(15-09-2025, 04:21 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote:Thats 11 players, 12 on the other side of the scale. If there were 4 wolves, it is not much to go on(15-09-2025, 04:09 PM)Kevin the Armorer Wrote: 4.5 hours until yeet and 4 players yet to post.I would have 2 wolves in the posters with 5 posts or lower.
Player Post Count
Prada the Seamstress 41
Benjamin the Alchemist 37
Kevin the Armorer 30
Boris the Fool 21
Betty the Beggar 17
Wendy the Wench 16
Dexter the Dragoon 15
Maeve the Madam 14
Chris the Carpenter 10
Donald the Spoofer 8
Edward the Barber 8
Moe the Innkeeper 8
Amy the Singer 5
Pat the Baker 5
Frank the Tank 4
William the Grave Robber 4
Ina May the Midwife 3
Magda the Maid 3
Laura the Lace Mistress 1
Gordon the Cook 0
Rhoda the Spinster 0
Robin the Jester 0
Vernon the Ranger 0
The Gang Solves The Werewolf Crisis
(15-09-2025, 03:59 PM)Chris the Carpenter Wrote:Call it a gut feeling, something seemed off to me about it.(15-09-2025, 03:20 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote: There's my suss list as of now
Ima...i think you slipped
Betty...initial posts
Chris...posts linked too much with Pat
Pat...posts linked to much with Chris
Discuss?
How are you linking mine and Pats posts?
Aside from someone saying our first posts were close in time with each other i dont think there's been any link but maybe I'm wrong
You are two i would like to hear more from
(15-09-2025, 05:08 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote:If there are 3 wolves then it is something to go on.(15-09-2025, 04:21 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote: I would have 2 wolves in the posters with 5 posts or lower.Thats 11 players, 12 on the other side of the scale. If there were 4 wolves, it is not much to go on
Depends how you want to look at it
(15-09-2025, 05:04 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote:(15-09-2025, 05:02 PM)Moe the Innkeeper Wrote: Reading back the only post that I can see being likely called out is Jabronies being in the dark, but I don't see that post as suspicious myself.Yes i think that post by Ina was a slip.
You think differently, that's fine.
Who you thinking as of now?
If ye are going to call out such small things as slips, no wonder players might be reluctant to post.
I'm an experienced player, I would never slip.
Happy to go up against anyone tonight though
(15-09-2025, 03:51 PM)Kevin the Armorer Wrote:First posts followed each other quickly and then a thanks too. Seemed off to me. I’ve noted it. It may be nothing, it may be something(15-09-2025, 03:20 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote: There's my suss list as of now
Ima...i think you slipped
Betty...initial posts
Chris...posts linked too much with Pat
Pat...posts linked to much with Chris
Discuss?
what do you mean, 'posts linked too much with'?
(15-09-2025, 05:13 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote:Why wouldn't it be called out at this stage?(15-09-2025, 05:04 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote: Yes i think that post by Ina was a slip.
You think differently, that's fine.
Who you thinking as of now?
If ye are going to call out such small things as slips, no wonder players might be reluctant to post.
I'm an experienced player, I would never slip.
Happy to go up against anyone tonight though
If you're village, then you should be posting. Get thoughts on thread. Wolves might fear slips and not post.
Even experienced players can slip.
Your post has done nothing but back up my thoughts.
MOD REMINDER: VOTING CLOSES AT 8.30PM
Famous for triggering Builebeag in her own game!
(15-09-2025, 05:06 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote:(15-09-2025, 04:58 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote: Yes, it's a good tactic imo because you give a roled player a heads up if they are in trouble. But more importantly, it stops a wolf wagon at the last minute.Sometimes roled do. It's very rare though that at least one wolf isn't in low posters.
I don't fully agree with always yet low, sometimes roled villagers play a quieter game too. It's not as easy as 2 of the lowest 5 posters are wolves. If only it was.
Who's on the chopping block for you Mr Scissorhands?
Right !now? It's W for Wolf.
You and William the Grave Robber.
However, I forgot I was even playing until lunch time today so I will try get a proper read back shortly.
(15-09-2025, 05:13 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote:(15-09-2025, 05:04 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote: Yes i think that post by Ina was a slip.
You think differently, that's fine.
Who you thinking as of now?
If ye are going to call out such small things as slips, no wonder players might be reluctant to post.
I'm an experienced player, I would never slip.
Happy to go up against anyone tonight though
That's a fair enough comment but could be said as any alignment tbf Ina. I think the lack of posting from a lot is highlighting stuff like that to me more than it normally would. As you know, it's hard day 1 especially with very little info bar Maeves death.
I find Benjamin suspicious but I also think they're a new player based off their posting so I'm not particularly comfortable voting them tonight if that makes sense.
So in the absence of that train of thought, I'm left with my own thoughts in relation to how you phrased that post, and also Moe's as I brought up earlier. And I'm also completely aware that it very well could be innocently posted. But I have to be honest, I've got nothing else right now.
I've voted. I may change my mind later but for now, I'm locked in.
