The Gang Solves The Werewolf Crisis

[Prada the Seamstress]

I'm also not convinced that Benjamin is the newbie that others have claimed him to be. I note that he has not expressly claimed to be new.

These are two of his earliest posts. Decent attempt at identifying roles and also the first to do so in the thread. It doesn't ring true of a first time player, even one who may have read over previous games.

So does the narrative make The Waitress the SK then? I'll give her some truth serum and make her tell all.....

Ok so here is my take from the OP.
The Waitress hates everyone. She is seen to be "playing both sides" (SK?)
Dee has turned into a werewolf and Frank calls her Froggy implying she is green. However, she said she is related to Dennis, yet Charlie calls himself Green Man.
Dennis is the seer (and immune?)
Mac is strong?
The McPoyles are not nice... but is Mac (Mc? related to them in some way?)... the have a crest - which seems to be a fireball of type, and milk which is poison but Charlie implies it could also be turned to a force for good "fight milk".

That is all I got for now

This is followed by confusing Ryan McPoyle and the milk with the Waitress as the SK. And despite being challenged on that earlier repeated it again.

Protected from what? From my notes from yesterday I had that "Dennis" is both seer and immune,  if that is possible?
I think Wendy gave the milk, and she is SK and that's who's on my vote sheet for the moment 
Reinforced by her reply to me when I asked her was Maeve her boss, she said she is only out for herself... or something to that effect.... I'm paraphrasing. It was actually even more direct than that.

Something feels off to me.

I agree to a point but I think it's something that can (and most likely will) be explored tomorrow