(15-10-2025, 01:46 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:

(13-10-2025, 10:45 PM)Prada the Seamstress Wrote: Rhoda, Mick, William, Frank, Edward

Edward SK
Posts enough to be sage but safe enough to not be noticed.

2 wolves in the other 4
Did Rhoda and Betty think they could get people onboard Wendy wagon. Me thinks yes

Watch the quiet ones. Throwaway votes as they did not want to impact a wagon against Betty and Rhoda

Won't be on thread until after munch so use this as a whisper in the wind if my presence is no longer in physical form

Prada had an alignment check, she named Edward as SK which we now know to be wrong.

She was suspicious of Rhoda who we now know would have shown as good.

I think Edward was checked and shown as bad, Prada obviously assumed SK.

I think Edward is a wolf and that's why the role claim was so confused and contradictory. Edward might well be a wolf tracker and can use that to find roled players.

I see everyone suspects me because of my Day 2 vote on Rhoda but she was suspicious as feck, so suspicious that many of you voted to lynch her last night. I voted for Edward because I thought he was the SK, I'll be voting for him today because I think he is a wolf and Prada got a bad result from her alignment check.

(13-10-2025, 08:13 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: My FFA:
Laura - reasons given in earlier posts but basically their read list is suss to me
Mick - has posted nothing of major substance, has not really called out anyone in their posts
Vernon - too conciliatory in their posts

I think I'm voting for Mick at this stage.

(15-10-2025, 01:59 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 10:54 AM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: I’d like to talk about singular voters, of which I am one. Would there be a wolf voting wolf possibility on a player getting no heat?

(14-10-2025, 11:01 AM)Pat the Baker Wrote: Its definitely possible, but its WIFOM at this stage

You, mick, vern, Frank, William... let's get reasons for why they voted where they did

(14-10-2025, 11:04 AM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: Frank voting Mick perhaps, Mick had zero heat.

You voted me. I know I'm not a wolf so that didn't happen there.

Mick voted William but William had been getting a good bit of heat through the day from Magda and Pat. I think Magda actually moved her vote to Rhoda from there but she'll clarify.

Vernon voted Pat. That was a fairly loud argument between the two of them. I'm suss of Vernon for other reasons though, not the vote. Like Betty their village energy just feels off and they've gone AWOL since the lynch.

William voted Prada, that's obviously not W/W


Not sure they'd have voted each other though, based on Betty's vote they look quite risk-averse as a team


Vinnie voted Edward alongside Prada, he's not a single voter per se but he can still be a wolf if Eddie flips SK

(14-10-2025, 08:40 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: I’ll move off Edward too. Rhoda should have enough votes in her so I’m gonna go Mick.

My own notes in my notepad has me question ing a William/Mick team but William was getting heat and had some votes already. Mick voted there around 7.30 so I disregarded them as a team. 
I’d written a Frank/Mick team a possibility because Frank voted Mick who wasn’t in danger in anyway. 



Mick’s posts are not rocking any boats and that is why I’m voting them. I may be wrong about a Frank/Mick team I don’t think I’m wrong about Mick. 

what made you vote mick, Frank?

(15-10-2025, 01:55 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:52 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: Do you just cherry pick random tidbits of conversations all the time or do you read the thread for context William.

Noticed this last night when he picked the second of my posts without actually reading the first that had exactly what he was saying I didn't say in it

(15-10-2025, 02:08 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:

(13-10-2025, 08:13 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: My FFA:
Laura - reasons given in earlier posts but basically their read list is suss to me
Mick - has posted nothing of major substance, has not really called out anyone in their posts
Vernon - too conciliatory in their posts

I think I'm voting for Mick at this stage.

(15-10-2025, 01:59 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: My own notes in my notepad has me question ing a William/Mick team but William was getting heat and had some votes already. Mick voted there around 7.30 so I disregarded them as a team. 
I’d written a Frank/Mick team a possibility because Frank voted Mick who wasn’t in danger in anyway. 



Mick’s posts are not rocking any boats and that is why I’m voting them. I may be wrong about a Frank/Mick team I don’t think I’m wrong about Mick. 

what made you vote mick, Frank?

