+- A sheep, a werewolf and a walrus walk into a bar. (https://forumofgames.com)
+-- Forum: Werewolf (https://forumofgames.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=9)
+--- Forum: Werewolf Games (https://forumofgames.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=26)
+--- Thread: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf (/showthread.php?tid=551)
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Benjamin the Alchemist - 14-10-2025
I’m just about to put a vote on Edward. Catch an evil kill an evil. Don’t thing Prada would have said “Edward SK” so matter of factly and we also don’t know exactly what her investigative role entailed.
I worry that an SK Gollum would have tricks up their sleeve (if Gollum wore clothes) so we need to at least wound them with tonight’s lynch.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Benjamin the Alchemist - 14-10-2025
Voted Edward at 3.43pm
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Pat the Baker - 14-10-2025
On magda. Their vote yesterday is only dodgy if rhoda comes back good. Up until then I didn't notice anything dodgy from them
Imo in order to make a better call on magda, we need to clear up rhoda. Basically I think magda is someone id be questioning more tomorrow if we yeet rhoda. Laura falls into that category but more suss atm than magda, as I feel Laura hasn't been trying to solve anything
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Pat the Baker - 14-10-2025
If we yeett rhoda and they are good, that should rest
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Mick the Drunk - 14-10-2025
(14-10-2025, 03:42 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: I’m just about to put a vote on Edward. Catch an evil kill an evil. Don’t thing Prada would have said “Edward SK” so matter of factly and we also don’t know exactly what her investigative role entailed.
I worry that an SK Gollum would have tricks up their sleeve (if Gollum wore clothes) so we need to at least wound them with tonight’s lynch.
It wasn't just her saying he was SK, she also says in that post to read that post should anything happen to her.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Pat the Baker - 14-10-2025
(14-10-2025, 03:47 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote: If we yeett rhoda and they are good, that should restRead, stupid phone
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Ina May the Midwife - 14-10-2025
(14-10-2025, 03:47 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote: On magda. Their vote yesterday is only dodgy if rhoda comes back good. Up until then I didn't notice anything dodgy from them
Imo in order to make a better call on magda, we need to clear up rhoda. Basically I think magda is someone id be questioning more tomorrow if we yeet rhoda. Laura falls into that category but more suss atm than magda, as I feel Laura hasn't been trying to solve anything
I agree it's why I haven't gone after Magda because it's literally only the vote that I find dodgy so far. If their posting was suspect as well it would be a different story
That and the fact that Betty didn't self pres. Why didn't she self pres? She would have tied the wagons
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Benjamin the Alchemist - 14-10-2025
(14-10-2025, 03:48 PM)Mick the Drunk Wrote:(14-10-2025, 03:42 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: I’m just about to put a vote on Edward. Catch an evil kill an evil. Don’t thing Prada would have said “Edward SK” so matter of factly and we also don’t know exactly what her investigative role entailed.
I worry that an SK Gollum would have tricks up their sleeve (if Gollum wore clothes) so we need to at least wound them with tonight’s lynch.
It wasn't just her saying he was SK, she also says in that post to read that post should anything happen to her.
Exactly and that’s why Edward has to go.
if Prada had something solid on Rhoda I think she would have been clearer. Especially with her last paragraph.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Rhoda the Spinster - 14-10-2025
No pockets in this cloak @Pat the Baker
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Magda the Maid - 14-10-2025
ive a vote in on Rhoda since about 3.30
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - William the Grave Robber - 14-10-2025
edward is defo bad, and likely SK. tracking prada is just far too convenient.
the question then is.....well its not really a question. we should vote him and (right now) prioritise rhoda tomorrow.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Ina May the Midwife - 14-10-2025
(14-10-2025, 04:22 PM)William the Grave Robber Wrote: edward is defo bad, and likely SK. tracking prada is just far too convenient.
the question then is.....well its not really a question. we should vote him and (right now) prioritise rhoda tomorrow.
Or shoot one, lynch the other 🤷🏻 if that ability is available 🤣
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Ina May the Midwife - 14-10-2025
(14-10-2025, 03:42 PM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: I’m just about to put a vote on Edward. Catch an evil kill an evil. Don’t thing Prada would have said “Edward SK” so matter of factly and we also don’t know exactly what her investigative role entailed.
I worry that an SK Gollum would have tricks up their sleeve (if Gollum wore clothes) so we need to at least wound them with tonight’s lynch.
