The Gang Solves The Werewolf Crisis

[Betty the Beggar]

Now your just throwing out random statements@Benjamin the Alchemist are you protected and you want us to vote for you so it can fail?

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Protected from what? From my notes from yesterday I had that "Dennis" is both seer and immune, if that is possible?
I think Wendy gave the milk, and she is SK and that's who's on my vote sheet for the moment
Reinforced by her reply to me when I asked her was Maeve her boss, she said she is only out for herself... or something to that effect.... I'm paraphrasing. It was actually even more direct than that.

[Wendy the Wench]

Call it a gut feeling, something seemed off to me about it.
You are two i would like to hear more from

So nothing, fair enough. If youre going to be making blanket statements you should expect to be asked to back them up. It looks weak as dish water when you cant

Well I did say it's because I felt the posts were linked initially.

You obviously don't understand the meaning of blanket statement so I'll ignore that part.

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

@Wendy the Wench  does that mean your boss is dead? Are you now self-employed?

I serve no ones needs, only my own

This is the post I am referring to
Oh no, sorry, the others say the poisoner is a vigilante or a wolf.
Either way, she is on my vote for now.

[Prada the Seamstress]

Protected from what? From my notes from yesterday I had that "Dennis" is both seer and immune,  if that is possible?
I think Wendy gave the milk, and she is SK and that's who's on my vote sheet for the moment 
Reinforced by her reply to me when I asked her was Maeve her boss, she said she is only out for herself... or something to that effect.... I'm paraphrasing. It was actually even more direct than that.

I thought the wolves had the milk? So if Wendy is the milk giver she'd be a wolf not SK? No?

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Yes my mistake. That was explained to me earlier.
Why would Wendy say that she is only out for herself though? That just seems like such a suspicious statement.
So while she might not have given the milk, she is still a suspect for me.

[Pat the Baker]

It doesn't like we are going to wagon anyone today which is good for wagonomics at least

[Moe the Innkeeper]

There were many in the inn last night, as I said a busy night. The few I mentioned were particularly lively. Whether werewolves were amongst my customers I do not know, there are rumours they may have bathed to hide their lupine scent and remain hidden.

did you have to bathe?

Not to disguise my scent as wolves do. I do of course bathe for cleanliness, Just a bath really of no importance.

[Dexter the Dragoon]

I've decided to be honest about my vote. It's going to Benjamin.

Why you ask? Well gather around ladies and I'll tell you. Men, you're welcome to listen too.

The reasons are twofold.

I don't believe Benjamin is the newbie he'd like us to think. It seems to me, he's hoping people will avoid voting for him in case they spoil their vote on account of the amnesty but I think he knows more about this 'game' then he lets on.

More pertinently, he appeared to be greatly envious of my impressive equipment. Who else would be jealous of a handsome male, that can turn the heads of the ladies, than an alpha wolf!?

[Chris the Carpenter]

So nothing, fair enough. If youre going to be making blanket statements you should expect to be asked to back them up. It looks weak as dish water when you cant

Well I did say it's because I felt the posts were linked initially.

You obviously don't understand the meaning of blanket statement so I'll ignore that part.

You said our posts are linked, that's a blanket statement. Which you later clarified to mean we had our initial posts close to each other.
Its nonsense from you, which I've noted, ill leave it at that

[Prada the Seamstress]

did you have to bathe?

Not to disguise my scent as wolves do. I do of course bathe for cleanliness, Just a bath really of no importance.

You know baths mean you literally are swimming in your own filth right🤣

Showers for the win!

[Chris the Carpenter]

I've decided to be honest about my vote. It's going to Benjamin.

Why you ask? Well gather around ladies and I'll tell you. Men, you're welcome to listen too.

The reasons are twofold.

I don't believe Benjamin is the newbie he'd like us to think. It seems to me, he's hoping people will avoid voting for him in case they spoil their vote on account of the amnesty but I think he knows more about this 'game' then he lets on.

More pertinently, he appeared to be greatly envious of my impressive equipment. Who else would be jealous of a handsome male, that can turn the heads of the ladies, than an alpha wolf!?

Amnesty?

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

What's wagonomics?