I posted it on the thread before I voted.

(15-10-2025, 02:08 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:46 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote: Prada had an alignment check, she named Edward as SK which we now know to be wrong.

She was suspicious of Rhoda who we now know would have shown as good.

I think Edward was checked and shown as bad, Prada obviously assumed SK.

I think Edward is a wolf and that's why the role claim was so confused and contradictory. Edward might well be a wolf tracker and can use that to find roled players.

I see everyone suspects me because of my Day 2 vote on Rhoda but she was suspicious as feck, so suspicious that many of you voted to lynch her last night. I voted for Edward because I thought he was the SK, I'll be voting for him today because I think he is a wolf and Prada got a bad result from her alignment check.

This doesn't make sense, why would they assume (and you even add obviously) that a bad alignment would be the SK. If anything they would assume a wolf as there are usually more of them in the game. 
I could have played this a lot better if I was a wolf, not make a mess like I did yesterday.

(15-10-2025, 02:07 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 02:02 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote: I know I'm not a wolf, Rhoda peeked you, Magda has role claimed, why would I look there?

Why are you ignoring the post from Prada? Edward obviously showed as bad.

That's why we are looking there. So if you wern't in the three and William was, do you concede William would be dodgy as fook?

We went with Prada's posts yesterday and got it wrong (probably more through our own fault than hers). Ed has claimed & Prada called Ed the SK. I think if Prada had definite info on Ed she would have called him bad, rather than SK. That's my read of it atm

(15-10-2025, 02:08 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:46 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote: Prada had an alignment check, she named Edward as SK which we now know to be wrong.

She was suspicious of Rhoda who we now know would have shown as good.

I think Edward was checked and shown as bad, Prada obviously assumed SK.

I think Edward is a wolf and that's why the role claim was so confused and contradictory. Edward might well be a wolf tracker and can use that to find roled players.

I see everyone suspects me because of my Day 2 vote on Rhoda but she was suspicious as feck, so suspicious that many of you voted to lynch her last night. I voted for Edward because I thought he was the SK, I'll be voting for him today because I think he is a wolf and Prada got a bad result from her alignment check.

This doesn't make sense, why would they assume (and you even add obviously) that a bad alignment would be the SK. If anything they would assume a wolf as there are usually more of them in the game. 
I could have played this a lot better if I was a wolf, not make a mess like I did yesterday.

(15-10-2025, 01:46 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:

(13-10-2025, 10:45 PM)Prada the Seamstress Wrote: Rhoda, Mick, William, Frank, Edward

Edward SK
Posts enough to be sage but safe enough to not be noticed.

2 wolves in the other 4
Did Rhoda and Betty think they could get people onboard Wendy wagon. Me thinks yes

Watch the quiet ones. Throwaway votes as they did not want to impact a wagon against Betty and Rhoda

Won't be on thread until after munch so use this as a whisper in the wind if my presence is no longer in physical form

Prada had an alignment check, she named Edward as SK which we now know to be wrong.

She was suspicious of Rhoda who we now know would have shown as good.

I think Edward was checked and shown as bad, Prada obviously assumed SK.

I think Edward is a wolf and that's why the role claim was so confused and contradictory. Edward might well be a wolf tracker and can use that to find roled players.

I see everyone suspects me because of my Day 2 vote on Rhoda but she was suspicious as feck, so suspicious that many of you voted to lynch her last night. I voted for Edward because I thought he was the SK, I'll be voting for him today because I think he is a wolf and Prada got a bad result from her alignment check.

(15-10-2025, 02:07 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 02:02 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote: I know I'm not a wolf, Rhoda peeked you, Magda has role claimed, why would I look there?

Why are you ignoring the post from Prada? Edward obviously showed as bad.

That's why we are looking there. So if you wern't in the three and William was, do you concede William would be dodgy as fook?

We went with Prada's posts yesterday and got it wrong (probably more through our own fault than hers). Ed has claimed & Prada called Ed the SK. I think if Prada had definite info on Ed she would have called him bad, rather than SK. That's my read of it atm

(15-10-2025, 02:27 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: Vote gone in now on Laura

(15-10-2025, 02:23 PM)Mick the Drunk Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:46 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote: Prada had an alignment check, she named Edward as SK which we now know to be wrong.