It's not just that either it's that if we hit the SK we cut the kill rate in half so it's a max of 1 potential death by the evils at munch as opposed to 2
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Edward the Barber - 14-10-2025
Vote me tonight and we are down another villager, a roled villager. It was not a one and done. However I will be munched in the morning if you keep me.
so we have to make a choice
lynch me and we are down probably 3 villagers by tomorrow morning (if there are again 2 kills)
keep me and we could be still down 3 villagers or we could potentially lynch a wolf/sk
I'll be honest, if I was not me I would probably vote for me, I picked the wrong player last night to track, anyone else and I could have looked better to everyone.
Ask yourself this though, if I was a wolf or sk, I could have lied and said I tracked someone else and got no action and I wouldn't have looked so bad. I'm a roled villager, I tracked Prada and unfortunately for me now they are dead and can't confirm anything
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Wendy the Wench - 14-10-2025
(14-10-2025, 04:52 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote: Vote me tonight and we are down another villager, a roled villager. It was not a one and done. However I will be munched in the morning if you keep me.
so we have to make a choice
lynch me and we are down probably 3 villagers by tomorrow morning (if there are again 2 kills)
keep me and we could be still down 3 villagers or we could potentially lynch a wolf/sk
I'll be honest, if I was not me I would probably vote for me, I picked the wrong player last night to track, anyone else and I could have looked better to everyone.
Ask yourself this though, if I was a wolf or sk, I could have lied and said I tracked someone else and got no action and I wouldn't have looked so bad. I'm a roled villager, I tracked Prada and unfortunately for me now they are dead and can't confirm anything
What, did you track them? Who did they visit?
This seems like a nonsense claim, now that they have said track, and not given any more info.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Ina May the Midwife - 14-10-2025
Tracker would make sense for a certain Ranger character. But yeah did you get a result on who Prada visited so? Earlier it was you could see if someone performed an action so there's a little bit of a contradiction there Steady Eddie
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Wendy the Wench - 14-10-2025
The correct term for what you are suggesting is watch, not track. Track should give you the player who they visited, ed or rhoda, or whoever.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Edward the Barber - 14-10-2025
(14-10-2025, 04:57 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote:(14-10-2025, 04:52 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote: Vote me tonight and we are down another villager, a roled villager. It was not a one and done. However I will be munched in the morning if you keep me.
so we have to make a choice
lynch me and we are down probably 3 villagers by tomorrow morning (if there are again 2 kills)
keep me and we could be still down 3 villagers or we could potentially lynch a wolf/sk
I'll be honest, if I was not me I would probably vote for me, I picked the wrong player last night to track, anyone else and I could have looked better to everyone.
Ask yourself this though, if I was a wolf or sk, I could have lied and said I tracked someone else and got no action and I wouldn't have looked so bad. I'm a roled villager, I tracked Prada and unfortunately for me now they are dead and can't confirm anything
What, did you track them? Who did they visit?
This seems like a nonsense claim, now that they have said track, and not given any more info.
The only info I get is if they completed an action or not during the night.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Benjamin the Alchemist - 14-10-2025
Eddie is full of it. In my humble opinion
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Ina May the Midwife - 14-10-2025
(14-10-2025, 12:21 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote: The reason I said I am not just a villager is because players have called for me to be shot. Otherwise I would have kept quiet. Unfortunately the information I have is not overly helpful. I was able to check someone last night if they had an action. I checked Prada, they had an action, unfortunately now they are dead. however it confirms to me that their action (investigating) was during the night.
What does investigator mean, like a seer?
Now unless they had this action on Sunday then they didn't investigate me. I had not action on Sunday night so I doubt Prada either. If she said I was the SK it was only speculation, as I know I'm not the sk and I doubt they used any action before last night
(14-10-2025, 04:52 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote: Vote me tonight and we are down another villager, a roled villager. It was not a one and done. However I will be munched in the morning if you keep me.
so we have to make a choice
lynch me and we are down probably 3 villagers by tomorrow morning (if there are again 2 kills)
keep me and we could be still down 3 villagers or we could potentially lynch a wolf/sk
I'll be honest, if I was not me I would probably vote for me, I picked the wrong player last night to track, anyone else and I could have looked better to everyone.
Ask yourself this though, if I was a wolf or sk, I could have lied and said I tracked someone else and got no action and I wouldn't have looked so bad. I'm a roled villager, I tracked Prada and unfortunately for me now they are dead and can't confirm anything
That's a pretty big detail to leave out that you could track a person Edward.
Track is a specific action where you follow someone and learn who if anyone they visited that night.
But that's not what you initially said your description is different 🤨
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Wendy the Wench - 14-10-2025
(14-10-2025, 05:03 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote:(14-10-2025, 04:57 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote: What, did you track them? Who did they visit?