[Prada the Seamstress]

I've decided to be honest about my vote. It's going to Benjamin.

Why you ask? Well gather around ladies and I'll tell you. Men, you're welcome to listen too.

The reasons are twofold.

I don't believe Benjamin is the newbie he'd like us to think. It seems to me, he's hoping people will avoid voting for him in case they spoil their vote on account of the amnesty but I think he knows more about this 'game' then he lets on.

More pertinently, he appeared to be greatly envious of my impressive equipment. Who else would be jealous of a handsome male, that can turn the heads of the ladies, than an alpha wolf!?

Amnesty?

Not sure if you're new or just not about of late but we've been operating under an amnesty for new players on day 1 from lynching recently. 

More about growing the community and allowing our new players to experience a decent run in the game than anything else tbh

[Edward the Barber]

Maeve had a very good handle on the game, 14 posts, with a lot of wisdom and good reading there. A great loss to us. She even seemed to have actually read the OP!
It would indicate to me that the wolves are experienced players.

are you experienced? this post seems a bit disingenuous

I have played before yes.
Don't know why it's disingenuous. Just calling out that the wolves have a good read on the game already.

[Prada the Seamstress]

What's wagonomics?

After the lynch we will get the voting results and some players try to work out the wolves based on the votes cast. Works better over a longer period and even better if we catch a wolf cos we can see where they voted

[Dexter the Dragoon]

"amnesty?" "wagonomics?" 'oh I'm just a poor newbie, with no Idea what's happening and I somehow missed all the earlier chat about amnesty'

*chuckles in handsome*.

You must be head of the local amateur dramatics society Benjamin!

[Moe the Innkeeper]

Reading back on the thread, not getting much.

Can't see why Maeve was targeted, she didn't stand out too much to me. The fulsome praise from Ed the barber after her death was a bit much for me.

Other things that stood out for me were Kevin posting several times about five wolves, which seems a bit overpowered to me. Is this deliberate distancing of a wolf by misrepresenting number of wolves. They are posting a lot and are opinionated which goes against that.

Chris the carpenter posting on the thread, saying they had only read page three struck me as a bit blase somehow. Obviously pot kettle given I missed all the roles in the OP.

Benamin and Frank are new so out of contention tonight, they are posting though which is good.

The more prolific posters are pushing buttons and prodding which is goodat getting info out. No one striking me as wolfy really.

Going to look at the low posters, but not no posters as they will be modkilled anyway.

[Wendy the Wench]

Yes my mistake. That was explained to me earlier.
Why would Wendy say that she is only out for herself though? That just seems like such a suspicious statement.
So while she might not have given the milk, she is still a suspect for me.

As in I'm a wench out on my own. My username here. 
But vote for me based on that if you want. At least youve given a reason to justify your vote

[Moe the Innkeeper]

Not to disguise my scent as wolves do. I do of course bathe for cleanliness, Just a bath really of no importance.

You know baths mean you literally are swimming in your own filth right🤣

Showers for the win!

A shower instead of a bath wouldn't fit my character.

[Prada the Seamstress]

Yes my mistake. That was explained to me earlier.
Why would Wendy say that she is only out for herself though? That just seems like such a suspicious statement.
So while she might not have given the milk, she is still a suspect for me.

As in I'm a wench out on my own. My username here. 
But vote for me based on that if you want. At least youve given a reason to justify your vote

Are you Pat's cousin/wife?

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

"amnesty?" "wagonomics?" 'oh I'm just a poor newbie, with no Idea what's happening and I somehow missed all the earlier chat about amnesty'

*chuckles in handsome*.

You must be head of the local amateur dramatics society Benjamin!

Rein yourself in Dexter! I didn't ask about any amnesty.
I thought wagonomics was where we circle the wagons and all try a voting pact, and I wanted to check. 
I do admit, I'm not great at retaining details. Don't do drugs, kids!

[Dexter the Dragoon]

"amnesty?" "wagonomics?" 'oh I'm just a poor newbie, with no Idea what's happening and I somehow missed all the earlier chat about amnesty'

*chuckles in handsome*.

You must be head of the local amateur dramatics society Benjamin!

