+- A sheep, a werewolf and a walrus walk into a bar. (https://forumofgames.com)
+-- Forum: Werewolf (https://forumofgames.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=9)
+--- Forum: Werewolf Games (https://forumofgames.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=26)
+--- Thread: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf (/showthread.php?tid=551)
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Frank the Tank - 16-10-2025
If the choice is between Laura and Mick, I lean towards Mick.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Frank the Tank - 16-10-2025
I'm back at work today, my posting will be falling off a cliff. Apologies in advance.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Ina May the Midwife - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 02:16 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: If the choice is between Laura and Mick, I lean towards Mick.
Looks like Laura's literally gonna zero post this phase anyways, not a single post since 9.22pm last night
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Mick the Drunk - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 02:18 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote:(16-10-2025, 02:16 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: If the choice is between Laura and Mick, I lean towards Mick.
Looks like Laura's literally gonna zero post this phase anyways, not a single post since 9.22pm last night
Has everyone else posted so far today?
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Rhoda the Spinster - 16-10-2025
One post from Vincent. None from Laura.
Has William been on?
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Ina May the Midwife - 16-10-2025
He posted a spreadsheet and ran away again
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Mick the Drunk - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 02:25 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: He posted a spreadsheet and ran away again
This has been my point the last couple of days, he pops up - tires to appear helpful and then disappears again
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - William the Grave Robber - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 02:29 PM)Mick the Drunk Wrote:(16-10-2025, 02:25 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: He posted a spreadsheet and ran away again
This has been my point the last couple of days, he pops up - tires to appear helpful and then disappears again
i also posted a decent theory (IMO) on the hobbits being tracked.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Laura the Lace Mistress - 16-10-2025
I'm back banging the same drum, why wasn't Edward killed?
Prada obviously did an alignment check on him, was he somehow corrupted by the ring and converted? Why track Frank and Ina? Could Edward be a wolf looking for a specific role?
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Edward the Barber - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 02:43 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote: I'm back banging the same drum, why wasn't Edward killed?I wasn't munched so you could use this as an arguement to save yourself from lynch
Prada obviously did an alignment check on him, was he somehow corrupted by the ring and converted? Why track Frank and Ina? Could Edward be a wolf looking for a specific role?
I picked Prada, frank, and Ina, I could have picked anyone else the last 3 nights and the arguement would be the same, why pick anyone.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Laura the Lace Mistress - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 02:51 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote:Why weren't you munched though? You've survived 2 now, you don't have arrows yet one of yours was used to kill Magda.(16-10-2025, 02:43 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote: I'm back banging the same drum, why wasn't Edward killed?I wasn't munched so you could use this as an arguement to save yourself from lynch
Prada obviously did an alignment check on him, was he somehow corrupted by the ring and converted? Why track Frank and Ina? Could Edward be a wolf looking for a specific role?
I picked Prada, frank, and Ina, I could have picked anyone else the last 3 nights and the arguement would be the same, why pick anyone.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Vincent the Artist - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 01:02 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote:That race is appealing to me.(16-10-2025, 12:58 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: Yep. There’s at least 2 wolves so our chances of getting one have to be good
I typed that with fingers crossed
It'll be interesting to see how people feel about it, at the very least.
So folks...
@Rhoda the Spinster
@Edward the Barber
@Laura the Lace Mistress
@Vincent the Artist
@Mick the Drunk
@William the Grave Robber
@Frank the Tank
Thoughts on a Mick VS Laura race? Let's get everyone's opinion here please and thanks, and yes that includes the two I'm suggesting for the race.
Sorry, I got notified that I got my promotion at work this morning and my desk has been a stopping point for people all day...
Don't they realize that my integrity in the game is being called into question!
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Edward the Barber - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 02:54 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:(16-10-2025, 02:51 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote: I wasn't munched so you could use this as an arguement to save yourself from lynchWhy weren't you munched though? You've survived 2 now, you don't have arrows yet one of yours was used to kill Magda.
I picked Prada, frank, and Ina, I could have picked anyone else the last 3 nights and the arguement would be the same, why pick anyone.
I've explained now a few times why I think I wasnt munched and if you have been following the game, you should know why magda was killed
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Benjamin the Alchemist - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 02:54 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:(16-10-2025, 02:51 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote: I wasn't munched so you could use this as an arguement to save yourself from lynchWhy weren't you munched though? You've survived 2 now, you don't have arrows yet one of yours was used to kill Magda.
