(11-08-2025, 05:21 PM)Dora the Explorer Wrote:You literally called it a reads list in your first post about it...(11-08-2025, 04:38 PM)Dexter the Dragoon Wrote: You are the one titling that a reads list, I never said it was a reads list, I labeled it thoughts for a reason. So you have done 2 read backs, what are your "thoughts" on posters as of now..
I didnt tilt it as a reads list, you asked me had I done one which is why I referred to your list as a read list/thoughts post.
I have some posters who I would suspect as being potentially bad, I already mentioned you, would be on my FFA. Friar Tuck is where my vote would be right now. I would peek you.
Amy is niggling me a bit and I am currently reading through there (She'd be the third person on my FFA. Countess Markevich is next.
I like Boris, I kinda like Gordon but he through me off with his two names for votes plan. This was a plan that was beneficial for wolves but I dont know would a wolf put that out there. This is what triggered the niggle with Amy, she was straight on board supporting that plan. A wolf might not suggest it but supporting it is less suspicious than making the plan.
I kinda like Lilly too put havent done a full read back there.
The rest I need to read more of
(11-08-2025, 02:37 PM)Dora the Explorer Wrote:(11-08-2025, 08:46 AM)Dexter the Dragoon Wrote: My thoughts from Sunday
Amy - First post just before 12, thanked post by Boris just before 4, no posts since
Friar - shoot peak game.. Has been started as both wolf and village so not alignment indicative
Boris - decent volume, asking questions openly discussing points. Niggly feeling about him. heightened with reply this morning, being reserved and not TOO pushy
McDonald - mix of aggressive questioning and helpful posts. Using posts to gauge reaction..
Oprah confusion/chaos central, 100% parroting others - will probably be voting here unless they actually start to wolf hunt properly (not saying "Are you a wolf" constantly)
Lilly little all over the place at the mo, will see how Monday goes, I did like their breakdown straight away - also see above, not a great response to that. (edited)
Countess M - lots of oneliners, bit if shade, bit of rules lawyering
Dora - one post saying they were coming back from hols and mechanics with numbers etc
Jacob put there neck out with conversions talk, could be a distraction or just Sunday musings. Brokedown the roles nicely
Vincent and Zeena - Newbies, not really into the game yet
Gordon - Some nice posts, actively engaging, explaining (see pickle post) and not afraid to bite back
Current Post Count:
Total Posts: 149
User
# Posts
Boris the Fool
38
Dexter the Dragoon
36
Lilly the Millennial
12
McDonald the Farmer
10
Gordon the Cook
10
Countess Markievicz
9
Oprah the Gossip
8
Jacob the Tailor
5
Zeena Warrior Princess
5
Friar Tuck
4
Vincent the Artist
4
Amy the Singer
1
Dora the Explorer
1
Raymond the Shoemaker
1
Moe the Innkeeper
1
I'm on holidays (not away though boooo) this week and have loads of stuff on throughout the week with the kids starting in the afternoon today. I'll be trying to follow along and post as much as possible anyways.(11-08-2025, 08:58 AM)Dexter the Dragoon Wrote: I've already said that I will be reading you in isolation so I will read that when I'm doing it.I like most of Dexters postings on a first read through, second time round though the reads list seems a little off to me. It is a big list but not actually saying a lot. More of a summary of what he has seen as opposed to his thoughts. Most places where he has a negative towards someone, it is generally followed by a positive. Then when challenged there is a bit of a role back and "I actually like you" type of reply. Feels like Dexter is a little bit keen to avoid confrontation
FWIW I've liked the defending of your positioning.
Anyways, thanks for putting your thoughts onto the thread.