Rein yourself in Dexter! I didn't ask about any amnesty.
I thought wagonomics was where we circle the wagons and all try a voting pact, and I wanted to check. 
I do admit, I'm not great at retaining details. Don't do drugs, kids!

Apologies the amnesty question was from Chris. The rest stands! The only one who'll be reined in around here is Digby.

[Pat the Baker]

Vote gone in for Laura

[Edward the Barber]

Is this correct so far?

Roles
Frank - vigilante
Dennis - seer (doesn’t work on Dee)
Mac - bodyguard
Charlie - joat/wildcard

Dee - an intruder - peeks good
Intruders - how many?

The waitress - SK

There is mention of milk and a shield in the OP so these may translate into powers? I’ve never seen the show so someone else may know if they are something that could be meaningful

I've a vote put in for Kevin. Sorry Kevin, just vibes at this point

This is, and to use your own words at Wendy, as weak as dishwater. Vibes is not a reason.

[Edward the Barber]

Sorry I don't know how I quoted the other Boris post there!

[Edward the Barber]

maeve and william also did this same exercise. are they also on your good list?

i have since read edward calling out the same thing and laura's fair enough reply. its something i'd do as well.

@Laura the Lace Mistress why are you praising yourself?

[Edward the Barber]

My FFA:
William
Laura
Chris

I will be voting here.

[Amy the Singer]

I'm also not convinced that Benjamin is the newbie that others have claimed him to be. I note that he has not expressly claimed to be new.

These are two of his earliest posts. Decent attempt at identifying roles and also the first to do so in the thread. It doesn't ring true of a first time player, even one who may have read over previous games.

So does the narrative make The Waitress the SK then? I'll give her some truth serum and make her tell all.....

Ok so here is my take from the OP.
The Waitress hates everyone. She is seen to be "playing both sides" (SK?)
Dee has turned into a werewolf and Frank calls her Froggy implying she is green. However, she said she is related to Dennis, yet Charlie calls himself Green Man.
Dennis is the seer (and immune?)
Mac is strong?
The McPoyles are not nice... but is Mac (Mc? related to them in some way?)... the have a crest - which seems to be a fireball of type, and milk which is poison but Charlie implies it could also be turned to a force for good "fight milk".

That is all I got for now

This is followed by confusing Ryan McPoyle and the milk with the Waitress as the SK. And despite being challenged on that earlier repeated it again.

Protected from what? From my notes from yesterday I had that "Dennis" is both seer and immune, if that is possible?
I think Wendy gave the milk, and she is SK and that's who's on my vote sheet for the moment
Reinforced by her reply to me when I asked her was Maeve her boss, she said she is only out for herself... or something to that effect.... I'm paraphrasing. It was actually even more direct than that.

Something feels off to me.

[Vernon the Ranger]

Hi all 👋

Howdy Vernon,

Is this you first time playing as a wolf?

I’ve entered the thread without waxing my back again, haven’t I?

Hey Kev 😉

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

You never answered my question Amy? About giving us a rendition..
Wendy also said she doesn't like sharing a mic. Or was that you. I'll go back and check later. Why not share?
And yes, I told Betty and others back on page 5 or 6 who I am .

[Amy the Singer]

Any songs for us Amy?

I'll open with a cover of Suspicious Minds

🎵We're caught in a trap, I can't walk out 🎵

[William the Grave Robber]

Had a full read back and this is what stood out to me so far.

Benjamin - newbie, but seems to be overplaying the 'I haven't a clue' act. Had a weird interpretation of the OP, said Frank called Dee Froggy, Mac might be related to the McPoyles, the crest is a fireball, called out Prada and Moe for using 'brah', said Prada, Kevin and Pat are all related, speculated Dee is a McPoyle, Dennis is her brother, Dennis is Pat the Baker and Dee and Dennis are wolves. Asked did the Waitress SK serve the poisoned milk, is Ryan the SK and repeated asking if the waitress SK served the milk. Could be a wolf playing the confused newbie. Gets a pass for today anyway.

Betty agreed that the waitress could have served the milk. Don't think they're a newbie so should know that the SK and wolves aren't linked.