She was suspicious of Rhoda who we now know would have shown as good.

I think Edward was checked and shown as bad, Prada obviously assumed SK.

I think Edward is a wolf and that's why the role claim was so confused and contradictory. Edward might well be a wolf tracker and can use that to find roled players.

I see everyone suspects me because of my Day 2 vote on Rhoda but she was suspicious as feck, so suspicious that many of you voted to lynch her last night. I voted for Edward because I thought he was the SK, I'll be voting for him today because I think he is a wolf and Prada got a bad result from her alignment check.

If Edward is lying about who he is, then how do you account for no counter claim?

(15-10-2025, 02:17 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 02:07 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote: That's why we are looking there. So if you wern't in the three and William was, do you concede William would be dodgy as fook?

We went with Prada's posts yesterday and got it wrong (probably more through our own fault than hers). Ed has claimed & Prada called Ed the SK. I think if Prada had definite info on Ed she would have called him bad, rather than SK. That's my read of it atm

I got my vote in just after 8 and declared it, I didn't try to swing it when Betty came under pressure later. I thought Rhoda was suspicious, I did right until she flipped.

BBetty was trying to get others on Wendy, why did I not move when Maeve voted for Betty?

(15-10-2025, 02:30 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 02:27 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: Vote gone in now on Laura

Up until Wendy flipped Edward was likely either the SK or a RV, why wasn't he munched?

(15-10-2025, 02:34 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 02:23 PM)Mick the Drunk Wrote: If Edward is lying about who he is, then how do you account for no counter claim?

Because nobody might have the role he's claiming.

We had Prada who could check alignment and Rhoda the seer. If Edward can see who used a night action it's a wolf role to hunt roled players.

We don't know the wolf roles, there could be an alpha who peeks good, a one time kill, vote manipulation, a tracking ability etc.

(15-10-2025, 02:34 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 02:23 PM)Mick the Drunk Wrote: If Edward is lying about who he is, then how do you account for no counter claim?

Because nobody might have the role he's claiming.

We had Prada who could check alignment and Rhoda the seer. If Edward can see who used a night action it's a wolf role to hunt roled players.

We don't know the wolf roles, there could be an alpha who peeks good, a one time kill, vote manipulation, a tracking ability etc.

(15-10-2025, 02:34 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 02:23 PM)Mick the Drunk Wrote: If Edward is lying about who he is, then how do you account for no counter claim?

Because nobody might have the role he's claiming.

We had Prada who could check alignment and Rhoda the seer. If Edward can see who used a night action it's a wolf role to hunt roled players.

We don't know the wolf roles, there could be an alpha who peeks good, a one time kill, vote manipulation, a tracking ability etc.

(15-10-2025, 02:30 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 02:27 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: Vote gone in now on Laura

Up until Wendy flipped Edward was likely either the SK or a RV, why wasn't he munched?

(15-10-2025, 02:45 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 02:30 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote: Up until Wendy flipped Edward was likely either the SK or a RV, why wasn't he munched?

I asked this earlier also, why wasn't I munched. Only thing I can think of is they thought I would be up for lynch today and keep any heat of the wolves. However that kind of changed when the SK was munched.

Fwiw, I got my first power to use Monday night, I rekon Prada might have also got their power the same time. So at most they got only one result. Why did they call me the SK when I wasn't. Getting a bad alignment and assuming the SK doesn't really make sense to me.

(15-10-2025, 08:32 AM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: Rhoda was one of our most valuable players and saving a player claiming to be a tracker was deemed more important than saving the player breadcrumbing the seer role
🤷🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️

(13-10-2025, 10:57 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:

(13-10-2025, 05:35 PM)Betty the Beggar Wrote: That last paragraph was meant to be protect Pat, not Ben confused myself while writing 🫠 no shade at Ben just think Pat is being targeted for little else really.

Speaking of protects I don't know what to make of these posts.
Betty initially said protect Ben, and then corrected to Pat.

