful, that's 7F:2T, (assumptions coming...) 6F:2T after murder, of the 8 remaining, we know there's at least 1 Traitor in Dora/Friar/Ed, let's say we take out both Faithful before we get the Traitor, that's 2 more banishments and 2 more murders, bring us to 2F:2T, Faithful can't win. That's assuming no conversions and no further info gained.

B) Banish Countess - she flips Traitor, we don't know if she lied or not, that's 8F:1T, assuming a conversion then and possibly no murder (have seen convert + murder before)... Then it's 7F:2T in the morning, no one is cleared and if anything it's new suspicion on everyone. Assumptions as above.

C) Banish elsewhere?

[Edward the Barber]

Friar announcing a prize is madness

The wolves will eat him for sure

Oh wait ?

[Friar Tuck]

Friar announcing a prize is madness

The wolves will eat him for sure

Oh wait ?

It possibly stops a wolf claiming one.

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Is one of the prizes another shield @Zeena Warrior Princess  @Friar Tuck

I'll answer in the morning if I'm still in the game, I just said I'd won one to stop a false claim.

If it is similar to countesses and can help the village it might be better to tell now so we can pick who votes where.

By hiding it you might look wolfy, waiting to talk to your mates over the witching hours to decide what to tell us in the morning.

[Gordon the Cook]

Is one of the prizes another shield @Zeena Warrior Princess  @Friar Tuck

I'll answer in the morning if I'm still in the game, I just said I'd won one to stop a false claim.

How does you saying you won one, stop a false claim. Make me understand it the way you see it.

[Friar Tuck]

I'll answer in the morning if I'm still in the game, I just said I'd won one to stop a false claim.

If it is similar to countesses and can help the village it might be better to tell now so we can pick who votes where.

By hiding it you might look wolfy, waiting to talk to your mates over the witching hours to decide what to tell us in the morning.

It's different to Countess, so I'm a bit dubious that you got the same prize again.