I picked Prada, frank, and Ina, I could have picked anyone else the last 3 nights and the arguement would be the same, why pick anyone.
You do know who the wolves have been munching, right?
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Benjamin the Alchemist - 16-10-2025
@Laura the Lace Mistress who is your pick for the other Wolf. There has to be 3 at least.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Laura the Lace Mistress - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 02:59 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote:I know why Magda was killed, you character revealed. My point was you said you have no arrows, yet one was used to kill Magda.(16-10-2025, 02:54 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote: Why weren't you munched though? You've survived 2 now, you don't have arrows yet one of yours was used to kill Magda.
I've explained now a few times why I think I wasnt munched and if you have been following the game, you should know why magda was killed
Did you know you'd get an arrow if you revealed? Why did Prada mention you and specify to read the post if she died.
She had an alignment check, you were mentioned in the top of the post. Rhoda was mentioned at the bottom and we know she wouldn't have peeked bad.
You could catch a wolf with your action, yet they don't seem bothered about you.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Laura the Lace Mistress - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 02:59 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote:Yes, but how do they know who the hobbits are? I've read William's theory but if they can see who has the ring the game is pointless.(16-10-2025, 02:54 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote: Why weren't you munched though? You've survived 2 now, you don't have arrows yet one of yours was used to kill Magda.
You do know who the wolves have been munching, right?
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Laura the Lace Mistress - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 03:04 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: @Laura the Lace Mistress who is your pick for the other Wolf. There has to be 3 at least.I think between you, Mick and William.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - William the Grave Robber - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 03:08 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:(16-10-2025, 02:59 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: You do know who the wolves have been munching, right?Yes, but how do they know who the hobbits are? I've read William's theory but if they can see who has the ring the game is pointless.
in the movies, when you use the ring, the enemy can find you.
so maybe 2 of our hobbits used the ring, knowing the would be caught the next day, and knowing it would be passed onto the next hobbit.
i'm only spitballing here.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Rhoda the Spinster - 16-10-2025
Hmm, so they become viable as hobbits/ ring bearers. Interesting.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Mick the Drunk - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 03:40 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote:(16-10-2025, 03:08 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote: Yes, but how do they know who the hobbits are? I've read William's theory but if they can see who has the ring the game is pointless.
in the movies, when you use the ring, the enemy can find you.
so maybe 2 of our hobbits used the ring, knowing the would be caught the next day, and knowing it would be passed onto the next hobbit.
i'm only spitballing here.
The would be very powered towards the wolves then if a villager using their power automatically lets the wolves know who they are
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Frank the Tank - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 03:40 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote:(16-10-2025, 03:08 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote: Yes, but how do they know who the hobbits are? I've read William's theory but if they can see who has the ring the game is pointless.
in the movies, when you use the ring, the enemy can find you.
so maybe 2 of our hobbits used the ring, knowing the would be caught the next day, and knowing it would be passed onto the next hobbit.
i'm only spitballing here.
So what you are suggesting is once the ring passes to another player, they get offered some sort of power, and if they use it, the wolves get told x player used a power?
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Ina May the Midwife - 16-10-2025
Or people are overthinking it.
Magda claimed she was a Hobbit on the thread. Nobody questioned it at all.
Pat was peeked clean as a whistle. Again, he wasn't being challenged at all.
Kill the clears and leave the unclears, it's not that complex guys. It's a distraction
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Mick the Drunk - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 03:51 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: Or people are overthinking it.
Magda claimed she was a Hobbit on the thread. Nobody questioned it at all.
Pat was peeked clean as a whistle. Again, he wasn't being challenged at all.
Kill the clears and leave the unclears, it's not that complex guys. It's a distraction
But Magda was an extra kill not a munch and it says it was by an arrow dropped Legolas. We have assumed this was a mod kill due to Edward claiming his character
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Edward the Barber - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 03:49 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:(16-10-2025, 03:40 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote: in the movies, when you use the ring, the enemy can find you.
so maybe 2 of our hobbits used the ring, knowing the would be caught the next day, and knowing it would be passed onto the next hobbit.
i'm only spitballing here.
