Round Table Discussion Thread

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

8 still here

[Dora the Explorer]

Im having second thoughts on friar, he could have kept stumm and not bring attention to himself if he is a triator. Dora flips good we immediately go after him

Gordo, moe, countess, what ye think?

If they had kept quiet it still would have been us two up for the banishment. By coming out they've tried to prolong their stay in the castle.

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Dora 3 - weyland, billy, friar
Friar 1 - Dora

[Gordon the Cook]

Im having second thoughts on friar, he could have kept stumm and not bring attention to himself if he is a triator. Dora flips good we immediately go after him

Gordo, moe, countess, what ye think?

my intention is to vote for friar. that hasn't wavered all day

[Gordon the Cook]

vote: friar

[Gordon the Cook]

dora: 3 : willliam, weyland, friar
Friar: 2 : dora, gordon

3 left to vote
zeena, moe, countess

[Moe the Innkeeper]

Im having second thoughts on friar, he could have kept stumm and not bring attention to himself if he is a triator. Dora flips good we immediately go after him

Gordo, moe, countess, what ye think?

They already had loads of attention on them and would've been up today with dora and maybe countess? They did narrow it down a little in that countess isn't in the picture at the moment

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

At this point I'd nearly leave it to coin toss

[Countess Markievicz]

I’m tempted to let random.org decide again… a big part of me wants to be right about my D1 read on Dora but her behavior last dusk and most of her posts today have me doubting myself. Friar’s claim, target and result don’t clear him for me, but nobody else has claimed a prize and since I know there were two prizes day 1 (Lilly’s reveal and my PM), it’s most likely he did win something.

[Countess Markievicz]

Here, I’ll stick with my gut, but support a coin toss, getting used to it now.

Vote Dora.

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Vote friar

Your call moe, its Dora or necros thumb

[Dora the Explorer]

Good grief folks, Friar almost certainly won a prize. They came out and said so yesterday but didn't say what so that they could concoct a scheme after the day had ended.

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Good grief folks, Friar almost certainly won a prize. They came out and said so yesterday but didn't say what so that they could concoct a scheme after the day had ended.

That is my main reason for him, if he had just left us something yesterday

[Dora the Explorer]

William was leaning towards Friar as being more wolfy than I am yesterday. Not sure what has changed to make them vote for me - they certainly didn't explain.

I still think Edward is a Traitor, his behaviour today has done nothing to persaude me otherwise, some of it has reinforced that opinion.

As to everyone else, I'm somewhat suspicious of Countess, Friar, and to a lesser extent Dora. But if Edward is a Traitor, then only 1 of those can be, and if push came to shove, I'd be leaning towards Friar. 

I'm neutral on Amy, Moe, Gordon and Weyland right now. 

I'm leaning Faithful for Zeena. 

Obviously I have myself Faithful, I wouldn't have thought I needed to state that, but so no one can misread and think otherwise. Sigh. 

Players - Amy, Countess, Dora, Edward, Friar, Gordon, Moe, William, Weyland, Zeena (mick, lilly)

[Friar Tuck]

Good grief folks, Friar almost certainly won a prize. They came out and said so yesterday but didn't say what so that they could concoct a scheme after the day had ended.

You doubted Countess too, are you suggesting we're both lying? If I'd said I had a trip wire the wolves would have tried to kill me.

[Moe the Innkeeper]

Ugh this is torture. I don't want to bring this to a coin toss again but I think it's friar

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Good grief folks, Friar almost certainly won a prize. They came out and said so yesterday but didn't say what so that they could concoct a scheme after the day had ended.

You doubted Countess too, are you suggesting we're both lying? If I'd said I had a trip wire the wolves would have tried to kill me.

You had a prize, what difference does it make what the prize was, I dont buy the reason

[Dora the Explorer]

Good grief folks, Friar almost certainly won a prize. They came out and said so yesterday but didn't say what so that they could concoct a scheme after the day had ended.

You doubted Countess too, are you suggesting we're both lying? If I'd said I had a trip wire the wolves would have tried to kill me.

Here we go again with this thing. I've already said yes I doubted countess. I don't think they're lying about there being a traitor in the three lily voters. I know that is definitely the truth. Wolves might have but you could've been shielded. I'm not saying you should have said what the prize was last night but your apparent use of it would be one of the worst uses of a prize if you were actually a villager.

I'm fairly happy saying the above because I know you're lying. If there was a shred of doubt in my mind then I'd feel bad about saying that to someone who might be village but you're not so I don't.

[Friar Tuck]

You doubted Countess too, are you suggesting we're both lying? If I'd said I had a trip wire the wolves would have tried to kill me.

You had a prize, what difference does it make what the prize was, I dont buy the reason

A trip wire could detect a wolf, but I declared a prize so a wolf couldn't.