This seems like a nonsense claim, now that they have said track, and not given any more info.
The only info I get is if they completed an action or not during the night.
Why did you say 'track'? That is a different role than what you are describing.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Edward the Barber - 14-10-2025
(14-10-2025, 05:04 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote:(14-10-2025, 05:03 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote: The only info I get is if they completed an action or not during the night.
Why did you say 'track'? That is a different role than what you are describing.
If track is the wrong word, then sorry. I only get info if the player completes an action during the night or not
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Magda the Maid - 14-10-2025
(14-10-2025, 05:07 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote:(14-10-2025, 05:04 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote: Why did you say 'track'? That is a different role than what you are describing.
If track is the wrong word, then sorry. I only get info if the player completes an action during the night or not
Surely when you are giving the command to the mods it is there for you, and you would know what it is. Be it a movement check, watcher or a track. So which exactly is it?
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Rhoda the Spinster - 14-10-2025
Why would a roled person ever not complete an action?
In my view, if you have power, you should always use it- albeit carefully.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Frank the Tank - 14-10-2025
(14-10-2025, 05:14 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: Why would a roled person ever not complete an action?
In my view, if you have power, you should always use it- albeit carefully.
He could watch a non roled player who doesn't do an action because there are none to do
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Ina May the Midwife - 14-10-2025
(14-10-2025, 05:16 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:(14-10-2025, 05:14 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: Why would a roled person ever not complete an action?
In my view, if you have power, you should always use it- albeit carefully.
He could watch a non roled player who doesn't do an action because there are none to do
Or someone who only has day actions
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Wendy the Wench - 14-10-2025
Vote going in on Ed.
If we are both alive tomorrow magda, i've not forgotten, i'll relook at you and ben then, just their are bigger fish to fry first.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Edward the Barber - 14-10-2025
(14-10-2025, 05:11 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote:Watcher, and I picked the wrong Blooming person to watch last night(14-10-2025, 05:07 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote: If track is the wrong word, then sorry. I only get info if the player completes an action during the night or not
Surely when you are giving the command to the mods it is there for you, and you would know what it is. Be it a movement check, watcher or a track. So which exactly is it?
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Wendy the Wench - 14-10-2025
(14-10-2025, 05:23 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote:(14-10-2025, 05:11 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: Surely when you are giving the command to the mods it is there for you, and you would know what it is. Be it a movement check, watcher or a track. So which exactly is it?Watcher, and I picked the wrong Blooming person to watch last night
a watcher is able to tell who visits a person, so you should have seen yourself visiting.
the spoofer nature or changing onto watcher has sealed it.
you cooked.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Ina May the Midwife - 14-10-2025
(14-10-2025, 05:23 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote:(14-10-2025, 05:11 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: Surely when you are giving the command to the mods it is there for you, and you would know what it is. Be it a movement check, watcher or a track. So which exactly is it?Watcher, and I picked the wrong Blooming person to watch last night
Hang on but Watcher means you get who visited Prada so you should have seen the SK there?
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Benjamin the Alchemist - 14-10-2025
Hahaha busted
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Magda the Maid - 14-10-2025
(14-10-2025, 05:23 PM)Edward the Barber Wrote:(14-10-2025, 05:11 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: Surely when you are giving the command to the mods it is there for you, and you would know what it is. Be it a movement check, watcher or a track. So which exactly is it?Watcher, and I picked the wrong Blooming person to watch last night
![[Image: wow-fascinating.gif]](https://media.tenor.com/OQqN2N1RRVsAAAAM/wow-fascinating.gif)
"Watching another player informs you who used a Night Action on that player, if any. You will not learn what type of Night Action was used on your target."
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Magda the Maid - 14-10-2025
Or what everyone else said 😂 spent too long trying to copy the gif address
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Magda the Maid - 14-10-2025
Could have just popped over to our Boards resources to inform yourself.. 😂
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Magda the Maid - 14-10-2025
Changing vote to Eddie
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Ina May the Midwife - 14-10-2025
Any Gollum gifs for us Eddie😋
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Pat the Baker - 14-10-2025
Keeping my vote on Edward so!
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Ina May the Midwife - 14-10-2025
I voted Eddie ages ago and I'm out this evening from about 6ish. Will catch up after I get back.
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - William the Grave Robber - 14-10-2025
what about the fighting irish? will the luck of the irish be in tonight?
RE: The Fellowship of the Ring Werewolf - Edward the Barber - 14-10-2025
Fair enough, vote me tonight. Read my previous post carefully though and spot the clue.
I won't plead my case any further, good luck village