(14-10-2025, 01:50 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 01:47 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: But we don't know what the Investigator role does.

It's a fairly big call as an investigative role to call out a player as a specific role and leave a 'please read me when I'm dead' calling card on it if you haven't peeked them

Yeah, I just have the alignment post in my head, Prada specifically selects your post with alignment in it and answers, basically saying they would check the alignment.

Are you the SK? 😂

(14-10-2025, 01:55 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 01:50 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: Yeah, I just have the alignment post in my head, Prada specifically selects your post with alignment in it and answers, basically saying they would check the alignment.

Are you the SK? 😂

Nope! Big ould villager head on me!

(14-10-2025, 01:42 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 01:36 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: Took some time away there to reflect.

Question: what would Gollum's alignment be?

To himself? Or am I misunderstanding the question?

@Ina May the Midwife I agree with you on Edward, MAgda, Laura. THink you need to throw Wendy in the mix there. I feel like there is tag teaming going on and Pat and I is getting caught up in the cross fire.
Interesting read on Frank but I would need more info. Were they just stopping MAeve from oscaring?

(14-10-2025, 01:59 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 01:42 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: To himself? Or am I misunderstanding the question?

@Ina May the Midwife I agree with you on Edward, MAgda, Laura. THink you need to throw Wendy in the mix there. I feel like there is tag teaming going on and Pat and I is getting caught up in the cross fire.
Interesting read on Frank but I would need more info. Were they just stopping MAeve from oscaring?

This is my question. If there was an alignment check, what would the alignment come back as for Gollum. 
They aren't aligned to anyone or any group. They are solo. They aren't aligned to the fellowship. They aren't aligned to Sauron. So what would the answer be?

(14-10-2025, 01:50 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 01:47 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: But we don't know what the Investigator role does.

It's a fairly big call as an investigative role to call out a player as a specific role and leave a 'please read me when I'm dead' calling card on it if you haven't peeked them

Yeah, I just have the alignment post in my head, Prada specifically selects your post with alignment in it and answers, basically saying they would check the alignment.

Are you the SK? 😂

(14-10-2025, 01:55 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 01:48 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: Who is He? Unless you dont believe Edward to be the SK?

I'm open to all possibilities, like Edwards claim is probably bullshit, but it's not being countered by anyone who had similar abilities or so.. so IF we were to take that as true, we need to look at other possibilities, and that leads to Rhoda from Prada's posts .

(The he was a typo, referring to Prada)

(14-10-2025, 01:42 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 01:36 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: Took some time away there to reflect.

Question: what would Gollum's alignment be?

To himself? Or am I misunderstanding the question?

@Ina May the Midwife I agree with you on Edward, MAgda, Laura. THink you need to throw Wendy in the mix there. I feel like there is tag teaming going on and Pat and I is getting caught up in the cross fire.
Interesting read on Frank but I would need more info. Were they just stopping MAeve from oscaring?

(14-10-2025, 02:05 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 01:42 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: To himself? Or am I misunderstanding the question?

@Ina May the Midwife I agree with you on Edward, MAgda, Laura. THink you need to throw Wendy in the mix there. I feel like there is tag teaming going on and Pat and I is getting caught up in the cross fire.
Interesting read on Frank but I would need more info. Were they just stopping MAeve from oscaring?

Ina is too quick to clear me. Is it because I declared them village?

(14-10-2025, 01:56 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 01:55 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: Nope! Big ould villager head on me!

An SK would say that! 😜

(14-10-2025, 02:05 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 01:55 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: I'm open to all possibilities, like Edwards claim is probably bullshit, but it's not being countered by anyone who had similar abilities or so.. so IF we were to take that as true, we need to look at other possibilities, and that leads to Rhoda from Prada's posts .

(The he was a typo, referring to Prada)

A typo, twice.

(14-10-2025, 01:59 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 01:42 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: To himself? Or am I misunderstanding the question?

@Ina May the Midwife I agree with you on Edward, MAgda, Laura. THink you need to throw Wendy in the mix there. I feel like there is tag teaming going on and Pat and I is getting caught up in the cross fire.
Interesting read on Frank but I would need more info. Were they just stopping MAeve from oscaring?

This is my question. If there was an alignment check, what would the alignment come back as for Gollum. 
They aren't aligned to anyone or any group. They are solo. They aren't aligned to the fellowship. They aren't aligned to Sauron. So what would the answer be?

(13-10-2025, 10:45 PM)Laura the Lace Mistress Wrote:

(13-10-2025, 10:38 PM)Prada the Seamstress Wrote: Would an SK game be to want to get wolves out first?

Post enough to seem village but not enough to draw too much attention on themselves

Sk can kill their wolf suspects, they don't need to make themselves a target. I'd say a sk is more likely to be quiet and try not to draw too much attention unless they're a really ballsy player.

(14-10-2025, 02:07 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 01:56 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: An SK would say that! 😜

I'm not moving onto Ina.
Do me a favor and tell me why ben is a villager. I can't see it, but nobody is mentioning them at all.
I could see myself moving my vote there.
I would like to here your opinions on ben.