[Gordon the Cook]

Good grief folks, Friar almost certainly won a prize. They came out and said so yesterday but didn't say what so that they could concoct a scheme after the day had ended.

You doubted Countess too, are you suggesting we're both lying? If I'd said I had a trip wire the wolves would have tried to kill me.

Why would the wolves ever kill you when you where up for banishment the next day.
It just doesn't make sense.

[Countess Markievicz]

If everyone votes, does the cycle end, or do we still wait till 10pm?

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

You had a prize, what difference does it make what the prize was, I dont buy the reason

A trip wire could detect a wolf, but I declared a prize so a wolf couldn't.

You're not getting what Im saying, a prize for a villager is usually good. Why were you not murdered?

Because I have a shield, because you didnt reveal what the prize was, or because you are a triator?

[Necro]

If everyone votes, does the cycle end, or do we still wait till 10pm?

Cycle ends.

[Moe the Innkeeper]

You had a prize, what difference does it make what the prize was, I dont buy the reason

A trip wire could detect a wolf, but I declared a prize so a wolf couldn't.

I dont understand this either and you've mentioned it before

If a wolf claimed a prize you could counter, if it goes to a vote you vs other claimer it would clear it and we have even more info. This wouldn't be the village reason to declare a prize, at least in my opinion

[Friar Tuck]

You doubted Countess too, are you suggesting we're both lying? If I'd said I had a trip wire the wolves would have tried to kill me.

Why would the wolves ever kill you when you where up for banishment the next day.
It just doesn't make sense.

If I'd declared a trip wire they would in case I used it on one of them.

[Moe the Innkeeper]

Right, screw it

Vote Friar

[Friar Tuck]

A trip wire could detect a wolf, but I declared a prize so a wolf couldn't.

You're not getting what Im saying, a prize for a villager is usually good. Why were you not murdered?

Because I have a shield, because you didnt reveal what the prize was, or because you are a triator?

Only the wolves can definitively answer that one.

[Necro]

All players have voted and there is another tie... Ye feckers and me on the phone 😂😂

Hang on and I'll get the result.... STAND BY

[Dora the Explorer]

A trip wire could detect a wolf, but I declared a prize so a wolf couldn't.

You're not getting what Im saying, a prize for a villager is usually good. Why were you not murdered?

Because I have a shield, because you didnt reveal what the prize was, or because you are a triator?

Oh I can answer that one. It is because the wolves were so annoyed that they couldn't fake claim the second prize that they forgot to kill him. Terribly nice of the wolves really. So kind to our friar they were.

[Gordon the Cook]

Why would the wolves ever kill you when you where up for banishment the next day.
It just doesn't make sense.

If I'd declared a trip wire they would in case I used it on one of them.

But, you are either a wolf, or a villager, as wolf, you know they cannot detect you, and as villager, they are always going to use dora to do the kill, so it was useless so, as the outcome was predetermined, no matter which you were are weren't

[Necro]

Grab your backpack, let's go Dora.

Dora the Explorer has been banished at random. I'll post the screenshot later folks as on the phone.

Dora the Explorer was Faithful.


FINAL BANISHMENT PHASE HAS BEEN TRIGGERED.

Stand by for further instruction

[Necro]

Final Banishment phase will now begin.

Rest easy tonight everyone.... No murder will take place.

The game will open tomorrow again at 10am in the Round Table discussion thread. Players will have three hours discussion and a vote between 1-2pm. The banished will be revealed on thread and then the players will have to answer a question whether they wish to continue the game.

If even one person states yes then the next banishment will be between 7 and 8pm

The question will be asked again and if we continue the game the thread will close until 10am Friday morning.


Proxy votes can be accepted if the times conflict for people.

See you all tomorrow morning!

[Necro]

Good morning everyone and welcome to the FINAL BANISHMENT stage.

Rules are as above. Next Banishment voting occurs between 1 and 2pm.

Discussion starts... NOW

[Necro]

Thread is open

[Zeena Warrior Princess]

Morning all

@Friar Tuck  anything to say for yourself?

[Moe the Innkeeper]

Right well this one is obvious

[Friar Tuck]

Morning all

@Friar Tuck  anything to say for yourself?

I'm not a wolf, despite the evidence. The only explanation I can think of is that a wolf won a prize and tampered with mine. The trip wire result was "Motion detected".
Has @Countess Markievicz ab opinion on this?

[Weyland the Blacksmith]

I think we need to go Friar and then depending on how he turns we might need to look at Countess.

[Countess Markievicz]

This is not a gastard game, I was told at least one of Lilly’s voters is a traitor and we’ve seen two of them flip Faithful so I have zero doubt you are the traitor. But well played!

[Friar Tuck]

Zeena 2 - shields claimed
Weyland
Friar - trip wire claimed
Countess - vote analysis claimed
Gordon

Could there have been 3 prizes and wolves won the others?