Going to have dinner and so on and check in later; see if anyone has incriminated themselves (any further)
Going to have dinner and so on and check in later; see if anyone has incriminated themselves (any further)
have we reached a consensus on the various roles? i see a few people have done this exercise already and i dont want to waste my time
(14-09-2025, 09:24 PM)Chris the Carpenter Wrote:(14-09-2025, 08:29 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote: Alright folks, reading night 0 never surprises. Always a few in the quiet poster vote with the thread being open a few hours.
Here's my take on the OP
Dennis- Seer
Frank - Vigilante
Charlie - JOAT
Mac - BG
Wolves - The McPoyles + Dee as alpha
The Waitress is SK
While this is basic I like it a lot, getting the info out there.Pat is on my good list
maeve and william also did this same exercise. are they also on your good list?
(15-09-2025, 05:55 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:(14-09-2025, 09:24 PM)Chris the Carpenter Wrote: While this is basic I like it a lot, getting the info out there.Pat is on my good list
maeve and william also did this same exercise. are they also on your good list?
i have since read edward calling out the same thing and laura's fair enough reply. its something i'd do as well.
(15-09-2025, 12:46 AM)Kevin the Armorer Wrote:(14-09-2025, 11:21 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: um, no. They are both wolves.
How the hey ho would I know Pat is a roll-ed (see what I did there) villager?
Dennis is the seer. Do you refute that?
Seer is a RV, not a wolf.
You say that Dennis is the baker.
These are things you said. I'm not making them up. we can read these things in the crap you have posted.
this is more a reminder for me to look into later on. its the most interesting interaction thus far into my read back
(15-09-2025, 09:16 AM)Dexter the Dragoon Wrote: Good morning Prada! *smiles irresistibly*
I took Digby out for a ride to clear my head and ponder the goings on in the village.
There's a few here acting very suspiciously. Kevin is coming across quite angry. Is that the wolf showing through? And Donald, very odd behavior altogether. That man couldn't be right surely?
At least *most* of the ladies appear virtuous to me.
*throws @Betty the Beggar a few quid*. Breakfast is on me. 😉
one could argue your behavior is also odd
(15-09-2025, 05:52 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote: have we reached a consensus on the various roles? i see a few people have done this exercise already and i dont want to waste my time
There seems to be broad consensus across the couple of summary posts although I've used William's (below) as my reference as it lists the named McPoyles from the OP whereas some of the others don't. That 4 RV is actually 5 RV but we only know that because Maeve drank the milk.
(14-09-2025, 12:33 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote: That's some OP! My take so far:
Village rvs
Dennis - seer
Charlie - joat
Frank - vig, says he can save Froggy. No idea who Froggy is.
Mac - bodyguard
Waitress - SK
Wolves:
Dee - peeks good
Ryan McPoyle - milk laced with horse tranquillisers
Liam McPoyle - crest "There’s no telling what it could do. Best we just avoid it." Powerful wolf with different abilities.
OP states they don't know how many McPoyles are out there so likely a few vanilla wolves too.
23 players
4 village RVs
1 SK
3 known wolves
My guess is there's two more wolves.
MOD ANNOUNCEMENT: A SUBSTITUTE HAS OCCURRED ON THE VERNON THE RANGER ACCOUNT
Famous for triggering Builebeag in her own game!
No real idea on who to vote for at the moment. As of now I'm looking to vote Laura the Lace Mistress, no strong take on this one just based on their posting coming across as not very insightful or helpful at the moment. Same thing could be said for many others, however.
(15-09-2025, 11:44 AM)Moe the Innkeeper Wrote: There were many in the inn last night, as I said a busy night. The few I mentioned were particularly lively. Whether werewolves were amongst my customers I do not know, there are rumours they may have bathed to hide their lupine scent and remain hidden.
did you have to bathe?
(15-09-2025, 01:32 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote: Maeve had a very good handle on the game, 14 posts, with a lot of wisdom and good reading there. A great loss to us. She even seemed to have actually read the OP!
It would indicate to me that the wolves are experienced players.
are you experienced? this post seems a bit disingenuous
I’ve only skimmed the thread so don’t think I’m ignoring anybody but I’m going back to the start again now 😊
(15-09-2025, 05:09 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote:(15-09-2025, 03:59 PM)Chris the Carpenter Wrote: How are you linking mine and Pats posts?Call it a gut feeling, something seemed off to me about it.
Aside from someone saying our first posts were close in time with each other i dont think there's been any link but maybe I'm wrong
You are two i would like to hear more from
So nothing, fair enough. If youre going to be making blanket statements you should expect to be asked to back them up. It looks weak as dish water when you cant
@Benjamin the Alchemist your either new to game or else trying to play the I dont know anything card.
However your response about why you had@Maeve the Madam on your list doesn't add up or why you said she needed a haircut that is all.
Is that why you gave her the milk,
However your response about why you had@Maeve the Madam on your list doesn't add up or why you said she needed a haircut that is all.
Is that why you gave her the milk,
I've a vote put in for Kevin. Sorry Kevin, just vibes at this point
The first one Betty. Sorry if I'm messing it up. If it helps, I'm really enjoying it. The logic is going over my head though.
It being the game, not messing it up, obviously
Users browsing this thread:
