The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf

[Ina May the Midwife]

My own thoughts on the remaining players (have excluded myself obviously lol)

High priority suspicions:

Edward - Prada's post stating he is the SK and for us not to ignore it, his subsequent claim. It's all quite inconvenient for Edward but it would be foolish to ignore the dead Investigators post.

Rhoda - Voting with Betty, neither self pressing. Red flags here in terms of potential W/W pairing. General posting is a bit scattered, could be a tactic, could be just how they play.


Mid tier priority

Magda - Becomes high priority if Rhoda is a villager (or the SK) based on vote timing. General posting has been ok but vote highly suspicious

Pat, Laura - Again these get upgraded if Rhoda is a villager (or SK). Likely one wolf at least in the three voting Rhoda in that scenario. Laura's readslist discussed at length yesterday. Pat drew a bit of heat over #onewolfgate on Sunday and Monday but posts in general have been fairly fine.


Lower tier, not priority (yet)

Vernon - Energy since the Betty lynch has completely dipped. Not as much enthusiasm or posting in general. Voted Pat.

William, Benjamin, Mick - Single voters last night. Benji arguably has the better thread presence of the three here.

Frank - Separating out Frank as there's a lot of villagery posts I like. Also a single voter but encouraged Maeve (along with Prada and Vincent) to not vote themselves. Not sure wolves would do this, though SK might. Fairly consistent with posting. Had a back and forth with Laura though the vote to Mick as opposed to their top target makes me wonder ever so slightly. Happy enough to place them here though.

Low priority

Vincent - voted Ed with Prada. Encouraged Maeve not to waste her vote. Villagery look anyways but given the outcome (Betty the wolf getting lynched) it gets extra marks.

Wendy - Vote switch killed a wolf last night. Wolves munching into Betty wagon indicates no wolves. Possible SK still, would upgrade if Edward does not flip as SK given the argument not to kill him, could be perceived as giving herself some extra cover given Prada's post


So if I was to rank all players from who I suspect most to who I suspect the least it would look like this

Edward
Rhoda
Magda
Laura
Pat
Vernon
Mick
William
Benjamin
Frank
Vincent
Wendy

So I want to go back to this which was obviously wrong LOL

Since yesterday Rhoda has flipped as Gandalf so was village.
Edward also seems to be Legolas
Magda has revealed her address in Hobbiton as well
And my top village read in Wendy was munched as SK.
Pat could have possibly been peeked as good? So could only be the alpha if such a thing exists in this game


Clustermuck doesn't describe this readslist.



Sticking with it though as the logic behind it imo was sound.


List would probably now look something like this from highest to lowest in suspicion terms


Laura
Vernon
Mick
William
Benjamin
Vincent
Frank
Pat
Edward/Magda

So you can take my FFA as 

Laura - day 1 vote and lack of activity since
Vernon - not seeing villageriness in their posting
Mick - Teflon Mick, tbh you could put William or Benji in here either.


Personally I think we can solve the game by going through the above 5 and Vinnie, though it would be handy to hit a wolf today if possible

I still think Vinnie has more positives than negatives going for him over the Maeve vote stuff but would need to see more from him today

Frank did not do any action last night according to Edward but that doesn't rule him out from anything, but I still like his posting so far and I think if Laura's a wolf then Frank isn't teamed with her (and the SK is now dead so that means he's village)

Pat, if peeked and this is not certain by any means, but IF he was peeked then he could only be an alpha wolf which we don't even know exists in this game so based on that widely assumed info he goes up the list.

Already mentioned Ed and Magda.