(14-10-2025, 02:19 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 02:07 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote: I'm not moving onto Ina.
Do me a favor and tell me why ben is a villager. I can't see it, but nobody is mentioning them at all.
I could see myself moving my vote there.
I would like to here your opinions on ben.

I never asked you to move onto Ina, but both yourself and Ina could potentially be the SK, and you would stay in that "territory" until the SK is found if it's not ye. That possibility shouldn't be discounted.

I'm neutral on Ben, I don't have them as village so I dunno why you would be asking me to tell you why they are village, they are pretty in the middle, haven't really posted anything out there and are pretty much not really putting their head above the parapet so to speak.

(14-10-2025, 02:19 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 02:07 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote: I'm not moving onto Ina.
Do me a favor and tell me why ben is a villager. I can't see it, but nobody is mentioning them at all.
I could see myself moving my vote there.
I would like to here your opinions on ben.

I never asked you to move onto Ina, but both yourself and Ina could potentially be the SK, and you would stay in that "territory" until the SK is found if it's not ye. That possibility shouldn't be discounted.

I'm neutral on Ben, I don't have them as village so I dunno why you would be asking me to tell you why they are village, they are pretty in the middle, haven't really posted anything out there and are pretty much not really putting their head above the parapet so to speak.

Quote:I'm neutral on Ben, I don't have them as village so I dunno why you would be asking me to tell you why they are village, they are pretty in the middle, haven't really posted anything out there and are pretty much not really putting their head above the parapet so to speak.

(14-10-2025, 11:01 AM)Pat the Baker Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 10:54 AM)Benjamin the Alchemist Wrote: I’d like to talk about singular voters, of which I am one. Would there be a wolf voting wolf possibility on a player getting no heat?

Its definitely possible, but its WIFOM at this stage

You, mick, vern, Frank, William... let's get reasons for why they voted where they did

(14-10-2025, 02:32 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 02:19 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: I never asked you to move onto Ina, but both yourself and Ina could potentially be the SK, and you would stay in that "territory" until the SK is found if it's not ye. That possibility shouldn't be discounted.

I'm neutral on Ben, I don't have them as village so I dunno why you would be asking me to tell you why they are village, they are pretty in the middle, haven't really posted anything out there and are pretty much not really putting their head above the parapet so to speak.

The only thing about Ben is Betty initially had them as a protect on their peek/shoot/protect, but then clarified and said they meant Pat.

(14-10-2025, 01:19 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote: Chucking a placeholder on Edward

@Edward the Barber was your power a one and done, or each night?

(14-10-2025, 02:38 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 02:19 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: I never asked you to move onto Ina, but both yourself and Ina could potentially be the SK, and you would stay in that "territory" until the SK is found if it's not ye. That possibility shouldn't be discounted.

I'm neutral on Ben, I don't have them as village so I dunno why you would be asking me to tell you why they are village, they are pretty in the middle, haven't really posted anything out there and are pretty much not really putting their head above the parapet so to speak.

Why are you neutral on Ben?
You don't have them as village, so what is left if they are not village?
Why are you not hunting?
You spent as much time talking about how myself and ina could be sk, so you are doing more sk hunting than you are doing wolf hunting.

Quote:I'm neutral on Ben, I don't have them as village so I dunno why you would be asking me to tell you why they are village, they are pretty in the middle, haven't really posted anything out there and are pretty much not really putting their head above the parapet so to speak.

If you were not a wolf, you would have actually done some work.

(14-10-2025, 02:04 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 01:50 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: Yeah, I just have the alignment post in my head, Prada specifically selects your post with alignment in it and answers, basically saying they would check the alignment.

Are you the SK? 😂

This is exactly what I am reflecting on.
I think I was too quick to clear Ina as aligned to the fellowship and village, when I forgot about Gollum. Ina can't be a wolf, but very possibly the SK.

(14-10-2025, 02:51 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 01:19 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote: Chucking a placeholder on Edward

@Edward the Barber was your power a one and done, or each night?

(14-10-2025, 02:38 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote: Why are you neutral on Ben?
You don't have them as village, so what is left if they are not village?
Why are you not hunting?
You spent as much time talking about how myself and ina could be sk, so you are doing more sk hunting than you are doing wolf hunting.


If you were not a wolf, you would have actually done some work.

yes because trying to say the investigator may not have been calling Edward the SK and that we should be looking at Rhoda is SK hunting. Get the boat Wendy, I have not said where i am voting. Do you think that anyone is going to lynch you or Ina before Rhoda or me. Lynch Rhoda, who i believe Prada investigated, i believe they are a wolf

you have done nothing apart from follow me around prodding and prodding trying to get me to reveal my role. i know what you are at. 

I'll outright say it to you! i believe you are the SK. i dont believe Edward is the SK and i think you have played this entire game trying to roie hunt. you did it with Pat yesterday also.

(14-10-2025, 03:06 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 02:51 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: yes because trying to say the investigator may not have been calling Edward the SK and that we should be looking at Rhoda is SK hunting. Get the boat Wendy, I have not said where i am voting. Do you think that anyone is going to lynch you or Ina before Rhoda or me. Lynch Rhoda, who i believe Prada investigated, i believe they are a wolf

you have done nothing apart from follow me around prodding and prodding trying to get me to reveal my role. i know what you are at. 