(14-10-2025, 12:05 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:

(13-10-2025, 10:45 PM)Prada the Seamstress Wrote: Rhoda, Mick, William, Frank, Edward

Edward SK
Posts enough to be sage but safe enough to not be noticed.

2 wolves in the other 4
Did Rhoda and Betty think they could get people onboard Wendy wagon. Me thinks yes

Watch the quiet ones. Throwaway votes as they did not want to impact a wagon against Betty and Rhoda

Won't be on thread until after munch so use this as a whisper in the wind if my presence is no longer in physical form

I stand corrected. I just noticed my time on the posts was an hour earlier.

Quote:Night Phase - 9pm−10am: The GM receives private messages from players with special roles. The Wolves choose their target, the Serial Killer chooses theirs, and any special actions are carried out.

The above post by Prada is 9:45pm. However it is 2 players she is calling out. Edward and Rhoda. Not just Edward here. 
The whoosh whoosh post really makes me think they checked Rhoda.

(15-10-2025, 01:21 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote:

(13-10-2025, 10:45 PM)Prada the Seamstress Wrote: Rhoda, Mick, William, Frank, Edward

Edward SK
Posts enough to be sage but safe enough to not be noticed.

2 wolves in the other 4
Did Rhoda and Betty think they could get people onboard Wendy wagon. Me thinks yes

Watch the quiet ones. Throwaway votes as they did not want to impact a wagon against Betty and Rhoda

Won't be on thread until after munch so use this as a whisper in the wind if my presence is no longer in physical form

Was Prada given inaccurate information?

(15-10-2025, 03:22 PM)Vincent the Artist Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:21 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: Was Prada given inaccurate information?

There could have been tampering. 

But I think the most likely thing from Prada's post above is that they were their own reads.SK was obviously wrong. That was a read. There might not be 2 wolves in the 4. they just picked 5 people who were suspect to them, assigned one of them the SK and then assumed 2 wolves in the other 4 players. 

That's not to say there isn't 2 wolves in there. There could be. I just think like the "whisper on the wind" is just their own use of flavour

(15-10-2025, 03:31 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote: And when I say they 'use that post', I mean they kill Prada for that post, to lead us astray

(15-10-2025, 03:29 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 03:22 PM)Vincent the Artist Wrote: There could have been tampering. 

But I think the most likely thing from Prada's post above is that they were their own reads.SK was obviously wrong. That was a read. There might not be 2 wolves in the 4. they just picked 5 people who were suspect to them, assigned one of them the SK and then assumed 2 wolves in the other 4 players. 

That's not to say there isn't 2 wolves in there. There could be. I just think like the "whisper on the wind" is just their own use of flavour

Prada also voted for Edward so it would make sense to call them out after the lynch

Now it could also be said that it would make sense it was Ed they investigated too. But we don't know what the investigation did (we are presuming allignment peek based on her posts), and we also don't know if Prada got a result, do we?

(15-10-2025, 03:34 PM)Mick the Drunk Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 03:31 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote: And when I say they 'use that post', I mean they kill Prada for that post, to lead us astray

Was Prada not an SK kill?

(15-10-2025, 03:33 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote: Sorry I'm stupid it was the SK who killed Prada, so SK leads us astray

(15-10-2025, 03:43 PM)Vincent the Artist Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 03:33 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote: Sorry I'm stupid it was the SK who killed Prada, so SK leads us astray

I think that's exactly what it was

(15-10-2025, 03:38 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 03:29 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote: Prada also voted for Edward so it would make sense to call them out after the lynch

Now it could also be said that it would make sense it was Ed they investigated too. But we don't know what the investigation did (we are presuming allignment peek based on her posts), and we also don't know if Prada got a result, do we?

I have been thinking about Laura's question to me, and going back to examine if Prada got a result.
Edward says his result came through both days after munch. That makes sense if it is an action tracker. The action may not be made until just before munch, so I think he is telling the truth on the timing of the answers.
My action I received the response after the lynch, in the night phase. However mine wasn't action based, just another alignment check really. 

Day Phase - 10am−9pm: This is the voting phase. Players discuss, debate, and vote to lynch one person they suspect is a Wolf. The person with the most votes is eliminated from the game.
Night Phase - 9pm−10am: The GM receives private messages from players with special roles. The Wolves choose their target, the Serial Killer chooses theirs, and any special actions are carried out.

