This is really difficult. I have now read through all 15 pages of the thread and finally made notes.
I'll try and be succinct.
And all in all, reading back over some of the posts now, knowing who players were, it puts a different slant on things.
- Pat was the Seer and yet he cast doubt on Ina initially. As he likely hadn't seen. Had he seen by the time he then voted Laura? If not. did he even get a chance to see, because he didnt say much else before his demise.
-Why do Kevin and William both talk about 5 wolves? And why does Dexter say twice about there only being one female wolf. Given that we are losing the lovely ladies left right and centre, that doesn't leave many in the pool.
- Prada seems to have a good read of the game, i.e. is experienced, but she also throws around a fair few red herrings. The Pat marrying his cousin was one oft repeated, one which she said she would stop, but sure what does it matter now that Pat is dead, and was shown to be a RV? So why continue the joke? She sows seeds for Moe and WEndy- now both known to be villagers- to be the married cousins. Prada also sows seeds about Boris and Donald (who we now know to be a FM), and accuses Moe, who we know was also a villager. She also calls MAgda "clued in" earlier on in the game, which is gas as MAgda had posted like, once, or sth at that stage.
- Why does Kevin point at Frank and me on several occasions despite admitting/ being told we are new? Granted he relented on me but picks up the Frank thread later on. Is this to divert suspcicion?
- Dexter also votes for me saying I am pretending to be new. Chris also seem to be protecting Dexter in some small way.
- I still think that occam's razor applies to the SK being a new poster. Therefore this points to Vernon and Magda. I do think it would be a stretch for Robin or Gordon to have pulled that off, and have to take Robin at his word when he says he wasnt allowed join til 10 am today.
- William points many fingers, but votes for Betty in the end, a villager.
-Laura darts in and out, sowing some seeds on Dexter for example. Why? Why in and out too? (No pun intended DExter)
- FEel like BOris is a villager.
That is all I got for now.
Need to go do some work in the lab before I get sacked.
I'll try and be succinct.
And all in all, reading back over some of the posts now, knowing who players were, it puts a different slant on things.
- Pat was the Seer and yet he cast doubt on Ina initially. As he likely hadn't seen. Had he seen by the time he then voted Laura? If not. did he even get a chance to see, because he didnt say much else before his demise.
-Why do Kevin and William both talk about 5 wolves? And why does Dexter say twice about there only being one female wolf. Given that we are losing the lovely ladies left right and centre, that doesn't leave many in the pool.
- Prada seems to have a good read of the game, i.e. is experienced, but she also throws around a fair few red herrings. The Pat marrying his cousin was one oft repeated, one which she said she would stop, but sure what does it matter now that Pat is dead, and was shown to be a RV? So why continue the joke? She sows seeds for Moe and WEndy- now both known to be villagers- to be the married cousins. Prada also sows seeds about Boris and Donald (who we now know to be a FM), and accuses Moe, who we know was also a villager. She also calls MAgda "clued in" earlier on in the game, which is gas as MAgda had posted like, once, or sth at that stage.
- Why does Kevin point at Frank and me on several occasions despite admitting/ being told we are new? Granted he relented on me but picks up the Frank thread later on. Is this to divert suspcicion?
- Dexter also votes for me saying I am pretending to be new. Chris also seem to be protecting Dexter in some small way.
- I still think that occam's razor applies to the SK being a new poster. Therefore this points to Vernon and Magda. I do think it would be a stretch for Robin or Gordon to have pulled that off, and have to take Robin at his word when he says he wasnt allowed join til 10 am today.
- William points many fingers, but votes for Betty in the end, a villager.
-Laura darts in and out, sowing some seeds on Dexter for example. Why? Why in and out too? (No pun intended DExter)
- FEel like BOris is a villager.
That is all I got for now.
Need to go do some work in the lab before I get sacked.
