There's a couple of things that seem odd to me so I'll put them out there for consideration or response.
Dexter: I found it peculiar that when the game was 5 v 4 and Scar was killed that Dexter was advocating shooting me. Shooting a villager at that point would have brought the numbers to 4 v 4 which if my understanding of the win criteria is correct would have given victory immediately to the wolves.
The rationale given was post progression which seems flimsy enough to encourage that risk.
Jacob: Having suggested that Dora peeked Amy despite it being against usual game mechanics I'm suprised that shortly after I asked for an explanation for that thinking and Jacob then dropped considering Amy.
Countess: Now that I know more about the game, I can't figure out why there was any ambiguity over Friar Tuck's village status.
Dexter: I found it peculiar that when the game was 5 v 4 and Scar was killed that Dexter was advocating shooting me. Shooting a villager at that point would have brought the numbers to 4 v 4 which if my understanding of the win criteria is correct would have given victory immediately to the wolves.
The rationale given was post progression which seems flimsy enough to encourage that risk.
(12-08-2025, 12:43 PM)Dexter the Dragoon Wrote: If we still have a gun I'd risk it and shoot Vincent.. their post progression is astounding for a newbie, so either they have picked everything up already. Or they are getting help structuring posts.
Jacob: Having suggested that Dora peeked Amy despite it being against usual game mechanics I'm suprised that shortly after I asked for an explanation for that thinking and Jacob then dropped considering Amy.
(12-08-2025, 02:11 PM)Jacob the Tailor Wrote: Alright fair it's consensus so Ill drop the Amy affront. I want Lily to pop into the thread and give us her thoughts
Countess: Now that I know more about the game, I can't figure out why there was any ambiguity over Friar Tuck's village status.
(11-08-2025, 09:20 PM)Countess Markievicz Wrote: do we think friar was good? doesn't really make much difference anyway.