(15-10-2025, 12:55 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 12:51 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: Well lookit, this to me seems to be akin to role madness more or less.

Let's examine the lore again.

The Fellowship has 9 members, 4 of which are hobbits.

There's also Legolas, Aragorn, Gimli, Boromir and Gandalf

That's 9.

Then add in what we know already which was Elrond, so 10 from 16.

Wolves - 3, maybe 4 plus Gollum Smeagol and that brings us up to 14/15.

Other possible characters would be Arwen (Elrond's daughter and Aragorn's lover), or possibly Galadriel.

Hobbits I'd view as sort of NRV+, as in they have an important role but perhaps not huge powers.

I can see a world where all those characters exist with minor powers tbh, specifically because it's based on Fellowship and all characters (iirc without checking) were in the OP picture.

And based on that (but why initially I was reluctant to dig deeper into it on day 0) is why I think we could be dealing with 4 wolves

Id agree it's pretty much role madness at this point.. what do you think of that part of the OP. What do you think that means.

(15-10-2025, 01:02 PM)Vincent the Artist Wrote: Not anything we need to worry about for a minute or two but would the wolves have been given a list of claimable characters who are not in the game. To protect them from a mass claim..

(15-10-2025, 01:02 PM)Vincent the Artist Wrote: Not anything we need to worry about for a minute or two but would the wolves have been given a list of claimable characters who are not in the game. To protect them from a mass claim..

(15-10-2025, 01:03 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:02 PM)Vincent the Artist Wrote: Not anything we need to worry about for a minute or two but would the wolves have been given a list of claimable characters who are not in the game. To protect them from a mass claim..

It's possible but given the mods are strongly advising against directly character claiming I'm not so sure.

(15-10-2025, 01:05 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:02 PM)Vincent the Artist Wrote: Not anything we need to worry about for a minute or two but would the wolves have been given a list of claimable characters who are not in the game. To protect them from a mass claim..

There is no character claiming.. but wolves could claim any type of role they want with it being hard to counter claim it. we just have to hope they slip up somewhat.

(15-10-2025, 01:13 PM)Vincent the Artist Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:03 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: It's possible but given the mods are strongly advising against directly character claiming I'm not so sure.

Wolves might have a mechanic to kill claims. It will be interesting to see what happens with anyone who has claimed if this is a thing or not.

(15-10-2025, 01:14 PM)Vincent the Artist Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:05 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: There is no character claiming.. but wolves could claim any type of role they want with it being hard to counter claim it. we just have to hope they slip up somewhat.

Oh, so Edward didn't actually claim legolas ? We're just assuming it ?

(15-10-2025, 01:18 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:14 PM)Vincent the Artist Wrote: Oh, so Edward didn't actually claim legolas ? We're just assuming it ?

He made it blooming obvious but he has not actually claimed it, importantly

(14-10-2025, 05:23 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 05:11 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: Surely when you are giving the command to the mods it is there for you, and you would know what it is. Be it a movement check, watcher or a track. So which exactly is it?

Watcher, and I picked the wrong Blooming person to watch last night

(13-10-2025, 10:45 PM)Prada the Seamstress Wrote: Rhoda, Mick, William, Frank, Edward

Edward SK
Posts enough to be sage but safe enough to not be noticed.

2 wolves in the other 4
Did Rhoda and Betty think they could get people onboard Wendy wagon. Me thinks yes

Watch the quiet ones. Throwaway votes as they did not want to impact a wagon against Betty and Rhoda

Won't be on thread until after munch so use this as a whisper in the wind if my presence is no longer in physical form

(14-10-2025, 10:40 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 10:33 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote: Why do you say you might be gone in the morning? If people are talking about lynching you  then you are probably the least likely to be munched/killed

Seriously?

(15-10-2025, 01:20 PM)Vincent the Artist Wrote: Forum of games is a killer on the phone battery. I'll be back after lunch and a quick charge of my phone

(15-10-2025, 01:21 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote:

(13-10-2025, 10:45 PM)Prada the Seamstress Wrote: Rhoda, Mick, William, Frank, Edward

Edward SK
Posts enough to be sage but safe enough to not be noticed.

