Post Game Feedback

[lorcand1990]

Just on convincing neo on endgame, one thing I tried to do, which would probably be considered more of a wolf tactic than village was that when I was replying to neos questions towards the end, I tried to be as direct and accurate as possible as that is neos style of positing. With you I probably had a different style of posting as I knew u were trying to set me up lol

I dunno if it had any influence but it can be one way of swinging someone's favour, by posting in a similar manner to them, and knowing what they are looking for.. or else I'm just talking complete crap, that's quite possible 

When you mentioned the Jan lynch post I think you were talking about your post where you said to shoot her before the lynch result.

To me, the Jan lynch post was Necro's announcement. That's where all that confusion came from!

It's easier to be direct when you're village too ...

No you're right, at first I was asking you about the Jan lynch post, I'll run you through my thought process, as it seems I've hit the holy grail and genuinely confused a wolf more than the village 

So when Jan lynch post was posted, I had an 'oh shit' moment because she could only survive a shot from the vig, a lynch would have killed her outright. I panicked because I remembered I was pushing for a shot on Jan, so could look bad for me. However I then remembered there were a few people calling for a shot & Neo was definitely one of them because they had asked me for my rationale at the time, so I went back and had a look at the posts around the time she was revealed. Loads of village were asking for a shot, but you were pretty quiet about actually shooting her. That's when it pinged I might be able to use this to my advantage and get you found out, especially since lady skunk was asking for a shot- that creates distance between the two of you

I needed to find out where your head was with it, but I didn't want to give you exactly what I was thinking because it would show my hand. The village had new info about Jan & I needed to tease out what you knew. When I asked 'is the game over' and you replied, I was fully expecting you to mention that Jan could only survive the shot and I'm clearly a wolf for asking for a shot. When you didn't I thought it was because you didn't want the village going back to those posts as it was actually a worse look for you than me- turns out it was the other reason & you hadn't noticed the Jan lynch post

When you didn't bring it up I knew I had you but I also had a little dilemma. I had to decide do I tell you exactly why it makes you look wolfy, or do I hold firm and keep relatively quiet until Neo/Duffman show up. I decided to wait because it could have gone this way:

Me: why didn't you call me out on the jan thing
You: what Jan thing?
Me: she was only bullet proof, said so in lynch post & i was pushing for a shot
You: oh yeah I know, I read that, obviously, I was just reading back around the time Jan was peaked. Lorcand you are such a wolf for that.. etc etc

Then you could have gone back and read the posts around the time of the shot & came up with a defense before village showed up.

By waiting until Neo asked & explaining it to him, even though I think he knew what I was up to already, it 100% showed you had no idea what I was referring to & hadn't noticed the jan lynch post or read back around the time she was peaked, which (in my opinion) was really wolfy

Looking back, even though I had a really bad first couple of days, that play was one of my better ones in WW so far!