The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

I’m home. Before I get bombarded with questions can you all show me why you’re saying that it was me that made the counterclaim.

Show me proof.

Why do you claim 2 dead hobbits knew you were a hobbit?

Ask yourself why two dead hobbits would both put me so low on their Process of Elimination lists. And when I say low I mean just not right at the bottom but the next one up. Pat (Sam) had Magda (Frodo) right at the bottom of his.

Make sense of that for yourself and then the answer is obvious.