So what you are suggesting is once the ring passes to another player, they get offered some sort of power, and if they use it, the wolves get told x player used a power?
What kind of powers? Apart from the usual seer, BG, investigator, and my power, the game has been fairly vanilla. I mean there have been no vig kills that we know of or no one has mentioned getting a peek for example
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Ina May the Midwife - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 03:55 PM)Mick the Drunk Wrote:(16-10-2025, 03:51 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: Or people are overthinking it.
Magda claimed she was a Hobbit on the thread. Nobody questioned it at all.
Pat was peeked clean as a whistle. Again, he wasn't being challenged at all.
Kill the clears and leave the unclears, it's not that complex guys. It's a distraction
But Magda was an extra kill not a munch and it says it was by an arrow dropped Legolas. We have assumed this was a mod kill due to Edward claiming his character
Yeah, and I suspect the wolves were allowed to aim that arrow, hence Magda got it through the skull. Bit unfair to Magda but them's the rules of this game unfortunately
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Laura the Lace Mistress - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 03:51 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: Or people are overthinking it.So why is Edward still here?
Magda claimed she was a Hobbit on the thread. Nobody questioned it at all.
Pat was peeked clean as a whistle. Again, he wasn't being challenged at all.
Kill the clears and leave the unclears, it's not that complex guys. It's a distraction
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Mick the Drunk - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 03:56 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote:(16-10-2025, 03:55 PM)Mick the Drunk Wrote: But Magda was an extra kill not a munch and it says it was by an arrow dropped Legolas. We have assumed this was a mod kill due to Edward claiming his character
Yeah, and I suspect the wolves were allowed to aim that arrow, hence Magda got it through the skull. Bit unfair to Magda but them's the rules of this game unfortunately
I get what your saying now - because the village slipped up and revealed then the wolves got an extra kill?
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Ina May the Midwife - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 03:57 PM)Mick the Drunk Wrote:(16-10-2025, 03:56 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: Yeah, and I suspect the wolves were allowed to aim that arrow, hence Magda got it through the skull. Bit unfair to Magda but them's the rules of this game unfortunately
I get what your saying now - because the village slipped up and revealed then the wolves got an extra kill?
Yup that's exactly it
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Ina May the Midwife - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 03:56 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:(16-10-2025, 03:51 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: Or people are overthinking it.So why is Edward still here?
Magda claimed she was a Hobbit on the thread. Nobody questioned it at all.
Pat was peeked clean as a whistle. Again, he wasn't being challenged at all.
Kill the clears and leave the unclears, it's not that complex guys. It's a distraction
Because people keep questioning him, even though the mods made it pretty damn obvious that he is who he says he is (to the detriment of poor sweet Magda)
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Frank the Tank - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 03:57 PM)Mick the Drunk Wrote:(16-10-2025, 03:56 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: Yeah, and I suspect the wolves were allowed to aim that arrow, hence Magda got it through the skull. Bit unfair to Magda but them's the rules of this game unfortunately
I get what your saying now - because the village slipped up and revealed then the wolves got an extra kill?
I presumed the arrow was RNG. If it included the wolf team or not, I don't know, but my presumption was rand().
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Frank the Tank - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 03:56 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:(16-10-2025, 03:51 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: Or people are overthinking it.So why is Edward still here?
Magda claimed she was a Hobbit on the thread. Nobody questioned it at all.
Pat was peeked clean as a whistle. Again, he wasn't being challenged at all.
Kill the clears and leave the unclears, it's not that complex guys. It's a distraction
Engaging with the thread, trying to help solve the mess that we are in, questioning, finding possible suspects, etc which is why I haven't voted him for lynch.
In relation to munch, there is that question, but I presume he hasn't been throwing any shade towards the alpha wolf that puts in the munch order, so the wolves that remain are taking the chance they won't be detected with their night action.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Mick the Drunk - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 04:05 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:(16-10-2025, 03:57 PM)Mick the Drunk Wrote: I get what your saying now - because the village slipped up and revealed then the wolves got an extra kill?
I presumed the arrow was RNG. If it included the wolf team or not, I don't know, but my presumption was rand().
What is RNG?
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Frank the Tank - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 04:10 PM)Mick the Drunk Wrote:(16-10-2025, 04:05 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: I presumed the arrow was RNG. If it included the wolf team or not, I don't know, but my presumption was rand().