I can see why Wendy mentioned Chrisopher and Pat being linked because they posted too soon together, Christopher 4 mins after Pat, Christopher thanked Pat and added him to his good list for his summary. When called out for clearing Pat when others had done the same Christopher said he only read page 3. I don't think 2 wolves would do this but maybe a pocketing attempt?

I can also see why Moe and Ina's posts look like perspective slips and they seem to separate themselves from the village, something to keep in mind.

Kevin and Prada's little spat could be two wolves attempting to distance themselves, it was obvious the yeeting Trump thing was a joke by Prada based on the real Trump, there was no attempt to start a bandwagon whatsoever.

I'm thinking of voting for Sweaty Betty at the mo.

[Prada the Seamstress]

I'm also not convinced that Benjamin is the newbie that others have claimed him to be. I note that he has not expressly claimed to be new.

These are two of his earliest posts. Decent attempt at identifying roles and also the first to do so in the thread. It doesn't ring true of a first time player, even one who may have read over previous games.

So does the narrative make The Waitress the SK then? I'll give her some truth serum and make her tell all.....

Ok so here is my take from the OP.
The Waitress hates everyone. She is seen to be "playing both sides" (SK?)
Dee has turned into a werewolf and Frank calls her Froggy implying she is green. However, she said she is related to Dennis, yet Charlie calls himself Green Man.
Dennis is the seer (and immune?)
Mac is strong?
The McPoyles are not nice... but is Mac (Mc? related to them in some way?)... the have a crest - which seems to be a fireball of type, and milk which is poison but Charlie implies it could also be turned to a force for good "fight milk".

That is all I got for now

This is followed by confusing Ryan McPoyle and the milk with the Waitress as the SK. And despite being challenged on that earlier repeated it again.

Protected from what? From my notes from yesterday I had that "Dennis" is both seer and immune,  if that is possible?
I think Wendy gave the milk, and she is SK and that's who's on my vote sheet for the moment 
Reinforced by her reply to me when I asked her was Maeve her boss, she said she is only out for herself... or something to that effect.... I'm paraphrasing. It was actually even more direct than that.

Something feels off to me.

I agree to a point but I think it's something that can (and most likely will) be explored tomorrow

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

Amy ain't got nothing on me. She's not fit to lace my heels

Now now. I'm happy to share my mic if you ask nicely

Wrong again.  You said you were happy to share. Never mind so.

[Vernon the Ranger]

Jabronies will be in the dark at this point. We won't know much until at least tonights yeeting. Unless some one has slipped up and we missed it, not a whole lot to go on

Why are you referring to Jabronies in the 3rd person? Are you not included in that?

Ina May, you never replied to this post from Benjamin. Why? 🤔

[Boris the Fool]

I am giving Frank and Benji a pass as new players (have my doubts on Benji but won’t lynch tonight just in case).

Also gonna ignore the no posters and Vernon as he has only entered the game.

My vote is gonna go for Chris for not bothering to read the thread even though we were only on page 3 when he entered. He’s not a new player but doesn’t seem to know what the amnesty is but knew day 0 not much happens.

[Moe the Innkeeper]

I'm going to vote for Magda, as a low but not no poster. Has three posts so far, all reasonable, mainly general observations about the game rather than about posters. They may be just busy but might also be a low lying wolf or SK trying to fly under the radar.

[Chris the Carpenter]

There is mention of milk and a shield in the OP so these may translate into powers? I’ve never seen the show so someone else may know if they are something that could be meaningful

I've a vote put in for Kevin. Sorry Kevin, just vibes at this point

This is, and to use your own words at Wendy, as weak as dishwater. Vibes is not a reason.

Its all the helpful posts, just comes across as someone padding their vote count without actually doing anything

[Benjamin the Alchemist]

I know the expression when you're explaining you're losing but here goes.
1) If Prada and William actually read through my posts they have quoted, then they will see that all of my theories are just that- and very confused at that- just throwing out ideas to provoke thought/ conversation. I am Ronseal. Newbie villager.
2) Why am I under suspicsion as a newbie and not Frank.  *sulks*

Also, I find it really interesting on point 2, that ye are all circling the wagons on me "for tomorrow" and protecting Frank. Why so? Are ye all communing in a back room somewhere?