I'll outright say it to you! i believe you are the SK. i dont believe Edward is the SK and i think you have played this entire game trying to roie hunt. you did it with Pat yesterday also.

Ya, this is a wolf. 😂🤣

(14-10-2025, 03:06 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 02:51 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: yes because trying to say the investigator may not have been calling Edward the SK and that we should be looking at Rhoda is SK hunting. Get the boat Wendy, I have not said where i am voting. Do you think that anyone is going to lynch you or Ina before Rhoda or me. Lynch Rhoda, who i believe Prada investigated, i believe they are a wolf

you have done nothing apart from follow me around prodding and prodding trying to get me to reveal my role. i know what you are at. 

I'll outright say it to you! i believe you are the SK. i dont believe Edward is the SK and i think you have played this entire game trying to roie hunt. you did it with Pat yesterday also.

Ya, this is a wolf. 😂🤣

(14-10-2025, 03:06 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 02:51 PM)Magda the Maid Wrote: yes because trying to say the investigator may not have been calling Edward the SK and that we should be looking at Rhoda is SK hunting. Get the boat Wendy, I have not said where i am voting. Do you think that anyone is going to lynch you or Ina before Rhoda or me. Lynch Rhoda, who i believe Prada investigated, i believe they are a wolf

you have done nothing apart from follow me around prodding and prodding trying to get me to reveal my role. i know what you are at. 

I'll outright say it to you! i believe you are the SK. i dont believe Edward is the SK and i think you have played this entire game trying to roie hunt. you did it with Pat yesterday also.

Ya, this is a wolf. 😂🤣

(14-10-2025, 03:08 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 03:06 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote: Ya, this is a wolf. 😂🤣

2 outta 3 for ffa0, not bad. pity i also had the seer in that ffa. eek can't be helped. RV's have a tendency to look a lot like wolves.

(14-10-2025, 03:09 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: I really don't know why Prada would have said that. I'm neither SK nor wolf. You will have to believe me on that. Or not- but to our detriment.
That whole thing about the morning thing about Edward is super weird.
That aside, I am not wholly convinced they are SK necessarily. I do think there are some posters on here deflecting away from them onto other random people or just moving the conversation along. For reasons best known either to themselves, or between themselves.

@Wendy the Wench why are you asking only about Ben and not about the other low posters/ one voters? And why are you asking only MAgda?

(14-10-2025, 09:09 AM)Prada the Seamstress Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 08:56 AM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: So Maeve hops on the thread and after a little bit of discussion hops on Betty, this means at this point the wagons are:

Betty - Ina, Edward, Maeve

Rhoda - Pat, Laura

One minute later, Rhoda posts the following:


That doesn't change the top wagons at all, Betty is still in the lead by a vote.



Magda then pops onto Rhoda at 8.58, tying the top wagons so it looks like this:


Rhoda - Pat, Laura, Magda*

Betty - Ina, Edward, Maeve

*Magda has last vote so if this was final vote count Rhoda would have been lynched


This post from Wendy comes post lynch closure - which confirms the top wagon and Wendy's last minute vote the killing blow on Betty.

Betty - Ina, Edward, Maeve, Wendy

Rhoda - Pat, Laura, Magda.

Last vote no longer matters as Betty has more votes, but Wendy likely would have gotten it anywho.

Two things I can't quite understand.

Why no self pres on Rhoda from Betty. Also, Rhoda doesn't self pres onto Betty either. Red flag to me there in terms of alignment, it indicates that both may be wolves and didn't want to vote each other.

Instead, Rhoda and Betty both end up voting Wendy together. Possible that they thought Wendy would have more votes and tried to make her the counter wagon? Can't answer that question firmly until we know Rhoda's alignment though.


If Rhoda is village or the SK, Magda becomes a highly priority possibility for wolf based on the timing of her voting Rhoda, as it tied the wagons with Betty.

We shall cross that bridge if necessary but worth bearing in mind. I'm not convinced that Rhoda's a villager though but I thought it best to include this in my post.

This is a great post.

Rhoda needs to be resolved one way or the other

(14-10-2025, 03:13 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 03:06 PM)Wendy the Wench Wrote: Ya, this is a wolf. 😂🤣

What were you at with me yesterday btw? You never really explained it, but you made me explain why I had an issue with it

(14-10-2025, 03:19 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 09:09 AM)Prada the Seamstress Wrote: This is a great post.

Rhoda needs to be resolved one way or the other

I dunno, I feel like this post would be more definitive if they had peeked Rhoda?

(14-10-2025, 03:28 PM)Pat the Baker Wrote:

(14-10-2025, 03:19 PM)Ina May the Midwife Wrote: I dunno, I feel like this post would be more definitive if they had peeked Rhoda?

'One way or another' is giving me pause for thought.. but they said rhoda needs to be resolved

(14-10-2025, 03:34 PM)Rhoda the Spinster Wrote: And other villagers too. Be like Pat- be wise and pause for thought. Look and you will see the real evil lurking. I am trying to root it out too.