(17-10-2025, 08:29 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:(17-10-2025, 08:25 AM)Edward the Barber Wrote: I have many questions from last nightI can't see Vincent voting Laura and staying there is Laura is a wolf. The vote was too close for that to happen, the wolves didn't know what way the vote would turn given you and I didn't vote until nearly 9pm. That is why I didn't say who I was voting for until after 9pm, they didn't get a chance to move.
Assume Benjamin is a wolf
He most know that killing the last hobbit wins the game, otherwise why the play last night. It would also make sense that another wolf would sacrifice if he has some protection. It is a pretty shitting power though as it basically outs 2 wolves at once, killing 1 of them. However, if this is all true, then game is over today at munch, unless Laura really is the hobbit and can protect themselves
Assume Benjamin is not a wolf
Then he must be the hobbit and countered Laura, which means Laura is the wolf. How did the deflection happen though, did he get to pick someone and got very luck picking Vincent or the rand was very lucky to us. I would have thought that is a case like this, the next highest voted player would get hit.
Another scenario is that both Benjamin and Laura are wolves, kill one clear the other. Then we still have a hobbit in play who should stay hidden
Yeah I agree with this, he could have voted Ben and it wouldn't have looked suspicious given we knew there are 2 wagons