The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf

[Ina May the Midwife]

Nah, I'll just lynch you because you can't prove shit bub. And I'm not the one on trial here.

You do you, Ina

Look so far your defence is:

'The dead players who happened to be hobbits had me on their good reads lists' which seems to be implying that you all knew who ye were. And I simply do not believe that 4 hobbits would know each others identities in a 16 player game. It's not feasible and way OP. 

The second part of your defence seems to want me to do your work for you in proving that you didn't counterclaim but in fact claimed first. That doesn't bode well for you either way, cos you know who pointed that out, right?

Vincent, the dead wolf. That's who.

Sorry Benji, it's checkmate unless you come up with some sort of plausible explanation that doesn't involve 4 hobbits all knowing each other and relying on a dead wolf's word that you were softing a claim first!