2 wolves in the other 4
Did Rhoda and Betty think they could get people onboard Wendy wagon. Me thinks yes

Watch the quiet ones. Throwaway votes as they did not want to impact a wagon against Betty and Rhoda

Won't be on thread until after munch so use this as a whisper in the wind if my presence is no longer in physical form

Was Prada given inaccurate information?

(15-10-2025, 01:18 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:14 PM)Vincent the Artist Wrote: Oh, so Edward didn't actually claim legolas ? We're just assuming it ?

He made it blooming obvious but he has not actually claimed it, importantly

(15-10-2025, 12:07 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 12:00 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: Why? What is your reasoning?

Gimme 30 mins or so and I’ll reply to you explaining my reasoning. I have to pop out and want to be here to reply to any follow up questions you have.

(15-10-2025, 01:21 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote:

(13-10-2025, 10:45 PM)Prada the Seamstress Wrote: Rhoda, Mick, William, Frank, Edward

Edward SK
Posts enough to be sage but safe enough to not be noticed.

2 wolves in the other 4
Did Rhoda and Betty think they could get people onboard Wendy wagon. Me thinks yes

Watch the quiet ones. Throwaway votes as they did not want to impact a wagon against Betty and Rhoda

Won't be on thread until after munch so use this as a whisper in the wind if my presence is no longer in physical form

Was Prada given inaccurate information?

(15-10-2025, 01:23 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:21 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: Was Prada given inaccurate information?

Could her info have potentially been tampered with either?

(15-10-2025, 01:24 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 12:07 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: Gimme 30 mins or so and I’ll reply to you explaining my reasoning. I have to pop out and want to be here to reply to any follow up questions you have.

(15-10-2025, 01:21 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: Was Prada given inaccurate information?

Hi @Benjamin the Alchemist  how's the reasoning going?

(15-10-2025, 01:26 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:23 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: Could her info have potentially been tampered with either?

She was our investigator so had no reason to lie to us. I doubt the post on thread was tampered with but the answer to her question may have been written in the wolf den.

(15-10-2025, 01:29 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: I think we are going to twist ourselves in knots trying to understand the mechanics until something actually happens to confirm them as tampered or wrong etc think for yourselves i suppose and make the decision if you want to believe anyones claims. dont take anything as 100%

(13-10-2025, 10:45 PM)Prada the Seamstress Wrote: Rhoda, Mick, William, Frank, Edward

Edward SK
Posts enough to be sage but safe enough to not be noticed.

2 wolves in the other 4
Did Rhoda and Betty think they could get people onboard Wendy wagon. Me thinks yes

Watch the quiet ones. Throwaway votes as they did not want to impact a wagon against Betty and Rhoda

Won't be on thread until after munch so use this as a whisper in the wind if my presence is no longer in physical form

(15-10-2025, 10:42 AM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: I get the suspicion but I didn't bus. I did spend the entire day pushing Betty even when others thought they spotted things about her (Magda, and Laura brought up different posts).

It would be a pretty hardcore thing to do on Day 1 to a teammate!

(15-10-2025, 01:46 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:

(13-10-2025, 10:45 PM)Prada the Seamstress Wrote: Rhoda, Mick, William, Frank, Edward

Edward SK
Posts enough to be sage but safe enough to not be noticed.

2 wolves in the other 4
Did Rhoda and Betty think they could get people onboard Wendy wagon. Me thinks yes

Watch the quiet ones. Throwaway votes as they did not want to impact a wagon against Betty and Rhoda

Won't be on thread until after munch so use this as a whisper in the wind if my presence is no longer in physical form

Prada had an alignment check, she named Edward as SK which we now know to be wrong.

She was suspicious of Rhoda who we now know would have shown as good.

I think Edward was checked and shown as bad, Prada obviously assumed SK.

I think Edward is a wolf and that's why the role claim was so confused and contradictory. Edward might well be a wolf tracker and can use that to find roled players.

I see everyone suspects me because of my Day 2 vote on Rhoda but she was suspicious as feck, so suspicious that many of you voted to lynch her last night. I voted for Edward because I thought he was the SK, I'll be voting for him today because I think he is a wolf and Prada got a bad result from her alignment check.

(15-10-2025, 01:48 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 10:42 AM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: I get the suspicion but I didn't bus. I did spend the entire day pushing Betty even when others thought they spotted things about her (Magda, and Laura brought up different posts).