What is RNG?
Random number generator
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Ina May the Midwife - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 04:05 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:(16-10-2025, 03:57 PM)Mick the Drunk Wrote: I get what your saying now - because the village slipped up and revealed then the wolves got an extra kill?
I presumed the arrow was RNG. If it included the wolf team or not, I don't know, but my presumption was rand().
Nah the kill post indicates that an arrow was stolen from Legolas' quiver and fired deliberately imo. The wolves gain an extra kill if someone character claims, it'll be flavored towards that. It's not random.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Rhoda the Spinster - 16-10-2025
Do we deffo lose if all the ring bearers get killed even if we still have more villagers than wolves?
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Frank the Tank - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 04:42 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: Do we deffo lose if all the ring bearers get killed even if we still have more villagers than wolves?
The Fellowship wins by eliminating all the Wolves and successfully chaperoning the One Ring to the fires of Mount Doom, cleansing Middle-earth of its greatest evil.
This sacred duty falls uniquely to the Hobbits among you, a burden few can comprehend.
Should the line of Ring-bearers be extinguished, the quest to destroy the One Ring fails, and with it, all hope for Middle-earth.
Yet, the Ring itself is a persistent and powerful force; even if its current bearer falls, its fate may not be sealed, and its dark influence may still be resisted.
The Wolves win when their numbers equal or exceed the number of Villagers, successfully corrupting or overwhelming the Free Peoples of Middle Earth.
The Serial Killer wins by gaining parity with the village & wolf teams, claiming the ultimate prize for themselves amidst the fiery ruins.
It isn't very clear what happens, did anything like this happen in the lore?
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Rhoda the Spinster - 16-10-2025
@William the Grave Robber and @Ina May the Midwife any insight to this? Sounds like we might still be able to win on the off chance the wolves manage to get another Hobbit
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Ina May the Midwife - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 04:47 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:(16-10-2025, 04:42 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: Do we deffo lose if all the ring bearers get killed even if we still have more villagers than wolves?
The Fellowship wins by eliminating all the Wolves and successfully chaperoning the One Ring to the fires of Mount Doom, cleansing Middle-earth of its greatest evil.
This sacred duty falls uniquely to the Hobbits among you, a burden few can comprehend.
Should the line of Ring-bearers be extinguished, the quest to destroy the One Ring fails, and with it, all hope for Middle-earth.
Yet, the Ring itself is a persistent and powerful force; even if its current bearer falls, its fate may not be sealed, and its dark influence may still be resisted.
The Wolves win when their numbers equal or exceed the number of Villagers, successfully corrupting or overwhelming the Free Peoples of Middle Earth.
The Serial Killer wins by gaining parity with the village & wolf teams, claiming the ultimate prize for themselves amidst the fiery ruins.
It isn't very clear what happens, did anything like this happen in the lore?
Well the whole premise of the books/movies is to get the ring back to Mordor and destroy it. So if there's nobody left to take it there....
I presume most can read between the lines
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Mick the Drunk - 16-10-2025
(16-10-2025, 04:47 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:(16-10-2025, 04:42 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: Do we deffo lose if all the ring bearers get killed even if we still have more villagers than wolves?
The Fellowship wins by eliminating all the Wolves and successfully chaperoning the One Ring to the fires of Mount Doom, cleansing Middle-earth of its greatest evil.
This sacred duty falls uniquely to the Hobbits among you, a burden few can comprehend.
Should the line of Ring-bearers be extinguished, the quest to destroy the One Ring fails, and with it, all hope for Middle-earth.
Yet, the Ring itself is a persistent and powerful force; even if its current bearer falls, its fate may not be sealed, and its dark influence may still be resisted.
The Wolves win when their numbers equal or exceed the number of Villagers, successfully corrupting or overwhelming the Free Peoples of Middle Earth.
The Serial Killer wins by gaining parity with the village & wolf teams, claiming the ultimate prize for themselves amidst the fiery ruins.
It isn't very clear what happens, did anything like this happen in the lore?
The wolves win conditions mention reaching the same number as villagers so reads like they still need to get to parity. The weird line in their conditions is the use of the word exceeds - wolves would never usually exceed villagers as the game usually ends when they equal the village number