(15-10-2025, 03:38 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 03:34 PM)Mick the Drunk Wrote: Was Prada not an SK kill?

Yeah I'm an eegit is the general gist of that

Howya anyway Mick, what ya thinking?

(15-10-2025, 03:45 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 03:38 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: I have been thinking about Laura's question to me, and going back to examine if Prada got a result.
Edward says his result came through both days after munch. That makes sense if it is an action tracker. The action may not be made until just before munch, so I think he is telling the truth on the timing of the answers.
My action I received the response after the lynch, in the night phase. However mine wasn't action based, just another alignment check really. 

Day Phase - 10am−9pm: This is the voting phase. Players discuss, debate, and vote to lynch one person they suspect is a Wolf. The person with the most votes is eliminated from the game.
Night Phase - 9pm−10am: The GM receives private messages from players with special roles. The Wolves choose their target, the Serial Killer chooses theirs, and any special actions are carried out.

Generally speaking I do think actions like allignment checks would get immediate responses once locked in, and action trackers would have to wait. So it does make sense in that aspect.

Is it weird that Prada went 'whosh whosh' in one her post. Someone said Legolas had a sword, .. and now Ed is Legolas

(15-10-2025, 03:49 PM)Mick the Drunk Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 03:38 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote: Yeah I'm an eegit is the general gist of that

Howya anyway Mick, what ya thinking?

I've been better Pat - I need to win the lotto so I can retire.

My top two would be Laura and William:

Laura for her D1 vote, her absence over the last two days - coming in when she is under a bit of pressure and disappearing again. She is also trying to twist posts to suit her narrative - Edward being a wolf and Prada being wrong - and when challenged on that she quickly moved on to Ben

William - it could be just his play style but he just seems to pop up randomly and post as if he is not reading the thread and has already checked out for today. Now I know that is a bit rich coming from a low poster myself but at least I am making the effort to follow the thread when I can and not just ignoring the posts.

(15-10-2025, 03:45 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 03:38 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: I have been thinking about Laura's question to me, and going back to examine if Prada got a result.
Edward says his result came through both days after munch. That makes sense if it is an action tracker. The action may not be made until just before munch, so I think he is telling the truth on the timing of the answers.
My action I received the response after the lynch, in the night phase. However mine wasn't action based, just another alignment check really. 

Day Phase - 10am−9pm: This is the voting phase. Players discuss, debate, and vote to lynch one person they suspect is a Wolf. The person with the most votes is eliminated from the game.
Night Phase - 9pm−10am: The GM receives private messages from players with special roles. The Wolves choose their target, the Serial Killer chooses theirs, and any special actions are carried out.

Generally speaking I do think actions like allignment checks would get immediate responses once locked in, and action trackers would have to wait. So it does make sense in that aspect.

Is it weird that Prada went 'whosh whosh' in one her post. Someone said Legolas had a sword, .. and now Ed is Legolas

(15-10-2025, 03:55 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 03:49 PM)Mick the Drunk Wrote: I've been better Pat - I need to win the lotto so I can retire.

My top two would be Laura and William:

Laura for her D1 vote, her absence over the last two days - coming in when she is under a bit of pressure and disappearing again. She is also trying to twist posts to suit her narrative - Edward being a wolf and Prada being wrong - and when challenged on that she quickly moved on to Ben

William - it could be just his play style but he just seems to pop up randomly and post as if he is not reading the thread and has already checked out for today. Now I know that is a bit rich coming from a low poster myself but at least I am making the effort to follow the thread when I can and not just ignoring the posts.

I didn't say Prada was wrong, I think she got a bad result and assumed SK rather than wolf. She clearly said to read her post if she died. The only other person she mentioned was Rhoda, Rhoda was Gandalf and would have shown as good.

(15-10-2025, 03:47 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote: You'd wonder why a villager has a watcher role with so many roles in play, is it not pointless?

A wolf being able to track a player with the ring would make more sense. Edward said he picked Prada because it was known she had a role, she had made that very obvious.