It would be a pretty hardcore thing to do on Day 1 to a teammate!

??

(15-10-2025, 01:52 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:48 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote: ??

Do you just cherry pick random tidbits of conversations all the time or do you read the thread for context William.

(15-10-2025, 01:52 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:48 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote: ??

Do you just cherry pick random tidbits of conversations all the time or do you read the thread for context William.

(15-10-2025, 01:49 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:46 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote: Prada had an alignment check, she named Edward as SK which we now know to be wrong.

She was suspicious of Rhoda who we now know would have shown as good.

I think Edward was checked and shown as bad, Prada obviously assumed SK.

I think Edward is a wolf and that's why the role claim was so confused and contradictory. Edward might well be a wolf tracker and can use that to find roled players.

I see everyone suspects me because of my Day 2 vote on Rhoda but she was suspicious as feck, so suspicious that many of you voted to lynch her last night. I voted for Edward because I thought he was the SK, I'll be voting for him today because I think he is a wolf and Prada got a bad result from her alignment check.

So who would you be voting for today and why?

(14-10-2025, 10:54 AM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: I’d like to talk about singular voters, of which I am one. Would there be a wolf voting wolf possibility on a player getting no heat?

(14-10-2025, 11:01 AM)Pat the Baker Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 10:54 AM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: I’d like to talk about singular voters, of which I am one. Would there be a wolf voting wolf possibility on a player getting no heat?

Its definitely possible, but its WIFOM at this stage

You, mick, vern, Frank, William... let's get reasons for why they voted where they did

(14-10-2025, 11:04 AM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 10:54 AM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: I’d like to talk about singular voters, of which I am one. Would there be a wolf voting wolf possibility on a player getting no heat?

Frank voting Mick perhaps, Mick had zero heat.

You voted me. I know I'm not a wolf so that didn't happen there.

Mick voted William but William had been getting a good bit of heat through the day from Magda and Pat. I think Magda actually moved her vote to Rhoda from there but she'll clarify.

Vernon voted Pat. That was a fairly loud argument between the two of them. I'm suss of Vernon for other reasons though, not the vote. Like Betty their village energy just feels off and they've gone AWOL since the lynch.

William voted Prada, that's obviously not W/W


Not sure they'd have voted each other though, based on Betty's vote they look quite risk-averse as a team


Vinnie voted Edward alongside Prada, he's not a single voter per se but he can still be a wolf if Eddie flips SK

(14-10-2025, 08:40 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: I’ll move off Edward too. Rhoda should have enough votes in her so I’m gonna go Mick.

(15-10-2025, 01:59 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:49 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: So who would you be voting for today and why?

It's in the post you quoted, I'm voting for Edward based on Prada's post. I think she did an alignment check on him, he came back bad and she assumed SK.

Will read back on others and give my thoughts later.

(15-10-2025, 01:55 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote: @Laura the Lace Mistress take yourself out of that D1 Rhoda vote & put William (name picked at random) in instead

Main wagon yeets a wolf. Do you not want to look at all at the counter wagon?

It's the D1 Rhoda vote we're looking at, not the D2

(15-10-2025, 01:54 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:52 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: Do you just cherry pick random tidbits of conversations all the time or do you read the thread for context William.

i was reading back on this morning and this stood out to me so i quoted it. then i gave up

(15-10-2025, 01:54 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:52 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: Do you just cherry pick random tidbits of conversations all the time or do you read the thread for context William.

i was reading back on this morning and this stood out to me so i quoted it. then i gave up

(15-10-2025, 02:03 PM)Mick the Drunk Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:54 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote: i was reading back on this morning and this stood out to me so i quoted it. then i gave up

What about it stood out though? I was part of a discussion we were having around Ina possibly bussing Betty so was in the context of the conversation at the time

(15-10-2025, 02:02 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:

(15-10-2025, 01:55 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote: @Laura the Lace Mistress take yourself out of that D1 Rhoda vote & put William (name picked at random) in instead

Main wagon yeets a wolf. Do you not want to look at all at the counter wagon?

It's the D1 Rhoda vote we're looking at, not the D2

I know I'm not a wolf, Rhoda peeked you, Magda has role claimed, why would I look there?

Why are you ignoring the post from Prada? Edward obviously showed as bad.